Webinar or Talk
Making Sense of the Hamas-Israel War with Daniel Pipes
Watch on YouTube
Description
The fighting that unexpectedly began on Oct. 7 has many puzzling aspects. For example, why did Hamas initiate hostilities against a much stronger opponent? Why were Israelis taken by surprise? Why did Israel receive 100-0 support in the U.S. Senate but now must defend itself against charges of genocide at the International Court of Justice?
Daniel Pipes, president of the Middle East Forum, will answer these and other questions. He has just completed a book with the working title "Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated."
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 23, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:09 all right good afternoon welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have Mr Daniel pipes president here at the Middle East forum and whom has just completed his latest book with the working title Israel Victory how zionists win acceptance and Palestinians get liberated join is to discuss making sense of the Hamas Israel war Mr pipes will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Daniel pipes thank you Stacy and good afternoon ladies and gentlemen it's a great pleasure to be back on the Middle East Forum podcast I actually initiated this almost four years ago in March of 2020 it's my first time back as a speaker we've had some close to 600 podcasts uh so I thank the many many
1:14 speakers who have joined us and in particular Ashley Perry who has done roughly a third of them every Wednesday so thank you to all and thank you to Stacy for your great moderation uh through all these years um as you heard I've just finished a book on Palestinian Israeli conflict and so I watch what's happened since October 7th with a special interest and I'd like to take up five topics excuse me which I find somewhat mystifying and would try and clarify I'll go through four of them fairly quickly and dwell more on the final one sorry about my first point is what's wrong with the Israeli military and more broadly security establishment how could it let something like October 7th happened and I would answer that I think that the first Zionist and then Israeli security establishment the military the
2:19 intelligence other Security Services law enforcement have been in rather precipitous decline over the past Century the zionists were very clever and very accomplished when they had few means and they the Israelis won an extraordinary war of independence in 1948 49 they won was probably the most lopsided victory in modern history in 1967 and then from then on which is now over half a century they have been in Decline famously in 1973 they failed to see what was coming from Syria and Egypt but there were further terrible uh problems in 1993 goal Accords made no sense at all to bring in your most violent and vehement enemy to be your neighbor and nearly Sovereign 2005 to leave Gaza and allow your enemy to take over
3:21 there uh the Israeli security establishment is not what it used to be and so 202 3 comes not as such a great shock after 1973 2005 that what it used to be it needs a real kick such as it just got in order to recognize its deep problems second while the Israelis responded to October 7th with a great deal of talk about Victory which was music to my ear um I think they quickly reverted to to a non Victory approach one sees over the last three months in a bit a lot of reversion example even though the gazen workers are now in retrospect understood to have spies Israelis immediately allowed in some 6,000 West Bank workers who presumably could be spies as
4:25 well uh the Israeli government decided to send Monies to the Palestinian Authority it has been AAS in K as an intermediary it has been supplying Gaza with fuel and water it has been ignoring the threat of West Bank building it has all it is there's talk of allowing the Hamas leadership to flee Gaza and set up somewhere else perhaps in Qatar turkey and there has been a surge in support not for those who are intent on ending hamas's presence but on those who are more moderate and less intent on Victory so I don't think there has been a fundamental change as in the United States after 911 when everything changed so one heard in Israel after October 7th I don't think everything changed I think what we're seeing is a reversion to the
5:30 then uh looking third Point looking at the responses to October 7th I think there are two responses one is that around the world from the United States of Saudi Arabia to India and Beyond you see that the establishment has favored Israel while the islamists and the leftists have favorite Hamas so uh there wasn't much attention paid but the house us house voted 410 to 12 or 412 to10 I forgot which uh in favor of Israel very strong resolution right after the uh the massacre the Senate voted 100 to zero uh Joe Biden came out at very strong States uh liberal figures like John fedman the senator from Pennsylvania came very strongly for Israel one saw many European leaders go to Israel stand
6:35 solidarity but then over time sympathy has eroded sympathy for Israel has eroded and that for Hamas has increased there's been a deep unease with Israel doing roughly what the United States and its allies did against Isis going in and taking out the enemy deep on ease and the Israelis are losing support all the time fourth point is that Hamas has a unique logic I don't have any historical example comparable to Hamas Hamas seeks death and destruction it doesn't seek to seek to win on the battlefield it seeks to lose it seeks for the people that it that it governs to be harmed to be bombed to be homeless to be hungry to be dead this is aasa's approach it is using the gazin as Canon
