MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Does a Third Lebanon-Israel War Lie Ahead? with Steve Emerson

Watch Does a Third Lebanon-Israel War Lie Ahead? with Steve Emerson on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Much has happened since the last round of Hezbollah-Israel warfare in 2006, with both sides very substantially increasing their arsenals. Moreover, Hezbollah has gained years of continuous field experience in the Syrian Civil War, while the IDF has implemented its Momentum tactics. Most observers say it’s not a question of if but of when a war breaks out. What are likely scenarios in such a conflagration? And what can we expect, given its armaments, geography and scale?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 9, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forum speaker webinar series and i'm stacey roman and i will be moderating this discussion today mirror please staff steve emerson director of the investigative project on terrorism join us to discuss does the third lebanon-israel war lie ahead mr emerson will speak for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question and with that i will turn the discussion over to mr steve emerson thank you stacy i see we have a guest named alfred e newman he's a gnome daguerre for a very uh distinguished scholar at the project on terrorism and i appreciate the invitation and the opportunity today we're going to be quick today uh i'm going to speak for about maximum 15 minutes and then we'll open up the q a so without further ado let's move on to the first slide

1:02 this is the worst case scenario what might happen uh under the worst conditions or scenarios should a war between lebanon and israel as you know has been making rather threatening sounds lately lately it's equipped with incredible of long-range short-range arsenals that can reach every square inch of israel israel has also a very advanced missile defense system and it's a pattern keg and one false move can cause what we call an unplanned escalation but there are other scenarios in which there could be a surprise attack by hezbollah that was uh easily envisioned by by uh when israel discovered all those tunnels uh in the last couple of years

2:07 that were incredibly well dug down at least a half a mile underneath lebanese soil going in maybe three quarters of a mile a mile into and then almost reaching upwards i'm not going to go into the exact distance but thankfully they were discovered by israel i think there were as many as five tunnels discovered by israel the plan was by hezbollah to invade through these tunnels attack northern probably capture and take hostage hundreds of civilians and bring them back to lebanon in that case there would have been a full-blown war um israel itself is living under a threat that grows dire by the day as more and more missiles are smuggled into lebanon and are with advanced gps systems and then of course you have a situation with

3:11 uh other fronts entering the picture as you can see on the right the iraqi militias now have the capability of striking israel uh syria through the iranian militias and hezbollah militias can strike israel and of course gaza uh through hamas and islamic jihad and also now the houthis have the capability of reaching a lot so that's a five-prong multi-front war under the worst case i'm not saying it's going to happen there's no certainty at all obviously deterrence is the is the key word but deterrence depends upon rationality and rationality doesn't always rain supreme among some of those actors next slide okay so um just to go over the major areas of conflict where the um major

4:15 arsenals or the tools of the conflict uh what are prized where most vulnerable the strategic targets in israel of course will go over that arranges everything from air bases to the power plants um to the nuclear reactors uh to the natural gas plant and the mediterranean there's the missile defense system there's the use of a cyber war and of course the worst case scenario the worst of the worst is the multi-front war um which would be and i did not include iran in this my presumption is that if iran entered a war with israel and it could um the u.s would feel oblig obligated to enter the war at that so iran would rather stick it uh stay and use its proxies which is armed very

5:21 to the teeth and to which israel does not have as we can a hundred percent defense against text okay so nasrallah has given some speeches uh one in in january i think 2019 uh another one uh last year he's named actually his his hit list of targets and everybody knows what they are and you can see on the maps on the both left and right um and in the middle the listing of what they are and it's it's it's no secret what he what he would be aiming at it would be everything from the big murray the damona reactor the israeli air force bases of the israeli ministry of defense known as the curia in tel aviv water desalination plants the gas uh oil production military facilities

6:26 and you can see uh on the on the right um the the missiles that would be used um from the katushas uh up on the very top uh down to to the fodgers kybers uh laws and we'll get into what these in terms of their capabilities the meaning how much explosives they can and uh considering that the katushas that had traditionally been fired by hamas against israel carried only maybe eight pounds of and we saw what damage they could do in stay road if they hit a target and they were wildly inaccurate the most advanced missiles we will we'll see by hezbollah which have advanced gps systems on them can carry

