Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
PM Netanyahu has a problem. He wants to delay or dismiss most of the judicial reform proposals that led to internal unrest. But his coalition partners insist on passing those reforms. Is a government crisis brewing?
Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15. He is president of Reconectar, an organization dedicated to relinking the over 200 million descendants of Spanish and Portuguese Jews to Israel and Jewish life. Originally from the UK, he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a BA from University College London and an MA from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 27, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:07 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider with Ashley Perry I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Ashley Perry advising to the Middle East forums Israel office join us here each week to update us on all the events going on in Israel Mr Perry will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli Affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much Stacy and good evening from Israel it's been another tumultuous week in Israel um it started really uh on Monday um with the passing of the first reading we should remember it's only the first of three readings of um a law that would end the Supreme Court's ability to use uh what's been called the reasonableness Clause uh to
1:12 overturn government decisions let's just take a step back um to see how we got here ever since this government came in there's been talk of judicial reform and obviously uh you know anyone who's been following the situation and Israel knows that there's been Mass protests and opposition to uh the the idea of judicial reform or at the proposals that were put forward uh at the beginning especially the idea idea that everything would be sort of passed in one go the ability of the car the composition of the current judicial appointments committee uh the ability of the Supreme Court to strike down laws uh this reasonableness clause and a host of other uh reforms um when there was great big great pushback not just from the streets with hundreds of thousands taken to the streets against it but also International reactions specifically from the US but also from other uh Partners from from Europe and elsewhere
2:16 from the Jewish world uh from ngos from organizational heads etc etc um then uh that basically pushed uh the situation where Netanyahu decided he would not be able to pass everything in one go and what he would do is he would then do what's been described as the salami method which means they'll do this piece by piece uh Yahoo has said that there's certain things that he's completely removed from the table or at least that's what he says to the outside world in for immediate interviews like the uh taking away the ability of the Supreme Court to override government decisions he said that's off the table but uh here in Israel he said it's on the table uh and that goes very much to the tightrope uh walk that prime minister Netanyahu was doing at the um what happened this week as I said is uh according to the opposition at least or the opponents on the street more so even than those in the knesset
3:20 um was to take the concept or the ability of the Supreme Court to strike down decisions on the basis of what's being called the reasonable Clause that means it's not specifically any one law that over rules that that the justices can say overalls a particular decision but whether the act or the policy or the law itself is reasonable now that's very controversial because if one looks at the origins of the reasonableness Clause they actually go back to 1948 in the UK that was where president was said and the precedent itself was that uh any decision or law that any reasonable person would find objectionable now that means only in vague stream cases uh would this reasonableness Clause be enacted uh Israel's uh judicial bench Supreme Court bench uh led by Howard Barack which was very much uh part of the judicial Revolution basically extended that to anything that they felt
4:23 was unfair unreasonable Etc this really in essence is probably uh the weakest part of the judicial reform this um taking away the ability of the Supreme Court to rule on the basis of um was actually even conceited behind closed doors at the president's by the opposition in negotiations over government reform it's probably the thing that most opponents would readily agreed to as long as it doesn't interfere in the justices ability to strike down um uh the ability of the government to appoint people for example aryadari was removed from his position because the Supreme Court said it was unreasonable that he uh serve as a minister after being convicted of uh Ford and all the other things uh in the past accepting a plea bargain etc etc and they forced
5:26 prime minister Netanyahu to remove area Dairy from this position that pot which wires many of the judicial former opponents was actually not even part of this law so as I said this law that was passed on Monday was for let's say most moderates in the opposition not the most significant part of judicial reform yet for the opponents on the street especially those who are running the um this was still very much a bone of contention and they felt that this was a threat to democracy they took to the streets on Tuesday after the passage of the night passed by 64-56 which is a long Coalition opposition lines uh we did see massive demonstrations at the airport around Tel Aviv around Jerusalem there are many many places throughout the country and it basically said sent a very strong message to Netanyahu that we're not going to allow you to do anything we're not going to to allow you