7:44 FL but not the usual kind of Canon F which goes and attacks the enemy this is Canon F which suffers and you can see how different Hamas is from hisbah in Lebanon and the PA in the West Bank both both of them are far more conventional they assess they look they make trouble they play games but they don't look to get smashed hisbah inadvertently in 2006 killed a couple of Israelis captured I think three Israelis and that led to allout war and right after the allout war the head of isbah hassanah said you know what if I known this would happen we we wouldn't have captured and killed those soldiers he thought that there was understanding you know you you keep it simmering which is in fact the case right now there's a simmering between hisbah and Israel hisbah is careful not to provoke careful not to get f35s screeching over Lebanon and bombing things Hamas is not careful Hamas wants
8:48 to have death and destruction the West the West Bank under the Palestinian Authority is much more careful uh Mahmud Abbas plays games he works with the Israelis here he murders them there but he's careful he doesn't want to be bombed he doesn't want to be uh overthrown he doesn't want to be uh destroyed in the way that Hamas does and I believe that Hamas is unique in this logic of losing in order to get sympathy from its allies in particular the islamists around the world and the hard left especially the left in general and the hard left in particular and it works to certain extent uh as I just mentioned support for Israel has eroded over the last three months my final point is to try understand the allies of Hamas they have engaged in a campaign that is hard to understand it's
9:54 aggressive uh it looks counterproductive for example the pramas elements in the United States have disrupted parades the Thanksgiving Day Parade in New York City the Rose Ball Parade in Pasadena uh they have disrupted traffic major ways to such airports as LAX and JFK they have blocked Manhattan one one early morning morning blocking Bridges and tunnel Havoc they have attacked Christian ceremonies Christian Carol events raising money for the blind in Melbourne Australia uh Christmas party of democratic operatives in Detroit uh they have attacked the
10:56 military they have uh vocally and in some cases try to make trouble for Air Force bases uh they serated Lloyd Austin the US Secretary of Defense with um horrible diddies outside his home on Christmas morning uh they have made themselves obnoxious why and then in another level entirely the houthis are doing the same in the Red Sea they're making themselves obnoxious they have little to gain by uh in interrupting Global Commerce they gain Nothing by having ships Go Around the Horn of Africa rather through the sez Canal it doesn't do them good uh it seems good to it is also the militias in Syria and Iraq have attacked American forces over 100 times in the
12:05 100 days since October 7th more than once a day so between these Antics in the west and these attacks lethal attacks in the Middle East what's going on are these hostile actions merely self-indulgent or they part of some strategy now they certainly seem to harm the Hamas cause the Melbourne audience for example booed heartily those who had ruined the fundraiser by screaming slogans um The Christmas rebers in Detroit were extremely annoyed by the uh disruption and recall the black Arab tensions that have been in that City for decades uh when the police eventually cleared the protesters in Pasadena the crowd burst into cheers interfering with Supply chains in the Red Sea alienates governments businesses and consumers worldwide so the goal
13:11 obviously is not to win friends rather what these allies of Hamas are doing I suggest is to imitate the tactics that I just delineated of Hamas the goal is martyrdom symbolic or real to win Islam and leftist support now this is highly unusual again jihadis normally want to win on the battlefield Hamas has purposely initiated conflicts against the more powerful enemy the Israeli military wanting to be smashed so it can become the victim destruction and death serve it its appeal Hamas wins politically by losing militarily following Hamas its American and mid East groups or Western these groups also aspire to win sympathy and support by losing disrupting Christmas parties football game parades New York City traffic and storming the White House as they did just a couple of days ago all go law enforcement into at least
14:15 arresting the protesters and maybe even beating them up likewise the houthi attacks on Red Sea shipping and the proxy attacks on US forces in Syria and Iraq intend to provoke an overwhelming us retaliation SE thus massacring Israelis disrupting world trade and inconveniencing inconvenience inconveniencing American motorists are not the primary goal but a means to the end which is to bait Israeli and American forces and thereby to AG Grant Hamas the houthis and their many allies it works and those allies do find such inspiring note in particular how Gau and suffering has replaced the Israeli trauma but this victimization game plays with fire a step too far such as the October 7th Massacre or possibly a hothy destruction of an oil tanker or fatalities at US military bases risks
