MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Israel is at war. What is happening and why? Have your questions answered.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 26, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:06 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider with Ashley Perry I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have Ashley Perry advisor to the Middle East forum's Israel office join us to update us on what's going on in Israel this week Mr Perry will be giving us a briefing on on the current situation in Israel for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question I'm sure there will be quite a few uh and we will do our best to get to as many as possible and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much St good evening from Israel obviously this is going to be very different because frankly Israel is different uh what happened on the 7th of October has changed Israel we won't know exactly how much but profoundly um I was just listening two minutes ago to someone who said their

1:08 whole life they believed in peace they believed in coexistence that ended on that Saturday the scenes and I'm not going to go through it uh some of the devastating scenes I'm in various groups and speaking to various people and I get sensed up I'm sure most people you know have seen some of this but uh just the the not even the numbers and the numbers we know the numbers are that more Jews were murdered on one day than any other days since the end of the Holocaust we know some of the gruesome Stories the 200 Israelis and other foreign Nationals kidnapped we know all that what I'm going to try to do uh tonight at least is try and give a little bit of context try and understand why this happened what is happening and what what's going to happen next I want to try and leave a lot of time for questions because I know people have information but maybe lack a bit of understanding to put it together and to try and tie all the different

2:11 things that they're seeing together so I'm going to try and get through uh what I have to say a little bit quicker and then leave time of questions so the first question is why now um it's clear that Hamas have been planning this with Iranian and other um assistants knowhow equipment for many months some even say years so why particularly now I I would suggest that the primary reason specifically now is because of the upcoming uh potential well now it's obviously put on the back burner and we'll see what happens then is the normalization with Saudi Arabia normalization with Saudi Arabia as I've said many times in previous uh Israel inside a webinar is a GameChanger for the region it dwarfs the Abraham Accords with UAE Bahrain Morocco and others because Saudi Arabia isn't just an other Arab country it is the most important country in the Muslim World certainly the most important country in the Arab world and it really does signal in a

3:15 large respect that the Israeli Arab conflict would have been over um the fact that the country with the two holy sites in Islam is now open to Israel and Israel is open to it is a game Cher and also let's not for get only a few weeks ago uh President Biden stood in New Delhi I think it was in India at the G20 talking about a new Transportation Corridor that would extend from India through the Middle East uh into Europe and crucially it would go through two countries Saudi Arabia and Israel so normalization wasn't just an interest for is and Saudi Arabia it was an interest for the US for India for other um players as certainly in Europe but it would have also side aligned Iran in a massive uh way and Iran quite simply and its proxies in the region Hamas and hisbah being just two of them it really would have changed the region and really sidelined and isolated Iran uh in a way previously not seen and Iran

4:20 clearly did not want that to happen so in the what was expected to be weeks maybe a couple of months before normalization with uh Saudi Arabia Iran decided to act um the question is how did it happen how did Israel let what happen that that faithful day um you know there are a lot of questions primarily uh they really go back to What's called the conception the the idea the conception goes back to the 73 War where Israeli generals intelligence security officials felt that the Arab W would not attack Israel in 73 because of the beating it got in ' 67 and they knew that they wouldn't be able to do it now so they ignored a lot of intelligence a lot of warnings and Israel paid mightily for that I think there were a couple of thousand Israelis K in the first few days of the war the conception here which was proven completely wrong is that Hamas while a bloody and you know according to their own Charter genocidal

5:24 uh terrorist organization the end of the day was the power might ofah and you know it's its pay masters in tran Hamas was seen as manageable it was seen as uh a place where if Israel continued allowing more workers to come into Israel improving the economy allowing more and more uh development in infrastructure then there was no interest uh for Hamas to launch any sort of attacks in fact Hamas officials have said that they lulled in is into this View that they would give up Jihad for the sake of a better life for its people clearly that was not true and Hamas have openly said for them Jihad and bloodshed murder is more important to them than a better life for their their themselves and the people that they uh purportedly rule over that's really the most important conception that was just thrown out of the water because of that there were clearly a lack of troops it

