Webinar or Talk
Israel's May 2021 Riots: An Assessment with Sara Haetzni-Cohen
Watch on YouTube
Description
Last year’s conflict between Israel and Hamas prompted Arab riots against Jews. While private organizations mobilized to protect the innocent, the police generally kept clear, signaling that they did not want to get involved or punish the attackers. What lessons can be learned from these riots? How can the police – and Israel’s government more broadly – be convinced to change tactics vis-à-vis Israeli Arabs?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 hello and good evening from israel uh we have a very special uh talk tonight for our um at least four webinar we're going to be talking tonight with sarah herzley cohen on israel's may 200 2021 rights an assessment uh last year's conflict between israel and hamas prompted arab rights against while private organizations mobilized to protect the innocents the police generally kept clear saying that they do not want to get involved or punish the attackers what lessons can be learned from these really unprecedented rights how can the police and israel's government and decision makers more broadly be convinced to change tactics vis-a-vis israeli arabs especially mixed cities tonight we are honored to have sarah hezny uh guyan who is chairman of my israel israel a zionist movement promoting pro-israel values within the jewish state after serving as an itf officer she worked with global jewish communities for the jewish agency and ward beta the uh the
1:03 movement of the revisionist movement she has a ba and an m.a from hebrew university jerusalem she was born in kieva part of chevron she now lives in with her husband and their four children in jerusalem uh sarah sarah will talk for about 15 minutes including showing some videos and then we're opening it up for questions please if you have questions write them in the chat box and i'll get to them after sarah's initial presentation so if you'd like to unmute yourself and floor is yours hi um good evening good evening from jerusalem uh good afternoon thank you everyone everybody to come here today and thank you for your time thank you for your careness thank you very much ashley thank you navedomi your representative the the forum's representatives in israel um thank you for inviting me my name is nicola and i'm the head of my israel
2:07 organization my israel movement and i would like to share a few words about my and then to show you a short let's begin with just a few words about the the ngo that i'm running my israel is one of the largest grassroots organization here in israel it's dedicated to promoting zionist activism online but also on the ground the movement was founded back in 2010 by niftari bennett and diana choked uh two very famous uh people today um but it was before they went into politics of course we don't have we're an ngo we're not affiliated with any political uh of course we have an agenda but we're not affiliated with any party we what we do every day we drive we drive change by empowering empower empowering sorry uh are more than 200 000 uh followers
3:13 most of them here in israel most of them israelis to take action um in order to defend israel counter videos and strengthen the jewish communities all around israel of course also in judea and samaria and i'm here today to speak about what happened in israel in the in last may in may 2021 um because my point of view my my professional life but also my personal life um changed in this month uh please let me let me start by sharing a short video this is a very this is uh you're going to watch a few minutes of a video um that we we after after a the the riots finished in in may we decided that we need to tell the story so so we ne we
4:18 made a movie about what happened in loud in the city of vlad um and i'm gonna show you four minutes uh out of it then if you want the full movie it's a 40 minutes movie and i'll be happy to share the link with you it's on youtube so uh let me let me please just share my screen and let's let's watch a few minutes from this video sound all right
5:40 yes so sir when you share your screen if you also click on uh share sound okay let me stop this sorry because it worked before let's stop this the sharing and let's try to do it once again sorry sorry for okay here it is the sheer sound i'm going to take it a bit okay there it is okay i'm gonna stop the sharing um this
9:48 is the okay once again it's from our video it's from the movie that we we filmed and edited once we understood that the the israeli media is not going to tell the real story out of i don't know pc or her reasons um and we decided to make this movie because we we felt that we have to tell this story um and i'm here as i said before i'm here to tell uh the story of may 2021 in israel um out of the perspective of a lot of people also in israel but especially out of israel in the month of may there was one main event in israel and it's the war with hamas uh the operation uh the garden the guardian of the walls operation the shomera humor in that was the main event that happened here in israel but it's not the only event more than a week
10:51 the state of israel was under a rocket attack a very violent rocket attack from hamas in gaza the missiles hit all around israel um and the cities of ashkelon berchevas the road were war zones uh during this this operation but the story of show me the story of this operation from my point of view but and also from a lot of israeli's point of view is not the story is not the missiles from gaza because we already did settle said but it's all we already got used to to living in a constant war with gaza you know every couple of years every few years we have we have you know this this um operation in gaza we have a war with gaza we haven't worked with hamas but so what was different in this month in this month of may that the story of may 2021 is not what happened with gaza
