MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

What are the real ramifications for Israel following the death and funeral of Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 3, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacey roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question now with no further ado i will turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening from israel lots going on i will start with what was described in the um and the uh sort of title for tonight's discussion and that was the death and funeral of al jazeera journalist sharing abu akler i'm sure most already know the details that she was killed while israel uh israeli forces were in

1:03 janine which has become a hotbed for uh terrorism especially recently quite a lot of the terrorists who have israelis in the last few weeks have come from the junior area and the idf and other security officials have been conducting quite a sweep day and night to a certain extent of many of the hotbeds of terrorist activity and what uh conspired exactly in janine is not certain what is certain is that the died from a bullet to the head um as one can imagine the palestinians immediately blamed israel and they went uh public relations overdrive that it was 100 percent israelis that even that they murdered her in cold blood from a short range and all these spurious accusations that unfortunately brought up by at least uh parts of the world uh israel being the democracy that is being let's just say um you know a place

2:08 where there's at least accountability didn't want to jump to conclusions they did say it first that it's more than likely that it came from palestinian positions they presented a few videos to try and further their point uh but they perhaps rightly so in a gunfight of this man i could not say unequivocally it was at their side or the other side uh they to do a joint uh analysis uh on on the body on the bullet on everything else for the palestinians but the palestinians obviously said no which leads many to believe in uh to wonder in israel what they had to hide they wouldn't share the bullet even though the pathologist said that it's uh unclear who shot it and there's no way they can equivocally unequivocally understand who it was and probably we will not know for a while one way or another if ever uh israel is conducting uh its

3:11 own investigation but it's very difficult because it doesn't have access to many of the important pieces um that would be necessary for such an investigation um but we'll have to wait and see exactly what happened probably some of the worst scenes that were broadcast around the world i remember seeing it on france 24 and they were considering everything else that's going on in the world they were showing this live non-stop in the corner of the screen was the funeral and again it was a lot of they said this they said that what seemed to be clear is that the funeral procession was supposed to take place uh in a horse to the burial that's what had been understood and agreed on there were israeli forces to make sure that there were no uh disruptions but then it appeared that other people took uh it into their own hands that decided they were going to take the coffin by foot which would have been an almost gargantuarly impossible task and then

4:15 rioters started to take advantage standing behind the pool bearers and throwing at the missiles or whatever it is of the israeli forces the israeli forces reacted and they were which looked terrible scenes of the israeli forces attacking even some of the pool bearers and others and obviously that's what was shown not what happened before um but it it it looked bad uh but israel is investigating it and it remains to be seen exactly what will happen with the investigation one has to understand uh what happens on the ground with what the terrorism has gone on with some of the nationalistic as they call them perhaps slogans that were sung during the funeral procession one has to understand arabic obviously to understand them but things like we will murder all the jews were sung during one of the funeral processions and and all that sort of thing so you know the places on edge after the uh terrorist attacks in elad in tel aviv and elsewhere uh israeli

5:19 security forces are understandably a bit jittery about things like this and one can imagine a funeral procession where people are chanting genocidal charts and throwing uh missiles walking through an area populated by jewish israelis would make any security forces a little bit jittery did they act proportionately did they act correctly especially with the world's cameras on them one could certainly argue that point and hopefully an investigation will look into and see what could be done in a better way what this means for internal israeli politics is that you know we've talked a lot about the 6060 and the knesset and ram being an extremely important member of the government if it wasn't already before the coalition and quite simply the more disturbances there are the more scenes like we saw and more on the temple mount the harder it is for ram to come to the government especially manchester ubas who really wants to stay in the government as long as possible it's harder for him to make the case

6:22 it's easier for those who are against iran's participation future participation coalition to come and say you know this is going somewhere we are our true partners and our involvement in this coalition is meaningful for the our public so these scenes don't necessarily uh mean too much for the average israeli it means a lot more for those watching international media around the world but it does have a knock-on effect for local domestic uh israeli politics um some interesting developments in the security arena this week uh um israel's defense minister benny gans is in the u.s as there are reports that an agreement the jcpoa could be returned to could be signed or something similar the iranian nuclear deal but perhaps just as interesting is that the u.s central command chief michael carrillo uh is in israel and not just in israel because you know he he this is uh he's been around the region but what is

7:24 interesting is he was taken to what's called the bore i guess the translations the pit in in of the uh kikiriya the israel's defense and shown information reportedly shown israel's and even parts of i'm sure he wasn't shown everything parts of israel's strategy uh in what's called a worst-case scenario in other words that iran uh is is making its way to a nuclear bomb what um is interesting about this also is that the us will take part in what has been um billed as one of the most important drills uh in israel's history it's a month-long drill looking at all sorts of things fighting abroad fighting at home fighting on the borders but there is one very interesting element which is supposed to send a message to tehran that israel is also going to practice the ability to strike enemies uh further afield and obviously