6:28 to pass even the weakest quote-unquote of the judicial reforms but basically what this really does is put uh Netanya on a bit of a quandary because he sees that the effect that the demonstrations are having on the Israeli economy he sees the effect that the demonstrations are having on security for example there have been quite a few petitions over previous months uh by Air Force pilots by people in intelligence agencies in Israel's hallowed 8200 unit uh people say that they will refuse to sub um if there is judicial reform and we saw yesterday that four Pilots uh did not come to serve in their units and apparently according to according to Behind Closed Doors this enraged Netanyahu who made the point that we cannot have a scenario where people do not come and do their service this endangered digital security it doesn't matter if it's for this side or that
7:31 side we cannot have that situation but the fact is that situation is happening which is uh really causing a lot of problems for Netanyahu at home and abroad what we saw this morning was or yesterday I should say was a New York Times editorial by Thomas Friedman um which basically claimed that the U.S Administration the byte Administration was reassessing U.S Israel ties now that caused quite a Tremor throughout uh Israel because it is known that Thomas Friedman is close to the Democrats close to democratic administrations to a certain extent even a mouthpiece for them so the fact that they put out this balloon let's say um certainly of course great worry even if there were subsequent denials uh by the U.S by U.S officials by and netanyahu's office by the Israeli government but the fact that it was put out there means that they wanted to send a message to Israel and at the moment
8:34 the American uh Administration is very much using a policy of carrots and steps towards Israel what I mean by that is the stick is um these these uh criticisms uh Biden himself was on CNN I believe it was where he called this government the most extreme uh he he ran against this government against netanyahu's ability to govern um Ambassador Knight who is leaving Israel he's finishing his tenure as a U.S ambassador to Israel also made a very harsh uh criticisms against this government and now we have this Thomas Friedman article this really is sending a very strong message to let you know that the U.S is extremely displeased I don't believe that there really isn't a reassessment of relations certainly there are disagreements that have been disagreements throughout the history of the US Israel uh relationship but it's more there to scare this Israeli government and that's pretty much the stick the carrot is something which
9:37 we've talked about in recent weeks is the Saudi normalization now as I've spoken uh about previously the Saudi Israel normalized agreeing potential agreement isn't really at this point about Saudi Arabia or Israel relations because Saudi Arabia isn't really asking anything from Israel and Israel really isn't demanding anything from Saudi Arabia the only thing that's left to be resolved are whether Saudi Arabia can get or can achieve its demands of the U.S really uh the ball is in America's court but America the American Administration the I should say the Biden Administration is very much sending messages to Israel uh through normal diplomatic channels through the media through Anonymous quotes that there can be no normalization while Israel this Israeli government is acting the way it is in Judean Samaria the West Bank the judicial reform Etc et cetera so it's claiming that if it would just give up these policies um Israel's Saudi normalization is just around the corner
10:40 um but you know for those who know behind the scenes as I said it's not really about what Israel does or does it's really about America but that is the policy that it's very much uh using a week today uh president Herzog is going to the US he is going to um uh present who's going to speak at the U.S Congress this is an interesting situation because um it's pretty rare that uh an Israeli president will get an invitation and I'm sure he'll he'll be meeting with um President Biden as well usually President Biden uh usually does these things or the president does these things last minute I'm sure he'll get an audience with President Biden and that will send a message really to netanyahua that while our relations us Israel relations are strong I'm ignoring you I'm keeping a sort of arms distance from you uh I'm sending a message to the Israeli people that I'm not against you I'm not against the state of Israel but I am against this quote-unquote
11:43 extremist government so be very interesting to see what happens I'm sure Netanyahu is certainly not happy about this invitation to president Herzog um but uh it will be interesting to see exactly what the messages that come out if there is indeed that meeting at the White House um and and what exactly is happening there uh closer to home uh Netanyahu certainly does have a headache on his hands with this Coalition because as I said while the opposition are very much against uh this reasonableness uh uh uh law that passed its first reading um and it's you know this this is the law that uh that netanyahu's promised will be passed through all three readings by the end of this current uh um a period which is at the end of the month uh they're really looking for far more they're looking really to change uh the the composition of the judicial
