Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Alex Selsky: Who Can Form Israel's Next Government?
Watch on YouTube
Description
In this episode of Israel Insider, guest host Alex Selsky, the Middle East Forum's Director of Israel & East Mediterranean Affairs, explains the race to form Israel's next government. Gadi Eisenkot holds the mandate after 67 Knesset members recommended him to the president, including the 19 Arab members, but the four Zionist parties of the opposition bloc have only 48 seats between them.
Selsky lays out the two paths to a minority government: adding Mansour Abbas's Ra'am, the option Yair Golan is pushing, or bringing in the Haredi party United Torah Judaism after Avigdor Lieberman dropped his boycott of the ultra-Orthodox parties. He discusses the criticism of Lieberman's reversal, the opposition's takeover of the Knesset's key committees, including Lieberman's new post as chair of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Naftali Bennett's pivotal position, and why he sees another round of elections as a real possibility that would suit Netanyahu.
In the Q&A, he takes audience questions on the effect of the Democratic gains in the U.S. midterms on Israel's coalition talks, whether Israelis would accept a government that includes an Arab party, why a unity government looks unlikely for now, why Bennett will not join Likud, the positions of Shas and United Torah Judaism, Israel's record with minority governments, and whether Netanyahu still governs while the opposition controls the Knesset.
Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:21 Where coalition talks stand
2:55 The Ra'am option
5:19 The Haredi option
9:04 Lieberman's reversal
12:10 The opposition takes the Knesset
15:38 Selsky's forecast
16:48 Audience questions
30:07 Closing
Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for new episodes and expert analysis every week.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 12, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 Another round of elections definitely is a possibility and I still think that this is what Nata wants and this is the best option for him because he will do better than the other side in the next round if it happens. [music] Dear friends, good evening from Jerusalem. Here's Alex Selki on our Israel Insider series and we will speak today about surprise surprise politics.
0:36 This is what you know occupies Israel is for the last weeks mostly and definitely this week and this week is amazing [clears throat] exciting and uh and full of you know surprises and I think the surprise will what I here to stay but but nothing is clear so let's you know I want to make some uh some order for you what's happening. So um we had the elections uh the results we uh we we spoke about them and we explained them. So now there's there is a opposition that tries to you know to organize in a creative way a possibility to build a coalition based on this opposition which was the opposition during the previous um term. But it's difficult. It's a
1:42 complex formula and uh it can go two ways or to combine in a way. One way is to take all the 48 seats of the four Zionist parties within the opposition meaning Eisenot, Bennett, Liberman and and Golan which are again Now you need if you need either majority, regular majority right above 60 or you can have a minority government less than 60 but you need to have more than the camp of Netanyahu and then you need that the rest don't either don't support any of the blocks war supports more one of the blocks but it's enough that
2:45 they don't support right but so so for example one of the pos so now there is a competition between two possibilities one possibility that yer gulan is pushing for and in a way agrees to is to cooperate with the Arab parties now here I remind you we have at the moment 19 Arab seats which is the highest ever. eight of which are of Ram party which is more for integration into the Israeli society and 11 of joint Arab list which is let's say roughly less integration into the Israeli society where you have more people who attack criticize Israel Israel as a Jewish state don't accept Israel as Jewish state
3:47 Mansur Abbas on the contrary of Ram does accept the Jewish state. He didn't declare that Hamas's uh terror organization but yesterday for example on the opening ceremony of the Knesset when the national anthem of Israel was played Abas stayed in the standing but didn't sing while the joint list MK case went out.
4:23 So, so one option as I said pushed by Ergolan and in a way um supported by Eisenhod is to take Ram which is seven mandates to add to the 48 and then you have 50 um uh 56. This 56 is more than 53 of Netanyahu's block. And then if you have the joint list, the Arab joint list not supporting So you are minority but your opponent is less minority. So you can survive and you can manage uh now how long you will survive and manage if you have organized you actually can survive uh for the long Another possibility and this possibility is not less interesting and even maybe more in a way is to cut to to invite and
5:30 to bring into this coalition the ultra orthodox the kedi parties. Now I remind you that the major slogan of the opposition block these four parties was the alignment of the serving right those who serve they spoke about the fact that Nathaniel sold the country right quote unquote to nonzionist he was ready to give them everything.
