Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
With Iran and its proxies threatening to retaliate for Israel’s spate of recent assassinations, does Israel face an all-out war on multiple fronts?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 21, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:09 okay good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forum's weekly podcast series Israel Insider my name is anaf colam and I will be moderating today's discussion we are pleased to have Ashley Perry adviser to the Middle East forums Israel office joining us each week to give us a briefing on the top events currently going on in Israel Mr Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience if you'd like to ask a question you can do so by using the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much ofnf and good evening from Israel when I first wrote um the title of this week's uh webinar about the uh the challenge and what it mean about hisbah and Iran attacking Israel I almost fully expected that to be in the past tense by now um there was a feeling that the attacks were imminent uh over uh Saturday Shabbat there was a
1:14 feeling that the attacks were imminent we even heard voices coming out of the US I think it was late last week that or even towards the end of the week that within 24 48 Hours the attacks would start one way or another I think Secretary of State Lincoln even alluded to that um um but we are still here uh and the attacks neither from hisbah in the North or Iran in the East have taken place at least not to a significant amount and certainly not uh what the so-called response to the assassinations last week of uh number two the chief of staff of um hisbah in Beirut and the assassination attributed to Israel by the Iranians and others of ish the head of the political Bureau of Hamas um in the heart of Terran in a rep revolutionary guards uh compound uh on the eve of the inauguration of the new president hugely embarrassing uh for the Iranians and
2:17 because of that they they uh have called for Revenge that Israel must be punished etc um the thing I should say at this point is as opposed to the attacks in really no one knows there's just pure speculation from wall to wall in the US in uh European capitals in Arab capitals in the region uh even in Israel I mean it's um there may be some people who who know uh something or have some ideas but usually these things are leaked usually these things come out and it doesn't seem like we're any the wise to understand um when these attacks will take place and the length and depth how uh brutal or not they may be both umah and Iran have said that as a result of these assassinations they're going to go harder than they were before Iran has said that it will uh respond more forcefully than the April attacks uh andah uh are talking about certainly
3:20 going much further than the attacks which are pretty much been just in the North mostly against military targets for the last uh 10 months that's the that's the first thing to keep in mind so everything I talk about From This Moment On is speculation it's opinion it's analysis but no one really knows at this point I I fully expected that there could be a possibility that we'd be holding this webinar as Rockets were flying uh above maybe in my safe room etc etc um but here we are it hasn't happened yet it could even happen tomorrow there is uh again you know everyone is floundering around looking for little signs and one of those signs that people are possibly pointing to tonight is in the early hours of tomorrow morning Thursday morning um Egypt have called on its airlines not to fly in or anywhere near Iranian airspace now they've claimed that it's uh perfectly innocent nothing to do with anything else but it it that that seems a little bit less likely but again we
4:25 just don't know the big um question from the Israeli leadership both political and Military are a number of questions first of all whether they need to put Israelis on standby uh longterm or medium-term or whether they just need to tell them a few hours in advance when they know um there's been major discussions on the home front about exactly what to do major meetings of the home front and there's been lots of training exercises uh not just the military but also medical facilities uh have done a lot of training exercises over the last few days there's even been talk or there was earlier in the week of uh creating some sort of tense cities in the south of Israel ironically there was talk of having places like stero niot perhaps becoming places of evacuation for those in the center of Israel like Tel Aviv and if we know uh these places there what in particular you know was the
5:27 place which was most under attack uh for the last number of years and obviously it was attacked on October 7th so uh there has been a lot of planning the government and the spokes people been under great strains to not show any panic and that's pretty much uh seen in the streets of Israel which is pretty much gone about its business as normal I myself attended a soccer match with my son yesterday there was no talk of uh postponing it or putting it off even though everyone in the stadium knew that at one point you know we could be under Fire and they even gave instructions at least twice during the game that if uh if there should be a siren exactly what to do the earlier indications of when a strike Could Happen uh pointed to a Jewish event next week Tish which is the nth of the Jewish month of a for those who do not know it is the day where Jews around the world commemorate the fall of the two temples and also many other Jewish Tri tragedies that occurred on
6:31 that day uh there was talk at least that the Iranians understood the significance and the symbolism of such a day and that could play into the fact that they could um you know deliver a more psychological blow on such a sad occasion but again this was speculation earlier than week we haven't heard since but the fact that it hasn't happened up until now means that certainly that dat could still be uh looked at what we do know is that the Us and other Western allies have been on a major diplomatic push to try and push the Iranians back from the brink to try and explain to them or threaten if you will uh why they should not do an attack and if they do it should be a lot softer milder um we've seen a massive military presence a massive military buildup with uh with um significant uh air power sea power moving to to the region uh much of it defensive but not only um it's
