Webinar or Talk
The anti-BDS Fight with Alan Baker
Watch on YouTube
Description
With the BDS movement again taking center stage with Ben & Jerry’s, how can Israel fight back? A legal counterattack offers the best prospects against those who boycott, divest and sanction Israel and ultimately seek the elimination of the Jewish state.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 6, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:01 hello everyone my name is naved romy i'm the director of the ivp israel victory project in israel today we are very honored to have a former ambassador ellen baker here with us for this webinar and i will give a short a brief about a ambassador baker a resume and then we will continue with our very interesting conversation so ambassador baker is one of israel experts in international law he served for 10 years as the legal advisor of israel foreign ministry followed by a four-year term as ambassador of israel to canada he was previously seconded to the un as a senior legal advisor to the he participated in the peace process negotiations with all israel arab as well as in the drafting of the various peace treaties and other agreements he also represented
1:05 israel in negotiations in the un various international treaties including the various international conventions dealing with international terror he has drafted in that international instruments regarding suicide terror and incitement detail he has he has published an extensive series of articles on various aspects of the middle east peace process as well as as well as on international law issues such as terror the icc humanitarian law and human rights law i also highly recommended to read his last article in jns about the incident with ben and jerry's he is presently the director of the international law program at the jerusalem center for public affairs he also has an independent law practice and the member of griftache an organization of retired officers of the israel defense force diplomats and single legal advisors hello mr baker hi good to see you good to see you thank
2:10 you for being here with us this evening and i told you before we when we spoke before that today i'm going to speak with you about the bds but as you said yourself this um issue can develop to many other terms to many other aspects we can go from this issue to speak about terms like ethnic cleansing and the occupied palestinian territories and even about some figures in the democratic party in the united in in the in the white um which somehow all these issues can as i said you have a long and very impressive resume that can give us a very interesting light on all of these topics but i will continue with maybe the most basic question can you give us an explanation about the bds when did it why it began and why it is so unique
3:17 compared to other battles against israel okay well look navi first of all i think the fact that we're devoting nominally this discussion to the issue of bds is paying too greater a compliment to the effect of the bds and its importance because in actual fact apart from the hype behind it it it has minimal minimal effect on israel's economy and on on israel's social scene it makes a lot of noise especially in light of the the recent issue with ben and jerry's the mere fact that we are turning it into a major discussion is exactly what the bds people are looking for that they're trying to extend and and magnify their effect far greater than than their effect
4:23 really is but to answer your question i think it really began at the durban conference in uh september i think it was 2001. i attended the conference a very nasty affair very difficult very but it was there that uh the there were wings to the conference a a a or a state uh conference between delegations of states and a ngo a non-governmental organization wing with all the various ngos and it was this ngo forum that adapt adopted basically a series of resolutions and recommendations and plans of action to boycott israel to sanction israel to to punish israel and to determine that israel is a an apartheid state ethnic cleansing and all the various buzzwords that the
5:28 international society has come to to accept they were stuck to at the urban conference it's interesting we're coming up now to uh uh the 20th of that conference and several states have already informed the uh the organ the un organizers that they're going to boycott it because it's a it's a political okay i will just i will just say that our guests here are welcome to send and i will try to to transfer the questions most of them if we will uh if if it will be possible to you but i i want to ask you something because you said something very interesting i think most people are forgetting about the durban um which many people even as i remember call it anti-semite conference do you it was anti-semite in certain ways
6:33 absolutely look there's no doubt about we we have to accept and we can't deny the fact that what whatever is happening today whether it's the bds or ben and jerry's or all the various the various u.n uh uh resolutions uh uh bashing israel or other organizations unesco uh all these uh the the democratic party in the us these various uh congress women who who who seem to have taken the lead in in in trying to to to to harm israel you can't you can't divorce all this from the element of anti-semitism that exists there because bashing israel and singling out israel apart from all other states in the world and there are there are countries that are carrying out the most inhumane actions against their own that that you know that are unthinkable
7:39 but nobody's talking about them and so the the mere fact of singling out the jewish state is basically in and of itself an act of no less than singling out the jew uh in in a particular state so so we we can't deny this now durbin uh um started this this ball rolled this ball rolling i i had long discussions with uh mary robinson who was the the president of the durban conference and the general of the un also um trying to warn them that look look at what's happening and and um nothing really helped and and i find myself sitting in the same row as people like yasser arafat and others who who openly made speeches calling israel an apartheid state so this was really the beginning of the whole thing there is a question here that repeat itself from several people about what you just described
8:44 and that's going on in campuses and in the united states and somehow the universities and their campuses became area and where the israeli and the palestinian conflict gets a lot of attention and then unfortunately many times um we can hear some extreme voices using the words that you said against israel ethnic cleansing and apartheid how can you explain this and also is there anything israel can do and to try and invite it look the the campus has always been a a center for for radicalism uh for radical thinking for for radical uh it's nothing new and especially today when when the the the the palestinians are being by in the international community and especially in international media and especially among hostile elements as