6:09 And now and and by the way and the one that was most um tough, most hawkish on this slogan was a victim and his whole campaign was based primarily on this. And now in the beginning of this week, a Vic de Liberman announces that he cancels the boycott of the Kedi parties and he's ready to negotiate with them and many different publications we already see and hear about him speaking to the head of the Yad Torah which is the Ashkenazi.
6:51 There are two parties inside but one list Ashkinazi list which has seven seats today. Shas still are not joining it but they but we do hear that you know and and and and and Derry maybe resign or he he resigns but he still remains to be the you know the the the position of of of you know of of Shas is still not clear but Shas is only six this time it's their biggest fall since almost the beginning of their existence. So then you can have the 48 + 7 which is 55. But these seven are not taken from outside like in the Arab option but it's taken from Natanyao block. So then he doesn't have 53 then he has 46. So you you in in in in this
7:58 possibility you again have a minority government but the minority is much bigger than the competing minority than the opposition and then Ram can be like the Arab joint police not necessarily inside but they can support from outside. Now Ram wants to be inside and as I told you part of bodies in this block want Arabs and now there is a competition between Liberman and Eisenhot because Liberman apparently by bringing the Karedi puts his conditions which everybody thought will be half of the term being a prime minister But he said and declared that he doesn't demand being a prime minister and and and and
9:02 okay and and no rotation if so first of all so why then okay many people say okay so how come that Liberman gives up his most important message for the last what seven years How come that one day, you know, he just flipped just just everything for the sake of, you know, throwing out Natao from the political map. And also you know we hear the voices of the whipper orthodox parties parties who say you know in one all the attacks all this hate that we had from the center left just vanished just disappeared because they need us now.
9:48 And the and the and the most interesting thing is that Nat that that Liberman speaks with the heredium on the draft law which he proposed in 2018 which many claim that is much better for than the last legislation proposed by Bose Bismouth which all the opposition parties said that is that. So how come now you bring the and giving them a better option after you made all your campaign on saying that you have to stop the kared rule and stop this bad law that nothing else gives them. So that's the the critics on on on this shift.
10:41 Liberman says listen we cannot get everything. the numbers don't allow us to you know to reach all our goals. So we have to prioritize and the first priority is to first of all get rid of Natanyao and then we and and and make the laws you know the most important laws of first of all as he claims to to limit for two terms the the term of the prime minister and to cancel the laws of the judic judicial reform um that was before October 7th the major the major issue uh how it will happen if it will happen it's very unclear for example just because yesterday we saw that Netanyahu sat with the leader of the Yadashkinazi party who is by the way the new leader
11:48 Yakov Vashil and uh after a very long meeting they briefed you know they announced to the media that they stopped the process of the Kedarian joining um the opposition. We will see we shall see you know in the coming days if that is possible. The meanwhile though very important things happen in the h in in the process in the progress of building the coalition. At the meantime at this erh interm period of establishment of a new government of a new coalition um the the the MK that received the mandate from the president to establish the coalition and and this is Eisenas.