7:34 largely a sh Force it's highly unlikely that all this Weaponry will be used in an offensive way against Iran or any of its allies even though American troops have been under attack in Iraq uh over the last few days from Shiite groups again aligned with um Iran um but it is a show of force it's an impressive show of force and according again to some analyses that has given uh Iran pause uh for thought exactly uh what it should do interestingly enough while we saw uh some significant US military figures uh come to the region and we know that defense secretary Austin and defense uh Minister uh in Israel Galant have been on the phone constantly uh several times a day and we've got readouts from those and it basically just uh you know takes the same position that the Americans will uh you know it it's non-negotiable that Israel's security should be in question it will do everything to defend
8:36 it and as we've seen it's not just words it's also in actions as this was happening in parallel interestingly enough um the I think it's the head of the National Security Council of the Russian Federation someone very very close to President Vladimir Putin was in Iran and there were a lot of questions exactly what that means first of all for anyone who still believes that what's going on in the region is not being played out on a major Global geopolitical uh level um we just have to see some of these meetings it's clear that um there are opportunities on both sides and the Russians are certainly taking uh advantage of the situation um but also it has been suggested that the Russians are bringing in and according to uh at least something that I saw that many Russian um deliveries by air came into tan or Iran this week uh it it suggested that it's probably to bolster Iran's air defenses against a possible uh Israeli attack and that certainly
9:39 does change the scenarios a little bit because uh why was Iran does have a relatively impressive air defense system certainly Russia's is more impressive even though it's again not at the same level of Israel's or even even the us but again we see it was very symbolic while senior uh American uh defense and security officials in Israel we see the Russians uh in Iran clearly taking sides and clearly um there's something going on on a far uh greater scale um the other thing that uh has really come out in the last couple of days is from an Israeli standpoint whereas Iran's threats are being taken extremely seriously what is being taken even more seriously is the threat from the north the threat from Nala the leader ofah has come out many times and said that we will hit them harder the question is again what exactly it will do at the moment as we know the last number of months it's largely not solely but
10:43 largely attacked military um sites and relatively evacuated uh areas of the north it hasn't gone beyond a certain point um so the questions on the table exactly what it will do will it uh Target civilians centers which uh if there should be civilian casualties from the Israeli side that will certainly in the words of uh defense minister Galant and others will up the anti and Israel will make not just hisbah but Lebanon pay um or will it just uh just I say you know will it uh attack military installations or military sites further south the question also which has U has been asked for a number of weeks is um will Iran or maybe even um you know will it be enough for them if they can manage to uh Target some Israelis or Israeli some sort of Israeli symbol aboard again embassies are under extremely high alert ambassadors are
11:47 being you know protected far beyond what they were even a few weeks ago um so all of these things are being weighed up what Iran and to a certain exent hisbah have to do is they have to show that they are responding they have to show that it's a greater response than they've used before but probably neither of them at this point it seems Iran or want what's been described as an allout War um his I've said for a long time they're not interested in allout war and I think that still uh stands but they will have to respond forcefully then number two uh the chief of staff of theah very close to was killed in the middle of assassinated in the middle of uh Beirut they will have to to show to say face they will have to respond they also have to take into account the fact that there's a lot of anger in Lebanon against uh hisbah at this point so probably they won't want to drag Lebanon into a war but again like we had in mams
12:51 there could be a major miscalculation which could in the end lead to that war but most Israeli political and security officials are certainly more worried about uh the north um and also because of its proximity you know hisbah is literally on the border of Israel it can uh reach Tel Aviv a lot quicker than uh than Teran can so uh that's probably where most attention but not all attention at this point uh is is facing also the fact that um there are all these uh uh anti-missile capabilities from the US and other allies in the region which obviously uh is not the case on Israel's northern border the then we move on to the question that uh you know in the words of ram Emanuel never let a crisis be wasted there's always an opportunity um it's clear that the us is going to want something for this backing for this security uh enhancement in the face of these threats from Terror on and what seems to be
13:55 taking place is there's been a lot of pressure from the top President Biden on prime minister netan to be to moderate his stance on the hostage deal and it seems like again according to reports coming out of the us we saw um uh Kirby say that we're as close to an agreement as we ever have and there's a lot of optimism on the US side and they're trying to push both sides uh to this agreement and they're going to try and use the time after these attacks from fah Iran as long as they do not go into that all out War to try and finally end this because there's a feeling if you end it in Gaza there's a hostage release uh ceasefire then hisbah will fall into line that's what they've said many times um and that's what they're really hoping because certainly the Americans do not want this war to continue they they want it as contained as possible they do not want it to become a regional War which obviously uh one uh major hit on Israeli civilian center from either side could
