MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Israel-Iran War Monitor

Watch Israel-Iran War Monitor on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Thanks for joining our exclusive live broadcast. Feel free to share your questions and interact with other participants in the chat.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 18, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:02 We have a significant broadcast for all of you today and updates coming from the region including the latest on the ground in Iran in Israel and in Washington DC with our guest pal. But first the headlines. The Iran Israel conflict has caused 585 deaths in Iran and more than 65 deaths in Israel with severe damage to civilian infrastructure in Israel including hospitals and energy facilities in Iran. Iran's access of resistance proxy network has shown notably restrained responses to this conflict with only the Houthis actively coordinating attacks. The Iran Israel conflict severely escalated in the seventh day with Iranian missiles striking Sarroa hospital in Beerva Israel in addition to Kon and other Israeli cities while Israel destroyed Iran's Arach nuclear reactor. Global leaders remain divided on the Iran Israel conflict with the US maintaining a defensive posture while considering intervention in a new timeline announced by the White House two weeks as announced by White House press secretary Caroline Levit. Israel has also

1:04 announced a new war goal of eliminating Iran Supreme Leader Ayat Kamei with some ministers calling him a modern Hitler. The Iran Israel conflict has reached a dangerous new phase on the seventh day with Iranian ballistic missiles deliberately targeting Seroka Medical Center in Beva early this morning, wounding 71 people and marking a significant escalation in attacks on civilian infrastructure. The hospital strike, which Israeli officials are calling state sponsored terrorism, came hours after Israeli fighter jets destroyed Iran's Aric heavy water reactor complex overnight, eliminating a key component of Tehran's plutonium production capability. This unprecedented direct military confrontation between these two regional powers has now claimed over 600 lives across both nations. The overnight Israeli strike on the Ara nuclear um excuse me, the overnight Israeli strike on the Ara heavy water reactor represents a calculated escalation in Israel's systematic campaign to dismantle Iran's nuclear program. More than 40 Israeli F-35I Adir stealth fighters penetrated Iranian airspace with apparent ease, completely

2:06 destroying the reactor's containment structure and eliminating its potential for weaponsgrade plutonium production. This follows earlier devastating strikes in the Natan's enrichment facility where the International Atomic Energy Agency confirms all 15,000 centrifuges were either badly damaged or destroyed. Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu speaking to domestic media today declared that Israel possesses the capability to destroy Iran's underground fordo nuclear facility without American assistance. We will achieve all our objectives and hit all their nuclear facilities, Netanyahu stated, dismissing suggestions that US involvement was necessary for such operations. The underground fortal facility buried deep within a mountaineer comb in Iran has long been considered Iran's most hardened nuclear site and potentially impervious to conventional Israeli bunker busting munitions. The systematic targeting has extended beyond nuclear infrastructure to Iran's military command structure. Israeli officials confirmed that now 14 Iranian nuclear scientists have been killed since the conflict began along with multiple

3:08 senior Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps commanders. And in addition, the IDF claims to have destroyed approximately 120 missile launchers, roughly one-third of Iran's total arsenal, and over 70 aerial defense batteries, essentially achieving air supremacy over western Iran and the Tahrron region. Iran's missile strike on Sroka came at dawn today, representing a troubling escalation in the targeting of civilian infrastructure. The ballistic missile achieved a direct hit on the six-story facility, causing extensive structural damage and forcing the evacuation of PA patients, including infants, from the NATO natal unit. where Iranian officials claimed they were targeting a nearby Israeli military intelligence facility that doesn't exist. IDF spokesperson Brigadier General FBI Definen condemned the attack unequivocally, saying, "Let there be no doubt the Iranian regime deliberately and maliciously fired at the hospital and population center with the intent to harm civilians." Perhaps the most unexpected development in this crisis has been the limited response from Iran's vaunted Axis of resistance proxy network. Hezbollah, traditionally

4:12 Iran's most powerful proxy force, has maintained complete operational silence despite Iranian pressure for support. Lebanese government officials have explicitly warned Lebanon has that Lebanon quote will not allow the country to be part of an Iranian retaliation, reflecting the group's weakened position following Israel's previous campaign and the installation of a new anti-hebahol leadership in Beirut. The Hotis in Yemen remain the sole proxy group actively coordinating with Tehran, launching multiple ballistic missiles to central is Israel and publicly announcing their coordination with operations carried out by the Iranian army. This marks the first time an Iranian proxy an Iranian proxy has openly acknowledged direct operational coordination with Tehran during active hostilities. In response, Israel has conducted major retaliatory strikes on Yemen's Huida port, causing an estimated $500 million in damage.