8:27 that's euphemism for iran and the u.s will be sub uh will be supplying or gas supply uh airplanes which is absolutely crucial because israel would need such um such capability if it was ever going to have a strike but be able to strike iran in multiple areas that would be necessary if they even dread to push back the nuclear program let alone uh destroy it so there's a very important message there perhaps the americans are trying to push the iranians uh closer to the table but certainly from israel's point of view it looks good for them that the americans are backing them but the americans are even taking part in their tactical and strategic you know plans and preparations for such a thing as one uh a member of knesset said this week his biggest worry at the moment with everything else that's going on is obviously iran getting a nuclear weapon and he talked about various

9:30 doomsday scenarios that wouldn't even necessarily mean a nuclear bomb landing on tel aviv there are plenty of other nightmare scenarios they could do which would be a step before but still be extremely punishing for israel and what he did say interestingly enough he said that the iranians are not hearing from the biden administration even what they heard from the [ __ ] from the obama administration he said we're not even talking about what uh what trump said even if the americans could talk like former president uh obama did that the military option remains on the table because he complained that we're not hearing that language from the byte administration and that's very worrying because the iranians were slightly deterred during the obama administration they did believe that the option was on the table they didn't necessarily think it was the primary option but they knew it was still there so they went a little bit slower during the biden administration uh there is that there is no fear this is what someone who who is relatively senior uh said this week so

10:34 with all this going on in the background uh the trip by uh benny gans to uh washington to talk about iran especially perhaps potentially on the eve of a return to the gcpo and the u.s central being in israel and sort of being given a hint that this is what israel could do if it feels iran is getting closer to the bond so certainly ratcheting up uh the pressure on the political front um it's it's also of course very interesting uh being in the knesset speaking to members of knesset and their parliamentary aides from all directions uh it does seem that there appears to be optimism that the government would see out this summer uh summer term and then during the summer break and then we would return after the jewish holidays and that's when most suspect this government will break up i still believe that it could break up earlier uh it could very well last until the after the uh jewish holidays but there's a lot of moving pieces that

11:36 would need to be uh in place uh for that to happen what is interesting is that the sort of uh flagship laws of this government of the laws to limit uh the ten year old terms to two terms of the future prime minister now seems extremely unlikely for a number of reasons first of all they pass through almost every single layer apart from one and if they're not passed by next monday uh they basically have to be legislated again and it's proving very very difficult don't forget uh these sort of laws are what's called basic laws are quasi constitutional laws which uh demand a 61 majority and with a coalition of 60 that's proving extremely problematic the jointlist had said the joint arab list which is in the opposition had said that it would support uh such a bill but what the opposition has cleverly done is made these bills into a no-confidence vote on the government and that is not something the joint list can stomach so at this point they're not going to vote for them which means that uh they

12:39 basically will not be able to be voted on during this commission um what is becoming a bit of a battle that the coalition seems to be potentially winning is a very interesting law that's coming up which was proposed by defense minister benny ganz that uh those who serve in the idf will be able to receive two-thirds of funding for further education after university college etc now in normal times this should be controversial and almost every zionist party or every zionist party would vote for it but obviously in this fought political condition uh everything is seen in the context of coalition opposition what the coalition is trying to do uh because it understands first of all that has 60 even with ron and ron probably won't vote for it uh that they're trying to put pressure on liquid uh to say you know this is a zionist value to to give support to our soldiers it's vitally important how can you leave our soldiers who who who contribute their time uh you know and even lives um to the defense of the country and we

13:44 should see to it that he could got put in a in an awkward position because to vote against this would be considered very unpopular they came out with a relatively clever pr trick by saying well we would only support it would give us hundred percent of the tuition now they know that's not going to happen because the budget is budgeted specifically for 66 percent uh two thirds and to re-budget it would mean that it would go into next budget which isn't going to pass as we've spoken about before so it's a bit of a a trick and finance minister has said anyway we would uh take the the final third for money which is anyway put aside uh for these matters so i could is trying to or at least uh netanyahu was trying to squirm out of it but he was sort of beaten to it by the fact that several of his liquid members of knesset said there's no doubt we have to vote for this law regardless of anything else that we are feeling uh this is an important law and we cannot vote against it which shows the pressure that is being put on not

14:46 just by the coalition but also by idf officials former itf officials so if this is passed uh next week uh this will certainly be a win for the and it does seem that the coalition at this point is trying to get as many wins as possible by trying to find as many issues and votes and bills which uh cannot be ignored by the opposition obviously this can only go so far but that is the uh tactic at the moment an interesting byproduct of this is the ultra orthodox parties which wouldn't necessarily support such a bill if they were in government they probably would support it but don't forget a large segment of the ultra orthodox population does not go to the army so they wouldn't be eligible for this and also they are complaining that they don't get enough stipends for yeshiva students so they they find this law a little bit problematic from their point of view and they find it problematic that lee could is supporting such a coalition bill and they have said that if you vote for this