6:26 being a Jewish holiday as well as the Sabbath uh some of the bases were down to a minimum uh there was nothing really up until a couple of hours before that really set off any Israeli intelligence alarms Bell alarm Bells um now that there were uh we did understand that there were training uh for this we didn't at the time I guess the intelligence officials didn't understand exactly what they were training for and kind of dismissed it as okay Hamas terrorist organization they're training but they're always training uh and even when they uh they started massing in the Border apparently the shim bet set down a small team of four or five people because they thought maybe there's an attempt at a kidnapping one person uh but nothing more than that clearly our intelligence was off our intelligence was incorrect our assessment uh just as importantly was completely Incorrect and we underestimated Hamas so the question then leads to what now the question you know everybody in Israel waiting for

7:29 this ground offensive uh to begin um there have been somewhere between 300 and 500,000 Reserve is called up something like 125% of call up there are people who didn't get call up and still have gone to units that they left or you know they retired from uh so it shows a really strong feeling amongst isra that something has to be done that this is a war that they have to win a war that they have to defeat their enemies because we cannot do this again in six months in a year or two years and the way Israeli leaders have been talking about is quite simply I've never heard talking about Victory talking about vanquishing our enemies and the Israeli public whether you are left Center or right because of what we saw because of the fact that I don't think there's a single family in Israel that's not affected by someone who was murdered that day someone who was kidnap that day someone who was who maybe just managed to get out sometimes by nothing short of a miracle uh Israel the Israeli public

8:33 is is really motivated to ensure that Hamas are not able to do something like this again but the question is why is it taking so long first of all the uncharitable uh analysts are saying quite simply we didn't have a plan for this and they're hurridly putting uh together a plan the second uh reason perhaps more charitably is we're trying to gather as much intelligence we uh it seems that we are sending in Special to kidnap uh some of the senior Hamas leaders to understand what is going to be expected when we do go into the strip uh thirdly perhaps uh one argument is that we are because we are we've turned off the electricity water and other utilities we're trying to smoke out some of the Hamas leaders who have built this underground Network under under Gaza we know from previous rounds as soon as uh they they launch an attack against us they will Scurry underground and leave the civilians to Bear the brunt well we want to make sure and already now we're

9:35 stared to see some of the senior leaders pop their head up here and there and we have been able to take some of them out uh the more time don't forget you know underground bunkers need air uh systems they need water they need electricity and uh without that um they can't stay underground for too long but the most important reason uh isah kah are really a threat the likes of which Hamas don't even come close hisbah have an army and a missile capability larger than most countries if not almost all countries in Europe that is a serious threat hamas's Rockets are not necessarily accurate hisbah have boasted and we take them at their word that they have missile capabilities that can reach almost every inch in Israel accurately it's a whole another ball game and Israel really doesn't want to be fighting on two fronts there's even a talk of three fronts because Iran is trying to move some of its terrorist proxies in Iraq towards Syria towards the Border uh with

10:38 Israel and they're certainly trying to rile up the situation in Judea and Samaria the West Bank so it is very possible and it's certainly a nightmare scenario for Israel that they could be fighting at some point over the next days or weeks uh on four on foref fronts uh hisbah to our assessment what for what I'm hearing have not made the the decision yet to go in uh let's not forget kah's main role from its pay masters in Teran is to act as a deterrent if Israel ever decides to attack its nuclear weapons capabilities so the question is whether Israel is bed down enough whether is Israel is weakened enough if it is then hisbah will come in if it feels that it could lose that ability because if Israel could fight back and really weaken hisbah then that severely weakens uh Iran and the region so there hasn't been a decision yet there have been regular rocket attacks regular shooting uh regular sort of entry into Israel from kah but it's more about testing the

11:40 water and more importantly from their point of view testing Israel's capabilities so we we're still waiting to see whether hisbah will make the decision but probably they won't make a decision till Israel uh enters the strip um finally we had president uh Biden visit recent Rec it was a strong show of solidarity a strong show of support uh because in addition to the fact that he became the first ever US president to visit Israel during a time of War uh the US has sent two uh USS warships um to the region uh just to the Eastern Mediterranean and that is also a strong message to Iran andah to stay out of the war it's clear the Americans are sending these messages to stay out uh not just through diplomatic channels but also through um this show of force and the fact is that the Americans didn't come empty-handed they came to um ensure that Israel had all it need all it needs to complete the task of destroying Hamas I