5:07 Military analysts, of whom we will hear many this afternoon, assess that Israel has achieved significant degradation of Iranian capabilities. The Institute for the Study of War notes that Iran has depleted at least a third and as much as half of its long range missile inventory with the frequency of barges decreasing from over 150 missiles in initial salvos to just 10 missile strikes today. Iran still maintains dangerous escalatory options. Supreme Leader Kamei speaking from an undisclosed location today rejected American demands for surrender and warned that US military in intervention would cause irreparable damage and draw America into the mother of forever wars. The next 48 hours will prove critical. France is preparing a diplomatic initiative for Friday's UN meeting while Russia and China increase pressure for immediate ceasefire. The wild card remains President Trump's decision on direct US military involvement which could either force a resolution or expand the conflict into a broader regional conflration. To discuss all these issues and more, I would like

6:09 to bring to you our panel of Middle East forum analysts and experts, including Michael Rubin, our director of policy and Winfield Meyers, our online editor, Jim Hansen from Washington DC, Alex Selski reporting on the ground from Israel, and Eric Navaro to comment on military matters. Michael, I'd like to bring you in first to first just ask the basic question. Let's say the Iranians give up their nuclear program. what's next? How does it get removed from the You know, Greg, that's an excellent question and that's not that's what's missing from the debate when uh we talk in the American political debate about whether or not the United States should join in. If the Iranians accept Donald Trump's demand for unconditional surrender, and it's possible they will, then we need to think about how are we going to get all their nuclear material outside the country so frankly they can't change their mind. We had some experience with that back with regard to

7:11 the dismantling of Libya's weapons of mass destruction where we literally deconstructed factories and carted them outside the country. In Iran, it's also going to mean uh taking the uranium out, the enriched uranium. It's going to mean uh interrogating scientists, looking over documents. Now, should we trust the International Atomic Energy Agency to do that? I don't think so. Uh the question is whether perhaps we might work with the Indians or some other party that both the Iranians and the Americans trust and for that matter the Israelis trust as well. But there's so much in the debate which we're actually not getting to. Now when it comes to this notion of the Supreme Leader denying out of hand, look, as everyone here knows, I'm a historian by training, which means I get paid to predict the past. And yeah, a lot of my critics would say I only get that right about half the time.

8:04 But up until July 20th, 1988, Ayat Humeni swore that Iran wouldn't stop the Iran Iraq war until I mean basically until he had achieved his war aims of ousting Saddam Hussein and conquering Jerusalem. Then on July 21st, 1988, he got on the radio and he surprised Iranians with an address. He likened it to drinking from a chalice of poison, but said, "I have no choice but to drink from this cup if I want the Islamic Revolution, the Islamic Republic to survive." Now, the time is now for Donald Trump to make Hamei drink from a chalice of poison, no matter what he might say. I also do want to say there's a bad thunderstorm coming through, so I apologize for the flickering lights. No, but I can't imagine it's any less worse off in Iran. Uh so we we we have had some uh smidons on this in terms of the quality in terms of how we're broadcast.

9:03 We are working at fixing this. But Michael, thank you for your analysis. Now bringing in the latest military element to all of this. I'd really if if I may, Greg. Yeah, sure. Um there there's one other issue regionally that we're not talking about in the West that deserves a little bit of note. Today, Grand Ayatollah Ali perhaps the most prominent Ayatollah outside of Ali Kamei, he's based in Nef, Iraq, issued his second statement. His first was right after the war began. And he basically warned that this is leading to a regional conflagration. and he argued that both the Islamic world and other countries should turn both towards religion and international law to solve the Iranian nuclear program justly. Now, without doubt, when you read Sistani's rhetoric, he's pro- Iran and anti-Israel, but his second statement doesn't seem as pro-Iran and anti-Israel

10:09 as his first statement. So it bears watching what comes out of Nef in Iraq because more Shia worldwide actually turn to Sistani for their guidance than towards Kame himself. actually brings up an interesting point, Michael. And while I do want to hear the military dimensions from Eric, I want to follow up with your question with your point, which is that there has been a historical split in the Iraqi Shia community in terms of those who are pro-Iran, those who are anti-Iran, most notably Maktal Suther, who ran on a platform a few parliamentary cycles ago, both being anti-American, anti-Israel, and anti-Iran. Do you find that in terms of those outside the clerical class that Shia populations worldwide are sort of turning away from Iran and any tacid support for it? And this also connects to the fact that if they're not necessarily supporting the revolution in the country, does that lessen the risk for retaliatory attacks outside of Iran's borders by Shia who previously were taking direction from Thran?

11:10 Well, first of all, no one has turned away from uh Ayatollahi, Ayatollah Kamei and their religious exesis more than the Iranians themselves. In Persian, they talk about Dini Kodiman, our personal religion, which they say in order to differentiate themselves from the state imposed religion. But when it comes to those outside of Iran, I mean, ultimately they're going to make their own decision. A lot of them are naively um sympathetic to Iran simply because they don't have to live there. But ultimately, if Iran collapses, the Iranians themselves, just like frankly many in southern Lebanon, are going to be leading the way to sh say, you know, you guys have been misled.