14:57 lead to that uh uh War um on another note we heard this week the election of y sin to the head of the Hamas political Bureau that was a position held by is until his assassination um it's significant on many levels first of all we are finally if you know most most people around the world would would would not necessarily uh you know see the difference but now we can put away any of this sort of symbolic difference of separation between the political and the military Bureau because they're both invested now in the same person uh before there was this idea and certainly ma major media Outlets tried to paint ishia as some sort of moderate as a politician as a diplomat um the fact that it's now in the hands of the bloodthirsty sin while the architect of October 7th there is no longer even that pretention or that guise that there is a separation um what it also tells us is it was a
16:01 victory within Hamas for the pro-iran section over the pro katari section which was led by khed mashal uh who was at least a candidate perhaps to take over um but the fact that U sinoa who's certainly uh more in line with Iran has a better relationship with Iran uh shows that the pro-iranian wing is working it also uh really puts the emphasis on this sort of overseas leadership uh back into Gaza itself um and uh it's it's it's important because um now there's really only one pressure point before with hania in Qatar um there was pressure from The Americans on the qataris to try and make a deal now that pressure will be far less because they don't really have as many pressure points on uh W who is hiding uh in Gaza according to Israeli analysis there are some who
17:05 suggest that this actually could even be a move by Sam inamas uh knowing that there's a good chance that sin will not see out this war that's certainly debatable and if Israel were to assassinate him that would take out the major part of the Kamas leadership and allow some of the more quote unquote moderate elements to take over and shap and stake A New Path for Hamas perhaps uh having some role in Gaza afterwards I'm not so sure about this but this is certainly a point of view that I've heard over the last week um just one last thing that was going on in Israel this week we had history um for the first time ever Israeli callup papers were sent out to members of the or Orthodox community and there was even a Day Of Enlistment um I think there was about 1,500 sent out and there was an expectation of at least 400 uh Ultra Orthodox um members of the ultra Orthodox Community toning up to um the enlistment centers to start their army
18:10 service in the end it was less than 50 uh part of it was the fact that hundreds of extreme Ultra Orthodox uh men came and demonstrated when I say demonstrated it was more like a riot and even on the second day itself they broke into to an army uh base itself and ran Riot this may have put off a lot of people that may have indicated before that they were prepared to do their service so on the one hand history was made after 75 years or 76 years or whatever it is for the first time ultra Orthodox um uh you know young men were sent enlistment orders and they some of them came but the fact that it was Far Far lower numbers than previously thought uh is going to certainly mean that many people have to start thinking again is this the best way forward and what sanctions could be taken if at all and what could be done to try and improve those numbers in the future um and with that I'm happy to answer any questions thank you for the update Ashley um I will start with a
19:12 question from borack cormas who asks do you think any hostage deal is possible in the near future with a sinir Le Hamas um yes uh there is uh you know sinir is in trouble uh this despite CNN's analysis this week that Israel has only taken out three fully three um of the 24 Hamas military units throughout the G strip it's clear that a lot more are either destroyed or damaged um sinir really isn't going to win this war um eventually Israel will get to more and more of them yes there can be new recruits but these are young uh inexperienced you know the the chain of leadership has gone a lot of it so sinir is in a difficult situation what the the one wild card that he's hoping for and that's why I don't see any deal being done or even moving forward uh in the next few days is he'll want to see what the response from Iran and hisbah is what his Hope was from October 7th
20:16 onwards or even before when he was planning this was that uh the the massacre would lead to something more Regional because he knew that Kamas on their own could not really deal Israel it it it dealt Israel terrible blow on October 7th but on a military level it is not able to really deal a major blow but if if he pulls inah Iran the htis other Shi groups Syria then perhaps there's more chance of Greater achievements that hasn't happened um but maybe again depending on the length depth breadth timing uh and most important importantly the possible number of casualties that come from these attacks uh maybe sin will finally get his dream and that means that a hostage deal will be pushed further away if these attacks come and go without too much uh Beyond it then sinoa may be again back against the wall and may be
21:21 thinking that the only way to survive this and to get out of this um is to a hostage deal right thank you now as Israel is awaiting a imminent attack from Iran how are the Israelis coordinating with the Arab states in the region well there's been a lot of behind the scenes diplomacy largely it's being led by the Americans and other Western allies um because you know many of the Arab leaders certainly don't want to be seen as being PSIs for Israel or you know in the service of Israel um Jordan for example has said that an again they didn't use the word Iran they said that no one should use our airspace at all on either side um and that's a message to the Iranians uh and that was probably uh was a result of American pressure um obviously you know Iran doesn't need uh Saudi Arabia um Iran basically can fire over Iraq you know that that's that's
22:23 not a problem for them Jordan is obviously a problem Syria is less of a problem um um so really the fact that Jordan and even Egypt again they don't really need to come over Egypt but Egypt have said also that they do not want the airspace being used so it's clear that Iran has been sent messages that the Arab world is not lining up behind it even though it has tried to largely through the uh Islamic uh organization of Islamic States um but there is apart from the Iranian proxy proxies themselves and the country is which uh where Iran has a lot of influence most of the other nations are certainly not lining up in any way shape or form in support of Iran all right thank you now uh Mario Fleck would like to ask why don't is why doesn't Israel call Lebanon as a country to take care and take responsibility for hezbollah's actions at the end of the day Israel has civilian areas being