12:46 appointments committee uh came on the news today to really send that message uh saying also that he will not accept any dilution of the reasonableness Clause as it goes through the second and third reading as we know usually what happens with a bill is it will go through its first reading then it will go back um to Committee in this case it will go to the lawn constitutional committee one by simple rotman uh who chairs it who is very much uh one of the proponents of judicial reform uh and certainly a Judicial reform maximalist and so basically he will try and keep it as much uh as possible that went through the first reading Netanyahu want to make it probably uh a little bit softer or want to take into account some of the criticisms for example one of the criticisms uh was that in the law it said not just the decisions of the Prime Minister ministers but also other officials and there's a concern that that could extend to Mayors and Municipal heads and basically make it
13:48 much wider uh than Simpang rotten for example would claim uh it is but now it'd be very interesting to see how much control netting your has because if this law really does go through the second and third readings untouched undiluted then that could be a problem for Netanyahu and that means that probably people at Simco ottoman Levine his Justice Minister are far more in control than he would like and then we get uh to the summer recess and then the the Jewish holidays and afterwards netanyahua was promised to allow other parts of the reform uh to be pushed forward so that's really where the eyes of both the proponents and the opponents to judicial reform are at this point there were Mass passive demonstrations really showing the strength of opposition in Israel to judicial reform and certainly that will be noticed by netanyahua but it will also be noticed by netanyahu's allies around the world including uh in uh DC in the White House
14:51 and elsewhere and certainly they'll be watching exactly the minutiae of the details of this reasonable Mrs because this has become very much a test case to see a who's in control of judicial reform and how far it's going to go uh and with that I'm happy to answer any all right thank you so much so the first question is from Eric stating some Jewish liberal groups are accusing Netanyahu of engaging in Janine with Hamas and Hezbollah to distract the public from focusing on judicial changes what are your thoughts on this well uh first of all interestingly enough there's been a lot of uh attacks from the opposition especially the right-wing elements of the opposition um that Netanyahu has not been fighting Terror enough and certainly you know factually to a certain extent that is true you know the bet uh the Bennett uh lapid government especially towards the end was in places like Janine almost on a daily or nightly basis uh trying to
15:54 root out Terror and trying to prevent attacks and trying to arrest uh or take out terrorists on their way to attacks uh so Netanyahu government uh didn't do it at certainly at the beginning in in quite the same Barista you know ferocity let's say um and there have been a number of uh Terror attacks recently so there is quite a glamor from all quarters for there to be a stronger approach and what we do know is that Iran especially has been putting a lot of resources into especially the refugee camp within Janine has become a bit of a safe haven for terrorists and terrorists sympathizers terrorist organizations so this um uh operation uh by the idea of integene was something warranted I don't think there's too many suggestions within uh um the Israeli security establishment that this wasn't warranted it certainly was warranted
16:56 um and not to say that uh netanyahua wouldn't want a distraction from this um but it certainly was very much warranted I again I think it'd have to be on the really really far left in Israel to find too many voices who would share that opinion um I don't know who in the American Jewish liberal establishment has um who has said that so I can't comment on that but in Israel that would be a very uh minor uh sort of thought process thank you David Levine points out the BBC and other government news outlets have uh libeld Israel for its actions in Janine accusing it of purposely killing children what if anything can the government of Israel do to counteract such distortions well if we if we knew the answer to that that would be the Silver Bullet so you know Israel has been dealing with um the foreign media you know let's say um for for many many years there's not much you can do in it is a democracy it
17:59 allows reporters full access it allows International reporters that allows local reporters allows Palestinian reporters full access uh pretty much on the ground you know and and you know there's not much it can do if an editor in London Paris New York Washington whoever decides to write what it writes uh the facts remain that uh you know while there have been uh criticisms especially from uh you know the human rights repertoire uh I can't remember her name an Italian woman who basically said that Israel is upsetting the international legal order which is an absurd comment with all the uh human rights of abuses and conflicts around the world that you know it just shows that there's a natural bias and you know some have even called her an anti-semite um and the fact is both her comments and quotes are picked up and they're used to justify headlines so there's really not much Israel can do they didn't allow this woman to come in to Judea in Samaria the West Bank when she wanted to