11:56 All right. Thank you very much, Michael Rubin. Now, we're going to bring in Eric Navaro, who is our director of military and strategic programs here at the Middle East Forum. And Eric, there was just a general overview of a change in the rhetoric coming out of the White House. And I'm going to ask you for the DC dimension, but in terms of the military preparation for what options President Trump has on the table, what is the Pentagon doing now to prepare for a strike if the president gives the Well, there were recent reports uh is already got his uh war planners uh kneedeep in operational uh detailed planning and I expect them to have a a a detailed strateg uh strike package already laid out and then just waiting for the president to get the go-ahad.

12:40 Now, what a strike on I personally believe that the president is simply weighing a limited strike on the Ford uh facilities. I don't think he's looking to get involved extensively. In fact, that's why you're seeing the constant talk of more negotiations and further diplomacy to force the Iranians to unconditional surrender without actually having to use military action. But if we limit it to just the Ford strike, you you would expect them they're going to use the B2 Spirit uh strategic bombers. They take off from Whitman uh air force base in Missouri. They can travel. They they fly over 30,000 feet above so they can't be really intercepted. Uh they dropped the GBU57 bomb that it's about 30,000 lbs of explosive power uh that detonates 200 feet below the surface.

13:30 And what they would do is they would drop multiple bombs to drill down to get as far far down into the facility as possible. Now there's risks with any strike package. They would have fighter escorts. They'd have electronic warfare to jam any potential interceptors, right? Uh the obvious the most obvious risk is they could miss, right? So obviously they have to do operational checks on the on the bombs. The pilots have to be expert. Israel has shown the way as far as tactical and operational brilliance. Um and I expect I fully expect our pilots to be able to get the the mission done. Now, the other the other risk would just be the contamination uh as a result of any explosions and what effect the area it would have to the area. Well, as someone who has served in Iraq, how do you respond when you hear critics of potential US involvement saying that no regime change or no forever wars is something that the United States going to pursue considering the fact the military is now perhaps getting ready for a strike that might lead to regime change? Yeah, I have a physical reaction. I got to bug up my butt about

14:32 that. Um because first of all limited bombing is not war right we have to define cl and cl uh with clarity what war is is a sustained violence to achieve a political aim right over a long period of time uh with a a significant opposing force fighting against us right a targeted strike on the nuclear uh site is not war but on top of that regime change does not have to mean nation building, right? And so the we need to learn the lessons. I think everyone is infected with Iraq war syndrome, right? And how the post Saddam Hussein time for the US forces was so difficult. I was there. I saw it. I understand. But that was a failure of execution, right? We were try we debatifi tried to debatify the country.

15:21 We disbanded the military and we tried to rebuild it in in the name of uh democracy. That's not what anybody is proposing here at all. Okay? Even with regime change, we're not talking about boots on the grounds. We're not talking about re uh uh creating a Jeffersonian democracy in Iran and us doing it um or Israel doing it. We're simply talking about force setting the conditions and forcing and allowing the Iranian people to rise up and change their regime which has been oppressing them for four decades. Now given that you've planned complex military operations, you identified the risks associated with US strike on Ford, but also for the past few days in commentary that you've been giving to this podcast. You've correctly pointed out how these Israeli strikes would proceed. How do you expect the campaign to unfold for the next few days from the Israeli side? Yeah, I think the Israelis are um have a very clear, deliberate plan that they're executing extremely well. In fact, better than they expected, right? And that that's why I argue uh on the battlefield once

16:24 you have unexpected success you have to maximize that. You have to jump on that and take that seize that opportunity. And I think the Israelis are doing that. I they have full uh air supremacy. Iran they they have they need to maximize the ability to constantly patrol the skies of Iran for targets of opportunity. They now prior to the attacks they had uh s you have a target list pre-planned target list. They've wiped out most of those already. Right now it's targets of opportunity. Now it's if a leader maximize uh maintain the pressure on the leadership. You saw the the the prime minister already identifying that the Ayatollah is now a direct target. Constantly search for the leadership and take them out as they pop up their heads. Also sever their ability to communicate with the and issue orders. then that drastically degrades their ability to respond to any any Israeli attacks. And then uh again, we've said this before, they're degrading the missile uh the ability of the Iranians to launch missiles. You see

17:26 that in the number of launches going down with each successive day, right? Uh one final thing, the news just broke about uh President Trump talking about potentially uh negotiating for two weeks. Remember the key with President Trump and he did this with the Houthi ceasefire as well is he is not handcuffing Israel to do what they what uh they they believe they need to do. So even if he if he waited and talked with Iranians as long as he does he allows the Israelis to continue to do what they're doing they will have maximum effect and it will only increase the pressure on the regime and set and again get set those conditions so the Iranians people can rise up. All right. Thank you Eric. And speaking about the impact of the Iranian missiles uh hitting Israel and their capability to do so, as we said in our opening remarks, there were some significant strikes on a hospital in Verva today in a uh residential area in Cologne leading to the which is south of Tel Aviv leading to the evacuation of 736 residents of that neighborhood to hotels in Tel Aviv and elsewhere. And