23:25 bombed from Lebanon well I mean in a sense it has um Israel doesn't have diplomatic relations with Lebanon um so most of the discussions are through um third party States whether it's through the us through OS oin who has been back and forth over the last few months trying to get some sort of agreement some sort of ceasefire um on the border the French are very involved because of their historic role in Lebanon and certainly the messages have been sent and the truth is that many Lebanese leaders either publicly or privately are certainly telling hisbah stop dragging us into this war we canot handle this we do not want to see it uh and they know that Israel has the capability to wreak a lot of Destruction and Chaos in Lebanon and many of the non Shiite um sort of supporters ofah are certainly against what are doing and we certainly prefer that this war uh sort of cease
24:31 immediately thank you now uh how have the recent assassinations of senior Hamas and Hezbollah leaders affected their operations and their strategic capabilities well I mean we can just go by what Hassan n said that it is a blow you know he was very close um with you know his number two in his organization who was his great strategist some say he even had more of a day-to-day role in the in the running of Hass is the spiritual leader he's the head he's been underground for many many years he doesn't do any public appearances um live public appearances I should say he records speeches all the time um um but so it he even admitted that it certainly hurt the organization but he said that we'll be able to replace him uh you know within within um Hamas certainly the the the the assassination of Muhammad death was a big blow also symbolically because
25:34 death even more than sinat it's probably the most respected um military leader in um in Hamas largely due to the fact that Israel tried to assassinate him many many times and he always seemed to escape um hania is less important um from a practical point of view this is a man who was a multi-billionaire living in Qatar hadn't visited the strip in a while was seen as extremely distant uh from the uh the general Palestinian population in Gaza but symbolically it was very important um and the fact that things have now all moved uh to sinoa in the strip is also now very significant because that moves the leadership from outside into the strip itself uh for the reasons that I said um but Hamas is in disy uh they haven't got a very organized command yes they are still fighting yes they're trying to regroup yes they're trying to recruit uh but a lot of the senior military leaders in Kamas um have been
26:39 killed and it's very it's easy to replace you know the the average soldier on the streets relatively but it's certainly harder to replace a major strategic military thinker like de and like some of the others that Israel has taken out over the last few months so certainly Kamas are in disarray are they defeated no U but they're certainly on their way to defeat uh but the assassination um will be a blow um but there are far more well organized um fighting Army you know there's this is not just a terrorist group this is an army with a chain of command you know there will be other people who will be able to come in who are privy to much of the capabilities ofah so probably in the long run it won't make much of uh effect but still it's it's still an important tactic through any War to try and uh assassinate the leadership especially the military leadership of your enemy so it is a blow as Nala conceded but it's not it's not going to mean that hisbah
27:43 is going to be any less of a functioning Army all right thank you uh I think we have time for one more here Jack werman would like to ask has the appointment of two new military commanders for the North and South made any difference I mean there were there was sort of some controversy of a a new commander in the north who's taking far more belligerent tone uh during one of his earlier speeches but again it's significant to a point um because at the end of the day the decisions are made by the political level uh in Israel um and let's not forget the chief of uh Chief of Staff the IDF Chief of Staff her Levy is still in position um there is a deep deep debate in Israel and it's happening on an hourly basis all over you know exactly what needs to be done with the IDF uh since October 7th and certainly moving forward because there is a feeling that they failed uh that they didn't understand the situation that
28:46 they pushed for a certain strategy from the political level um and the top levels the top echelons of the Army is still full of the same uh way of thinking that we can uh deter the enemy through non-military means or try and embolden them and make sure that they do not uh you know attack us um so probably won't have a major effect um probably uh only after the war we'll start seeing uh some major you know sort of house cleaning uh within the IDF maybe even the political level uh that's what everyone is sort of waiting to see because there is this feeling in the middle of War you don't really make too many Replacements that's why we haven't seen the resignation of the IDF Chief of Staff we did see uh the resignation of the head of intelligence and the IDF but we did not see of mosad and some others um so it's clear that at this point in time sort of rallying the flag and you know we have to stick with what we have
29:49 but I'm sure we'll see a lot more cleaning house uh after the war is finished okay thank you now unfortunately we have reached the end of our podcast for the week uh I apologize for not being able to get to all the questions we had quite a few of them just flooding in towards the end there uh Ashley I want to thank you again for taking the time to update us this week thank you very much of course and for our viewers and listeners please be on the lookout for our weekly podcast offerings email coming out over this weekend we thank you all again for joining us and for your participation and I hope you all have a wonderful day