MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider

Watch Israel Insider on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

The Jewish High Holidays finds Israel in the midst of a second lockdown. Anger at the government is building on all sides to the point that polls show that Naftali Bennett's Yamina party could be within striking distance of the ruling Likud party. Can Bibi "the magician" turn the tide?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 11, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 hello and welcome to the middle east forums is webinar series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today rare police have mr ashley perry adviser to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box looking at the bottom of your screen to type your question and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley berry thank you very much stacy and good evening from israel um as always a lot to get through uh as we speak the cabinet is meeting on how basically how to react to the latest figures in coronavirus the last few weeks those of us those who have been with us every week have said have heard that the numbers in israel are just getting

1:01 steadily higher and higher i think we reached almost 7 000 in a single day yesterday and that's you know we were talking a week or so ago how 5000 was a was a massive amount you know even a few weeks back even 3000 4000 was a massive amount so to get to 7 000 granted testing is up i think there was even a as much as sixty or seventy thousand tests throughout the day so testing is definitely up but there's around eleven percent uh uh uh uh percentage coming back and so that's that's reason as well and that's obviously the important thing to look at interestingly enough i just read a figure that said in the ultra orthodox community it's 25 which is more than double uh the national average and every fourth person who goes to get tested in the ultra orthodox community comes by positive so obviously very wiring numbers there but basically the discussion in israel over the last week or so has been what do we do

2:04 what is the answer uh we're currently in a lockdown which has so many exceptions you're allowed to work pretty much anyone's allowed to go to work you're obviously allowed to go for food shopping you're allowed to go for home improvements you're allowed to go to demonstrate you're allowed to go to synagogue you're allowed to do all these sort of things and there was a feeling that a lot of people take advantage of these exceptions because obviously the police can't tell who's telling the truth and who's lie um and the numbers kept steadily rising even though usually when there's a certain restriction you don't see the results of it for at least two weeks if not more um but basically there was a feeling that it wasn't being taken seriously the rose steadily but there were two major uh sort of exceptions that either side of the political spectrum wanted or didn't want to deal with on the right a very thorny issue uh was attendance in synagogues we are in the middle of the high holy days we just had rosh hashanah the jewish new year next sunday night and monday we'll have

3:06 yom kippur which some uh claim is the holiest day in the jewish calendar and only five days after that on friday night and saturday we have the start of sukkot which goes on for a week so basically we're not in the holiest time of the year for jews and the question is should uh synagogues be open to what uh during rosh hashanah there were some very complicated rules which we spoke about last week and basically there's a for many that synagogue should just be closed and people should pray outside and it seems like obviously that was a very thorny issue shasta leader arya derry apparently walked out of the cabinet earlier on in the day because they were going to close them closed down synthetic completely for yom kippur and there's been a big debate about that some religious politicians have said they should absolutely stop close close their uh the synagogues close the yeshivat they're learning seminaries and basically everyone should pray and

4:07 learn outside from this from this point on uh but it's a thoughty issue that if for example we have two chief rabbis in israel safari and ashkenazi there's a split the ashkenazi chief rabbi has said yes we should close the synagogues the safari chief rabbi said but we should limit it and as we've spoken about before netanyahu's last real remaining loyal uh partner in the coalition are the ultra-orthodox parties so for them it's an important health ministry director met tonight with uh rabbi kamini uh kaminsky who is the leader of uh a big part of the ultra-orthodox public so to convince him would be uh a major uh you know uh positive for the government to be able to then move into a lockdown which would include closing cynicals on the left the big issue is whether they should allow demonstrations as uh people know there's been strong and significant demonstrations

