MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Alex Selsky

Watch Israel Insider with Alex Selsky on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Benjamin Netanyahu faces high tensions in putting together a government. What do they suggest about the months and years ahead?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 30, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider this week with Alex selsky I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Alex delski a senior advisor to the Middle East forum's Israel Victory project join us this week to update us on all the events going on in Israel Mr salski will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli Affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question now with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Alex selski hello dear friends it's me again week after week a replacing Ashley Ashley just doesn't feel well so we all pray for his health and I'm replacing him well we have a very interesting week and actually a very interesting day from one hand you know we still um indeed I may say in the same even

1:03 stage in the coalitional negotiations because they are not closed yet we don't have a government formed and we don't have yet a coalition of agreements with all the parties with all the major parties but we do have progress which is very interesting and can show us and teach us about the future and we have a interesting things happen we have a very very interesting interview that Benjamin Netanyahu gave it to a former New York Times journalist and gave very interesting insights into his security and a international policy politics Vision which will we will speak about and also another issue that I would like to touch is something that is a very sensitive very Central and very important I think even for this talk

2:07 because it touches the relationship between Israel and American Jury very much and if it's about American Jury it's about America which is the change of law of return so to the beginning and start from the first point so as I said the government is not formed yet and the the major challenge at the moment exactly as it was last week is the agreement with the religious Zionist party head by headed by a bitrich uh we have lots of information lots of briefings lots of um blame trade from both sides but we see that the negotiations have progress now what we see is two very interesting first we see that it's not so easy and I

3:10 said that a week ago that it means that you know we all thought that here it comes you know a government the dream government of Netanyahu having 64 mandates and now it's so clear that it's as we say in Hebrew you know fully right-wing government so there will be full consensus and it will be formed so easily and will uh uh govern you know with uh will with consensus and full understanding between the players for three or four or five years maybe by the way some speak about a possibility that this government may be a maybe it will be governing even close to five years uh or even more I will not get into it it's some very specific thing and not sure it will happen but but here we see that there are big tensions between the players and

4:16 there is much of a misunderstanding there is much of political tension and something that is so clear you know that the Zionist religious party got 14 all together together with benver with additional party but again is uh within the 14th so you know apparently in very uh we can expect that smart Rich will get something very very a high very significant position and he wants to be the defense minister and Netanyahu doesn't give him now why Netanyahu doesn't give him it's a very good question now we some may say that Netanyahu doesn't want to give him security Ministry because of the potential tension with the United States that how come he can give such a such a sensitive and significant the ministry to right-wing you know some

5:20 will say extreme right wing the politician but I would like to remind you that in the past he gave it to bogia alone who then was portrayed definitely as a very right wing and then he gave it to liberman who was definitely portrayed as the you know Hawk I think that even the you know the the perception of a hawk of liberman then was maybe even stronger than the perception of a hawk of smartwish today and then he gave it to Bennett definitely was you know accepted as a hawk and and you know and and the government survived and the country survived and Netanyahu survived now he neutralized them also very well and put them into you know his very cautious policy but I'm saying that because I think that this is not necessarily the reason some say that maybe the reason that he

6:23 doesn't give the security Ministry to smartridge and at the moment keeps it to himself can be two one is definitely keeping it within we could so maybe he thinks about someone from the court to give it to it can definitely be you have Gallant major um General in reserve very respected one the one that should have been a chief of staff was not given to because of political attention so definitely he is I think at least in in the in the public opinion I don't know if it's in netanyahu's head but in the public opinion he is maybe the number one nominee but there is another version which I hope will know soon the answer but the other version is that it might be that Netanyahu doesn't want now to give the security Ministry because he keeps it to a potential

7:30 a additional expansion of the Coalition now who can it be it can be guns now I would like to remind you that guns in the last elections run together with gidon's son now we cannot assume that guidance will join the government with Netanyahu he said that and I think we might believe even though in Israeli politics you know I don't think that we can trust promises you know after what Bennett did I think promises you know is not something that we can count in but in this case I would put you know I would put a lot of percentage big chances that get ansar will not move but if even he will not move I think that if guns will come with his mandates only within his faction without the mandates

