MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Israel’s Seven-Front War: #3 Gaza with Daniel Pipes

Watch Israel’s Seven-Front War: #3 Gaza with Daniel Pipes on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Oct. 7 set off a series of shocks, from the IDF’s initial failure to the disruption of Red Sea shipping to a crisis on American college campuses. The situation in Gaza itself has also been unpredictable: agonizing hostage videos, Netanyahu demanding an “absolute victory,” an elusive Yahya Sinwar, and a failed $300 million American-built pier. What does this confusing picture amount to? In what direction is the conflict heading? Where is it likely to leave Israel, Hamas, and the Gazans?

Daniel Pipes has taught Middle Eastern and world history at Harvard University and the University of Chicago, served on the State Department's Policy Planning Staff under President Reagan, founded the Middle East Forum, overseen $25 million in grants, and written eighteen books. His nineteenth, Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated, appears this month.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 22, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:09 good morning we'll begin our program in just a few moments good morning my name is Jeffrey herps and I'm president of American Jewish University and welcome to another program offered on our digital open learning platform today it's a pleasure to again join with our colleagues at the Middle East Forum as we present our series Israel's seven front War today I'll be talking with Daniel pipes about Israel's war in Gaza but first welcome back to American Jewish University since the beginning of the pandemic we've welcomed many tens of thousands of people on our over 200 digital programs we hope you'll go to our website www.ju.edu often to see the exciting programs we have coming up on Thursday at noon Pacific time I'll be talking

1:14 with Admiral Mike Mullen former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff about the wars in the Middle East Admiral Mullen of course was America's top ranking military officer for four years and I'm sure we'll have a fascinating perspective today it's a pleasure to welcome Daniel pipes president of the Middle East forum and publisher of Middle East quarterly his writing has focused over many years on American foreign policy in the Middle East as well as on Islam he'll have a new book appearing in June called Israel Victory how zionists win acceptance and Palestinians get liberated and you'll see the link to his website in the chat function at the bottom of your screen I'll be talking with Daniel for about 15 minutes and then we welcome questions from you the audience please start submitting your questions by the Q&A function at the bottom of the screen now and I'll get to as many as soon as possible program as total will last for about 30 minutes Daniel welcome pleasure

2:18 to talk with you today and it's been a pleasure to work with you and your colleagues thank you Mutual Daniel looking back to the day after October 8th um it was obvious that Israel was going to begin military campaign against Hamas over the last months what surprised you or what's noticeable about how that campaign has evolved I got to say Jeffrey that everything that's happened since October 7th is surprising H October 7th itself was a shock uh and so much that's happened uh where to start uh the Israeli incompetence and lack of preparation was surprise uh I believe that Hamas itself was surprised it did not expect to kill and capture so many people and probably not happy about having done it because it led to much greater Israeli

3:22 reaction the outside world surpris the outside world has surprised me in the sense that amas is able as it has been for years but even more now to convince many Muslims islamist Muslims especially and the left that it is the victim no matter what it does no matter how brutal it is how many people kills takes hostage it is the victim that message that convinces so many on the left and among Muslims is I got to say a surprise uh the solidarity with Europe sorry solidarity with Israel on the is a surprise uh the emotional support for so everything is surprising where do you think if you describe the current situation now what do you think are the most important things to observe in the next few weeks or months what are you paying attention

4:25 to to me the Great self-contradiction is both in the Israeli government and the American government the two key actors outside of Hamas the American government we see President Biden as a long and deep sympathy for Israel feels for Israel is concerned about Israel's security and at the same time has an election coming up in what five months now and wants to keep his left wing which is viciously anti-israel board so how does he reconcile his own concern for Israel with the need to appease keep on good terms with the toxically anti-israel left of his party and that has led him to adopt inconsistent positions as symbolized by the speech he gave last Friday just three days ago and which made no sense at all a pure self-contradiction similarly in Israel

5:29 you see another self-contradiction because they're two goals that are both Paramount and they're self-contradictory one is to defeat destroy Hamas which prime minister and many others have many times repeated no more Hamas on the other hand the return of the hostages now if you're going to get the return of the hostages you have to negotiate with Hamas if you're going to negotiate with Hamas you can't defeat Hamas so uh the Israeli government has renounce these two contradictory goals as though they can do them both at once they can't and it goes back and forth uh those of us who watch these matters closely try and figure out what is the actual real Israeli priority the Paramount priority and it keeps being unclear because they go back and forth so I think that's at the heart of this what is the American government policy what is the Israeli government policy now there's of course Hamas but we don't know anything about Hamas so I can't really talk about it the tensions there too but we don't know enough to speak