5:09 especially outside the prime minister's uh residents in jerusalem but also in tel aviv and other places throughout the uh ongoing for some months now uh they've had quite a consistent presence thousands even get into tens of thousands at one point uh and basically the left uh believe that is you know the right to demonstrate is one of the pillars of democracy and even when the situation is uh challenging as it is now that should still remain uh interestingly enough there was a poll done undertaken and released wasn't undertaken today but it was released today which showed that a of the israeli public i believe synagogue should close and demonstrations should be curtailed at least for now i think about 70 percent said demonstration should be stopped uh during the lockdown and 60 said synagogue so there is a massive plurality for both measures and it seems like uh both netanyahu uh who represents the right and bernie garcia who's the alternate

6:11 prime minister represents the center left i've now come to the conclusion there needs to be a complete lockdown they're talking about a stronger lockdown than there was even in april and may we know exactly what that means but it seems that they've come to a consensus that not only will synagogues be closed uh the right to demonstrate will be stopped at least very severely curtailed for the next few weeks people will not be able to go to work as normal and will be restricted to our homes or within a kilometer of our homes maybe even less for the next few weeks as one can imagine uh this has as we've seen in recent weeks this has harmed uh netanyahu's popularity rating uh it's coincidental but quite good for this uh webinar that they release polls every wednesday night here in israel and has gone down again in the polls he's down his party's down now now down to 29 seats and uh naftali bennett's you mean a party is at 21 or 22.

7:13 um there's still there's still a gap but a turnover of four or five seats from uh liquid to uh could change that map considerably interestingly enough they asked an extra question this week which really could change the map which everyone is now talking about is there's and it could member of knesset who's the head of what was called the coronavirus committee and uh since the beginning she's been a bit of a thorn in the government side whenever the government has wanted to uh uh place restrictions uh sometimes that people said we're too confusing where the gyms can be open but this can be closed or restaurants can be but not take away but this and that and seen by many much of the israeli public to be a rational voice that basically whenever she holds her committee in the connecticut she asks the experts the representatives of the relevant ministries to come in and say show me the data until you show me the data i can't make a decision at the beginning she was given a lot of uh where basically she would oversee the

8:18 government decisions to decide whether they were allowed or not because obviously in our parliamentary system the legislature has oversight on the government and has the uh has the bottom line decision uh when it was shut when it was seen that she was uh preventing a lot of the government decisions uh prime minister netanyahu and his people basically uh clipped her wings and took away her authority and gave it to other committees which they had more control but she remained head of this committee made a lot of noise because she was seen as someone who was just being you know who was just saying let me see the figures before we make any rational decisions etc etc so now uh the pollsters who took the polls uh basically asked a party led by her how many seats would it and it showed eight seats and at least three of them would come from when they could now that does change the map somewhat uh because it's a bit of a wild card there are some conspiracy theorists who believe that this whole difference of opinion between

9:19 netanyahu openly disparaged her and claimed that she's responsible for the loss of lives openly on his social media this week there are those who believe that this is all a show and they've created this whole show to pick up uh disappointedly could voters people are disappointed netanyahu but still believe in that general political direction and as soon as elections would be over next time she would then hand her seats back to the liquid allowing them to retain uh their previous strength that's a bit of a conspiracy theory it's possible uh you know we talk about uh prime minister netanyahu being the magician in israel and certainly i've spoken many times as a as a campaign strategist as a communications person that there really is no one better to learn from than uh prime minister netanyahu really he's he's a step ahead of everybody else everyone else is playing checkers and he's playing chess so it wouldn't surprise me if they were doing something like that um other events this week

10:23 israel sent over a delegation to bahrain to try and uh sort of uh work out the final normalization agreement because as we saw with the ceremony in the white house we signed a agreement with the uae but it was just intention to normalize agreement with bahrain so that needs to be worked out the head of bahrain and prime minister netanyahu had a good chat uh this week and it seems also the f-35 issue with the uae came up again with the americans pretty much confirmed that they will go into that process of very possibly they probably selling the uae the important f-35s this obviously became such an issue that defense minister and ultimate prime minister benny gatz is currently in the after meeting with his counterparts to ensure what israel calls or what is called uh maintaining israel's qualitative military edge as we know israel quantitatively doesn't have the numbers uh of its enemies at least its previous enemies uh