7:29 payloads of hundreds of tons of pounds of high explosive that can literally do massive massive damage um i mean take out entire um blocks uh buildings in a single blow um the stud missiles that we saw hit israel back in 1981 i believe it hit tel aviv i think one or several did tel aviv and took out buildings unfortunately there weren't any casualties but um the those are tame compared to what hezbollah has today um so this will be up on on a on permanently upon on middle east forum you know uh channel youtube channel so you'll be able to study it let's move on to the next one okay so hizballah's rocket arsenal is one of the most advanced

8:34 rocket arsenals uh held by any middle eastern country today any european country today i i suppose i have to be corrected here whether the united states is probably the only one of the only countries that can rival hezbollah in terms of their missiles estimated to be 130 to 000 missiles as you can see on the left on the bottom left they range from short which is less than 70 kilometers about 50 miles uh to long range less than 250 kilometers maybe so they can hit every square inch of israel you can see on the map um the the ranges and you can see the amount of actually that it would take to strike once they were launched from lebanon so tel aviv would take 75 seconds to hit a target once it was launched

9:41 uh to hit a lot would take 195 seconds to hit anything short of tel aviv would take as little as 50 seconds uh as far as pgms which is precision guided no one knows exactly how many uh the uh hezbollah has been able to retrofit but it's estimated to be at least 500 to 1000 which means that on those long range missiles which could be on the if you look on the right side uh the zelda ii um which can carry payloads of um sorry we just lost here let's go back um payloads of um uh hundreds of pounds of explosives that can do very serious damage um massive damage i'm not going to get into the destructive power but let's just say it can hit with precision um

10:45 and the we'll talk again in another slide about what israel has to defend against it but up on the left-hand corner that's a headline from the recent jerusalem post by a quote by an idf general saying in a future war israel will be hit by 2 000 missiles a day um now we'll go into the scenario of what that means and whether in fact the israeli defense system that they've set up through their anti-missile system can actually defend against that type of assault let's go on to the next slide okay again this is again another very intensive slide so i'm not going to get into the to the intensive details of it it's more of an of the previous slide the left slide is you can if you have trouble sleeping uh this will either keep you

11:51 up at night or it'll make you go to sleep so either one uh that's the left uh excel basically describing the hizballah weapon system everything from their to their range um and um to the number estimated number that they have uh on the right side of course is again uh the visualization of you know the capabilities how how fast how long it would take to launch again a long-range precision guidance cut which is uh could take 195 seconds not a long time but enough time for people to get into a uh shelter but if it was going into that's only 75 seconds again these are not a long time there was a

12:54 massive assault um it would cause it would not be the situation as you would have let's say in southern israel where there is more time under the iron dome uh when when it rings out uh for people to get into a less vulnerable position either into a shelter or in in into a building under a safe part of a building let's move on okay this is the israeli defense missile system here um and it it consists of the missile system is really the the first part of defending against the the missiles which is the iron dome and it says 10 000 it's the number of uh missiles it has that the iron dome can can launch the david sling um the arrow 2 and the arrow 3 which

14:00 are more recent highly advanced anti-missile systems which are ballistic missile systems and on the right side you can see the chart in terms of their capabilities uh in terms of what they're directed against what they're designed to defend against but their ranges and everything now what it doesn't tell you is what would happen under a scenario in which there were 2 000 missiles launched at israel in one day because we know from prior experiences with hamas or the islamic jihad launching a a high frequency of rockets against israel uh in uh in the last year and a half it overcame the iron

15:04 it simply was not able to uh uh keep up with the missiles and it it's it the frequency of missiles and the number of missiles was too much so the the the problem here and the israeli generals have admitted in fact that were 2 000 missiles to be every day the majority first of all would not be precision-guided but they would be launched and any number could hit uh randomly a civilian or a defense target again um the israeli defense missile system those operating would have to decide by the trajectory whether in fact to try to shoot it down or not but uh if we're talking about 2000 missiles it would be fairly divided between long range short and middle range um certainly the do not have the capability of