11:55 is what happened here in what what's called little israel but in the cities in the mixed cities in in the main roads in um isolated uh towns in galilee in the negev this is the the main story the main earthquake that happened here in israel and this is what this is why i'm here for um to tell this story so so the operation of shomer operation in may in gaza but it all started when hamas decided to shoot missiles over jerusalem it was jerusalem day it was this you know they say flags celebration in the old city uh it was may 10 uh and hamas shoot uh missiles over jerusalem over the capital of israel because that's what he what was his his statement that we're fighting for jerusalem we're gonna free jerusalem right um uh it didn't start out of the blue uh it
13:00 was a client the climax of a very very months here in jerusalem in the city where where i live during these months it was also the ramadan fest there were every day every day there were violent from arabs through towards jews in jerusalem in damascus gates in the temple mount in shekhirah in the the light train everywhere you know in these parts of uh we called it the the tick tock intifada because they put it on tick tock and you know they made it very cool to attack uh to attack jews to to split uh coffee on jews uh um faces that you know uh to hit jews on the train it was it was really cool to do it and they put it on tick tock it was really a trend so this month was was a lot of tense here in jerusalem and then on monday's
14:02 afternoon may 10th uh it it blown up totally when hamas intervened uh and shoot missiles over the capital of israel so in this evening except missiles and i i i took my keys and we went uh to to the out of out of the the the main living room because we wanted to to take shelter uh we're not used to to have missiles here in jerusalem we have a lot of a lot of other uh terror attacks we but but missiles is new for us so anyway this evening accept missiles there was a very violent uh uh evening in all around israel what we call mixed cities where arabs and jews usually living together peacefully but in in that monday it all erupted and it it became a new a new center of violence that we haven't seen before so in jaffa in akko in ramle in lad
15:06 there was like a a volcano of our violence erupted uh from the arabs towards the the jews uh the jews and their property jewish property synagogues um their cars their apartments the the nice museum that was in lod but towards it was very clear where the violence began and the who who they aimed it so what we saw that on one hand we saw a violent mass writing from the arabs towards the jews on the other side what what you would expect as as a citizen that there will be someone who who will protect you and this is the the job of the police but what we found that the police was not uh and this is so so so we have you know that that's a blast on one hand mass of of arabs are attacking you and
16:10 calling allahu akbar and the this is death to to to the jews um and on the other side the police is is not there they're not there at all and people are calling the police and and begging them we have if you if you watch the movie you can hear the people are begging the police the police to come and the police is saying oh we're taking care of it we can't do it or we have a lot of incidents so just sit in your home and don't do anything don't go out uh et cetera so so we thought you know so we thought it it's a one evening um um a crisis but not uh it happened it continued to happen to be uh through a few days uh so it was monday and then tuesday and then wednesday and during these days no at all in these cities in these mixed cities in aqua in the afore in lord in ramle also in the galilee in the galilee and the negev um they blocked main main
17:15 roads with uh with fire they took the electricity out um and it was it was a big a big thing so in akko for um most of most of the the violence was around the old city um dozens of jewish shops and businesses were looted and uh hotels were set on fire one one person one jewish person avihar evan he's he was 84. he couldn't make it to escape the hotel that he was staying in and he was burnt to death um also in in the streets of aqua they they hunted jews so they they they succeeded to catch um you know three uh uh three people uh and they lynched them three of them were hardly injured crucial injured and they still you know
18:20 take these injured over their their body and their their um let's go to lord so in love uh half of the of this what what you need to if you do know if you don't know lord is is the center of of israel it's five minutes ten minutes away driving from the the uh international airport of israel from that bag and it's the center of israel it's not you know somewhere aqua is far away but not not that i'm justifying anything but aqua is far away so so you know nobody knows or it takes time the news to to to arrive but lord is in the center of what happened in lord that the the half of the city were set on fire the the um it started by rioting mass writing
19:25 that aimed to the municipality and to police cause and policemen and to jews every jew that they they could catch in in the street uh that they they did what they could do um so so these these are these riots also included a murder they lynched a one person who uh drove his car his name was igalio they lynched him by with the with with rocks they uh set on fire eight uh eight dozens of of cars of uh of the jewish that belong to jews were set on fire a few apartments they broke you know people ran away from from their apartments they took their families they took their kids and ran away uh so they too so they broke into the apartment