11:27 during the wars if it's establishment 67 73 etc we could count on having anything close to the numbers of our enemies and opponents in the region so the idea was that americans would ensure that israel always had the qualitative military edge not just by supplying israel with the latest technology but also ensuring that they didn't sell it to any other regional actors the sale the very possible sale of the um tye is something which has disturbed some in the defense establishment so um defence minister gantz was in washington to try and see how that can be worked out because it's obvious that the americans made a commitment to the uae as part of this package deal uh to sell the stealth uh fighters uh so what does that mean for israel and i'm sure something will be worked on another level uh suiting these representatives with the uae uh with americans to try and work out um

12:31 their differences at the moment the uh is this leadership is on sanctions list in the u.s and there's been a lot of talk that they'd be brought off because obviously it's an interim government etc and part of that is also they're trying to push at least trying to work out a way that they will normalize relations with israel either sudanese president or the interim leader i should say of the council i met with netanyahu and uganda earlier in the year so it does seem like it's moving in that so people of uh people are assuming that certainly sudan could be that next country that i was talking about to uh relations with israel um a lot more to talk about i'm happy to answer your questions to this point all right thank you so much so the first question is is uh what's the general consensus of how much of the covet spike in numbers is due to increased testing versus

13:33 just an increase well as i said um there's certainly been an increase in testing and increase in numbers but the the thing to look for is the percentage of uh positive uh what i think they call morbidity um basically that is going up i mean we had at one point uh there was a one or two percent uh positivity uh rating so it doesn't matter if it's a thousand tests a hundred tests a hundred thousand plus one percent is obviously very low but the fact that we're now up to eleven percent that means one in ten people who are being tested more than one in ten uh are coming back with a positive uh result so it doesn't really matter how many being tested uh israel's increased capacity is certainly means more positive um but basically it's just saying what the situation is you know we've always known that there's a lot more people who uh the virus than we know about so in every country where there's going to be increased testing there will be an increase in the number of infections but with all as i said the number the key number

14:40 to look for in every day is not necessarily the number of infections not necessarily a number of tests although that is important is how much percentage comes back and 11 is is extremely high and i think one of the highest around the world at this point in time so speaking of um we talked about this last week but has there been any change in the severity of the positive corona has there been any sorry i don't know so the question a change in the severity of the testing but just the cases of corona um can we talk about ah oh sorry as many um they haven't gone up as much um the number of serious cases or the number of hospitalized this is basically the key for any country as we saw in italy in spain where the health system gets overwhelmed no country wants to see that so israel has a certain capacity that's a lot of people complaining that our capacity is far too low that we've only got five six

15:41 seven hundred uh hospitalizations and uh you know the whole the whole country has to shut down as a result um that's that's basically an underfunded system we haven't really massively increased the number of beds and capacities since since the first wave and that's a lot of people have have a problem with that some say i think only 13 beds were it was increased by 13 beds from the first wave to the second wave and obviously that's not good enough uh for the amount that we're seeing but we're definitely seeing numbers of serious cases we're seeing more people and ventilators and certainly more people dying i think today there was 31 people who died and that that's a very big number considering only a month or so ago we were in single so these numbers are certainly going up so the seriousness of the cases is going there is a big debate in israel exactly if and when the system will be overwhelmed and there's a big disagreement amongst the

16:44 hospitals earlier in the week the health ministry put out these figures that says that almost every hospital was over 100 capacity said that certain hospitals are 130 percent capacity and then suddenly these numbers were gone and they asked the hospitals themselves and for example one hospital called sheba hospital was said to be 130 percent capacity and they actually said actually we're only 50 so the health ministry had to scrub the numbers completely and they said there's no no data it went from numbers to no known data so there's something went wrong uh there but it's clear that regardless of what the true numbers are we certainly don't want to get to a case where the numbers are so great that you have to start turning people away and you have to choose who to treat him not to treat that's the biggest fear in the system uh what we do certainly is we see that the the capacity is far greater of the numbers are far greater let's say in the north with a lot of uh with a lot of arab towns and villages