9:48 the poor underdogs that they're doing israel wakes up in the morning and decides to bomb them and for no reason at all this is the the the the food that they're being fed and and this is what what um molds their their their position when i was ambassador to canada a few years ago the israel apartheid week began at the university of toronto and since it spread throughout the whole of north america and uh um i i wanted i i invited myself to to speak at the week i was warned by the israeli foreign ministry no you shouldn't do this you'll get attacked and it's dangerous and one thing in another but but i insisted and the message that basically i came with was look you people don't understand what apartheid is and you don't understand what israel is and and somebody has to to you what these two phrases are so that you will understand
10:50 that you don't know what you're talking about and in my opinion this is the only way that that can be that we can deal with all this these various movements on campus have to be have to be dealt face on by the individual jewish and it's not just a matter for the israeli ambassador or the israeli ambassadors because the israeli representatives because you know they're they're considered to be a biased uh funnily enough the the local community jews and non-jews need to be able to come out and speak including academic staff and others and unfortunately too many academic staff are afraid of their own jobs and they're afraid to come out and and say what needs to be said uh you know i'm happy to see that that jewish students organizations are doing this but i think jewish communities throughout
11:53 north america especially but also europe need to give the the backing and support to to to acquire the information necessary in order to help the students this is what i'm trying to do from israel to provide the reasoning to provide the answers to to provide answers to the various questions uh so that these people can can face the the accusers on campus there is a question here i will try to phrase it and um how it says it slipped away but i will ask you to how would you do the difference between you talked about anti-semitism and the durban conference but where is the line between anti-semitism to a criticism that someone wants to say about israel okay look this is this is the classical question that that's
12:54 the the today is is is at the attend to the attention of everybody uh we've got this uh working definition of anti-semitism by the international holocaust association i think that's the name ira which basically connects between classical anti-semitism and the the form of anti-semitism of singling out israel as the the the the country among the other countries uh um now this th this this is a non-binding definition it's not a perfect definition they they had to find the lowest common that everybody would accept so it's not binding it hasn't got any teeth a lot of countries have agreed to uh identify with it but these same countries still vote against israel in some of the most disgusting resolutions in the united nations and their parliaments and their
13:57 their leaders still come out against accusing israel of doing all sorts of things that they know uh aren't true but they're they're jumping onto the bank wagon the so um it's very important now to to to try and face those countries that have agreed to acknowledge and identify with this definition of anti-semitism and to to to ask them to implement their their or or their identification and and not just to pay lip service and then go ahead and participate in votes against israel on resolutions that are blatantly untrue false but they know this but for their own political interests for their own economic interests they go along with it you've been you've been also a legal in a in a a very high profile legal what do you think is the best way to
15:05 defeat hamas is it um agreements and to come to summa i don't know how to call it a legal agreement is a an army defeat how should we handle this organization look hamas is is the the organization that won the elections in the gaza strip it it's part of the the the palestinian leadership it's they're not it's not a joint leadership because they're at loggerheads with the the palestinian authority with so you can't say it's a unified leadership but it exists it represents a a a considerable of population of the gaza strip it's not just a terrorist organization it's an that has its own social and economic and educational infrastructure so it's not something that you can just the the you know get rid of either in my opinion militarily or or otherwise
16:10 it exists and it represents a growing among uh the fanatical islamic elements which are growing and increasing um that is should be of concern to so how do you deal with it i remember when i was ambassador in canada a lot of canadian parliamentarians said well why can't you people just come to an agreement with hamas like you came to an agreement with with the palestinian with the plo and and my answer was look look at the philosophy of hamas the basic philosophy of hamas which is the islamic the basic islamic philosophy is that there's no room for any non-muslim in the area whether it's a jew a christian or anybody else they're infidels and they always were infidels and they still consider themselves to be the and so the only way to get rid of them according to the hamas charter is to fight and to destroy them
17:14 and to throw them out so to try and negotiate with that type of it's like negotiating with god that's bible that's their creed and they they're not they can't change this it's part of what they view as the the the the what muhammad bequeath islam so therefore the only way to deal with it is how if it's possible at all to come to some type of modus i can't see any chance of their joining any type of peace process because the the whole concept of peace with the jewish state is is is something that they they can't fathom acknowledging the fact that they can't get rid of us and they can't defeat us so they're going to have to somehow live with us and this is probably the the way if at all that it might eventually be if they get a pragmatic leadership that's prepared and capable and has the
18:19 following the the public following to do i'm going back a bit and because it's the second time i see this question how do you explain the fact that um some of the anti-summit uh profile or shapes that you gave an example for before are being used by people in the jewish community or sometimes by even jewish organizations well this is again something that's very upsetting i i often find myself when i'm talks and lectures especially uh in north america or in europe that the the most difficult uh people attacking me are jews um and uh it's probably some type of of uh elements within the jewish with their their their their hosts with with the the the trendy