15:48 we're going to demand many bills uh that we want and demand that you support them and even find coalition support uh for them as well finally before i go to questions another interesting development came out this a couple of years ago there was quite a controversy when the government passed what was called the nation-state law which defined israel as the national homeland to the jewish people defined for the first time ever put in law things like uh hatikvah being the israel national anthem and the uh blue and white uh magic darby star of david being the flag etc etc and the languages and it was considered controversial at the time because it didn't talk necessarily about proponents would argue that there are other basic laws that do as details were released uh this week of a drew's soldier who comes from the jewish minority was killed three years ago abito lima finance minister basically said it's time that we changed the

16:51 nation of state law to ensure that our brothers as he put it the jews brothers in arms um also feel that it's their state and we don't leave them out and propose that the nation state law be modeled far closer on the declaration of independence now this isn't going to happen and that's probably more about political um uh understandings in charlevoix 10 will always have a significant vote from the community and even have one of their ministers from the jewish community so it's probably more to play for that yamina and new hope gideon sal's party i've said that they will not uh countenance any change um to the nation state law obviously iran are disappointed if it doesn't come up next week at the moment it isn't so it will be interesting to see what happens with that i don't see how it can come up because of this right disagreements over it and i don't think that it will be good enough for ram to

17:54 be able to come out openly and support it so these are all things that we've got to look forward to next week but as of now i'm happy to answer any of your questions all right there we go all right uh thank you so much jacob hershman asks uh can you please comment on gantz's report reported comment that israel could be swallowed up following the reported whatsapp post referring to an arab takeover of the negev and galileo as being not that far from reality i i i don't know what this is referring to i haven't seen that so i can't really comment on it all right uh dear strauss asks what about today's ruckus in the knesset with the ugly insult from the joint arab list could you comment on that well it was it wasn't from the whole list it was from ahmed tibi who's been known as a controversial figure uh for for a uh it took place uh with um

19:01 uh mira binary of uh the yashatid party uh again it goes back to the whole sort of debate over shiran abu akla the al jazeera basically tibi was talking about disturbances on the temple mount what he would claim was excessive police violence against worshipers there and uh mayor of bernary took exception to that and uh tibby shot back at her or someone who says that they won't apologize for the as he put it murder of uh the al jazeera journalist is not going to give him you know any comments and then when she to confront him he called her human scum now this is someone who has been uh abused in the past by other members of the joint list she was called a clucking head at one point which was considered a misogynist comment and she got quite emotional about it and left the plenum uh in tears it's

20:04 unfortunately the type of thing that we see and hear far too often in the knesset um the diatribes the discourse has certainly gone down uh ahmed tibi was uh uh you know taken out of the knesset by the deputy speaker at the time of guinea for his comments uh what was described as disgraceful comments which disrespected and dishonored the knesset and and that's uh that's really what happened there's not really much to say beyond uh what's uh you know deputy speaker sabah said that they were just you know they were disgraceful and disgusting and uh dishonorable uh comments uh for any knesset member to make so i can't you know there's nothing much more to be said on that all right thank you uh h fragment uh asks gantz appears to be placating rom by condoning building by the palestinian authority in area c what is your take i don't think it's necessary placating

21:07 iran we have seen that even in previous governments granted the previous government for this uh defence minister gans was also he was also defense minister but that was without run there's been a lot of talk about that for for a lot of time it's mostly i would say not necessarily duplicate ram it's duplicate the international community the international community especially the europeans but also the are very keen on allowing palestinian building uh in area c but that being said the majority of it is very very close to palestinian areas it's not in the middle of an israeli area it's not too close to israeli towns and cities in judea and samaria and it's a relatively minimal amount but i would say it's less about iran and more about placating the international community thank you debbie friedman asks according to carolyn glick monsoor abbas uh is working to undermine israel's sovereignty on the temple mount along

22:09 with jordan's king and turkeys erdogan which would also undermine israel's legitimacy in general and that bennett is tone deaf to this can you please comment i i would disagree with that you know manso abbas has his electorate and he has his issues and is a religious muslim obviously al-aqsa is very dear to him and i would say more than he you know more than it's an issue for him it's an issue for the arab street uh the muslim uh met much of his base he is someone who's really trying and and you can see it really trying hard to maintain his relations with this government with this coalition trying to stay inside he's really trying to fight off those who would leave it tomorrow um i i would say that's not necessarily the case behind the scenes he's really trying to find solutions uh moderate solutions for this again he's not going to become a zionist overnight he's not going to become someone who who believes that israel is going to have more rights