17:47 are populated and also in places like with a high ultra-orthodox and our other areas don't have the same level of intensity in their hospital capacity but still we're seeing regardless of where it is today it's clear that the numbers just going up and up and it will overwhelm the system eventually if we allow it to so you mentioned that there are a few except for quite a few exceptions to the um is there any contact tracing going on using cell phone locations or you know tracking the contacts with the positive tests yes i mean the way it works is that as soon as someone uh has their uh test come back positive uh basically what they do is they track everyone was who's in a certain radius for a certain amount of time usually they judge it if you're within two meters of someone for over 15 minutes then they then receive a message uh which means that they have to go into isolation for two weeks if they're

18:49 symptoms if they're feeling unwell or have symptoms then they also go for a uh but there's been a lot of criticisms a lot of people have gone into lockdown where they didn't need to um but basically that one of the major problems and something i didn't speak about is interestingly enough naftali bennett the leader of yamina who we spoke about a little bit earlier he came up with a 20-point plan of what he would do if he was early in the country that's the sort of positive i hesitate to call it stunt but certainly communications message that people relate to they don't necessarily just want to hear people bashing the leadership but come up with their own ideas and he certainly did that this a lot of positive coverage and one of the things he did criticize or he said that he would do is um epidemiological testing where we the sources of major spreads and deal with it in a far more clever manner than we are just reacting to the situation rather than being proactive so that's not happening at this moment that's something nathalie bennett

19:51 certainly has called for and a lot of the public are calling for so the numbers as i said are still going up and at the moment they're pretty much out of control and the lock down the idea of the lockdown uh is to really get them under control and start moving in the negative direction again thank you just mentioned the 20-point plan we actually had a question come in about can you give us your opinion of it as well as a brief rundown for our viewers who may not know uh i don't think i'll be able to repeat all the 20 uh points i would recommend anyone who wants to read it uh nathalie bennett has posted it on his own personal facebook page also in english and also in hebrew uh it's pretty comprehensive it really does deal with all sorts of issues his main thing is if we just put a lot more uh resources into convincing people to wear masks then we could deal with this in six weeks his major headline from his 20 points is we could deal with this in six tweets we i don't think he uses the word get rid of coronavirus but certainly take the

20:53 numbers down within six weeks as i said it's a very good positive message 20 points is to my mind a little bit too much as a communication strategist people can't really relate 20 messages it was my suggestion to a number of mks a while back that you should have four or five very pointed very consistent and convincing messages uh positive messages uh that would be able to deal with the current advice arguably better than the current leadership uh but i can tell you that after bennett and we can see this in the polls the fact that he's taking a positive line rather than bashing the government he's saying this is what i would do uh is resonating with the public um and the fact that he went into such great detail for those who have the time the energy to read them uh they're quite i would say pretty good suggestions especially from someone like me who's not a medical uh expert but they make a lot of sense and certainly these are 20 things that the government is not currently wonderful thank you so moving on to the

21:59 how large is the uae's military force and do they have trained air force that can use the f-35s or is it a possibility that the planes will wind up in another country's hands no i don't think so you know the the americans first of all uh interestingly enough uh david friedman who's the american ambassador to uh to israel uh said today that you know at the best case scenario nothing will happen for seven or eight years you know these deals take a lot of time um there's a lot of training they have to uh you know obviously get the the hardware specific for uh the country itself you know it's it's not it's not just a simple you know they have a few sitting around in the warehouse and then they just send them off you know in a couple of days a couple of weeks these things take a lot of time you know an israel orders a certain you know new it can take a long while and a big part of that is training uh you have to obviously train uh the personnel to this new technology and the f-35 is a new age stealth fighter plane um