15:20 jeopardizing the very existence of these organizations and therefore I conclude that despite their impressive short-term successes I think that overreaching and therefore failure are to be appear to be their eventual fate all right thank you so much for that uh we have quite a few questions coming in uh JLS is the two-state solution essentially dead and was it always a western fantasy I don't think so I think it's a fantasy now uh given that the PA or any other Palestinian group uh seeks the destruction of Israel but one day if there is an Israel Victory and a Palestinian defeat and a palestin giving up on its the rejectionist uh goals yes there can be so it's it's not possible anytime soon but it's an abstract possibility yes it's it's conceivable thank you Eric silov asked
16:25 do you think the Israeli objectives for the Hamas War were realistic in lie of the world politics and the entrenched Hamas ideology in Gaza well we all called for Destruction elimination of Hamas me myself included at the very beginning and now 100 days on it's a little murky as to what exactly this means I think what it means is one the ending of any Hamas control in Gaza and two uh reduction or perhaps even elimination of its funding by States uh the ideas will continue but the organization need not so no I don't think it's unrealistic it is realistic and the Israelis are determined uh prime minister Netanyahu gave a talk just to yesterday day before in which he said we are determined to have total Victory so and you know no one's going to stop us not the international court of justice
17:27 not our allies going to go for this I seem determined good for them thank you on that note um Larry Greenberg asked given the geopolitics can Israel really extract itself from the vassalage to the US well vasel is a strong term uh the US is a great power the great power Israel is a small country 330 million versus 10 million uh Israel cannot build its own fighter aircraft its own uh Naval vessels and so forth Israel needs allies and in particularly United States but there is forse trading going on Israelis can bargain not just for money but also for leverage Israelis have Alternatives that they can turn to United States needs Israel it's not just Israel needs United States United States needs Israel Middle East is at the center of the world it's extremely volatile there is no other country in the region that shares our and with with which we had a strategic
18:31 Alliance turkey was that way but not for the past 20 years so Israel stands alone in the Middle East we need it it needs us so I don't think it's vassage these are the tensions inherent in an alliance between a great power and a small power very well put uh Kenneth gross ask what will it take for the US to demand a Surrender by Hamas as opposed to this U ceasefire mission if the US were to stand up to Hamas would the there would still be multiple protests here um but would that make uh we won't make the situation worse by siding with Israel correct well the United States has become an active military ally of Israel without saying so much the United States has within the last few days killed a number of houthis and attacked a number of houthi installations in Yemen uh was not portrayed as something helpful to Israel but rather for freedom of navigation but in fact the United States
19:35 of Israel on the same side so that Alliance has deepened also earlier maybe in October November uh us ships shot down missiles going from Yemen to Israel something that had not happened before so things are changing and while uh there's a reluctance on both sides Israeli and American to know what I just said I think it is a new reality thank you and I will follow up with question of my own on that one um you mentioned the establishment versus the islamist and leftists U sport foras can the establishment stay strong with Israel uh and and or will it cave to the um islamist and leftist pressure well there are three groups basically you have the anti-israel left by the way I don't use the word prop Palestinian they're not in the least prop Palestinian they're anti-israel they couldn't care less about Palestinians there's the anti-israel cohort uh which is primarily on the left
20:38 and which is vehemently against Israel Jeremy Corbin for example has joined the South African effort at the icj and then you have those who are supporting Israel strongly supporting Israel and unwavering in their support then you have those in the middle who feel the pressures Joe Biden would be a perfect example his instinct is friendly to Israel but they're plenty in the Democratic party who are hostile to Israel so he's trying to have it both ways he's trying to please both sides The Diplomatic missions of Anthony blinkin reflect the confusion of this position where this middle Group which includes many many Western governments including the American where they will land is still unclear but so far they have basically stood by Israel providing arms as I just mentioned in effect siding with Israel militarily uh it has they have wavered
21:42 they're no longer where they were three months ago but they are still there so I think I think the record suggests that this middle group will waveringly stick with Israel thank you very much uh Steve even asked given what we know now about the scope extent and sophistication of the underground city and tunnel systems how could this have been developed without the knowledge uh of the Israeli intelligence and given that unra is so embedded in every aspect of Gaza is it not possible or credible that the UN body uh could not have been aware of the intent of this well unra is not defending Israel the Israelis basically knew they called it the Metro uh they knew about the tunnels but they what they didn't know is that Hamas was ready to attack in the way it did on October 7th uh they had this notion that Hamas was settling in and becoming more a governing Authority and
