Webinar or Talk
Qatar's Eid Charity: An Investigation with Martha Lee, Abhinav Pandya, and Jordan Cope
Watch on YouTube
Description
Recently, the Middle East Forum came into possession of tens of thousands of leaked documents from a self-admitted “semi-government” charity in Qatar founded by a U.S.-designated terrorist. The documents reveals that Eid Charity has donated hundreds of millions of dollars to Islamists and jihadis around the world. With other organizations, MEF has researched the use of these funds. What has been found so far? What does it mean?
MEF’s Washington Project Director Cliff Smith will discuss these issues with Martha Lee of Islamist Watch, Abhinav Pandya of the Usanas Foundation, and Jordan Cope of Stand With Us.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 all right let's get started uh hello everyone my name is cliff smith with the middle east forum i'm the washington project director and today we have a and somewhat unusual webinar that i think you'll find very enlight a while back the middle east forum came into a recipient of documents detailing almost 46 000 grants totaling over 770 million dollars made by a charitable organization controlled and run by the qatari regime called the sheikh ibn muhammad al-thani charitable association otherwise known as the eid charity and these grants went among other things radical islamic organizations all around the world investigators from the middle east forum as well as some of our friends and partners have been researching these grants and the organizations that they funded for months just recently they published a series of op-eds detailing a number of these grants and where they went to and um they've been writing articles about their findings in the last few weeks and
1:03 uh where they went and today joining me is three of those people that have studied these grants studied the organizations they went to and um tried to kind of understand what is happening with qatar and with the organizations they are funding uh joining me today is martha lee of the middle east forms um islamist watch of pandea of the usanus foundation based in india and jordan cope of the director of policy education with stand with us and the qatari finance fellow at the middle east forum anyhow i'm going to ask you guys a series of questions um some will be rejected to you guys generally otherwise will be directed to you guys specifically um but you can answer um as you see fit um but let's start with the very basics um what is the eid charity and what is this relationship to the qatari world family anybody who wants to answer that yeah go ahead and start martha why don't you give it a shot
2:06 yes um so a charity is has been described by the government as a semi-governmental organization so i think it's uh quite evident that they that they have ties to the regime um they've also participated in a number um of events where their their strategy and policies were um said to be organized along um with the qatari government so i think there's really little doubt that they seem to be working hand in hand and that aids projects are certainly not independent from qatari policies and what exactly do they do on a day-to-day basis as an organization um so i see it's it seems that their um their main activity is to distribute um the grants that we'll be speaking about today so they're um active um throughout the world and many many different countries and do you believe all of these are to um
3:10 promote the regime's policies or or is it just general some do and some don't how do you view their well for example i wouldn't say necessarily that every single organization they've given to is islamist i don't think we can say that for sure but i think that just the fact that so many of the organizations that have received grounds from aid or tied to either lawful islamist or even islamist terrorist organization does indicate a clear pattern of support for jordan your recent article focuses mostly on recipients actually in the middle east um and it noted in one section and i quote the al isan charitable society a recipient of nearly 17.8 million and a terrorist organization designated by egypt saudi arabia united arab emirates and bahrain for their connections to al-qaeda and i was wondering um this is obviously a pretty um
4:12 striking and and um overt act of funding a uh a terrorist organization how typical of that is the the funds distributed by the e charity in the middle east based on what you've seen so cliff i actually had uh two articles on on the subject and i happened to do some translation work so i got to see the documents firsthand and to see the organizations they were going to and funding for terrorist organizations is nothing that was so discreet it obviously mentioned the name of the organizations that received such funding such as the ls sun which received approximately 17 million dollars and is reported to be headed by a former member of um al-qaeda in the arabian peninsula's rami council his name is abdullah al-yazimi and so there are a bunch of other charities affiliated with al-issan such as the rahma charity foundation which is also designated by the quartet
5:16 other concerning organizations included the el hikma aliamania which received approximately 6.5 million dollars and upon further research it was discovered that they helped smuggle fighters um into iraq and were also reported to have provided material support for al-qaeda leaders in yemen and saudi arabia and these weren't the only organizations that warranted cause of attention many hamas affiliates also received money ihh a islamist organization from turkey that is designated as a terrorist organization in certain parts of the received a whopping 23.2 million dollars and so it becomes evident um throughout the receipts that i helped translate that qatar has helped disguise um its funding for islamist and terrorist organizations as humanitarian relief yeah so so in other words you see that that you know that one particular you
6:18 know sort of striking thing that i is not unique you've seen many such things in similar ways it's certainly not unique um in regards to hamas affiliates i identified um six to six just straight off the bat um that happened to have ties with hamas um one organization for instance even happened to invite um ismael haniya um the the head of the political bureau of uh hamas to their other organizations included um islamic whose khan yunus branch in gaza actually shares the exact same name of the organization that was actually founded by the founder of hamas sheikh ahmed yasin and so you see a lot of these organizations the islamic charitable society of hebron uh received about five million dollars and is reported to have been um a part of