12:46 He got 67 voices h that recommended him to the president including the 19 of Arabs, He can replace the speaker of the Knesset and the heads of the major biggest Knesset committees which is the security the defense of foreign affairs and the financial committee and Liberman got the the the the he's the head now from today of the defense and foreign affairs committee which is actually actually one of the two of the most important committees in the Knesset. The other committee, the financial committee got some new MK from Bennett's party. But the most important that there is a there is no chair speaker at this time. There is a committee it's called Vadab. It's like the committee that that that you know internal committee that manages
13:50 actually the Kesset at the moment. And this committee also is taken by the opposition block. So at the moment in terms of the mechanism of the Knesset management all the major committees all the major roles are taken already by the opposition and it's easier for them to manage at this at this period of time you know to to to be able to to form a uh next week you know we will see what option uh prevails the the the you know the option of Arabs or the option of the ultra orthodox and the interesting the most interesting voice actually is not of Eisenhot and Liberman because we we hear exactly their opinions and positions and Golan's position is very you know far left to go you know fulltime with Arabs all 19 to to to to put in including the join list but the
14:56 most crucial opinion and position is actually the position of Bennett who together with laid I remind you is 12 but he's alone in seven so without him nothing can happen and he still insist he he he he declares some vague declarations you know we work hard to establish the the next coalition, next government. But it's clear that he will not be the one willing to go with the Arabs. But I remind you, he already did that. He was the prime minister on together with Ram already. So he definitely can do that. So at the moment if you ask me and I summarize here I think that the heredi option is at the moment gets high chances even though Natao says that he you know stopped it with Ram I think also possible joinment of the both Arab lists I don't
16:03 I I don't think possible I don't think possible Liberman doesn't let it happened and he says, you know, we better have Kared than the Arabs. But I still do think that there is high chance that they will not agree that they will not find a common ground for all of them and another round of elections definitely is a possibility and I still think that this is what Nata wants and this is the best option for him because he will do better than the other side in the next round if it happens. Uh that's uh that's what I wanted to say on my side. Now let's go to the comments and the questions. David Levvin asks, "What impact, if any, does the impending loss of a Republican Congress in the US have on the outcome of the current attempts to for a new government in Israel?" That's a good question. First of all, we didn't speak about it in the con, you know, in the context of Israeli politics
17:09 But it's definitely connected. I think that um this shift um um uh the the wave [snorts] right the blue wave in the Congress that happened in the states definitely helps the opposition to claim and to criticize the policy of and to convince that you know he has to be replaced. We heard Trump saying that, you know, the age should be stopped. We heard Trump saying that the war is over.
17:51 We heard Trump saying that there is a a very big dislike to Israel. And all this is amplified by the opposition block uh or the change block as they call themselves and and as they are called the change block, right? the opposition to block to actually, you know, to actually claim that this is another proof that Netanyah has to be changed because he lost America. another question of Jay Lewis, do you really think Israel is will accept a government that include the Arab party?
18:30 Well, Israel has already accepted a government that includes the Arab Arab party. This is the government of change the last one between 2021 and 2022 where Napali Bennett was a prime minister and Nafali Bennett you know not a lefty not a leftist right he was you know just 10 years ago he was the Bengir of the Israeli politics in a way right he was the far right and and and he and Lieberman and Gidonsar in the previous government accepted Mansur abus and drum then having five mandates sitting as full part of a coalition not outside support for minority government. So if this can happen this already happened so so definitely and and also let's be clear and we hear that all the time now from that Nata negotiated with Mansurabas too. So you know speaking about the fact that you know the change
19:33 block can sit with Arabs and the Netanyao will never do that. We know we know that this is not right. We know that Netanyahu negotiated with Mansur Abbas and Matsur Abbas also claims that he already sent him messengers even on this round already too. If Israeli society first of all when you you know Israelis when you say Israelis there are no Israelis there are many different So if uh you know the joint the the the the change block the opposition will be able to uh to accept the joint Arab list which is more right left more anti-Israel anti-Zionist than Mansur Abbas we see that Liberman doesn't let it happen so they don't have the majority for that but Yurgulan definitely you know accept accepts them with open arms. So uh again when you say Israelis it it's
20:38 Israeli politics is not one unity. Okay. By the way, many of you may definitely ask, okay, Alex, but you didn't speak even about the possibility of a joint um unity government, which definitely majority of Israelis want, right? Because I don't think that it's possible. I think that all the talks about the UN governments at the moment at least until Eisenhower and Liberman and Yolan and and and Bennett and and and Laid explored all the possible options for them to form a government. I think the unity government is not possible. And by the way, Netanyahu says, you know, unity government is under me. I don't see Liberman definitely goes for it. I don't see at this point so far Eisen could goes it. I definitely don't see Bennett does it. Even though Bennett can surprise, he already surprised right in 21 flipping to another side. So I think
21:42 it's early to speak about a real possibility of unity government ifsoever if if if at all. Jack was exactly the the question you know um the extension from I just said you know why doesn't Bennett join with guys you know in Hebrew we say she's a personal right which is not personal is you know people asking how come how come there is such a you know hate uh toward Netanyahu is the the prime minister with uh a short pose of uh one and a half years of the previous government for the last 17 and all you know in in two months it will be
22:45 already almost um 18 years. this Knesset on the inauguration of this Knesset he became the MK that served in the largest number of Knessets more than Shiman Paris he's here very long and he you know he in a way doesn't let the second and the third the next generation of the litters to you know to replace him and and and and they suffer They want to, you know, throw him out.