18:29 I'd like to bring in Alex Selki to give us a little bit more of a update of what's happening on the ground in Israel. What's the civilian response like to these missiles falling and how do we get to the point where perhaps uh there's going to be a little bit more of a harder response, a harsher response by the Israeli government to be Iran's targeting civilians. Right. Good evening from Jerusalem. So yesterday I told you that part of the restrictions were lifted and the atmosphere and the feeling was that you know we uh you know after 5 days only after our attacks Iranians uh don't succeed to really launch significant valleys of missiles on Israel. But today in the morning exactly at the hour when for the first time since the beginning of the war people were on their way to work we had a well it's not significant valley because it was only about 25 rockets but it hit

19:34 damage significant damage. The biggest one was the major hospital in the south of Israel in the city of Beer Cheva considers to be the the capital of the south. It's a very big hospital that was uh receiving actually the biggest numbers of uh the soldiers from Gaza and uh the heat was you know by just luck nobody knows how but that exact department was evacuated yesterday by again some you know decision from above.

20:08 no casualties at this hit. But h it the the first question was definitely if it was you know maybe Iranians did it in purpose. you know, they didn't fire for two days and today they did it to surprise us. But anyway, everybody understood today that it's not over and that they they definitely continue to fire and the you know the very uh powerful atmosphere and feeling and spirit of yesterday was shifted by much more challenging feeling of how we continue to work with this kind of attacks. But the HR command didn't change the restrictions because as you know we speak as I speak in the media on behalf of the Han command and explain that part of the war is our resilience is our power and part of this resilience and power is to work and to uh and to be active and to uh to keep the country going and that's what it is

21:12 and Israel is definitely is back to life even though we had this attack and even though we had this damage, nobody knows what it will be tomorrow. Nobody knows how the things will develop tomorrow. But yet the feeling is that we uh that we win and uh that Israel have as as as we spoke the supremacy and and and targeting the targets that it wants. Alex, one of the things that we've heard from some of our friends in the uh Iranian opposition is is that they wished that Israeli government leaders would allow the opposition to speak for itself rather than the claim to speak on behalf of the opposition. Uh, do you think that there is something better that the Israeli government could be doing in its messaging to the Iranian diaspora and the people who are against the regime in order to sort of tighten up their messaging as to not be seen as being against Iran and the Iranian people, but to actually allow the Iranian people to decide for themselves

22:14 what their government should look like in the future? You're definitely correct. And these thoughts, you know, we can hear them in Israel as well that say that, you know, if Israel will be the one, if Israeli government will be the one that calling for the regime change, we can see exactly the opposite reaction that people in Iran will unite, you know, against the attacks because after all, you know, attacks are not on when you see uh, you know, Israel attacks, many can say, listen, these are attacks on Iran and not on the regime. regime. So it definitely everybody speaks about the fact that Israeli government cannot make the regime shift. The the the only way to this is from within from the Iranian people and as you definitely right it should come from within. It should come generally from within and I think Israel should create the conditions for that but but less speak as a governmental voice to call to regime change because

23:19 it can do the the opposite effect not for all but definitely for part. Do you feel like the homeront is in Israel is is right now uh facing any economic setbacks? Are there any issues dealing with uh challenges for going to work, sending kids to school, getting ready for summer vacation? I mean, these may seem like mundane items during a war, but they very much affect the Israeli populace. Can you share any stories with us about hardships that the Israeli civilian population is facing? Well, you know, we you know, Israeli civilians are, you know, for better and for worse are very, very experienced in war. I you know remind you that this week is not the first days of war after since October 7 and uh Israelis know how to behave in war and just look you know look on the this you know if you want to understand Israeli resilience just just think about the fact that we call the to to take Israelis from Thailand and

24:24 Greece back home where they you know will face the rockets It's rescue flights. Okay. Usually, you know, in war, rescue flights are those that take people from the war zone outside and Israel is called the flights from Greece, you know, sunny Greece and and Bangkok back to to, you know, to the to the war rescue fights. The resilience is very strong and the spirit is very strong. But you're definitely right. the country cannot be paralyzed for long. And part of the decision to continue working and to get people back to work is that the country economically in terms of spirits and resilience as well, but economically has to continue working and people have to you know to to to to make money for living and this is a big part. So that's one of the one one of the challenges of a war that cannot be so long if these rockets will be firing so much and paralyzing the economy.

25:28 Thank you. Now to bring a little bit more in depth from the Middle East forum's deep bench of writers and analysts, I was hoping to invite Winfield Meyers to talk about what we call our three article segment. Uh Win, what are the three things that our readers and our watchers and our listeners have to view today? have to read today and at a rate I've never seen in 19 years here which is a tribute to our authors. Um what I want to call attention to is by Michael Rubin who just left us a few minutes ago. Um Michael has a new article out called the west and the UN should withdraw recognition of the Islamic Republic. um that he argues I think convincingly that in as much as the regime in Tehran is losing legitimacy in the eyes of the people uh nothing the the outside world should do nothing in the world to help prop it up uh to help lend it a veneer of legitimacy and among the things that should happen is that the EU in particular uh the United Nations itself

26:32 and say Australia New Zealand other such countries should withdraw their recognition of it including at the United Nations itself. Uh because at the moment it's still a member and according to the standards there in good standing at the United Nations. Um revoking that or threatening to revoke that puts it on thinner ice and conveys to the populace and to the rest of the world that the regime's days may be numbered that it's whatever legitimacy it enjoys is um limited. He also that article contains Michael is wonderful with pathy statements. Anyone who knows him knows that the best one in that one is it is quite likely today that the Islamic Republic has greater support in the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft than it does among the Iranian people. I think that's a says a great deal about where that stands.