7:21 hamas dawa network between 2000 2004 the jerusalem international foundation another notorious organization designated by the united states received about 3.7 million dollars the ibinba's charitable society the society's president has previously expressed a will for closer cooperation with hamas and um the uh the al-nusra charitable society which has ties to the irbin buzz society which as i after mentioned um has expressed the will to get closer with hamas and so you see these trends recurring time and time again i think one of the most shocking discoveries was and it wasn't necessarily something new but the receipts inspired an investigation into the qatar committee for the reconstruction of gaza giving all this funding where we discovered three million dollars donated despite the org having received
8:23 many many millions of dollars in the past and what we saw was something striking and that was posts that have since been taken down from the facebook page of the organization but pictures ultimately depicting um the head of the qatar committee for the reconstruction of gaza a state ambassador muhammad al-ahmadi meeting members of the palestinian-islamic jihad who have no real humanitarian efforts and they refuse to engage in the political process so this excuse of qatar using charity and relations with hamas and other terrorist organizations as a means of serving as an intermediary in the region simply is not true the funding to a large degree as well as their political ideologies endorse islamist ideologies and terrorist organizations and i think we learned that a lot through the receipts got it um um it is no secret that qatar is increasingly aligned with pakistan and
9:26 thus a de facto in opposition to india's interests so perhaps it comes as no great surprise that as you put in your article over 1200 transactions made to either directly under the name of the e-charity if their individual contributions a total of 28.49 million um that is 7.82 million in u.s dollars was transferred to eight salafi-based islamist organizations in india um with wahhabi with hobbism being the salah um the version of salafism being the national creed of qatar can you explain a little on what you found in these grants and um how will you think it helps the qatari regime's goals thank you so much for inviting me today in fact i must say that this is a very very critical national security issue for india and you know as i found in this these 1200 transactions that this has been going on since 2008 but the case in india is a little
10:28 complicated and a little more convoluted and mysterious i must say because the state intelligence agencies in kerala uh and some of the national level intelligence agencies they were flagging the you know i would say the infiltration of the foreign money and they add to some organizations like pfi for the last three decades but due to some political reasons and because it suited some of the political actors the issue was never taken then in 2012 there was one huge website you know not very prominent they also revealed a set of documents you know which uh brought forth these transactions but most importantly in the each charity this you know the the recent investigation which i did now i came across this data i mean this was the most i would say you know detailed uh exposing on how they were funneling money and the interesting part is that you know it was the 1200 transactions were there and they came to the eight groups basically and most interesting let me just know yes so
11:31 there's a long list okay the largest transaction came to salafi philanthropic society it's a kerala based group and the total number of transactions was 769 and it in in figures it was 4.9 us million dollar now it must be brought to uh to highlight that uh caroline is the state which sent the highest number of foreign fighters to isis from india and kerala has been witnessing a very strong onslaught of wahabi extremist influence over the last two to three decades because there's this huge population of expatriates the kerala people working in the middle eastern countries in the gulf countries and they come under these especially the middle eastern wahabi or extremist influences and certainly i mean because of those linkages that they are able to better exploit like what these what this charity funnels into india now most interestingly i'll just bring some more facts you know which will be of interest to the audience and the people interested in
12:33 counterterrorism salafi philanthropic is also has ties with raf that's another qatar charity which has uh you know strong relationship with the al-qaeda affiliates like jabat al-nusra and muslim brotherhood and then the dr hussain madhur he is heading the kerala philanthropic society and dr hussain motherboard is also the head of kerala which is the largest salafi group of kerala and in the past many people uh with isis who later on joined isis they were found to have previous links with this organization uh though in public domain the organization the claims to be a progressive organization but it has been found in various instances that they disseminate very radical and extremist content so this gentleman dr hussain he in a facebook video message openly praised dr mr amma mako and we all know who mr zakir naik is mr
13:39 zakir naik was the head of the peace education foundation and he allegedly inspired the isis attackers in bangladesh and after that i mean since then he has been absconding from india and he was always preaching very radical extremist content now many employees of the peace education foundation of which mr m akbar was the head they were found to have ties with the isis in fact the main coordinator of iskp in kerala abdul rashid abdullah he was once the employee of peace foundation and mr allegedly as told by abdul rashid abdullah he tried to protect the identity of two of the employees of the peace foundation because they had traveled to afghanistan to join issk so i mean i just want to highlight how these organizations in kerala which are receiving which received this biggest brand from the e-charity they have very strong ties with the isis affiliates or the people who were joining isis and in their schools they were already very extremist content