16:12 striking all of them or even half of nor would they have to because if if most of them are random as most of the rockets that are launched against southern israel by hamas the iron dome is needed only in about 30 35 of the rockets and missiles launched against israel by hamas and islamic jihad that is those that the uh the idf can determine whose trajectory is likely to land on a civilian or a strategic target now this does not include something else which is the israeli ability through their aircraft to hit 3 000 launchers in a day we'll see that in the next slide um but also the israeli ability to itself now only a third of all uh israelis have uh shelters

17:19 and that is a problem but then again there are parking lots there are uh built in there are multiple big shelters that are built in other uh so the the lack of every home to have a shelter does not fairly convey the issue that uh of vulnerability there's less vulnerability than that would then that statistic would betray itself okay let's move on okay so you can see up in the right hand corner this is a headline from the white from the jerusalem post in the message to hezbollah this is from the february 16th of this year jerusalem post headline and the message to hezbollah iaf israeli practices of force practices uh striking 3 000 targets in 24 hours back in the 2006 war against hezbollah israel took out the uh hezbollah

18:27 launchers um immediately with their air force but then again at that point uh and i i'd have to be corrected here because i don't remember the exact number but i think in 2006 hezbollah only had about uh 10 to 15 000 uh missiles with a lesser number of launchers here the issue is the number of launchers and israel has a pretty good idea of where those launchers are and we'll see a map of that in a second but the ability to take out those targets 3000 is pretty impressive now still um that still that means that there's still going to be tens of thousands of other remaining uh for uh future days if the conflict lasts more than 24 hours nobody knows how long a conflict will last um the the war in 2006 correct me if i'm

19:32 i think it lasted 34 days it seemed it would seem to have seemed to have escalated uh because of the way it was fought um in large part because i think the israelis were unprepared for that type of war but they have learned a lot of lessons since that war on the left side you can see the fact that they have are about to require 50 f-35s which are the most advanced aircraft in the world bar none absolutely amazing aircraft they can do everything but cook you breakfast in the morning and they probably can do that as well they have 50 f-15s and and they've got up to 300 f-16s so they've got a pretty pretty good air force and they have amazingly talented pilots as you know so um given the fact that they have the capability of striking 3 000 targets in 24 hours that that is a message to hezbollah what a preemptive attack could do

20:38 let's move on okay so let's say hizballah decided that they were going to do a surprise attack and uh as israeli intelligence uh as has determined um at some point in the last few years given the fact that those tunnels were built with the of carrying out a surprise ground attack of capturing communities in the north there is no doubt that hezbollah has contemplated that in the recent in the recent year and last year uh nasrallah has given interviews saying that he is not interested in a war with but nasrallah's word veracity isn't something that i would uh put any money on um though it is interesting that after the 2006 war

21:40 given the amount of destruction that the lebanese infrastructure suffered as a result of the war nasrallah did give several interviews saying had he about the amount of destruction that would have hezbollah and and the lebanese infrastructure civilian infrastructure would have suffered he would not have instigated that war which he did by the surprise attack on the patrol on the northern border in which uh two reservists were kidnapped and killed as you know and then the israelis uh uh try to limit that war in the beginning by seeing if they could capture the squad of hezbollah that had captured the two reservists that didn't work and that slowly escalated over the next two weeks into a major ground war the hezbollah are more in there in their uh missiles

22:44 but they do have uavs uh which is a supply by iran and they're also manufactured themselves they have some tanks and they have anti-tank missiles uh the only question is um whether the new israeli uh anti-tank um are able sorry about that are able to oh hopefully okay yes i can see that um whether the anti the new system of very sophisticated anti-tank missiles that the israelis are actually selling to the united states are capable of the anti-tank missiles by the hezbollah and it's an open question next slide we're going to move very quickly right now okay um this is the hamas rocket range we've already gone over it again it shows you