8:33 of Gideon Tsar which are four taking his six it's a lot but it's more than a lot it's gives to Netanyahu a possibility to keep all three major Partners who he expects tensions with smart rich and benvir keeping them on low you know fires saying you know it's no problem you want to live live because Smart Switch is seven and and Ben verse 6 so uh and guns will be six so after if guns is in so Netanyahu will have 71. so from 71 you can subtract six or seven easily so it gives him a possibility to much more much more

9:37 easily govern and control the government in each one of those players who definitely can you know cause tensions to him and leverage and pressure he will say okay no problem you can live uh I definitely think that it crossed his mind I definitely I'm definitely sure it crossed his mind I'm definitely sure that it's something that he would be very um he would really like to do I'm not sure he it will happen though I remind you again that he already once brought guns in and you know fooled him just fooled him and everybody everybody spoke that [ __ ] will be fooled and he was a now on one hand you may say you know guns already learned the lessons he would not do that never but you know I would like to quote you know a very very beloved book of mine and of many and different men Israel is you know The

10:42 Alchemist by Paul oakell and there is a very very popular saying there the things that happen once and apparently will not happen second time but things that happen twice uh very definitely will happen third I think that you know after the gas was kind of I think a fooled by Netanyahu and I think Gans was the last elections also fooled by gitonsar if you ask me telling him stores that together they will form a government I wouldn't I wouldn't count out a possibility that guns can be convinced and also by the way guns I think is a very kind of you know naive in in a good way politician meaning that he really really thinks about the values about you know the

11:46 goals and about the countries so if he understands that it's good for the stability and for the goals of the government for you know dealing with Iran and so we didn't Saudis and Palestinians and economy and everything I definitely think he might do that so that's about the government now Shas is not fully closed yet but we do see things in closure now I would like to speak about the interview of Netanyahu and then go back to love return which which is connected to some of the closures I will go fast because we're already in 12 minutes so uh Netanyahu gave a very interesting interview that relates to us to Middle East forum and to Israel Victory project very much and he said a very interesting things when he was asked what will be his goals during this term he said that the first

12:51 goal will be to prevent Iran from a he said from eliminating Israel I don't I doubt and I wonder if he you know doesn't exaggerate but let's believe that that's what he thinks I don't think that there is a country on Earth that can destroy Israel but you know he has or more information or more motivation so but that's what he names his first goal preventing Iran from ability from having nuclear weapon and second to bring he said you know to expand the circle of peace and to make peace with Saudis and he says that it will actually de facto eliminate the conflict between Israel and the Arabs and the Arab world because it will mean that the full majority of

13:55 the Arab world will have peace in normalization with Israel definitely the biggest players but he says that it will not eliminate the conflict with Palestinians but Palestinians are about one or two percent of the Arab world so we will close peace with them after in better conditions that we and I quote will be able to live with now I think and I hope that he means what we speak in Israel Victory project for years already that he will be able to force enforce Israel's condition on Palestinians and actually defeat them not negotiate not giving them concessions but defeat them and enforcing Israeli conditions on them after he understands that they are they don't have a you know a backup now what he says also is very interesting he says

14:57 the Palestinians are the a a a sorry I forgot I think the word but I will I really want to I I really want to find and say that because I think this is a very very important quote it says that Palestinians are the tale wagging the body of of the Arab world it's very interesting it it does mean that he gives big credit to Palestinians big credit to Palestinians and I think that it again it shows us an Israel Victory project how how we must concentrate ourselves on the Palestinians are not thinking that they're puppies because we must concentrate on defeating them and and and then the conflict fully will be over and Security will it will be provided and the last thing I would like