14:41 secondly another large cache went to the symposium educational charitable society which was nowhere uh to be found in the public domain no online presence nothing but then we found that they were sending money to a very remote district in up superficially or in the public domain most of the people would say that they were sending money to build mosques or some kind of welfare works but they were funding money to al-faro which is an organization with salafi beliefs working in that area and the organization was very active against the and the sufi muslims which is the liberal i would say mildly liberal and the local strain of islam but at odds with the wahabi extremists and uh they were trying to i mean involvement for polarizing activities communal activities so i mean this is you know i mean i'll just address the other issues later when you ask more questions but this is what i want to highlight that some of these organizations that they have very strong links with the people
15:43 who joined isis or nurtured those kind of ideologies and they are trying to reach out to the very small and remote parts of india okay um fascinating that it is so close to even isis that's uh that's really shocking martha are you focused mostly on money going to european countries and you've detailed several instances similar i suppose to epinev that gifts were going um to mosques that had very close ties with isis including one where an isis recruited recruiter regularly preached prior to his arrest was it prevalent do you think that gifts were given in europe to mosques that had isis recruiters and do you think they had a goal and de facto of supporting isis in this way or is this sort of a side effect so i think um so europe received only a small portion and so as cliff mentioned um there was a total of 70 70 770 million um just globally distributed
16:48 europe got a small portion but what's interesting in europe is that um i think often struggled to find um enough funding um such as in france so i think that gives qatar um a huge influence when they are giving when they're just giving as much money to these um these islamic centers and so um yeah i think it's very interesting that in all these different countries in europe that we looked at um mosque after mosque was directly tied to either isis or al-qaeda this type of terrorist organization so i think you mentioned there was one that had a isis preacher who was there and at the time the swedish security um service because this one was in sweden said there was a clear picture of radicalization and recruitment um at that mosque and another mosque also in sweden where the imam applauded isis for taking over the iraqi city of north sources was 2014 and even encourages followers to finance isis
17:51 so um as for whether qatar is uh directly supporting um isis i don't think that this gives us enough information to but i but i think it's uh undeniable that qatar is clearly supporting um extremism throughout europe and as we can see with these ties to isis and al-qaeda that can that can directly lead people being radicalized and eventually to terrorist attacks fascinating um so i'm going to ask one more question and then we'll go to audience questions so if any of the would like to ask a question go into the q a section and you can type in a question that can hopefully be asked on the air in the meantime got one more um also martha you noticed in your article up until 2014 saudi arabia was pumping a lot of money into foreign islamic organizations many of which were troubling but that has been massively scaled back in the past seven years or so um and the saudi arabia further as everybody
18:53 knows now considers organizations like the muslim brotherhood of threat rather than sort of a partner um and you mentioned the article that qatar has more or less seemed to take over where saudi arabia led off um and this goes to all of you and you can all answer in anything let's say do you think this has any wider implications about extremism extremism funding us strategy you know indian or middle eastern strategy and what is it you know how should this fact be handled and what does it mean i suppose i'll just say that i think that because saudi arabia funded extremism for so i think that many lawmakers or maybe not say updated and still maybe see saudi as a mainstream but i think what these grants tell us is that qatar has clearly replaced saudi as the main funding source for islamist extremism and i think that future policies need to take that into account certainly um the um the u.s government um has
19:56 historically had a decent relationship with qatar do any of you and any of you answer this um do you think that any of this kind of information is seeping into the u.s government um i mean what i'm asking do you think the united states has a how should i put this they have a way of addressing this i think that's what's being asked they have a method of addressing these kind of problems with guitar or are they just fully putting their head in the i would like to take this if that's possible i think there's sufficient evidence to show that this is not a partisan problem this is something across the whole political spectrum in that american politicians and our government are engaging with with qatari leaders whether that be in the qatari business council whether that be uh previous officials secretaries of state in particular and multiple administrations have recognized
20:58 the strong role that qatar plays we trust qatar to provide us with a military safe haven in the al udaid air base um we afford them so much opportunity to serve our country but at the end of the day um it is my belief that qatar is not a real ally as they continue to fund terrorist organizations and islamist organizations throughout the region that threaten american security and at the same time they're also giving funding to american and there is such a strong tie between qatar and the united states today and the fact that our country doesn't better um the security threat that qatar poses is is concerning and i think we need to that reportedly in the past um qatar actually reportedly hosted khalid sheikh between the years if i recall correctly 1993 and 1996 and it's rumored that qatar might have actually even helped khalid sheikh escape when the u.s was closing in