27:23 Another by Sheay Hatiri who has been on these broadcasts before. America must pick a winner among the Iranian opposition. Um Sheay worries that an overthrow of the uh Ayatollah while not anything to be regretted per se uh and and while you know we've talked about before any of the Mussolini treatment or whatever happens to the man if that happens um while that can be celebrated it can also open uh a great deal of chaos uh within the um country uh and that's particularly true because the strongest elements within Iran now tend to be the besiege the the militant youth connected to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and members of the IRGC itself. And he fears that should chaos ensue um uh an even worse element can come to power or at least cause it could cause a civil war throughout the country that would be on the scale of Syria civil war. It could go on for years. It could be devastating. Um his partial solution to that is to have an American

28:27 uh intervention. So that uh we he says the only only a great power can do this and we're the only great power who can do it. Uh so that we intervene to force Hamini to um relinquish his power and hand it over to someone else if he is still alive. It's a Shea's argument again is is this is a way to avoid uh chaos. Um and a second article I would third article the second by Shay I would note is something that's going on now the it's titled disconnecting the internet foreshadows Iran using its people as human shields. Um I think we mentioned this a little bit in yesterday's broadcast um once the internet is taken down by the regime itself which it had not wanted to do before. Some of our authors have pointed out earlier in the week uh that the the regime did not want the internet to come down all the way because that interferes of course as we all know with banking with commerce with everything we do uh being done on the internet. Uh but when the regime itself comes out and

29:30 does it, he says this is order in order to uh alienate everyone, to isolate them, to prevent them from contacting one another as best they can, and that he reminds everyone that this is a regime that like Hamas uh is happy to use its own populace as human shields, happy to sacrifice them uh to preserve its own um existence and to forstall its eventual fall. So those are the three of the articles among many that I would recommend to our audience today. I can't hear you, Greg.

30:06 Before we get to Jim, I'm going to ask that enough bring up that video that uh we had shared regarding a statement from the White House press secretary Caroline Levit. And then Jim, I' I'd really like to know what the White House dimension is right now considering yesterday there was a meeting with the National Security Council. We heard about ongoing negotiations that have been going on between the Iranian foreign minister and special envoy Steve Witkoff. We also heard about some sort of a a time delay in terms of being able to make a decision, which would be considered a sort of a a presidential directive of two weeks rather than having to do it right away. Uh enough. Can you pull up that clip?

30:46 Okay. Uh we'll try to uh get to our producer in a second. Uh but I'd like the uh the audience to listen to this uh briefly uh just so that we have the opportunity to see what the press secretary was saying regarding the ongoing situation in Iran. I know there has been a lot of speculation amongst all of you in the media regarding the president's decision-making and whether or not the United States will be directly involved. In light of that news, I have a message directly from the president and I quote, "Based on the fact that that's a quote directly from the president for all of you today. So, we'll kick it off for questions here." So Jim, uh, hearing what the press secretary had to say that now we we've seen the White House sort of punt the decision on whether or not to strike Iran with two weeks, what what does that

31:49 mean in terms of what the uh, new US national security policy is towards Iran? Why are they waiting? Uh, is this a good decision? And what can we expect next? I I think it's relatively unchanged. President Trump has said he wants a negotiated settlement and he opened that statement saying he believes negotiations are possible. His envoy, Steve Witkoff, has been in contact by phone with the Iranian foreign minister multiple times. They haven't come to any conclusions. Enrichment uh of uranium on Iran or Iranian soil seems to be the sticking point for them. Uh but overall there is at least conversation going and the president seems to have made the decision that he can bomb them whenever he wants but he can't unbomb them and I think that's where he is. You know at this point it's not like Iran is going to make a breakout build a nuclear bomb in the midst of Israel kicking them up and down the street. That's not a danger right now. So he's taking the opportunity to see if perhaps some level

32:53 of sanity within the senior leadership of the Iranian regime uh leads them to believe that their utter destruction underneath, you know, the might of the United States added to the deadly accuracy and precision of the Israelis is something they don't want to face. And I think that's wise. There's there's no better solution to this. And I said this yesterday, I'm not clairvoyant, but this is what President Trump wants. He wants to be the peacemaker of this war. He does not want to be the architect of an American attempt at regime change.