23:22 And they also definitely claim that he does bad for the country. And they have many, you know, rightful claims like they claim that October 7th is the continuation of his policy, you know, to have kamas. Netanyao definitely, you know, and his supporters claim that, you know, he's the leader, not because, you know, he doesn't let them just because, you know, he's he's democratically elected and and and and that's democracy. Um, and again it I I don't see Bennett does it because all his ticket why the center left accepts him from the far right that he once was is because he's Nathaniel and that's his ticket. He will not do that unless I don't know. I I I I don't see him doing it. That's his political credibility. That's his political message to replace him.
24:28 You know, ideologically there is no problem. There is ideologic and another thing that they all of them they don't trust Nathaniel because Nathaniel you know they were all all of them you know Lieberman and Bennett and Eisenot you know in a way were well Eisen got less but Bennett and Liberman definitely these were very close people to Netanyao and and they don't believe him and Lieberman definitely you know has many claims proving that Netanyao cannot be believed And the biggest maybe um case study for his ability, you know, not not to be trustful is the the rotation government with Benny Gunce where he, you know, signed the agreement with Benny Guns saying, you know, I will do half term and you will do half term and everybody told guns, this is Nathaniel, he will not keep his agreement. He will not keep his promise. You will see. And that was happened. and and and Liberman brings many examples uh why can be can
25:34 be trusted and they have also claims against Netanyahu for you know for being uh caring for himself and not for the country. Um let's let's go for more questions. What is the position of Misra as opposed to Europe? And I suppose that the question was of shas as opposed to well I explained at the moment they you know they they they don't explicitly support the change block and they they in a way sit you know with nothing else but they they didn't they didn't exclude this possibility and there are talks So, so but again as I the change block they don't really need CH okay it's enough for them to have
26:39 only the Ashkinazi they have seven seats so uh so it's good enough for them and if Shas stays in block this is good enough [snorts] has Israel ever had a minority government that worked that's a very good question. Israel did have a period where the government didn't have and that didn't last long. It didn't survive for long. It's and and and and you know and definitely when Netanyahu is the the opposition had with you know most experienced with all the political you know most erh [clears throat] black tricks. So, uh that's that's a very good question. If it if it can survive, yes, but but but I
27:42 think it's very very hard. Um in view of the committee committees run by the opposition, does the government still govern? That's a good question. Yes, the government still govern. He's N that is still the prime minister. Okay. The fact that the opposition got the change block, got the control of the Knesset doesn't mean that the government has fallen. No, it means that they now will do everything to form the government if they will not succeed.
28:19 So the mandate I explained that in in in times uh in previous webinar so the mandate will go back to Netanyao and if Natao will succeed you know his government just prolongs if he doesn't succeed so the the the automatically and then in other elections and in the mean during which He continues to be prime minister, he is prime minister. Now if he's prime minister for the next 2 3 weeks or for the next few months that's you know that depends on the opposition and their ability to establish a that's a good question. Does Nathaniel first of all the previous question sorry was by Larry Greenberg about the government and next question is by Mahad Honari right I I tried to pronounce it
29:27 right this is a a beautiful Persian name does sincere is Nao sincere when he speaks about forming a national unity government. Is this a possibility? Well, I I I spoke about it widely. Um it is a possibility theoretically. I don't see at the moment if opposition succeeds to do it alone, they will not go definitely not under him. And he says, you know, I I'm the biggest party and if you don't succeed, so you know, I'm the head. So let's let's wait if they succeed. We have unfortunately you know many many many questions very good questions because you know the topic is definitely very interesting many questions but unfortunately we uh we're finished so I promise that next week we will still speak about the same issues but with much more results and much more
30:33 clarity on this. So uh stay tuned. You know, Israel is always interesting and definitely in politics. Thank you very much and all the best from Jerusalem.