MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Why do Islamists Fake Hate Crimes? with Ahnaf Kalam

Watch Why do Islamists Fake Hate Crimes? with Ahnaf Kalam on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Earlier this year, international media uncritically reported that Uthman Ibn Farooq, a prominent Islamist preacher, had been attacked on the streets of San Diego by a knife-wielding "Islamophobe." Investigator and writer Ahnaf Kalam thought the tale a little too neat. In recent series of articles in Focus on Western Islamism, Kalam uncovered compelling evidence to suggest that Ibn Farooq faked his own stabbing. What was his motive? Is this the only example of fraudulent Islamist claims of hate crimes? Why does the media naively accept such unverified claims?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 30, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good day my name is Sam westrop I Am the director of the islamist project and welcome to the Middle East forums regular series of webinars I'm delighted to be joined today by anaff calendar we will be speaking to us on the subject of deceitfulness the interestingly interesting rise in the examples of falsified or seemingly falsified hate this is a subject we've written and talked about a bit before but enough let's head straight into it um enough is a writing researcher um he contributes to the focus on Western islamism our counter-islamist publication and as a contributor to a variety of prominent uh mainstream media outlets around the um enough uh tell us about um this rather interesting Shake you've been writing about in recent days um who is he where's he come from and what sparked your interest in this man um uthman even Farooq is a preacher who

1:07 is based in San Diego California he is uh perhaps best well known for uh his street dawah where he sets up a booth on the Streets of San Diego and he will proselytize Islam and he will debate people of other faiths uh Usman IBN farrukh in March of this year had claimed publicly that he was stabbed by a knife-wielding man shouting anti-muslim slurs at him and after he reported on this incident uh it had gone viral it was reported across the globe in a very short amount of time it reached as far as South Africa and Nigeria but uh I saw the video of the alleged incident after it had gone viral and right away it just did not pass the sniff test for me uh there were way too many red flags from the questionable blood you see in

2:11 the photo he posted immediately after the attack the uh lack of an actual video documenting the altercation the way that he would later speak about the incident publicly uh it just didn't add up and so curious to find answers as to what actually happened I first searched through the San Diego city's public records database and I found nothing and so then I contacted the San Diego Police Department who told me that uthman never even so much as filed a police report to them about the incident uh after I reported these findings in an article at fwi uthman IBN farrukh chose to double down on his story he basically claimed that he didn't file the report with the San Diego Police Department but rather with a uh with another Police Department within the greater San Diego County he also came up with this uh very lazy excuse that if he were to release any

3:16 details about the incident or about his attacker who is now supposedly in jail then his own personal information might get leaked and his security would be compromised because apparently islamophobes would come after him uh now uh since uthman had specifically named the San Diego County I decided to get in touch with the San Diego County's District Attorney's office and once again they told me that they have not received any records from this case from any law enforcement agencies in the entire County interesting and so well I think quite a few questions come out of this but one I think is the key one is why was the media so willing to believe this shapes claim to have been attacked um what why was there an initial rush to report was there any skepticism from

4:18 local media from from International media about this uh you know once it was uh reported that this incident likely never took place uh we didn't really get many retractions or clarifications or uh any edits to any uh mainstream reporting on the story uh I feel that is because uh oftentimes the mainstream media is also complicit in trying to paint a certain narrative uh we saw this with that Infamous jussie Smollett hoax and it's the same narrative that these islamists are trying to portray uh before the details are even released they will jump on these stories and uh deep down I I personally think that it's because they desperately want these hoaxes to be true so that they can effectively portray the world as US versus them or as uh you know we are the victims they are the oppressors it's very easy uh that narrative is very effective uh in bringing people to your cause when people uh see you as the

5:21 perceived victimized Underdog in any circumstance now I should mention to the audience if you if you have questions uh as we discuss this please use the Q a box at the bottom of your screen type of question I'll be able to see us and I'll try to get to it into your course uh enough I understand you recently attended a conference where this shake even farook was was speaking did you ask him there about uh these claims about his his claims to have been stabbed in and your findings that he may have made the whole thing up yeah so uh last weekend uh Usman Farooq was one of the speakers present at a salafist islamist convention in my city in Colorado uh it was called ilmacon and so I purchased a ticket to this event in hopes that I could ask uthman directly about the incident and so Sunday evening when I was finally able to ask my question predictably uthman was unable to provide a single answer instead he resorted to