33:25 And that's where he stands right now. Now, we heard from Prime Minister Netanyahu in a statement that he made earlier today when he was visiting Siroka Hospital that the president and his involvement would be welcomed by Israel, but would be considered a bonus and would not be necessary. Considering the fact that the Israelis, at least publicly, think they can go it alone. Does that change the president's I think he's been telling Benjamin Netanyahu all along, keep going. You know, I mean, why not? It's been tremendously successful. Israel has been far beyond the the level of destruction anyone thought they'd be able to do with the costs to themselves that they have had to bear. So, I think there's there's no question that President Trump sees that as enough pressure on Iran to try to force them to capitulate and that the Israelis see themselves as capable of basically destroying everything they need to. The one sticking point is for the mountain, you know, below 60, 100, however many meters underground it is.

34:28 The the Israelis to destroy that would probably have to use ground forces, which would be hellish. That's a a horrible thing to contemplate. I I I believe it could be successful. The costs would be extreme. The US, on the other hand, could start dropping the massive ordinance penetrators are our giant bunker busting bombs on it and basically shake it to nuclear dust as President Trump has called it. So, I think if it gets down to that as an endgame piece, uh it might be better for the US to do that rather than the Israelis run a commando raid. But best case scenario, the Iranians surrender and we worry about Michael Rubin's uh consideration that we now need to figure out how to get rid of all that nuclear material. So, let's break that down for a second. If the Israelis decide to take out Fordo themselves without US support, what does that look like? I mean, let's ask you and Eric. You used to serve in the Green Berets. You were special operation forces soldier. Eric, you've been deployed to the region multiple times. you've had your own experience in

35:32 How would the Israelis take out Fordo through a ground raid? Let's uh let's ask Eric first and then we'll go to Jim. Well, first I wouldn't advise that. Um I think that it is buried deep. You'd have you'd have to um infiltrate the you'd have to overtake the defenses on the ground. um you'd have to infiltrate into the tunnels and then fight your way uh for every inch through the different corridors and uh and the entire labyrinth that probably exists below uh below ground. Below ground combat is always difficult. Think of the tunnel rats in Vietnam. Think of any any type of close quarters fighting. Extremely difficult, fraught with risk, high casualties. Uh uh I would definitely not uh look to do that. that I I would recommend against that. Um I believe that the in addition to the the ground um assault. I I think the Israelis could do it from the air, but they would have to do it in successive raids, which exposes their pilots and their

36:37 capabilities to uh more risk. But the point is the the massive ordinance penetrator could do it in one night. Um, and that's kind of the the calculus that the two sides need to uh take into consideration. Now, Jim, back in the fall of last year, there was an Israeli raid on Syria's chemical weapons program, but it was also a facility underground uh within stones throw of Israel's borders. It wasn't the 1800, 2,000 kilometers to reach Forell. Um, do you think that they can repeat this?

37:08 What would the air element look like to that? How would they transport the troops from Israeli soil to Foral and then back to Jerusalem? Yeah, that is one massive logistical nightmare and operational nightmare. Um, if you recall, the greatest commando raid ever conducted was done by Israel putting uh, you know, a Mercedes limousine into a C130 along with their troops and flying to Antebi to rescue hostages from an airplane hijacking. So there's a possibility you could fly planes there with vehicles on them and troops and do that and potentially bring a a massive amount of explosives with you, you know, and create the opportunity to start blowing it piece by piece uh into dust. They've also got some of these very interesting oxygen depleting style bombs. Uh that would be another way. If you're underground, you're relying on uh reprocessed oxygen.

38:03 cut that off and all of a sudden there isn't anybody inside to fight anymore. I'd say if I if I had to be BB Netanyahu, I would be telling Donald Trump, wouldn't it be nice? Could you just leave the keys to a B2 in the ignition somewhere on Diego Garcia and just walk away for a while? We'll gas it up when we're done, you know, and just let us let us borrow it for a while. We won't scratch it up at all. Uh but it's it's it's a hellish raid no matter how you try to do it. Um, if they've got air superiority and they've got the essential something related to ground superiority, then you could you could treat it more like a conventional operation. But I think everybody uh would prefer either a surrender by the Iranians or the US to punch enough holes in it that it turns to dust. Uh, this question comes from Susan on Facebook and I'm going to open it up to the panel. Are all the planes and bombs needed to finish the job still in Missouri or some positioned closer to the region?

39:04 Well, the B2, the main base is in Missouri. Um, and the B2 does not have to be positioned forward to uh execute the mission. That's what makes us such a a strategic asset. Uh, now I do I did see reports that uh there are B-52s uh prepositioned at Diego Garcia. Again, the defense uh department has maneuvered multiple assets, air, ground, and uh and naval all throughout that region in in the case of any type of retaliatory strikes of course from Iran, but also they they want to give the commanders on the ground and the president a full menu of options for different actions that he can take.