22:48 was losing its revolutionary Zeal and Hamas played along with that and encouraged that so the Israelis were blind to what they were seeing they saw it and there are plenty of reports of Israelis who in the military who were watching this and intelligence and saw that uh they were that Hamas Was preparing but the high command just was blind to it it was a conceptual problem it was not an intelligence problem it's a conceptual problem and it's akin to the except the akin to the conceptual problem the israelit had in 1973 they assumed that Anar sadad would not attack until he had more advanced planes they just assumed it so they didn't see what was coming because they had a con concept what they call in Hebrew conia they had a concep then they had a concep now that caused them to be blind to the facts at their fingertips thank you uh Jr Pride ask the igc seems to be anti-israel in principle how should Israel respond regardless of
23:52 any decision by the I JC J IJ I think the Israelis are doing the right thing which is to go and uh present their case to find someone who is got a good internationally uh they might well lose but I don't know how consequential is look again there are three parties there are those who support Israel there are those who are against Israel and then there are those in the middle who are not quite sure and all the attention is focused on them will they be influenced by the icj will they be INF inuenced by the media coverage will they be influenced by a whole array of developments but I would suggest that as time goes on that middle Tren between Pro and anti-israel is getting smaller and smaller more and more people especially the last three months have picked sides and know what they think and so uh my opinion will not be changed by the icj's yours probably won't be changed by it the number of people whose
24:56 in whose views will be be affected by the icj verdict probably is not that great Fair Point uh Doris ress uh where where is China in all of this what about China are they involved China's had a pretty good relationship with Israel for decades now but that has seriously gone South The Tick Tock the Chinese social media is vehemently anti-semitic uh and the Chinese government is siding ever more with the forces Iran in particular so China is coming out of the neutral zone into the Hostile and it makes sense because United States is close to Israel so China doesn't like Israel thank you L uh Brodney asks how do we bring the kidnapped home alive my advice to the Israelis would be
25:59 to deemphasize the hostages not to make this a major focus of public attention but to focus on Victory and I think that is the way to get them back alive not through yellow ribbons and photographs of those missing I think it's a enormous mistake it would be smart to push that whole topic aside say to the hostage families your your loved ones are very much on our mind we're doing everything we can we're not doing it by dealing with Qatar and Hamas we're doing it by winning thank you uh Steve asked where do you see the Israeli hisbah face off going was I mentioned earlier hisbah is playing the game knows the rules of the game Israelis know the rules of the game in 2006 the Israelis broke the rules of the game they're not likely to break him now uh his does not want to be smashed sees that the Israelis are
27:02 angry and I think the last few months are likely to the the lowgrade hostilities of the last three months are likely to continue I would be surprised if it flares into allout Wars such as was in 2006 or now in Gaza that hisbah doesn't want that thank you uh BPZ asks any IDE who will uh live and or govern Gaza after Victory well I don't know who will I know who I want of I believe there are plenty of Gins who despise Hamas and despise being used as Canon for Hamas and who want normal lives by normal lives I mean lives comparable to those in Egypt the West Bank or Jordan where they're not well let me not C West Bank Egypt or Jordan where they're not particularly friendly to Israel but they live side by side with Israel without
28:05 making trouble uh I think there is a body a cohort of Gins who will work with Israel to set up an Administration a police force and govern The Entity as a quasi governmental agency I think it's possible and I very much hope the Israelis go in that direction I hope the US government doesn't get in their way this is the best thing for Gaza the best thing for Israel absolutely and in our final few minutes here Jonathan Green asks what will total Israeli defeat of Hamas ultimately look like will there be a sitdown and a signing of a surrender document Japan or Germany in World War II or will the there be no hamnik left to surrender and the surrender will be assumed I don't think there has been a surrender ceremony since 1945 perhaps there has been but I can't think of any no there will not be any surrender ceremony but there will be a collapse of Hamas Authority and Hamas ability to
29:09 reach into Gaza and provoke hostilities against Israel that will be victory for Israel thank you so much um so sorry I didn't actually plan another one um but yes we have so very many questions left uh I truly apologize uh that we have not gotten to all of them they were fantastic but we can do another we can do another five minutes oh wonderful okay so Steve asks what does it take to allow Israelis in the north to return home this is a big problem that Hamas sorry hisbah hostilities have disrupted the lives caused hundreds of thousands of Israelis to have to move away from the northern border the border with Lebanon uh I think the Israelis need to reach some kind of uh one of these unofficial agreements with hisbah that they stop this and they do that by making it clear to hisbah that this is