23:48 the lethality of the hamas range keep okay so summary you know again worst case scenario again that's what we're talking about one possibility surprise attack by hezbollah the other possibility is israel says you know we can't live under this threat of uh of a uh a guillotine any longer we're gonna hezbollah now while we can because it's only gonna get worse the other possibility is just an unplanned escalation something happens up in the north and it just grows over a series of hours or or there's a multi-front war against in any case there's going to be a lot of casualties and a lot of carnage no matter what unless it's limited in the very beginning or unless deterrence works and and i myself am rather cynical about the notion of deterrence working with actors like nasrallah or okay let's open up your questions all right thank you so much so the first

24:53 question we have in is what is hezbollah's ultimate gold gol and is there a possibility that hezbollah and israel coming to some kind of agreement um well hezbollah's statical is is the same as as iran which is the destruction of the zionist state without any compromise whatsoever i don't see them changing that goal at the only thing stopping hezbollah right now is the is the fact that the israelis have a more powerful military than hezbollah or are able to carry out uh damage against the lebanese infrastructure for which hezbollah will be blamed for um do i see look it's the same question you could ask about hamas versus israel hamas may be a little bit more pragmatic because they depend upon israel

25:57 for its survival but uh but hizballah today right now is well lebanon is suffering the worst economic debacle in its history the the lebanese uh economy has suffered the its the currency has been devalued by up to 90 just in the last year alone it's on the verge of a total economic collapse and hezbollah is being blamed for it and historically well at least as far as i uh ever since hezbollah has been implanted there i have never seen as much resent popular resentment against hezbollah so there might be even an opportunity for an uprising against his beloved but again then again hezbollah has a lot of toys meaning weapons so and they're not going to leave voluntarily so i i i don't see a peaceful resolution here well you preempted my next question to what extent do you think lebanon's deteriorating domestic situation deters

27:00 hezbollah from seeking conflict with israel in the near term i think there is a deterrent effect i think it's a good question i i think i think that uh the fact that uh hezbollah was blamed for the port of blast in on in august of 2020 because it operated the port it owned the the containers that the ammonium uh and i can tell you that with almost near certainty that it owned the ammonium nitrate that exploded and because a lot of it was being siphoned off over the years to syria for the barrel bombs and the likelihood is that that ammonium nitrate had been used for um uh intended for uh against israel and so um but the the the deterioration of the economy has been uh absolutely so destructive to the lives of most lebanese that there have

28:07 massive demonstrations against hezbollah not just by christians but by sunnis all over the country and by a fair number of shiites i know when i was doing a story about the destruction but by the port of beeru explosion i lebanese generals four stars and two in the lebanese army and sunni generals and they were very bitter about his they wanted them out immediately i also interviewed several shiite leaders who spoke off the record but they said they wanted hezbollah also they blamed hezbollah for the destruction of the lebanese economy since they were so corrupt um and recently a uh the main lebanese uh the main hezbollah bank was hacked and the identities of the main account holders was leaked and it showed even more corruption of

29:11 what the hezbollah is doing to the economy so i the question is a great question i think this has had a deterring effect on nasrallah's understood thank you would any other countries come to the aid of israel if this worst case scenario were to happen other than the us for example are egypt and jordan likely to remain quiet if an attack comes from lebanon and syria i that's a good question i i doubt i don't know that i don't think that jordan would uh as far as egypt um the the only ability of egypt possibly would be the egyptian navy but i don't know that they would come in in support uh nor do i think the israelis would need it um the only area that the israelis would possibly need assistance would either be if the their supplies ran out

30:15 as they did run out in previous wars and they needed the u.s to resupply them either in missiles or ordinance or if they suffered a serious setback and they needed some tactical assistance by fighter aircraft and that really i think the only country that would assist israel i don't think the europeans uh would ever lift a finger to help israel i think only the u.s would thank you is what red line crossed by hezbollah would cause israel to preemptively attack them and is there any scenario you can envision which would result in israel using nuclear weapons to take out some or all of the missiles and some enemies have aimed at it well that may be beyond my pay grade um so i appreciate the question um i i don't know that i'm i don't know anybody has the answer