39:43 When one of the great things that we've been able to do at mforum.org, both on the Iran war blog and also on the um the uh uh uh article section where we have the Iran reporting section is to highlight the very intricate uh complexities associated with the Iranian opposition. And uh Anthony asks us now uh based on fundamentalist Islamic tenants, any agreement that Iran now enters into will be no more than a temporary expedient tactic and will not be a long-term binding commitment. Uh do you think that the Iranians are engaged in their usual chconery and and uh sort of uh you know fool me once, fool me, don't fool me twice tactics or do you see the Iranians getting beat to a pulp and maybe saying uncle drinking from that poison chalice?

40:42 I think I would not take them seriously in diplomacy. That's what some of our authors have written over the last few days. Unless and until uh you have friendly troops in the room with Hamini uh pointing uh M4s at him and then telling him to sit down and shut up and sign on the dotted line. I I don't think anybody would should take Iranian diplomacy seriously in that measure. Again, unless they have literally surrendered um which uh you know would be a godsend, but as Jim and Eric point out, that's be a far-fetch. We'll see what happens with that. Um, but our that's what our authors have been arguing all along also. All right, I'm gonna take this question, I think, which is about the overseas uh Iranian community versus those who are active inside the country. And Robert asks, can you discuss what we know about the active protests from within Iranian civil society, not the overseas Iranian community? Also, are ethnic irudentist groups an active threat to Iran? Should Khani fall? Uh the Middle East forum has

41:46 extensive connections with Iranian opposition leaders both inside the country and outside the country. And what we're hearing, more specifically over the last 24 to 36 hours since the internet blackout has effectively eliminated those within Iran's ability to communicate with the outside world is is that now that the Iranian secret police headquarters has been bombed, now that their main broadcasting and propaganda outlet has been destroyed, that there is an effort by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the Besiege to start rounding up members of the Iranian opposition and those who may even look the wrong way on Iranian streets, accusing them of being Mossad spies and putting them in jail. There's been some prominent activists who I won't name them here right now until it's publicly available who are now behind Iranian bars. There are others who have fled from the regime. But the more hopeful story that's coming out of the country is even though that there may be some who are being imprisoned, many more are coming to the street.

42:46 There was an active firefight that was reported two days ago in Ray. There was images from the Iranian Iraqi border of Iranian Kurdish elements sitting in Iraq getting ready to go into the Condiel mountains to start combating the IRGC. There have been protests which have been taking place in the Baluchi areas for the last year and a half and there's plans there I believe as well to start having solidarity. But the main message that I've been receiving from opposition leaders is that both the United States and Israel should not be speaking about regime change in so far it's the decision of the Iranian people to rise up against their oppressors against those who have been engaged in acts of suppression for the past 46 years. And so long as it's an Iranian calling for regime change in the Iran, it'll be a lot easier for those in the country and for those outside to unify to be able to have a united front against the Islamic Republic and the regime. So, Robert, I hope that answers your question. Um, but we also have another point, and Eric, I'm going to go to you as our resident

43:48 uh sort of business expert on this, which is as Iran's leadership gets more desperate, we should be mindful of the Iranian threat to energy shipping through the straits, perhaps if we hit Forell, at the same time, we should be hitting their anti-shipping capabilities on the Gulf. What's your take? Well, I would agree with that, right? Uh I believe that that's what um some of the strikes have been to take out their naval uh capabilities for that exact reason so they can't uh threaten shipping traffic in uh in the straight. Um also don't forget uh I think this ties in with uh President Trump's previous trip to the region and with the f heavy focus on investment and business opportunities and trade with those countries with uh Saudi Arabia and others. So Saudi Arabia could up their output in the event that there's a a disruption as uh of oil supplies coming out of the straight of Hormuz. Uh so there's different counteractions that we can do. Um if that was to happen, I don't expect it personally. Uh I believe that the if you look the Iranian regime

44:51 is turned inward outside of the volleys of missiles that they're launching towards Israel to show that they may you know still have some uh strength and be dangerous. They've turned they turned the internet off in their own country not because of what Israel is doing but because of what they're afraid their own people will do. And so they're inward they're looking they're afraid. This is why I say all we have to do is continue the pressure on and on the leadership right continue to strike at them continue to keep them hiding and worried about their own survival and then set the conditions for their own people to rise up and take them out.

45:32 Thank you, Eric. And now I understand there's also an update that we've received, Alex, from some of our connections uh in Iran. This is to answer Robert's questions for an update on what's happening on the civil side in Iran in terms of protest sabotage. Is there any news coming out that you've been able to monitor from Iranian telegram channels or from some of our friends without naming names of what's happening inside the country as a result of the US uh excuse me of the Israeli strikes and the instability of what may be happening inside the country's From my understanding and from what I see and from what I hear from my friends, Iranian friends, our friends, people still are afraid and we don't still we yet don't see you know big I think protests and uh organization and organizing but we see lots of people try to create uprising many exile leaders from uh Europe and United States try to