20:29 they looted the apartment and they set it on fire what we also met in lord that there were dozens of shooting uh shooting in the streets an illegal weapon held by the arabs in lord and it didn't happen in akko it did happen in london it took everything to to this very high level of violence not only rocks not only cocktail molotovs but also shooting that we never never met it before what now now let me talk about what what we did so we arrived uh to lod basically on on thursday so the whole mess started on monday and from monday to thursday let's say to wednesday night we were busy we were shouting through our keyboards um we pressured and we put you know we posted the videos and we called the
21:32 parliament members and we called the minister of the internal security and we we said you know someone needs to do something uh it's not about me to you know i i'm not supposed to do anything like this um so we try to to to put all our energy on waking up the on wednesday night we understood that it doesn't matter how how hard we we try and how loud we shout nobody's home you you know the police is not functioning uh the orders that they're getting is not they have no not enough policemen and the the orders that they're getting are very very moderate they couldn't shoot the the arabs that they couldn't even do they didn't really do anything and what we
22:35 decided that it's it's us or nobody so we physically arrived we physically arrived on thursday to i'm gonna finish in like in a few minutes uh three minutes um so we physically we decided to arrive to lord physically and to assist the local residents together we um we set we set a situation room uh that was placed in a youth club and we called any help we could get from the outside we recruited help from grassroots support we called volunteers to come to lord we asked people with licensed weapons to come and help us uh you know keep the the apartments that nobody will loot them and just save anything we could uh we called medics we called people with drones everyone we we can we
23:36 we called um we also uh we also founded a call center we recruited a a bus with the armored glass from the yasha console because we you know shooting all around the city and we wanted to to take volunteers from one place to another so we couldn't do it with private cars we asked the asha council to give us um a special bus that that if someone shoots at it that you know nothing happens um and with all this we protected we protected the city we protected the the local residents we protected the houses the um the community centers the uh the synagogues everything we could we wanted we worked in coordination with the police but the police did not uh help almost anything so what we did is a savory civil um the
24:39 change arrived on friday's eve when the police finally um brought special special forces and we you know we backed up uh we we're we we don't want to to be there we don't want to replace the police and then uh we just left uh very moderately and uh we we stayed there just to just to assist the elderly and uh to to give us assistance to anything that they need you know uh uh not on the not on the war zone after all this mess finished we understood we have uh another job and the job is to tell the story everywhere we can so this is why we uh edit we filmed and edited the movie five days in may uh we added the english subtitles and this is why we're act we're acting everywhere we can to raise awareness to understand we have a new
25:44 challenge here in israel a new danger uh you can also call it the new battle of that we never heard about we never thought about it before but the state of israel as a state not uh not the ngos also even though we're happy to help uh but the state of israel needs to be very anxious about this um these events these events happen again uh so uh thank you this is thank you thank you very much sarah for that uh listen uh i you know someone also experienced it uh there's so much to talk about there's so much are happening and really as you said this was the unprecedented part of that we've we've faced our kids we've had operations against hamas but this was really unprecedented and really you know touched the psyche of so many israelis because you know while we know that the mixed some of the big cities there can be tension we've never seen to that level so i'd like to ask you as a first question because time is running out
26:46 what do you recommend the government do to make sure that the next time uh there is some sort of operation or whatever it is uh that this doesn't happen again that's uh that's what would your recommendations be to the government to the decision-makers to the police the police cannot do it they they don't have enough uh forces they don't have enough um they can't do it uh by themselves uh they need more power they need more uh more units more you know they need to to to learn what they how the the how the special forces are uh acting in judea and samaria for example with civil uh population and try to copy to to inside of israel it might be sad uh it sounds sad but that's the situation now i want to tell you another thing ashley when we arrived to loud on
27:52 there were tons of policemen a lot of of policemen and police women they didn't do anything they didn't want to win they just you know you know what that what was their goal to to have quiet so when i came there and we said we called the the um the uh the the um assistance of of uh of uh the minister and we said listen we want to work with the police we don't want to we we don't want to do it alone um we want to work with the police and you know what he told me you want to help go away go back to your home and then i told him listen we're not going no anywhere now if you want to work with we'll be very happy to if you don't we are here do you think one of the uh the answers greg roman asked if one of the answers is to declare martial law and send in