6:26 shouting he resorted to name calling he called me a liar he called me in islamophobe at one point in a desperate last-ditch effort to uh Dodge the he even claimed at one point that these people right through these same websites that also claim that school shootings involve paid actors which I shouldn't have to say is absolute nonsense but it's just a another tactic that he was using to to dodge the question once again okay so we have this judge we have a very prominent Street Preacher seemingly faking a stabbing attack on himself along with a video and a huge amount of press we have that video now apparently um and we have him getting very defensive in public uh calling you a a liar and so on will there ever be a reckoning for someone like IBN Farooq Who Lies who deceives his way into claiming that the the islamophobia problem is so great

7:30 that he is literally being stabbed as he tries to carry out his preaching on the Streets of San Diego well you know they're uh in in his particular case I I believe that the answer is no because uh I don't know what further recourse uh exists for Usman Farooq uh the San Diego Police Department the San County District Attorney's Office a number of other local police departments have all uh said the exact same thing which is they they've not even heard of this incident they have no recollection or or any record of this ever taking so I think this is why uh Usman IBN farook and other people who do these uh this is why they resort to uh the the things that they're doing right now all they can do is deflect and call their critics Liars call their critics islamophobic uh because he knows I'm sure deep down that uh that that's all he can do um if if he really wanted to clear his

8:35 name and set the record straight it would have been very easy to provide even a name any piece of information pertinent to the case but he's been up he's been unable to do that and I suppose even if we can't see evidence of it there'll be plenty of ordinary Muslims out there moderate regular Muslims who become aware of your your writings become aware of your your pieces and someone like Evan Farooq will be less welcome in the in them their mosques in their Community Center and so on so perhaps his Reckoning is a slow burn a more long-term uh pernicious Revenge than than something we can see and and claim credit for but this is this is fascinating because a lot of islamist groups in this country and I'm sure our listeners will be aware of of this have uh you know they spend a great deal of time justifying their existence because of this apparent fast islamophobia threat as they call it now there's no doubting that there was occasionally violence against Muslims

9:37 and some horrific violence that that by very unpleasant dangerous uh uh uh uh radical networks of other of other sorts um but is this happening on a scale that people like IBN Farouk or groups like The Council on American Islamic relations would like us to believe is this is this is this happening is even fruit just the exception and most of all the other incidents are are genuine do you think or or should we be more skeptical of this claims of an onslaught of islamophobic attacks across America well um even farook's incident is certainly not uh certainly not the exception in that uh while absolutely these these attacks against Muslims absolutely happen um to a scale that we may not know but it is very common very frequent that we have had these instances of Muslims staging uh anti-muslim Acts that uh end up getting debunked but

10:43 nevertheless you have groups like care like you just mentioned you have uh uh mpac the Muslim public affairs Council who also will run with these stories uh without checking them without uh without a moment of scrutiny uh and these fake uh islamophobic hate crimes happen much more frequently than I would say real ones do from what I from what I've gathered here uh for instance in 2016 a Muslim student in Louisiana reported that she was approached by two males one wearing a Donald Trump hat and the other shouting racial and religious slurs are uh she claimed that the two men forced her to give them her wallet and her uh later she was charged by the police department for filing a false report when it was revealed that uh that this never likely took place this whole thing was staged and set up uh another instance that really stands out here very similar

11:45 a year later in 2017 a Muslim student at San Diego State University had reported that two men had approached her after allegedly making comments about Islam and Muslims and about Donald Trump but this time not only did the girl claim that the two men who approached her uh stole her purse and her backpack but she also initially reported that they stole they stole her car uh she later redacted this part but a later investigation uh after later investigation uh it was determined that the investigators on the case were confronted with a hoax the victim of the alleged incident stopped cooperating with law enforcement and there are so many similar cases just like this one so many manufactured uh but what's most remarkable to me is that they invent so many hoaxes and they are so dependent on these hoaxes to push their agenda and construct their