12:44 mean we'll see in the days and weeks months perhaps even longer whether it's able to do that but at the moment we have extremely strong support from our American Allies from many European allies so I'll have to wait and see um and with that uh I'll take any questions on anything I've mentioned thank you all right thank you so much um wow uh Carrie hillbrand asked on on your last note with the uh the aircraft carriers uh with two American aircraft carrier battles groups in the Eastern Mediterranean can you envision a scenario where they would actively commit military assets um well let's let's just say Israel has always prided itself on never asking any foreign entities to fight our battles uh we don't ask a single uh citizen of another country to put down their life or try and fight our battles Israel is always very proud of that and we mention it frequently so I think that would be a very last case scenario um I don't think that they would get involved

13:47 in the fighting there is talk and there have been some White House officials who have claimed that possibly if they really feel that hisbah coming in in a really strong way uh perhaps other Iranian proxies then perhaps it would get involved in probably a more limited manner I don't see the American Army coming in full force like we saw in Iraq or other places um but certainly it's it's more of a deterrent at this point Thank You Anthony field asks how does Israel win the war of Minds when some of the media are so quick to spread the blood liel based on uh the say so of Hamas without evidence yeah I mean it's it's utterly remarkable you know I'm working uh a little bit with the media and you know Israel Israelis said uh you know a couple of days after the massacre they found babies with you know beheaded babies you know I I don't want to go into some of the pictures we've seen and

14:49 some of the scenes but still to this day they want to see evidence but when when Hamas say one minute after rocket attack that Israel uh dropped the missiles on it on on a hospital and 500 people died and even those numbers have been remarkably driven down um then the media accepts it so it's it's very difficult what I would say is um that Israel is improving uh in previous rounds let's say um it took at least two or three days for Israel to get the truth out and it was irrelevant the story had gone by then so the fact that we were able to show absolute incontrovertible uh proof that uh the attack on the hospital came from an errant Islamic Jihad missa and we showed it not just from our own sources we showed it from Arab sources we even delivered chatter amongst Hamas operatives that admitted that this is exactly what happened so it's

15:51 incontrovertible proof which we we've shared with our allies and most importantly we've also shared with the media now again many of the media say well Kamas said this and Israel said that well Kamas is also an organization that claimed that no civilians were killed on October 7th so I'm it's it's not clear to me why they are an organization to be trusted and I hope and the message is trying to get out there I hope that the international media will take everything that now comes out of Hamas because everything comes out of Gaza Strip is from Hamas they are the rulers there they're the ones when when you hear these things Palestinian Health Ministry it's Hamas and so I hope everything that comes out of there now is taken with a grain of so I'm not overly optimistic but I hope at least some in the media today will do a little bit of soul searching I certainly hope so uh Adam Perry asks will the events on Saturday likely and any chances of normalization with the Saudis and what has their response been over the last 10 days well I I'll even take it broader

16:54 you know the especially last night with what happened with the hospital and the jumping into conclusions that it was Israel we heard from across the our world condemnations of Israel you know some going further than others claiming that it was intentional whatever we haven't heard any we haven't heard any from the Arab world who now accepted that you know with all the proof that we've put out there it's in the public domain that um it was in Israel but what we are hearing behind the scenes um is much weaker let's say um the condemnations are strong and obviously they have to take into account their populations but the reason for Saudi Arabia coming closer to Israel the reason for the normalization that was on the cusp of a becoming reality hopefully will still be true after the war it depends how long it takes depends how what what the you know what the um the the the amount of casualties it's certainly a setback absolutely a setback but uh it all it also depends one thing

17:58 is also important is that many of these countries came to the table the Abraham Accords the Nega Forum Etc not because they suddenly became Zionist but they understood Israel's place in the region first of all in its fight against Iran but second of all because Israel is strong Israel has tremendous intelligence uh capabilities Israel has tremendous military capabilities Well that took a knocking uh that Saturday uh severely and that won't help our cause because if you look throughout history the Arab world the Sunni moderate pragmatic Arab world has sort of always sat on the fence and moved uh whoever is the strong horse whether it's the first world war moving from the Ottomans to the um to the allies and the second world war from the Nazis to the Allies in the Gulf in the Cold War sorry uh from the Soviets to the Americans whoever is the strong horse in the region they will move too um and Israel certainly that that view that we are one of the strong horses in the region took a bit of a blow but hopefully we can regain that hopefully through defeating