19:21 the trend the public trend uh to israel also we're talking about a new the old generation of of of pro-israel jews uh uh is is being replaced by a new generation of of young people who don't have the same roots they don't have the same family roots they don't have the same educational routes and they they take up the the trending viewpoints that happen to exist within a uh a country or state or or community uh uh and and they they take this up and they feel that because they're jewish they have to be all the more persistent and all the more vocal in in doing this and it's it's very depressing and uh i i personally call these people self-hating jews and i think one of the the the the u.s senators is a in my view a typical example of this the the guy bernie sanders from vermont who
20:26 who's influenced ben and jerry's uh and i and i think this is there's a lot of maybe not self-hating but jews who want to prove their their with the local trends going on and if the local trend is to criticize israel and to attack israel then then they they'll go along with that it's it's sad but it's a a fact that we have to deal with and the only way we can deal with it exactly as i said before through educating them through explaining to them through answering questions explaining why the the the basics that being fed the the the terms such as occupied palestinian territory is a false term the uh ethnic cleansing it's untrue apartheid it's it's not it's not understood that the whole concept of israel isn't understood by these people and they need to be it needs to be
21:28 explained to them because they they're lacking this these basic facts and they they very easily tack on to any trend that happens to be popular can you try to address i know it's a complicated question but can you try to address the legal issues relating to jewish settlements in judea and samaria for example i know there are people saying that judaism samaria is an apartheid state but israel inside the 67 lines is not an apartheid so can you try a in a short way to try and explain the the legal issue of this area how do we have four five six hours look um in 1967 israel entered the okay um israel apart from from extending its law to to eastern jerusalem
22:29 the rest of the territories remain uh administered by israel there are there are those who call it occupied territory uh legally uh the term occupation is a term uh that's become a politicized but it's it's a term that stems from the the fourth geneva convention of 1949 and i don't want to be overly legalistic but that refers to a country which takes territory of another country during the course of a war this did this didn't happen in our case because the the west bank and the gaza strip whenever jordanian sovereign territory or egyptian sovereign territory so there there was never a a situation that can be defined as occupation the same with the term palestinian these areas have never been palestinian there's never been a palestinian state there's never been any international determination resolution or treaty or that determines that the territories are
23:36 so therefore the whole term occupied palestinian territory is a false term it doesn't exist and the palestinians themselves have agreed in the oslo accords that the final status the permanent status of the is a negotiating issue with israel and this negotiation has yet to be so the whole issue of the status of the territories is still open now according to international law uh um a country that administers has the prerogative to administer land as long as it's not privately owned now all israel's settlements are on public land which is not privately owned settlement on private land is absolutely prohibited and i was a member of a governmental committee in israel the the edmond levy committee that examine this and we determined that nobody is allowed to to to build a settlement on territory which is
24:37 privately owned on land which is privately owned owned by by local arab residents and there's a complicated legal procedure that one has to go through to prove that you that the land isn't privately owned and so anybody who claims that the israeli settlement activity is illegal uh again doesn't fully understand the legal situation a lot of people claim that the geneva convention prohibits the truck the force transfer of population into occupied but first of all israel hasn't indulged in forced transfer this whole provision of the the fourth geneva convention in 1949 was drafted in order to prevent what the nazis did of mass transfer force chancellor of and this is isn't what israel has been i live in a settlement i'm signed onto a contract with the israeli government that everything is subject to
25:39 the outcome of negotiations between the israel and the palestinians so no no israeli settlement except on land that was previously owned by jews like in in chevron or various other places no settlement has any permanent status pending the outcome of negotiations so these whole buzzwords of illegal settlement uh um occupied palestinian territory uh uh and these various other things that they're they're false expressions that are simply being banded in order to to to uh bash israel without any basic legal understanding of the situation i'm sorry to with for a long answer but uh these are very common it's a very complicated question but but this has to be explained to to these people as i said before all these things need to be answered and and the answers exist and let me just
26:44 refer to the website of the jerusalem center for public affairs jcpa.org and and i have several papers that i've written there which respond to all these questions and in fact there are two papers uh uh one is called ten false assumptions regarding israel answering these questions and debunking 11 more false assumptions and i attack all these various assumptions and give to the point uh responses and it it's well worth while going into that website and and pulling down these uh these answers because they're very hey ambassador ellen baker the time flew and hey i wanted to give you more time to summarize but even at this time we have only left with two minutes and i have to apologize to all the people that asked so many questions and i just didn't have the time to ask all of them and i want to tell you for the time you've been with us
27:48 and do you want to say something for a to summarize this a webinar something that you want to well i i look i think the main message that i've tried to to pass on is is is the need to to educate the need to to acquire the the answers to the in order to pass them on whether it's to the campuses or whether it's to the jewish communities non-jewish communities churches mosques in order to provide the the real answers genuine answers and and not to to be uh not to enable false er er er accusations and allegations to be and and to be uh magnified i think this is the main message and this is the vital thing this is what i'm trying to do in the jerusalem center this is what i've tried to do during my period as ambassador and as a legal adviser of the israel's foreign ministry
28:49 anytime you want to come back and and have a further chat i'll be very happy thank you very much a former ambassador and biker it was a uh to have you with us uh here in israel it's tonight in the states it's noon so it's been a pleasure in both times thank you for your time and i thank all our guests today and as ambassador baker said i'm sure that we'll have more opportunities to host here with us thank you all you're welcome bye-bye