31:19 about the latter question about a nuclear weapon but uh israel has always stated that they're not going to be the first to introduce the problem is that if they are the second if they use it as the uh a second strike that means they've already suffered a a fatal first blow so um you know that's a it's a question that almost answers itself um i i think there are other steps today that can be used before a nuclear bomb is used there is emp which can um can take out the the the electrical grid of an entire country without the destructive power of a nuclear weapon um and and that's something uh that i i'm not saying the israelis are considering or have or have the capability i'm just suggesting that that is something that is far less that other countries within the same

32:24 technical capabilities that israel have uh are certainly have considered if they if their existence was ever threatened by a neighboring enemy um the red line is a good question um because um the the issue for israel is is one the hezbollah threat today is an existential threat there's no doubt about it but hezbollah also knows that for them it's an existential threat so there we have the the the same doctrine of mad mutual assured destruction they kept that was deterrence they kept the peace between the soviet the russians in the united states for so many years each one was afraid to to launch an attack because they knew what would be happen afterwards now having said that there are other scenarios in which um you know there could be a a much smaller attack let's say

33:30 um by hezbollah in kidnapping um a invading the north a northern community a kibbutz or a small town on the north remember they're right on the border literally on the border you look at the um and uh if there's a tunnel that has not been discovered by israel uh although the israelis think they have discovered all tunnels uh they use that tunnel and they kidnap and kill you know 30 or 40 uh israelis that could start a war not necessarily a war that would be an all-out scenario war that is a worst-case scenario war could start out as a limited war but i think as any military technician knows you can't control the outcome of a limited war once it starts um if it escalates into areas where

34:34 it causes serious casualties one side or another or it it it ends up threatening let's say existentially let's say israel then israel would be required by its citizens to protect them so it would have to take it to the next tier again this is all speculation and i know you know it's it's easy to speculate but i've been in years past when i uh was a consultant to the pentagon um uh i game scenarios game warring where there actual gaming out scenarios in different regions of the world and i participated game scenarios with israel against it's some of its neighbors particularly hamas islamic jihad against iran and hezbollah and the scenarios were

35:38 ranged from best case scenario to worst and included nuclear bombs and included just tactical weapons as well they all have to be included in any type defense planning and i don't want to pretend that i have the answers here because nobody has those answers once some type of military facilities break out you never know where it's going to lead understood so our last question of the day is how much confidence do you have that the biden administration would actually get involved if iran attacked or in this case hezbollah's worst case scenario as well isn't there a commercial right now no i'm kidding okay um how much confidence i i i think that first of all israel has always said that it does not want a foreign or american uh you know fighters or

36:43 rely on american depend on american they could fight its own wars um and in fact um the only 1973 war was the only war when israel needed a resupply of weapons when a lot of its planes got shot out of the sky in the first days against by the uh sam missile defense system supplied by the russians having said that the only question i would say that if existential um let's say existentially was a an issue was an issue and its leaders asked for the assistance i i would think that i i have no doubt a bad administration would assist but it it would require you know a

37:48 on the battlefield in which israel really felt that it was seriously threatened existentially and uh i don't know that i can see a scenario at this point that israel would be put in that thank you so much and real quick before we go can you tell us where we can find some more of your work yes you can you can find um well you can do two you can go to our website and it's on the screen it's it's called the investigative project on terrorism but i'll spell it out it's but if you want to get our newsletter or emails and we send out emails about uh islamic terrorism about the effects of is of terrorist financing uh money laundering also about uh islamic reformism um a whole spectrum of

38:52 pretty good articles um i think i can say that uh i learned a lot from my mentor daniel uh and uh he taught us well and um so we we give middle east forum a good run for their money so if you want to get our newsletter and emails all you need to do is send an email to stop terror s-t-o-p-t-e-r-r-o-r aol.com and say please subscribe me and we'll subscribe you free of charge no problem all right thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar thank you again mr emerson for taking time to speak with us today you're welcome stacey for our viewers and listeners please be on the lookout for our weekly webinar offerings oh my apologies it's actually we will not be having webinars next week i forgot to update that uh thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day we'll start back up the following monday have a good one