46:36 call them and Israel is do all the possible and we just spoke about it that on one hand it can help on the other hand the calling from the Israeli government can do the opposite by uniting the people you know against uh against the attack. So I think that yet we we we we don't even get to any tipping point and the conditions yet are not ready but but but again I want to say it's only one you know it's even not week in few hours it will be a week since the attack to expect that things will be so fast I think it's it's exaggerating you know I wasn't the Soviet Union when it collapsed it doesn't happen in in a week. It doesn't happen in a in in a year. I think that this attack and it's not over yet, but it definitely will put the conditions for this, you know, domino effect, which I don't know how long it will be, but

47:40 definitely we have to be patient and to see that the Iranian people take the initiative and it I I believe it will happen, but it but I believe it will take more time. Thanks. And and I also understand I want to bring Jim Henson back on here. Uh Jim, you've been involved in information operations for the past 10 20 years. Your experience whether in the army on the civilian side uh demonstrates that there might be some messaging that is not going on now either by the Israeli government or perhaps coming from the US government in terms of what they should be saying to the Iranian people. If you were in a position to advise the White House or the Knesset or the Prime Minister's office, what kind of advice would he be giving to them about how to speak to the Iranian people as these strikes go on?

48:25 Start airdropping them Starlink terminals. I believe Elon Musk has turned on uh Starlink capabilities for Iran. He announced that on X uh and that would bypass the ability of the regime to shut it down. and if they get access to the rest of the world, I think to Alex's point, uh, they might see that a lot of people around the world believe this is the end of of the regime. So, I think there's they and I don't blame him. He said, he's right. It's a week. What do we expect in a week? You know, you cannot expect people to rise up against a 45 uh years of tyranny or because in one week a lot of stuff blew up. That's not going to happen. So, I think one uh one way they might just keep their heads down and be smart about this is there's no need to go force on force with the regime. Either one of two things is going to happen. Either the US gets in and destroys a lot more of the regime's capabilities or they do capitulate and President Trump starts peacemaking. And I believe that would

49:28 have to encompass some sort of elections, some sort of ability for the Iranian people to choose. You can't just make a deal with the same tyrants and say, "Okay, why don't you guys be better?" Maybe, you know, because the Iranians hold elections. They're faux elections. They only allow the candidates they want in. Call them on their game. They claim to that elections are real. Force the UN or someone to go in, hold elections. The the Mullers, the Ayatollas would lose overwhelmingly. They have, you know, less than 20% of a popularity among the people. So, those are a couple ways I think the Iranian people can keep hope and potentially get some more information if they can get access back to uh the the people out here saying this is a this is a great thing happening. Let's keep it going.

50:16 Winfield, you've written and uh not written per se, but you've reviewed extensively dozens of articles on the status of the different fronts that are involved in the Iranian opposition. You have the monarchists, you have the communists, you have the Kurds, the Azeris, the Beluchis, you have the Kameis, you have those who are unaffiliated. And in your review of all this literature, what do you see the interplay being between the Iranian opposition outside the country and those people inside the country? Do you have any thoughts on that? Yeah, I think it's gonna it's very complex is my understanding. I'm by no means an expert on that but it the um you have uh some of our authors uh Luckermanman Rodpiki for example and others arguing for uh increased autonomy among Kurds in Iran for the ballukes also uh for them to take advantage of this opportunity they've spoken of it and analogously to what happens what has happened in Syria with the north of Syria being um autonomous and an autonomous Kurdish

51:19 region Um then I many of our authors have also said on the other hand u Iranians are nationalists. Many of them are even you don't have to be Persian to be a nationalist in Iran. We've had several authors argue that over the past several months long before the the war of Israel began. um and that when you begin speaking about um overfederalizing if you will in their eyes or splitting up the country that you and can in fact weaken your cause that people may rally around even an oppressive government. So, um, as far as the diaspora goes, what I know of it, it comes primarily from reading Michael Rubin and hearing him talk and others about it, which is that it's, um, very diverse. It it ranges from ardent monarchists to communists and everybody in between. Um, some of whom want nothing to do with the Palabi dynasty, others of whom have never given up their loyalty to it. Um, so I think rallying around a central figure or a central

52:21 party makes a lot of sense. Whether or not it can be done, it's going to be very complex and as as others have pointed out, it can't happen overnight. This kind of thing is going to take a little while to do even if even if the chaos ensues, which is what she's point, chaos may be everyone's enemy even if the Ayatollah is overthrown in the process. All right, I want to thank our panel for joining today's edition of the Middle East Forum Israel Iran War Monitor. We'll have an update at Iran War Monitor.com that later this evening on all the news and events that happened uh over the last 24 hours. You can also reach the Israelis Iran uh war blog which is at meforum.org. you click on the upper leftand corner and for all the latest news and updates and should there be any intervention from the United States or any other breaking news, you'll be able to get a link from us in an email and get information from us as it happens. Thanks to our panel, Alex Selki reporting from Jerusalem. Uh Eric Navaro giving us military analysis from

53:24 Florida. Uh Jim Hansen from Washington DC. And also um Winfield Meyers giving us the latest from our bench of writers. Thank you very much and I hope you all have a great day. Tune in tomorrow for the latest edition of the Israel Iran War Monitor and live updates from the Middle East Forum. Thank you.