15:59 to say I I hope I have another minute a very important issue that uh we we experience now all the religious parties all the religious parties demand in the Coalition of in the Coalition of negotiations the demand from the code a change a major change in the law of return and I just want to remind what is the low return low return is the law that provides a eligibility rights for Jews and members of their families to make Kaliyah as we call them Israel repatriates or immigrates to Israel now who can do that a Jew being Jewish meaning having Jewish son or daughter for a Jew meaning second generation we call it and a third generation okay now what all of the what all of them demand

17:04 all the religious parties is a to to cancel the paragraph of the third generation now it will be a major major change in the whole conception of who we give the eligibility right to come back to to make careers but on but today in the morning happened what I was telling for all these days that we could will be against why liquid will be against because it shut the door I may say shut the door with a liberal American Jury because as we know the liberal American communities religious streams and the biggest of them the reform one they by their law by the internal Allah they accept those who have Jewish father as fully accepted Jews by the way

18:10 I think the conservatives somehow close to it but I'm not sure they have law as reforms for that doing that will ruin will shut the door of relationship with this community which already are very bad because Israel goes to the right in terms of security in terms of the conflict with the Palestinians but it also goes very much to the right in terms of policy religion and State so if we do that we will shut the door and then also the relations between and the United States even now they are very partisan but if we do that it will be even more pardoned because all those Jews who support the Democratic party will be even further much much further so we will we will expand this Gap with Democrats and liberal Jews much further I don't see

19:15 Netanyahu does that and today in the morning he said that we could will not agree to the change in the law of return this is a major conflict now in the and I just checked you know the news and spoke to people just before our talk yeah so far there is no even reply or reaction from the religious parties to this statement of the good I don't know how it will the result but I think that after all they will just accept it but they will demand something in return by the way I don't know if in the beginning they would really they really wanted to get it or it was something to negotiate but this is a very interesting issue and that's how it is resolved now and we will see how it's going on I I took time right yes absolutely yeah so we have quite a

20:17 few good questions coming in uh Carey hillebrand asks in Practical terms how would the proposed change in the law of return impact on Aliyah especially from Russia in the Ukraine Ukraine that's a very very good question um twice once because you see why the whole issue of the reform and law of return is raised now because we have now a big wave of immigration primarily from Russia and Ukraine because of the war it's apparently this year the number will be the number of the volume of the immigrants will be twice from the last year and what we also see that today majority about 70 percent of those immigrants today are not Allah Jews meaning they're second and third generation and their spouses which uh definitely for all those who

21:23 are very you know who worries for the Jewish character of the state is a big concern now there are those who come and say listen second and third generation even if they come with no knowledge about their identity they develop their identity here and I can give you a whole lecture about how this right in many many cases and I'll give you I'll tell even more you know we have a in in the beginning of the state of Israel we have many of those who came who were not Allah Jewish and became Heroes of the Zionism and we didn't count them as as not likely Jewish but today because the the character of the state is more and more Orthodox so we count a logically so but but this government is going to be you know the most lucky Ultra not even Orthodox Ultra Orthodox governments as it seems so they want to

22:27 close it because of what they see but I want to tell something that to our viewers and listeners that the real problem of the third generation is not the problem of the post-soviet jury because first of all post-soviet jewry overruled you know we we tend to think those who hear about the problem of you know non-judicial yeah from the former Soviet if if you dig in you'll see that the total majority in total 70 of all the only immigrants from the former Soviet Union are logically Jewish okay only 30 percent like in the beginning of the 90s of the limb of the immigrants were Allah Jewish and it decreased decreased decrease until now and it went until 30.