30:12 unacceptable uh that this will cannot go on um and I think hisbah would would recognize that yeah they can't keep 300,000 or so Israelis from living in their homes indefinitely but the Israelis are have a full plate and they focus more on Gaza than on Lebanon so that hasn't happened yet thank you David Kaplan asked how much is the conflict with Hamas similar to addressing the symptom and not the virus I.E Iran I ultimately yeah Iran is the head of the Hydra and uh it is behind the attacks in Iraq Syria Lebanon Gaza Yemen uh who knows where they'll go next yeah the Iranian regime has to be addressed and in particular the nuclear infrastructure has to be addressed uh the IR the Iranians are going ahead full speed uh us shows concern but has made
31:16 it clear it's not going to do anything who knows that could be a faint but at this point there's no reason to disbelieve it yeah Iran is the ultimate source of so many of the Middle East problems and the US government has never since 19 sorry 1979 made it a goal to overthrow the government of Iran we've never helped dissidents uh to to do anything and particularly in 2009 we do anything uh year plus ago with the uh many demonstrations across the country we didn't do anything uh it's time to conf front the real source of m e problems tan thank you uh Jack B say if the icj rules against Israel isn't it possible that any and all officials Minister even the PM could be arrested while traveling abroad I'm not one to tell you the legal uh fine points of it but it could well
32:23 complicate Israeli lives uh in countries that would accept verdict uh and presumably Israelis would know which countries they are um but probably those are the countries that they wouldn't want to go anyway but yeah you're right it it could complicate their lives legally speaking Fair Point uh thank you Amelia lit says has there been any consequences for the journalists accompanying Hamas uh hamas's murderous Rampage they've been noted and pointed out but I don't know that they've been fired much much less penalized not that I'm aware of thank you uh Ethel asks meanwhile the slaughter in uh Russia Ukraine continues with no outcry about the innocent civilians being killed uh why the different approach why when Israel asks is there's such intense scrutiny yep not just Ukraine but uh are you aware of the 1027 not 107 but 1027
33:31 Insurgency that took place in October in uh Myanmar and Burma major major effort by the insurgents to overthrow the horrible government there major event um you have to look hard to find any news coming out it uh much less Sudan or Eastern Congo or other much larger uh conflict zones yeah well I think the Ence is that when westerners are involved against non-westerners it's news and all the more so when it's Jewish westerners but westerners in general fting non-westerners the Americans in Iraq or French in West Africa or other examples it gets a lot more attention than when it's non-westerners fighting thank you um so Helena asked what about Russia which side are they on there's
34:34 there's a lot of geopolitical questions here well this uh October 7th has had a lot of lot implications places you'd never expect I mean Harvard University's president you know never expect uh the Russians have become ever more clearly aligned and uh allied with uh Iran and so they are ever more clear on that side but the Russians don't need more enmity so they're not making trouble for Israel gratuitously they don't need Israel to make trouble for them so there's a certain kind of ceasefire between uh Russia and Israel particularly in Syria they're not they're not making trouble for each other maybe in the future but not today Jack werman asks uh given that Hamas does not seek victory in Gaza how will Israel determine its end point in the world war well Hamas does seek Victory but not on the battlefield it seeks it by
35:38 finding support around the uh I answer the question the same way Hamas needs to be eliminated from holding any kind of power in Gaza I think thank you and uh before we go is there is there any chance for escalation of the Israel Hamas war is there any indication that this could spread to Iran and the US and world powers getting involved in this well it has Yemen boies United States Britain it has already spread it could spread to Lebanon uh I don't think the Syrian government is looking for trouble with but uh it could spread in other ways uh there are reports suggesting that Iranian insurgents and uh conspiracist are on the march in Jordan uh who
36:41 knows uh there there are plenty of implications far more than I ever would have imagined three months ago and they've not stopped in particular the houthi disruption of World Trade has potential for all sorts of trouble what if they do blow up an oil tanker imagine what comes after that yeah it's potentially a lot more ahead thank you so much these are troubling times but I'm sure here at the Middle East Forum we'll be keeping you all a breast of the situation and any uh research that we find out in articles all right so thank you so much Mr pice we have come to the close of our webinar thank you so much for joining us again for the first time in four years here my pleasure thank you for all the questions I see there plenty more I'm sorry we can't get to them perhaps on another occation absolutely we'll have to have you back uh for our viewers please join us Wednesday at 3M Eastern for Israel
37:44 Insider with Ashley Perry thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a