19:01 come because it was clear that you know there was no real interest in gathering facts she she'd already decided that Israel was guilty of all manner of uh you know human rights violations or war crimes as she puts in so you know Israel didn't allow her in uh just you know you know not give her any sort of further legitimacy than she has but at the end of the day she still has a massive soapbox and people like agencies like those that she works for uh ngos around the world who mirror and copy and parrot what they say uh what she says and others say it's pretty much copy paste uh you know that they're going to get picked up by the BBC they're going to get picked up by the New York Times they're going to get picked up by International uh news agencies and there's really not much Israel can do Israel can put out the facts as much as it can if it's become uh certainly a pretty good at its messaging or at least a lot better than it used to be the IDF has social media channels it tries to put out information in real time tries
20:03 to put out videos it tries to put out pictures it tries to present proof uh that it goes after terrorists and the fact remains that the overwhelming majority of those that it kills are competence uh even if they're claimed to be 17 years old you know five minutes later Hamas will bring out a picture and a video of them with the Hamas headband with a an uh AK-47 whatever it is in their hand uh talking about how they want to become a martyr and all that sort of thing so I I'm confused exactly what critics of Israel would would do when a 17 year old with a with an assault rifle or you know who would want to go and perpetrate a terrorist attack should his role just ignore because that person is considered underage I mean it's an absurd thought but uh this is what Israel unfortunately has to deal with and I'm not really sure although we could certainly criticize Israel's public relations in certain uh areas it's certainly getting better but on the other hand it really can't censor what
21:05 uh international news organizations uh thank you uh before we get into the other issues you discussed today uh murdad consare yes any update about the status of the kidnapped Israeli scholar in Iraq is there some kind of prisoner exchange plan with a brand I mean I have no I mean this has only just been released to the public this was obviously very sensitive information there was a reason why I wasn't reported for months probably because they didn't want to um you know sometimes when these things are reported then they become a lot more difficult there's a lot more pressures a lot more sensitivities uh so the fact that they were reported this now probably means that they've reached a dead end with behind the scenes diplomacy uh there is talk of this um exchange um happening but I really have no information uh Beyond what's reported in in the media obviously Israel is doing as much as it can as it would for any uh of its citizens uh kidnapped anywhere in
22:07 the world but I really don't know too much more uh beyond that thank you David S levinas why would the Saudi government care what Biden has to say about relations with Israel because if we look at the Abraham Accords agreements um you know each of the countries pretty much got something from America alongside uh normalization with Israel obviously normalization with Israel has its benefits uh and the UAE and Bahrain and Morocco and other countries are certainly seeing that but at the end of the day they needed something a little bit more to get you know to get going um the uh the UAE got you know uh up-to-date fighter uh Jets uh Morocco got recognition of uh West is controlled over Western uh Sahara um I think it was Sudan um got taken off the uh the American Terrorist supportive country supported uh terrorist list of countries approaching terrorists uh and various
23:12 other things so Saudi Arabia are certainly not going to do this for cheap you know especially as their relationship with the Biden Administration has certainly not been as good as it was under the Trump administ registration and we saw this cold shoulder from the beginning and it warmed up a little bit when the US needed Saudi oil and uh you know reserves and all that sort of thing but the Saudis want assistance they want assistance with a civilian nuclear uh program they want some sort of Defense treaty they see uh the rise of Iran in the region they see Iran's you know hurtling towards nuclear weapons capability and they want certain guarantees from the US at this point that's more important to them than anything else and they believe the Saudis believe that the US wants normalization with Saudi Arabia and quite frankly I'm sure in the lead up to uh you know Joe Biden's re-election bid it would be nice to have uh you know some sort of signing on the White House lawn between Saudi and