19:02 Hamas and terrorist organizations which none of them have any love for uh we we'll be able to regain that uh that position uh in the Middle East and gain once again the the trust of our allies and would allies thank you Larry Greenberg asks is it true that despite Biden's president presence in Israel that uh blinkin has been strong arming Israel by threatening to withhold replenishment of munition especially the bunker busting bombs unless Israel relaxes its forthcoming invasion of Gaza no I I haven't heard that um yes they the the Americans want to hear what is Israel plan they want most importantly for the Americans they want to know if you do defeat Gaza if you do uh you know Vanquish them uh sorry Hamas what is your plan for the day after uh and Israel is very focused on its plans to Vanquish to defeat Hamas and it's less focused on what happens the day after but that is excuse me something in

20:05 which the Americans have very much been uh been pressing but as far as looking to withhold Munitions or supplies or anything like that at the moment that that's not the case thank you and in a wider scope uh f vanar as there have been news reports at least uh coincident in time of both diplomatic pressure on Israel to moderate its military response in some way and of course perhaps a delay compared to expectations in a larger ground incursion into to Gaza uh Israel sounds determined to take necessary actions but will it be able to do so as a diplomatic reality well you know I I always say that during every previous operation and again this is quantifiably uh uh qualitatively different um there is a diplomatic clck and it starts taking the the moment Israel takes any action and we have been taking action even though we haven't sent in ground trips we have been uh bombarding Hamas from the air uh trying to really uh you know uh smash as

21:10 much as possible its intelligence and Military capabilities uh but the Diplomatic clock has started ticking and it always does tick and and and and I always say that from previous um you know the clock was a little bit smaller now it's now it's significantly bigger because of the the the Carnage and the and the POG that Hamas committed against Israel it's certainly bigger but it is still moving and we've already seen some um countries around the world calling for this calling for that so we'll expect that and as soon as we go in the casualties probably on both sides will start to increase um you know we see some playing this this this ridiculous game of Numbers Game you know when when more Palestinians are killed and Israeli suddenly the the war becomes moral and it should stop as if that is the key indicator you know if so then the Nazis would still be in power because if you look at how many Germans were killed in the second war as opposed to how many Americans or or Brits you know quite simply if if we go by that criteria then

22:13 should have stopped the war 4041 and the Nazis would have remained in power I mean that's quite simply a ridiculous measuring tool uh for the morality of a war uh we quite simply Israel needs to go in to defend itself to ensure this POG r that this massacre never happens again and to make sure that all of our other enemies whichever border they are in or further away do not try anything like this again it it is a war I wouldn't say necessarily of survival although it could well turn into that if it if it becomes uh greater and there are more and more enemies but certainly it is a war that will encourage our enemies if not done correctly uh or maybe discourage if if you know inacted in the correct manner to ensure that Hamas really does not raise its head again absolutely um so K hbr wants to switch gears here will effective pressure be put on Egypt to close off the weapon smuggling roots and tunnels into Gaza if not why

23:17 not well Egypt hadn't really doesn't really have any great love or any great uh Ambitions to see uh Gaza militarized so I'm not quite sure where that comes from I'm sure there there is some smuggling there's always some smuggling but whether it's done with the AC acquiescence of the Egyptian authorities I doubt it in any great uh or effective uh particular way thank you and on the other side of things uh there's been talk that uh Egypt isn't allowing uh Gaz and refugees and you know the the civilians to to go through the gates is that still happening or will there be pressure to to allow them in yeah I mean it's very important to understand when people talk about the Israeli blockade that there is one border that Israel does not control uh Egypt is not opening that border um there is talk of maybe dual citizens being able to leave from there um and Israel said after President Biden wanted some sort of humanitarian Corridor which

24:21 Israel said we we're prepared to give humanitarian Aid Etc when we get our kidnapped abducted back um or at least allow the Red Cross in and at least a bit more information about their uh well-being uh but until then there will be no humanitarian Corridor but Israel has agreed to provide humanitarian Aid in the Sin um so that's obviously a delicate diplomatic Balancing Act if the Egyptians want to help but they're also worried that they could be overrun by God thousand and that's something which they've always fought against so again at the moment they're not opening the doors um but uh you know they they they will probably have to make some gestures and probably at least let dual citizens leave through that route um Israel as I said really wants as much as possible uh to ensure that you know gazin can get to Sinai can get out of you know innocent