23:18 but the real problem would build the reform now let's assume God forbid but don't tell me it's not possible in 5 10 15 or 20 years it will be a big wave of anti-Semitism in the United States now those who say it will never happen know nothing about Jewish history because Jews were bitten always in the places where they succeeded the okay it was in Germany in France and Spain it's another whole lecture but that's the fact so it can happen it will not happen because only one reason because I will put my IDF Foreman come to take the Jews okay if they will not come fast by themselves so then if big wave of Alia reformed Jews will take place they will come in much bigger numbers of not Allah Jews but they will not come as Soviet former

24:21 Soviet Jews saying yes yes you're right you know we're not good enough we will you know we will do whatever you say because they were not knowledgeable reformed Jews of the United States will come and say no no you don't teach us we'll teach you we have institutions we have money we have all the structure you will not tell us how to be Jewish we will build our institutions within Israel so it has huge effects on American Jury and definitely if it happens it can have huge effect on the Aliyah from the form of Soviet Union by the way not only again the assimilation is in every Community around the world except maybe maybe maybe the only community that has the lowest acceleration rates is France but it's whole whole other lecture sounds like a fascinating lecture uh Doris Royce Strauss asks could you talk about Iran's hand in the latest

25:23 Jerusalem bombings and other latest terrorist actions and the need for Netanyahu to show he will take care of this without Greer schmuck rich or ilk without what uh the religious scientist parties Iran well how Iran is involved in the latest Terror attacks well we definitely know that Iran is funding all the you know all the big Terror groups you know in in in in one way or another and supports them so if you know you we don't need regime to be involved in every you know every terror attack we just know that the motivation and the inspiration and the and the backing for the whole anti-israeli Terror comes uh from Iran now it doesn't mean again it doesn't mean that Palestinians are not motivated

26:26 by themselves much of the money and much of the uh as I said backing comes from Iran's Iran so definitely we understand that it's all connected a if if the fact that this government is very religious doesn't subtract at any any extent the will to you know to uh to step around from nuclear weapon I don't see connection maybe you think no no no connection all right thank you Jeffrey's Chef asked do you think that an Israeli Victory will include Hamas accepting defeat if we will be strong enough they will be forced to you know it depends on us as as you know as Daniel pipes I I always quote him as saying you know uh

27:30 you know Japanese Wharf defeated and Germans were defeated so Palestinians are what Superman no economy no Army no real state so how come we think we cannot defeat them they're like small militant group that's it but what we need is the belief in it within the Israeli Society the problem after all is the spirit of Jews not the spirit of Hamas I'm sure we can defeat them it depends on us yeah absolutely uh Larry Greenberg asked Netanyahu has declared that Israel will not be governed by the talmoon by addressing the crude seculars and those who did not vote for him has he alienated the religious Coalition no I think he just balances it just balances it but also remember that liquid definitely originally is you know

28:34 right-wing liberal movement liberal meaning not religious now majority of liquid borders are very uh traditional we say you know traditional in in Israel is something a parallel to conservative movement in in America you know in the official name of conservative movement in Israel is okay the traditional movement so majority of no who are traditionals in Israel people you know who don't count themselves as are not identified as religious but they you know they keep they they feel Jewish and they keep Jewish but they're not you know Allah style of living people and many many of the good voters are like this and Anthony also understands that you cannot you cannot you know after all you know

29:38 politics it's always about a you know to what extent you go to the to the uh um to the extreme and if you go too much to one extreme it will always balance itself you know you can see that an American politics very very well so he understands that you know he's the potential of his government to go to religious extremists it's very high so he understands that he must balance because if he doesn't balance it may fall because after all somebody will just you know from liquid will just leave understanding that there is too much pressure from from the people and and and as in Israel every day when you feel political tension the channels the media channels are pulling every day so you can see what's happening like what what the people feel and if to and that's

30:41 what happened by the way to the previous government it fell because it felt the people so if this polling will show to fully goodness okay that this government went to some extreme too much they they may resign and and and the government will collapse he understands that and he understands that he must balance and he balances you know it's not black and white Nothing in life is black and white definitely Judaism is not black and white the scale is so high and and he balances it and he does it right for he definitely for himself and I'm sure for the Israeli society as well absolutely thank you so much for for that explanation we've come to gloves our webinar and podcasts actually Alex thank you so much for taking time to update us this week thank you and thank you Stacy thank you for all our viewers absolutely and for stepping in so

31:44 quickly uh for our viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1pm Eastern with enough Kalam discussing why do isms fake hate crimes thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day