24:14 Israeli leaders but also as I said in my early remarks he also doesn't want to give this as a price to Netanyahu feels that netanyahu's government is more extreme and is creating problems uh in Julian Samaria the West Bank judicial etc etc so yeah it's it's uh it probably the Biden administration at this point from from what we see is far more intense among just dangling that carrot there keeping the Saudis at arm's length uh trying to explain to the Israelis that the Israeli government that it's their actions which is preventing this normalization whereas at the end of the day it's really the US that can make this deal happen thank you so much uh don't say ball uh as was it former Chief Justice Barack who came up with the starting and the application of the reasonableness standard and in the proposed legislation if the reasonableness standard is disallowed is there something to be used instead suggested or proposed in the law
25:17 in addition what might have been applied before the reasonableness standard was it wasn't uh former Chief Justice Barack as I said it actually goes back to a British law in 1948 actually did a bit of research on this so that's how I know um but it was adopted in a more extreme nature in Israel in other words a wider Nature by Barack and those uh who sat on the bench with him and those who followed him up until that point um hadn't been used in Israel Israel existed for 40 something 50 years whatever it is uh without the use of reasonableness especially in its uh sense that it's being used today the government the judicial reform proponents would say that it's unnecessary because there are laws uh on the statute books and then for justice cannot find a law uh that specifically uh you know ensures that a government policy should be made illegal then
26:22 then there's no reason for them to do so what they claim is that if the defense minister decides on a particular policy he is taking into account other professional advice or economic issues security issues all sorts of uh planes whereas the Justice ministers don't understand and are not privy to many of these discussions many of these calculations many of all the different um uh you know advices that they're getting so how can they be able to overturn a decision policy based pretty much on their own view of the situation don't forget using a reasonableness means that there is not a specific law that's being contraved it means that the justice has suggested or has said that the policy or the law itself is just not reasonable opponents let's say or judicial reform would say is undemocratic because the it's the uh democratically elected representatives who should decide policy
27:25 it shouldn't be for the uh justices who are not uh democratically elected to decide for or against a particular policy of course there are many uh jurists and experts who would argue that the truth is somewhere in the middle perhaps there should be a more limited use of reasonable to something more aligned with its original use as I said in in many other countries around the world there is the ability to use a reasonableness but it's certainly not as broadly used as it is uh in the Israeli context so there isn't something to be put instead because what proponents the judicial reform would say is you have hundreds if not thousands of laws you can check all of these to see that if a particular policy or particular law is not contravening something else don't forget there are basic laws against discrimination against all these things so you don't really need stubbornness to uh to base something that's you know the government policy is discriminatory you already have a law so proponents would say that there's enough already in there uh to to ensure that you don't need
28:28 reasonableness and if there isn't then then the proper place is the legislative legislature to legislate and fix those gaping holes thank you so much uh Carey hillebrand and Eric both asked about uh has Israel reached a decision as to how to react to the Hezbollah intrusion into Israeli territory near hard dove um well it's still trying diplomacy um basically Amos hochstein who is the U.S mediator was in the region um what it now appears is happening is Hezbollah very much trying to use these as a negotiating tactic to try and ensure that the fence it's quite a complicated issue but on the on when when Israel uh removed itself from Southern Lebanon it did according to what the UN decided was the demarcated Border Hezbollah dispute I think it's 14 points of that demarcated border as I said that was a un demarcated the so-called blue line one
29:31 of these places is a village called Raja in the north um and basically Hezbollah say that part of it is part of Lebanon the northern part and Israel has put a fence around the hot the northernmost part which means it's all inside Israel um Hezbollah demand that fence being removed and it's now uh suggesting to the U.S mediator it seems that it will remove its tense if Israel removes its fence from the northern part of the village of rajao so it seems like it's being played out diplomatically at this point uh Hezbollah did try again uh to try and get across the border at other points it certainly ratcheting up the heat on the on the border but at the moment the tents remain very well thank you so much we've come to the close of our weapon iron podcast Ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week absolutely thank you glorious where viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1pm Eastern for a webinar with Edward Ludwick discussing uh focus on
30:34 Palestinians not their leaders thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day