23:03 i'm assuming i'm not an expert on the uae's military but i'm assuming that they would ask what if they didn't think that they would have the capability to use it and i don't see uh you know having it and then allowing another country uh to have it the americans are too astute uh to just give away the hardware without severe and very strict uh conditions so you know from from now until the point uh where a uae pilot gets into an f-35 that is theirs is many years away so i think that uh hopefully answers that question thank you do you think that the peace agreement with bahrain will filter down to the population since it's a majority shia muslims it's a good question um there is a lot of work by iran uh specifically in bahrain because obviously iran is uh is the shiite nation the shiite nation and bahrain does have a shared majority there's a lot of complaints during the

24:05 arab spring that iran was and it certainly was putting a lot of pressure putting out a lot of propaganda to try and topple the leadership there um and that's still ongoing we have seen positive vibes let's say from from bahrainis just as we we have seen from immoralities towards this peace agreement but it's certainly a lot more sensitivities because of the makeup of their population but just because someone is shiite doesn't necessarily mean that they are a support of iran or they're to iran's advancements um so but there still is going to be a pocket of the public the population that will buy the iranian rhetoric but at the moment it doesn't seem to be an uh decision to normalize relations with israel from within bahrain you and how influential do you think the interim government of sudan is in this uh normalization of relationships it's it's an interesting

25:12 one because they called it interim and a few weeks the leader the head of the interim basically said that he he doesn't have the authority to normalize relations with israel because they're interim and they have to wait until after elections but at the end of the day i can tell you sudan want more than anything else is to have the sanctions lifted that is extremely crucial uh for everything for their economy for diplomatic relations to be welcomed back into the family of nations so if the americans do dangle uh the possibility of sanctions relief at this point i think sudan will pretty much sign on to anything including normalization with israel so i think that's probably what's happening even though the sudanese representatives have now left the region have gone back without an agreement but again i think the israel factor here in israel and those who are interested in israel that for us is a big issue but at the end of the day for the sudanese the big issue is the sanctions relief

26:13 um and i think uh israel's sort of a passing issue but something that may get put into the wider basket of of these thank you and has there been any movement under the radar with palestinians in terms of a negotiation for a two-state solution uh quite simply no the palestinians if anything moving further away from it there seems to be agreements between the palestinian authority and hamas obviously to fight against these normalization agreements interestingly enough we spoke about it a few weeks ago but the arab league is very much uh not taking the palestinian uh as let's say as seriously as they've had uh previously they used to have a palestinians used to have pretty much uh an open door to whatever policies they wanted to push in the arab league but that's certainly not the case anymore the palestinians are extremely with this but there's no signs that this frustration will lead

27:15 to any sort of openings at this point uh indirect let alone direct negotiations i don't see that uh happening uh in the near future as i said if anything they seem to be moving away from that they seem to be moving to a point where they're calling for a third intifada they're calling for uh violent rejectionism um so i think uh the chances of any sort of even director of amen at this point i think stacy has gone so i'm going to read a question because i also have access to the what made you strongly believe prior to the uae bahrain agreements the issue was if it all happened minimal annexation i think this this this point is that i said uh you know when the annexation issue was on the table that i didn't believe there was going to be too much for anonymization

28:17 and it was going to be more of a minimal because quite simply i felt and this has been proven now that for prime minister netanyahu it was never a major thrust it was never a priority for him it was an election promise that he kind of just had to abide by and and it got a bit of momentum from the meeting with president trump in the white house but i never believed it was a he had a really strong intention to do much there i thought he would do something but with everything else on the table with the normalization agreements it's uh shunted aside uh quite easily stacy i just decided to ask myself a question for one of the questions perfect i'm having some internet yeah all right well that takes us up to the half hour we've come to the closer our webinar ashley thank you again for taking the time to update us absolutely thank you good luck with the and for our viewers thank you for tuning

29:19 in and i hope you have a great day