6:34 it Daniel thanks for that let's explicate a little bit both the Israeli and the American positions there's been a lot of talk about how uh prime minister netanyahu's own political support which is based on a complex Coalition within his cabinet also um muddies and makes more complicated War the war aims do you think that the current political structure supporting Netanyahu that allows him to stay in power allows for any kind of uh clear Israeli policy or is it one that forces him to muddle through uh you're absolutely right that there are two politicians two parties in his Coalition who made it clear that the hostages cannot be the Paramount priority that destroying her L must be and they will quit if that's not the case but there are other parties who could join them now they're not parties who want to save netanyahu's government but they might decide that should push

7:38 kab they would be willing to save the government in order to get the hostages released so the internal Israeli politics of this are very complex and nobody knows whether G Leed liberman others might join if SM rich and B beer allowed um but ultimately really it's decision what's his Paramount priority so far he's fudged he said they both are well they can't both be we'll find out eventually I don't know I don't know nobody know dobly the Prime Minister himself doesn't know do you think there's much demand for what is Israel's day after vision for Gaza do you think it has one uh prime minister Netanyahu on a number of occasions has especially in March of this year it has outlined what he prefers to see and I'm happy to say that

8:41 I think it's a very good Vision um but it's not been much talked about for the last two and a half months so I'm not sure if it's still his vision but essentially it was to have Israeli military control briefly and then find Gins non- Hamas or anti- Hamas Gins to work with I think that's by far the best solution you don't want the Palestinian Authority you don't want the Arab states you don't want International soldiers you don't want Israeli soldiers you want gin who are willing to work with Israel and as I understand Gaza as I understand the suffering of the gazin at the hands of Hamas I think there are plenty such cins who if assured that Israel will be there and not abandon them would be willing to work with Israel so I hope that continues to be the Israeli plan for the day after he hasn't talked about

9:45 it and a while now so I don't know but so far that has been the articulated plan when under what criteria does biben and yahu declare victory in God a not every Hamas fighter will be uh dispatched uh it will still have support among the population when do you declare victory nany has sounded a bit like Churchill uh he's talked about absolute Victory and total Victory and complete Victory and and the like uh his his some of his speeches have in some ways echoed chch uh if you go back to World War II Nazism was destroyed not every Nazi was destroyed the ideology of Nazism was not entirely destroyed but Germany emerged as a non or even anti-nazi State uh I think taking into account the

10:49 many many differences that is roughly what Israel with Netanyahu would like to see a Gaza where Hamas and its Jihadi ideology its anti-zionist it's maneuvering its power are destroyed now there will still be people who are pro Hamas there will be troubles to come but if the Israeli military can take control of the entire strip which is after all quite small and can find anti am cins to work with or reputable or serious or trustworthy then I think there can be a post Hamas Gaza that works that's decent decent is my word I don't see this being Democratic I don't see this being a place where you and I would want to live

11:51 I would say the goal would be something like what one sees now in Egypt or Jordan these are police States but there police states where if you keep your nose clean you don't insult rulers you don't get to be too difficult you're left alone I'd like to see that Gaza Daniel on as side and part of your answer you pretty much rejected the Palestinian Authority having a role in Gaza do you want to expand on that a bit the Palestinian Authority and Hamas are similar in their goals which is destruction of Israel they're different in their personnel their tactics uh their ideologies but they're really no different than their goals and Hamas in some ways is a better enemy for Israel than the PA be because Hamas is overt it tells what it

12:54 thinks it makes no pretense of accepting Israel the PA which came into existence almost 30 years ago as for all that existence worked to undermine Israel to destroy Israel but somehow rather managed to fool people few Israelis fewer and fewer but still much of the world including say the US government thinks oh the PA is great we can work with the pa pa is abominable the PA is unacceptable I believe the PA should be brought to down it doesn't need to be brought down through Force by the way just not handing over money Israelis are fully within their rights not to turn over the monies that they agreed to turn over because the PA has not fulfilled its condition PA doesn't fulfill its conditions Israel doesn't have to fulfill its conditions I wish the Israeli government would stop turning over money but prime minister Netanyahu in the security establishment see the PA

13:57 as helpful as I think that's a big mistake but that is until now their view they would rather have the PA with all its faults which they're perfectly aware of then to be rid of it and start over Daniel is last of my questions and we'll go to questions from the audience and thank you for submitting them and please keep sending them let's go back to the United States policy Gaza Israel so throughout since October 7th there's been emanating from the Biden Administration in the hope of a big diplomatic bankshot uh that you solve the uh uh problem in Gaza uh there's normalization uh between Israel and Saudi Arabia and therefore a realignment is set up um and there's been a lot of talk about do operations in Gaza help or hinder that kind of big diplomatic uh play what's your view on that uh and especially the Saudi uh Prospect in principle it's a great idea in fact I