23:11 on the temple mount and the muslim population less but i certainly would disagree with that characterization he's working to undermine if he was given a cult launch obviously like many if not most muslims he would there'd be no jewish visitors or perhaps even no non-muslim visitors and certainly having no israel security forces up there but you know he he's not from the hawkish side of ram he's more of the dovish side he does want a partnership he made very interesting comments today at rahman university we're saying you know partnerships between jews and arabs should be the end not just the means to the end we really need to work together we need to find a way to work together and and i see most of the comments that mahmud uh that man saw about i should say has made over the last year again if we if we're wanting to become a passionate zionist and agree with us on every point while there's plenty of designers who don't agree with

24:13 many of the things that happens on the temple mount so i don't think that's a fair characterization and i think that him individually is really trying as much as possible to try and become a moderating force in our politics rather than the opposite thank you uh just asked will ayman ude and opher casif face any repercussions for attacking a police officer and will the supreme court ever back removing knesset members who are against the idea of a jewish state um well the first thing uh there are investigations uh there are calls from the investigations including from the speaker of the knesset who certainly can recommend lifting uh immunity it's quite a difficult process to lift the immunity of any member of knesset uh so there's quite a process to go through so it means to be seen exactly how far post that process will be and as i've touched on this before about the the supreme court uh going against

25:16 some members of knesset who have not supported israel being the national homeland of the jewish people unfortunately that will probably continue just because of the the politics of the situation not necessarily the legality of the situation there has been many members of knesset from our parties um who are called into question the legitimacy of israel as a jewish state but they have not been removed from the electoral process and i don't see that necessarily changing in their future thank you a little off topic here carrie hillebrand asks what's significance if any do you see with uh hezbollah and its allies losing the parliamentary majority in the lebanese parliamentary elections um well significant because hezbollah has certainly been losing popularity with the economic situation don't forget the blast in the port in beirut uh a while back they're hemorrhaging uh support but uh one shouldn't overlook uh the lebanese political situation

26:18 that's just going to be it's not going to necessarily weaken them unless the other two blocks can work together which remains to be seen there's three blocks in lebanese politics uh hezbollah's block certainly lost uh in the recent elections but it remains to be seen whether any of the blocks can work together to form a government so it just seems that there's going to be a bit of a vacuum uh for now um so it's certainly not good for israel when there's a vacuum it's not good when is hezbollah in power in lebanon either would be great for israel be grateful stability and peace in the region if the other two blocks uh get together but don't forget hezbollah is more than just a political party it's a paramilitary force with with a lot of strength physical strength military strength so they wouldn't give up on power any sort of power very easily and they would use the gun uh perhaps to do what the ballot box didn't so um while it certainly is significant that hezbollah lost popularity uh in the

27:21 elections what's going to happen next is is still open to question but it does seem that there's going to be a lot of further instability in lebanon in the near future all right and bringing us back full circle uh robin jonas s uh the pictures during the funeral of the al jazeera funeral were very disturbing can you explain why the israeli police used force again i know i'm sorry you went over this already or what happened and how can this be avoided in the future are there plans in place well there's no plans in place because no one could foresee such an event as but what the israeli police said and and this is what they put out that they had agreed with the family um of the journalists that uh the procession would be in a the coffin would be in the house and it would be taken to its final resting and that's clearly not what happened what they claim uh the israeli police is

28:23 that that a mob came into the hospital and took the uh took the coffin and decided to try and uh proceed uh on foot the israeli police at the same time were being charged and and throwing things and they reacted did they react in the right way that remains to be seen there's an investigation on going whether it were the pictures and the scenes that they look bad on international tv absolutely did the international uh many of the international journalists talk about or show the initial scenes of the coffin being taken and the uh the rocks and the petrol bombs being thrown did they show the um chance of the funeral possession where they called to murder jews knowing that the procession could go through a highly populated jewish area no so the the pictures that made the international media certainly looked bad but they certainly weren't the whole story but could the israeli police have done better again that's for an investigation

29:26 to decide but hopefully that they will learn lessons because again it's very very difficult to foresee exactly what's going to happen could they have just allowed the whole procession to happen and being hijacked by writers and and it could have descended into violence and even bloodshed it's possible that's certainly what the security and police forces uh worried about most so they felt that they had to be on the ground they felt that they had to have an understanding of the family they invited the brother of the into the police station the night before to try and work out what would happen to explain what and where the israeli police would be and what they would be doing so a lot of it was known before unfortunately there were also those clearly who wanted to try and score points and use the the journalist body and coughing for political agenda that's clearly what ended up having happening were all the mourners involved absolutely not with

30:28 islam who pretended to be mourners to try and score political points and make into an international incident which it clearly became absolutely all right thank you so much again for uh readdressing that uh we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with rich gazelle discussing persecuted christians of the middle east thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day