22:03 eventually escaping to pakistan and so we really need to reevaluate whether all of these benefits lucrative benefits that qatar affords the united states is it worth it yeah so there's a related question that an audience member is asking and that is from david levine we have an administration in washington that willfully ignores or denies the dangers of radical islam look at how they managed to turn the texas synagogue attack into i'm not sure what their motives were how can we ever through the most research such as the speakers possibly translate into effective government action when our own subvert such corrective actions so yeah i guess what that's really asking is you what would be a step that washington could take does anybody think that could sort of be effective policy it's trying to push back against this i guess you could go answer that too jordan i have to be careful how i answer this and in which role i would start off by just saying education is key educating our congressmen and our congress women and our senators about
23:07 the dangers that the qatari government poses the funding that it provides to hamas um the the assistance it's provided to muslim brotherhood affiliates in egypt um in yemen throughout uh north africa and the middle east we need to start with that i think that is ultimately what i can emphasize today i'll let others i guess take away if they want to discuss further specific policies anybody else uh cliff can i can i just take this question now though i'm not an expert on american issues in american affairs but i i seriously feel that especially among the political class there seems to be a very easy acute it's a lack of understanding especially when it comes to these radical extremist so i must say it's not just about when we look at the funding or when we look at you know some of these like you know groups funding or like even the government's funding the
24:09 the most crucial aspect is the ideology which is walking behind i have worked in jammu and kashmir over the last three four years and a five years must serve and you know i have come across a very simple fact that some of the groups know are working as a very legal entities like you know and they have tie-ups with the government they have links to the government but their core belief in a very extreme is in a very salafi wahabi strain of islam that is something which needs to be taken care of and until and unless they continue to stick to that so they are bound to get back to something which is very extremist or something which is ultimately aiding and supporting these terror groups whatever funding whatever charity is coming through these religious groups or the charities working with some religious association or god it is bound to when it is you know by default it has to go into something which is either extremist or which is either related to terror groups because again once again the linkages go to the ideology when the salafi ideology the
25:12 shias have no right to exist if you talk i have spoken to their clerics and all they very seriously argue that the problem is that i mean if if you go to the very rigid interpretation not a rigid a very i would say fundamentalist interpretation non-muslims they will have to live like a dimi and they will have to pay taxes to live as a citizens in a uh caliphate-controlled territory or even the non-conformist muslims which includes the bahraini or the sufi muslims of india or the shias or they don't have a right to exist as muslims the problem is the ideology so i guess you know we need to educate the lawmakers that any organizations which may be existing as a completely welfare entity but as long as they continue to stick to that ideology there is a problem uh that with that actually it's one other audience question they'll ask um um is qatar's aim in these donations mainly advancing qatar's or radical islam's objectives i guess i would say you know i guess the better way to ask
26:14 that i would say is you know can you tell the difference between um cutters interests and cutters ideology might be another way to put in if i may quickly take this i think it's important to understand the smoke machines that cotter employs they have an incredible airline that always wins awards qatar airways sponsoring sports um sponsoring media sponsoring universities qatar portrays itself as this patron of arts of the sport of modernity but at the end of the day at the same time it's still funding radical ideologies and we have to reconcile the charity that qatar is ultimately sponsoring versus the ideologies that are counter-intuitive that they're also sponsoring and when we understand these two together we realize that often a lot of qatar charades are simply smoke machines designed to disguise what its true ideologies are which are islamist in nature
27:18 um i think we have time for one more question here the u.s has a large air base in cutter which you guys have mentioned before uh i believe you did jordan and it needs to protect it might make it difficult to challenge cutter in these issues is there anything that can be do you think to change that dynamic jordan or anybody else i think we need to we need to be very careful regarding who qatar's allies are at the end of the day qatar pretends to be an ally for the united states and an aid in helping mediate the the situation regarding the taliban in afghanistan but at the end of the day it also offered safe haven to many of the taliban's leaders um it's also been rumored that coupler has supported the um the irgc and so we have to continue balancing the benefits of qatar's incentives and understanding the security threats and the security
28:21 threats are very real all right that's just about time for today thank you very much for quality can i just make a point before we wrap real quick we have to go in just a few yes yes so actually you know in my findings i came across that most of the organizations were getting funding in india they were changing names they were not existing in public domains and the intelligence and investigative agencies they either had a very poor track record of them or they were simply not aware so there is a very strong likelihood that some of these groups may route this money from india taking advantage of the empathy of the intelligence agency then this money may end up in the us through some of these uh i would say you know uh remote channels were coming from india because in u.s there's a much more investigation understand anyhow thank you very much for a fascinating webinar we have to uh get get on today but thank you martha jordan and epona for you for coming on and thanks for discussing this important issue i'm sure we'll be
29:23 hearing more about it in the future thank you very much