15:02 promoted this in an article in 1990 n less I called it the outside in you know you get a deal Israel gets something from the Arab states and give something to the Palestinians in principle great idea since October 7 it's out of the question there's no way that the Israeli government can or should be induced to accept the PA taking over in Gaza in return for relations with diplomatic relations with Saudi Arabia no the I would say from my point of view and I would hope the Israeli government point of view the PA Gaza is absolutely unacceptable it is no less an enemy it should not be given any reward or any increase in power uh in order to get U for Israel to get relations with Saudi Arab relations with Saudi Arabia are great it' be wonderful if that happened but it's not worth it for such a price at this point Daniel let's go to questions from the audience as I said please keep

16:04 submitting them and I'll be talking with Daniel for about another 15 minutes uh got a couple questions Daniel on what one uh member of the audience says Israel has lost many opportunities in the ongoing war of public relations um can you comment on what Israel could be doing to begin that win war yeah I completely agree the emphasis has been from yesterday's Israel parade in New York to every other asbra effort has been bring the hostages home has been essentially yellow ribbons has been look how we've been murdered raped uh and otherwise abused I don't think that's a winning message I would like to see the Israelis point to the disaffection of Gins towards Hamas that's a powerful message Gins despise Hamas in their great multitude

17:09 they want out from Hamas Hamas is evil Hamas is tortured and murdered Goins as well as Israel that I think is a far more powerful message so uh I don't think saying woe is me we've been harmed is the way to win public support by saying whoo are the Goins have they've been harmed and let us tell you how let us show you let us broadcast for you let us make this available to you and the Israelis just don't do that uh a couple days ago they made the idea made available a single conversation between one of its officers and a gosin where he said how much he hated Hamas but you have to look very hard to find that it's just not part of what they do I think that would be the key to show how horrible Hamas is not towards Israelis but towards their own subject population Daniel what's been your evaluation of the media's coverage of the war it's been very

18:13 interesting imagine you and I were neighbors and we had some kind of Feud over I don't know trees or dogs or whatever it is and the local newspaper got interested and was on your side against me and it decided to publicize everything it could about me it searched my whole background found people who don't like me went on and on and on and and only good things about you now all this would be accurate there are people who don't like me I have done things which I shouldn't have done you are a great person but it is biased by virtue of the coverage it's not false it's just biased and that's what the mainstream media has done with Israel and Hamas is it looks at all the things that it can find that are bad about Israel or about Israeli Behavior Israeli mistakes and it makes them big as possible whereas Hamas and it's far more Grievous behavior is not

19:18 discusted uh so there's a bias by virtue of the nature of the coverage we see almost nothing about Hamas and how it treats its own subject population again the Israelis aren't doing it and the media isn't doing it and therefore the onus is on Israel now I'm not say Obviously the Israelis are are angels they're not they make mistakes but they are a democratic country uh pursuing with the rule of law a defense of totalitarian movement that is brutal and uh there's no comparison but the coverage makes it look like Israel is the aggressive evil party Danel who do you think's done the best in terms of media's coverage of the conflict who do you look to uh I tend to look to Israeli Publications in

20:23 English uh and they provide serious coverage as Times of Israel Jerusalem Post Israel national news uh also Alam Miner in the United States endless endless cage and if you look hard you find what what's really important Daniel another question from the audience um revolves around Egypt uh and what Egypt has done or not done for Gaza and gazin and specific question the audience member writes is why has the US avoided pressuring Egypt U and also wants to know about the United Nations um us relationship with Egypt Israel's relationship with Egypt complicated how do you see uh the Dynamics playing out there yeah good point uh Egypt like other arabic speaking countries has a contradiction as well in that the have long ago come to the conclusion s

21:32 do went to Jerusalem in 1977 47 years ago long ago come to conclusion that it's time to end its conflict with Israel it's too painful for Egypt militarily economically and otherwise they want it over but because 1977 or some 25 years the Egyptian government have presented Israel as the Zionist enemy that must be obliterated it inculcated an anti- sentiment anti- sentiment in the population that remains there so you have an anti-zionist population and a government that wants out that has been essentially out since 1973 since 51 years ago the government has been out it talks but it doesn't do anything really serious against Isel and so the government would like to be out of it but the people are not ready to be out of it and there therefore you have lots of country so for example the houthi attack on shipping in the Red Sea is a disaster

22:37 economically for Israel which counts on Suz Canal tolls but the government barely says a word because it's afraid that its population is happy about the houthi attacks because they're somehow anti-israel uh you see this in the in cairo's relations with Hamas well it doesn't like Hamas the government is anti-muslim Brotherhood at its core and yet and Hamas is musim Brotherhood and yet it is very careful with Hamas so uh the government of of Egypt as well as Jordan uh are very careful with this problem and uh show kind of snarling Grimace at Israel without really wanting to do anything negative towards Israel but they need to for domestic purposes Daniel another member of the audience writes Hamas recently