28:55 the army maybe it's a job that the police simply can't do maybe it's a job for the idf as you said some of the units of which have more experience dealing with these sort of issues i do think i do think that we need special forces like in the us or or this this way or another you you can we can learn from the us we can copy it i don't know we i just know that the that the police cannot do it by itself they can't they're not capable of doing it they're saying it themselves you know i i'm we're we're making a lot of uh a lot of a lot of meetings in in the knesset in order to in order to to wake the system up and then the police representatives they come and they say we can't do it next time we can't do it ourselves next time so what we need now one thing that i do uh recognize that in the leadership of israel
30:00 unfortunately they don't want to deal with it it's not it's not politically correct to deal with it you know people just just want to to put it behind and to erase may and not not to deal with not to think okay we have you know something happened here in may it might be a one-time you know one-time show or one-time incident but it might not so what do you do if it's not the last time uh that it happens and i don't think uh what what i recognize and god help me and please please make me wrong um that uh the the leadership of israel is not dealing with it uh enough so so what we as an ngo we're getting every week so last week we got three uh three different people from all around israel calling us and saying
31:03 listen we need to take care of ourselves can you help us i found a i don't know something for for our local local uh neighborhood watch sort of thing yes something so can you help us can you help us connect the police so they're they're calling an ngo to do it that's that's absurd sir but we only have time for really one more question but there has been a request to put the link to the video in the chat box so while i ask the final question if you can maybe uh put the link to the video so people can watch it uh after this but i would like to we asked what what can be done next time you know god forbid there is a sort of uprising whatever you want to call it so local intifada but what can be done in between is it a mentality change that needs to happen amongst the government amongst the police and what's the decision-makers is there something that uh can be done at what level uh forget about waiting
32:05 for the next level of violence what can be done now when there is no operation ongoing that there isn't a heightened sense of violence what can we what what can you can you give us two or three practical steps if you were in a decision-making position what would you recommend to do in these mixed cities like lord rambler and others okay here so the first thing you need to strengthen the police you have to do it um you need to strengthen the police in these cities but not only uh not only in these cities uh also in the negev when they have tons of of uh right of weapon uh you need to strengthen the police you need to to see more police in the streets and you need to give them uh the right orders okay so so they can have uh the tools to to deal with these little terrorists um this is the first thing the the second thing is about the judicial system so
33:09 the the first thing that you would expect that will happen is that the judicial system will look on may uh and we'll see may as you know as something that you need to to deal with it very severely we don't see it we don't say it the judges just today uh judges give very light punishments to the writers uh and they you know they just as i said before they try to erase uh may they try to say yeah so it it's not as dangerous today as it was in may it was a one-time um eruption um and you don't i don't recognize the judicial system that's supposed to to be one of the you know it's a very important um uh in in this string of of uh of uh
34:12 of justice that they don't give the right punishments they give very light punishments um they didn't catch everyone they put all you know that they put the the cove with the mask so so they can't be recognized uh but you need to put this the shin bat in in in this uh in this issue and take you know and give very strong punishments to to whoever did all the all these crimes uh so this is the the second thing and you need to talk about it you can't say what you hear all the time in as a pattern goes in israel that they're saying that these um these um terrorist attacks were not uh it came out of poverty it came out of uh out of uh you know they have too much uh illegal um illegal uh weapon in the in the arab population so they try to give
35:17 excuses but if you won't tell the truth to yourself you couldn't you can't deal with this uh in the right and the proper and and one last thing that i think that it's very uh is very important is to collect the the illegal the illegal um um you could see that in lawd it took one step thank you thank you very much sarah for the fascinating insight into what were very traumatic events last year i would recommend everybody to watch the video i'm sorry we went over a little bit uh tonight that was because of technical issues at the beginning thank you so much i'm sorry we didn't get to all of your questions there's a lot of uh you're you know i'm sure sarah you can approach her in a variety of ways to find out i'll write my email um i'm gonna write my email uh down here so
36:21 you can please feel feel free to contact so please uh you know feel free to contact sarah to ask him more questions as i said that's uh uh there's a lot to talk about uh you know there's i think there's almost 30 questions which unfortunately weren't able to get to so please write down the email uh and watch the video to find out more about this because this really is uh has become a new front you know we've had a front against hamas against hezbollah against others but we've never seen at least not for many generations such a front in our in our cities and really in our major central towns so this is something that we should be keeping up thank you again sir and good night from all of us thank you