12:48 Narrative of course with the help of groups like care and mpac and others and yet they still have not worked out how to make these fake hate crimes even remotely believable for the most part so just to dive if you had to Hazard a why does it benefit islamist groups portray this deeply dangerous islamophobic Society in other words why does it benefit islamist groups that they are the victim do you have any thoughts on that why does that help them to be the victim uh well it it certainly helps them in the current climate and certainly in the climate of the last presidential uh cycle of last presidency uh so many of these cases involve uh Donald Trump or or they involve this uh this enigmatic sort of Boogeyman of these racist white you know usually Trump supporting men uh it plays very well to them in in these

13:51 times because for well it plays very well for them for the same reason that the Chelsea smallett hoax played out so well for Jesse small out until it was revealed that it was entirely a hoax uh people you know whether they know that these things are uh truthful or whether they have any idea that they might be staged that doesn't stop them from exploiting them and using them to to to just ride them to their political excuse me to ride them to their political ends which could be uh you know an anti-trump thing in these cases uh they just want to paint a narrative using facts that don't exist to paint a picture that is not supported by reality that if you are a Muslim if you're a practicing Muslim let's say if you wear your hijab uh then you should prepare to be the victim of this next incident you should you should be on the lookout you should effectively be paranoid that some knife-wielding islamophobes are going to

14:55 attack you or steal your purse or what have you so just a reminder to the audience if you do have questions uh for Mr Callum please do use the Q a box that was on your screen and Stephen gerzov writes and he says uh we need an acronym for this type of of hope so word we can use to to embarrass them for for carrying this out in the first place uh for not for the media not following up on it and for the idea that in the blank phobia is being driven uh uh uh by this this failure to to hold uh deceitful Islam is accountable um but I yeah it's it's there's obviously this is obviously a phenomenon you've come up with quite a few examples and I'm sure there are others and I believe we've discussed and written about some of those other examples in various pieces of the Middle East Orem uh in in the past um so whether we have a term for it or whether we just draw attention to it um there's clearly an effort we made here but but Stephen goes on to say we need serious prosecution for people

15:57 finding these false claims or making these these these these now I guess that would apply if they're actually reporting this to the police but in IBN farooq's case right we don't think he even went to the police there was no contact with law enforcement that that was made up as well as claims we believe his claim is that so so I mean I mean we already spoke about a reckoning but is there anything more that Muslims should be doing ordinary moderate Muslims who are sick of this from their self-appointed islamist leaders there's anything more that we should be doing is there anything that journalists should be doing aside from being better at their jobs uh who is not doing what here uh you know I think all of those groups of people that you just mentioned there are uh are to to varying degrees equally guilty of doing the same thing uh journalists and in this case Muslim communities Muslim advice advocacy groups uh non-profits none of them bother to employ even just the slightest amount of uh skepticism or you know or even just a basic

17:02 rudimentary journalistic questioning process to uh you know to get even even if it if for nothing else than to to just get the details of these incidents and these attacks but uh they don't do uh and I'm uh perhaps speculating here but I think journalists oftentimes don't do that because they have a very attractive story that will surely go viral and get plenty of clicks but Muslim communities don't do that because they already have their narrative from the moment that they read this news report which which the journalists in question here uh did very little to corroborate and actually verify they run with these whether it's true or not and frankly I don't think they care if it's true or not there's been past instances where representatives from the Muslim public affairs Council have have basically Justified these fake anti-muslim hate crimes uh by saying something along the lines of uh let's say that it's the climate