23:38 assassinated a clan leader who is willing to challenge them for ruling Gaza is it far-fetched to think that any gazin are willing to risk aligning themselves with Israel or that such Gins exist they definitely exist and you're right to point out that it's risky thing to do and I did mention earlier that the Israelis have to be there to protect them and not let them out uh to dry they have to Israel has to be there in force and has to work with these gazen administrators and police force and Educators and others uh yes I do believe uh that it can be done but it will take a real intense effort on the part of Israel to find the right people to provide them a security to fund them initially at least and to build up a new regime in Gaza again Gaza is a tiny Place shouldn't be that difficult Daniel we're getting out of

24:42 time but we have a few more minutes so let me try to get to as many questions as possible okay I'll be brief please be as in-depth as you as you choose um another member of the audience writes um after Mahmud abas uh leaves the scene one way or another would your evaluation of the PA change and its prospects both in the West Bank Gaza I doubt it the leadership of the PA is deeped in anti-zionist ideology and it's hard to imagine anyone having the power to make those changes look look at Saudi Arabia you have a kingdom a police state and a new guy comes in Muhammad bin Salman and he can make changes he's got that kind of power I don't think Mahmud Abbas can make that

25:44 kind of change I don't think a successor can the PA is an amalgam it's not a power structure and therefore I think it's unlikely to change its spot it will continue to be vicious uh totalitarian movement that it is today it is extraordinary how focused it is on on the destruction of Israel everywhere you go in the West Bank more than in Soviet Russia or Nazi Germany you're surrounded by messages about hating Israel destroying Israel killing Israelis it's just pervasive I have a hard time imagining imagining that that any single person could change that Daniel another member of the audience a good friend uh writes historically you have often espoused the concept that the solution of the conflict between the Palestinians and is and Israel is the defeat of the Palestinians and then have Israel dictate the terms of Peace uh similar to the resolution ending World War II has the event of events of October 7th and

26:49 aftermath changed your views on this uh well thank you for bringing up Israel Victory as you heard in the introduction that is the title of my book coming out in two weeks uh I believe that October 7th has made it all the more possible because pre October 7th I called for pulling down both the PA and Hamas and at that point getting rid of Hamas destroying Hamas seemed like a very remote possibility now it is on the plate it is what the Israeli government is saying it wants to do uh so that's far more with reach than it had been before October 7th uh the PA Still Remains at a distance because as I mentioned before the government Israeli government wants it there um so I think it's somewhat closer than it was before and let me just add that um I don't see so much the Israelis dictating the terms as I see the Israelis working with

27:54 Palestinians who are ready to work with Israel or friendly to Israel uh to make changes I think we have reached the point after a century and more of Palestinian rejectionism that there is a cohort of Palestinians who are skilled energetic and ready to work with Israel and Israel should wake up to them Israel has never paid them attention never seen them as a possible alternative to the rejectionist legacy of aminos yasar saraad mmud abas Yahya SAR has never looked to this other body of Palestinians didn't look to them in 1967 it didn't after the Israeli victory in the Six Day War it didn't look to them in 1993 with the Oslo Accords I hope it look to them in 2024 Daniel last question lot more that we could go through the audience I'm afraid I'm going to miss out on several dozen questions

28:56 but IR plays an important role in all of this uh in Israel's seven front War um in your estimation of what happens next in Gaza what are the Iranians goals and how does that play out in the complex relations between Hamas Israel and the States well the Iranians seek a ring of fire around Israel Lebanon Syria Jordan uh Saudi AR IA Yemen Egypt you name it they want to have Israel surrounded they want to choke Israel they want to destroy Israel they've done well uh they have control of four arabic speaking countries now uh they want to build on that they want to increase it they want to keep the pressure up uh death to Israel you know it couldn't be more clear uh the Israelis have been cautious too cautious in my estimation uh they should have done more

30:00 I hope they will do more to uh stop the Iranians whether it be this ring of fire or whether it be the nuclear weapons uh the Israelis are pretty much alone and they have real power and they can take steps what they did against Iraq in 1981 Rock was completely unpopular President Reagan was Furious but they did it and it was a huge hugely positive step they did it in 2007 in Syria nobody really noticed uh time to do the same with Iran today Daniel pipes pleasure to be talking with you about Gaza uh we obviously could go on for quite some time let me thank you both for this discussion and for your partnership with the Middle East Forum on our series Israel seven-part war next week at 11 am pacific daylight time I'll be talking with Hadi AIS noted Syrian analyst about

31:04 Israel's reactions and relations and war with Syria we hope you'll join us then and we also hope that you'll check out the websites of both the Middle East forum and American Jewish University for the many programs we have coming up which we hope will provide you Insight on these fascinating and difficult problems Daniel thank you so much for joining us today it's been a pleasure talking with you uh and also thank you to the audience I hope to see you on Thursday with my discussion with ad Mullen and many times in the future thank you so very much goodbye