25:24 uh gin can get out of the line of fire because Israel has no interest in targeting civilians so it wants to get them very much out of the line of fire so it can really fight Hamas in in a in a more Equitable manner thank you and I know you're not a military expert here uh but Daniel volberg would like to know what exactly is the the general feeling what is your assessment of the likelihood of action in Gaza being more of a Precision strike rather than a large ground offensive that it'll be a combination of I mean we're already trying to strike we're trying to prepare the way for the ground forces the fact that we caught up hundreds of thousands of people don't forget the people who are now going to the front they have lives they have their doctors their lawyers their shopkeepers their street sweepers they everything in between um and it cost the Israeli economy billions uh to have them sitting and waiting I wouldn't say sitting and waiting they are training um and there are plans and and you know they are trying to enact them um so it's not something that Israel can uh have

26:28 going on for too long so there will be a ground Invasion there will be targeted assassinations of senior Hamas officials which has already taken place and taking out some of its intelligence and Military capabilities but there will be almost certainly a a ground of invasion at one point soon talking about a matter of days as I said you know Israel there are a few reasons why Israel hasn't gone in yet some of them seem to be highly legitimate but I would say the most important one really is just keeping an eye on what's going on inah because that is the scenario that Israel is most worried about if it really does send in many troops into Gaza and it gets bed down there you know maybe that's the moment decides now we've got a real an effective chance of causing a lot of Bloodshed Mayhem Chaos on the northern border absolutely and that's Eric sar's question do you think heah is waiting for Israel to go into Gaza before they attack that is uh assessment of many uh they want to see if Israel does get bed

27:31 down if it does get weakened if it uh if it feels that it can deal Israel a really heavy blow um then it will act if it believes not and if it will if it believes that Israel still has the capability to deal it a heavy blow then uh that will be part of the assessment because as I saidah is completely funded completely directed by Iran by the ayis uh in Iran um they are oppressing the Lebanese people they destroy their economy they're destroying the country uh they have zero accountability they are there for one reason and that is to serve their masters in Teran so if it's in uh teran's interest if they believe that they can deal Israel a heavy blow at this point while remaining relatively intact to to to fire another day then uh then they'll probably decide to enter so we'll see Day by day Israel is uh is sending messages um America is sending messages because we would like very much

28:35 to focus on uh Gaza and Hamas at this point Thank you and I know uh sitting here in the US it's easy to say but um yeah Eugene Lea asks what would you recommend to Diaspora communities nowadays besides rallies and hasbara activities we're we're feeling a little useless over here yeah I mean there's many different things you know maybe people can think about who they can Target locally which companies uh organizations are invested not just in uh in Iran but also Qatar which is a major funer of uh Hamas uh that's on the sort of the larger level I've said to people and again this is getting a little bit more personal this is pushing my sort of political U stance aside as a person living in with family and friends around the world um the most important thing that you can do is just reach out to Israelis because for the last couple of weeks you know it it it's it's it's

29:38 very difficult to be Israeli at this point to see the scenes that we've seen to prepare our kids to watch over our kids to run into the shelters uh you know we just had to build you know um we every every Israeli house but most Israeli houses have safe rooms they they were built ostensibly originally uh for Saddam Hussein's scuds then they were kept for uh you know Kamas Rockets rockets and we have to run into them several times a day I'm in one now you can't see because I have a a background but the most Haring thing that I've had to do this week is I've had to get a piece of wood to go across the door of the handle uh to my safe room because we're not talking about Rockets just Rockets anymore we know now people can come to our doors they can open up our doors and do all sorts of things to our families so now we have to think it's not just rockets that can come to our safe room it's people and people who want to do the most best of your things

30:41 to us and our family and that's what we have to think about so anyone around the world reach out to anyone you know in Israel tell them that you're thinking about them people that you may have not spoken to for 10 20 30 years doesn't matter at the moment we we feel isolated we feel the world doesn't get it we feel that people don't understand what we suffered everybody in Israel suffered regardless of who they are where they are everyone knows someone who was kidnapped who was killed who was there who survived who's now getting caught up we're all this is all we're dealing with now 247 so I would just say on a personal level just reach out to people and just let them know you're thinking about them and I think that really will make uh people's day so I know we've moved a little bit away from the politics and the diplomacy and the security issues but I think it's important to even think about these little gestures at this time absolutely thank you so much for that ending message uh we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast Ashley thank you for taking time to update us

31:43 this week thank you for our viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1 pm Eastern for a webinar with Kenneth Leven discussing how the Oslo syndrome led to the Gaza War thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day stay safe