18:06 that is making these people do these things it is the the constant fear of of trump and of trump supporters that would drive somebody to do this but there's there's no skepticism and there's also no accountability after the fact you know okay now the groups we've mentioned groups like care which like impact a lot of these I think our listeners will know or be familiar with the idea that this is part of of an islamist network of the United States called the Muslim Brotherhood but is not the Muslim Brotherhood is he he comes from a more salafi style thinking and and just while you know while we've got you um uh you attended this conference in Colorado that you mentioned um this was not your typical run-of-the-mill business conference it's not the islamists that most of our listeners are familiar with these were hardcore salafis I believe um uh tell us tell us about this conference is this what were they saying and do people like farook uh does he

19:12 does he have a particularly large Network on which his his sort of extreme uh ideology is is being pushed in advance does he have a serious Network behind him yeah this uh this conference was interesting while in person and even as these events were happening uh in the building and on the live stream there were very very few people present or watching considering uh some of the speakers that were present uh with uthman IBN Farooq he is actually a very uh well-known pretty famous uh islamist preacher across the globe uh his his one message Foundation YouTube channel his his organization has hundreds of thousands of subscribers and viewers uh all of his social media posts are met instantly with thousands of commenters singing his praise and that's been very evident throughout this whole investigation in this whole ordeal uh uh you could debunk uthman IBN farooq's

20:18 claims very easily and provide evidence and yet his strong and extensive Army of supporters just seems to cast all of the evidence aside because they they just so desperately want his story to be true uh this was the seemed to be the case for the most part at this conference I attended this weekend uh while there was definitely a a strong amount of expressed support for uthman even farook there was also a equal amount of uh division that took place within this conference when another uh notable islamist called Daniel hakikachu at this conference they'd set up an entire panel basically challenging hakikachu's views and his positions and some of the claims he's made a video of this altercation of this of this confrontation it was posted to YouTube It's received like nearly 50 000

21:21 views to date and all of the hundreds of comments seem to be overwhelmingly in support of hakikachu and actually against uthman IBN Farooq so I am curious to uh to see how some of these divisions play out especially uh in light of the events at this conference this weekend I see so it's possible that should uh additional internal islamist divisions continue to grow continue to flourish but these ostensibly or seemingly fake hate crimes that Farooq relies on to advance his own brand may end up working against it we may find at some point uh Islam is even citing our material perhaps as part of these disagreements which isn't which is something we have seen before I think in other countries so this is fascinating um we have had a couple of questions just asking again about what is the who is the target for these these fakes uh seemingly faked uh uh incidents they're just about uh uh fellow Muslims fellow

22:25 islamists uh but then a few people ask well or is this more about the American political systems as a way to to embarrass the right and someone even asks is this a way to embarrass president Trump which I think is is quite a question um so so uh enough what do you think is this all about internal Muslim politics or is this about wider broader societal and political uh stuff as well yeah you know with the uh I I do think it's a little less about internal Muslim politics with regards to uh these uh these hate hoaxes these fake hate crimes I think most of these hate crimes that they stage are more aimed at uh yes the political system we saw many many claims of uh Trump supporters or people wearing Trump hats or people uh you know espousing pro-trump rhetoric that all turned out to be false but it's a very common theme stringing all of these separate incidents together uh like I mentioned a moment ago I think

23:28 no matter what uthman even farrukh says or any of these people who are staging these hate crimes saying there will always be uh certain dedicated fraction of their followers who will uh who will just follow and believe everything they have to say no matter what uh but uh as a whole I think most of this is certainly more politicized against the American right in many cases uh against the American left really anybody who has been critical of Islam or islamism using these manufactured hate crimes they uh these people now have ammunition to say that uh this leads to this and before you know it you have people stabbing you and stealing your car because they are islamophobes and I thank you for your time um where can our listeners go to read your your writings and to to follow your yes uh so I uh I am a regular contributor at the focus on Western

24:30 islamism publication uh which is probably the uh the most pertinent writings uh on topics like these uh I write on my sub stack page it's just my first and last name anafkalam.substack.com and you can follow me on Twitter it's my first and last name anaf Kalam okay okay Anna thank you so much for your time today uh to everyone else thank you very much for joining another Middle East Forum webinar this is a regular series if you would like to sign up to learn about additional webinars please do so at me forum.org thank you very much and have a delightful weekend bye