Webinar or Talk
Drones and the Transformation of Warfare with Seth Frantzman
Watch on YouTube
Description
As militaries incorporate artificial intelligence and new air defenses into modern warfare, drones increasingly play a central role. In Ukraine, Russia uses imported Iranian drones to terrorize Ukrainian civilians. Iran drills to target Israeli naval facilities. The West and China race to roll out the best new drones. How will these new systems, combined with ground robots and sea-based unmanned vessels, remake war? How does it specifically affect the Middle East?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 29, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 All right. Hello and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast. I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today. We're pleased to have Dr. Seth Fransman, Middle East correspondent at the Jerusalem Post, executive director of the Middle East Center for Reporting and Analysis and author of several books, including his latest drone wars. Join us to discuss drones and the transformation of warfare. Dr. Franceman will speak for 15 minutes and open it up for questions. Should you wish to ask a question, please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Dr. Seth Franceman.
0:38 Well, great. Thank you so much for having me tonight. Um, there's a well, I guess it's tonight here. It's it's the afternoon there. Um, so there's a lot to cover. I have 15 minutes and then I'm happy to take some questions. So, I'll try to try to go over some different things. I wrote a book uh several years ago called Drone Wars which looks at the kind of subjects we're gonna I'll talk about today. It talks about kind of the history of drones and how we got to where we are and the kind of global arms race for better drone technology. And I kind of wrote it as a way to answer the question, you know, are drones for warfare, what the tank was, you know, for warfare in the 30s and 40s or what modern battleships were in the First World War or something like that. What what is this technology mean? And obviously the word drone is a kind of big catchall phrase. It can kind of mean almost anything. Um there are drones that are used obviously robots that are on the land. There's there's things that are in the water now, unmanned surface
1:41 vessels. For our purposes, I think we'll talk about uh remotely piloted vehicles or unmanned aerial systems, which are basically the UAVs or what you'd think of as a as a predator drone. And then the whole managerie or kind of evolution of how they they're they're all sorts of different types of them, whether it's very small, you know, handheld drones that you can, you know, operate from your phone or something. I mean, obviously there's commercially available ones like that, quadcopters or or ones like that that the military can use up to drones that are are very very large like the United States uh Global Hawk, which costs about $200 million and is used for um basically massive surveillance. You can it's up at, you know, 30,000 feet or whatever and it can it can do surveillance similar to what a a U2 spy plane would have done back in the 1950s. And obviously with drones, the big the big win is that you don't have to have pilots in them. But obviously if you're spending $200 million on them, you can't exactly lose very many of them. So with that being
2:46 said, let's look at the kind of current state of affairs that we're seeing these days in the Middle East and also in the in the wider world. Just this week, there was a report of a drone attack on Isvahan, which is in Iran. And according to the Iranian sources and I guess the Wall Street Journal and the reports, several drones were apparently involved in a very successful attack against some sort of Iranian uh military facility or or weapons manufacturing site there. And that just brings into stark contrast, I think, that we are seeing today.
3:24 Iran has actually condemned a Ukrainian official for basically saying, "Well, we warned you. You shouldn't be sending, you know, drones to Russia." And this is a very fascinating, sudden, interesting story because we have a we have drones being used to attack Iran. Iran is a country that's involved in building weapons of mass destruction like the obviously Iranian reinment, uh, ballistic missiles, and it also builds drones. and Iran's drones have showed up being used by the Russians to attack Ukrainian uh Ukrainian cities and civilians mostly over the last year of conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
4:05 And I think it's worth thinking very quickly about how that web all connects. Iran, a country that is obviously a threat to the Middle East, a threat to Israel, very anti-American, a country that's developing what, you know, nuclear weapons probably, but it was generally thought of as a weapon whose p or a country whose power doesn't extend a lot beyond the Middle East. Nobody thought of Iran really invading Europe, right? All of a sudden, Iran is exporting drones, which are a weapon system that most people thought of as something that the United States or high-tech countries kind of dominate.
4:40 exporting drones to Russia. Russia is a country that got built Sputnik and was um you know one of the first into space. So how is it that Russia needs Iranian technology to fight a war against Ukraine and how does it all add up? So with that being said, let's go back, you know, 30 40 years and I I'll give you a quick a brief in kind of introduction of how we got here and where we where we might be going. So if you go back to the 1930s,4s,50s and 60s, obviously what you had in terms of air forces and and aerial assets was things like uh you know jet planes or propeller planes or helicopters.
5:25 And when the United States was involved in fighting in places like Vietnam or all over the world, it made sense if you were testing new missiles and planes and technology that you might want to test them on on objects that behaved like a plane. So what drone the original drones were basically target basically things that were built to be targeted and they would be launched and then you'd shoot them down. Uh and then later on you also had drones that were used on one way or certain types of missions to do photographic work, but in those days you have to remember there wasn't there wasn't real-time video. So you'd fly a drone over something and take a bunch of pictures. The problem with that is once you retrieve the pictures, they're already, you know, a half day or a day old or a week old or something, right?
6:12 So actually, if you're trying to fight an actual battle, how does it how does it really help you to get those pictures back? It's not necessarily that great. So what what the real revolution in terms of having the technology was already there to build remote control planes. I mean in those days you could even have child's toys that were some sort of remote control things. But the real revolution was something that Israel figured out, which was that you could use relatively cheap, basically a large remote, you know, a large kids toy or a small plane remote control and you could put um real-time video on it. And once the technology for video and communications caught up with the fact that you had technology that you could build things that could fly around, all of a sudden there was a huge breakthrough in in terms of Israel using rel in the beginning relatively simple basically drones that they would fly over to figure out in real basically in real time where were Syrian air defenses in uh at that time Syrian air defenses in Lebanon. the drones that Israel had built that actually been they had originally thought that they could be
7:14 used in the against the Egyptian front. But as we all recall, there was a a peace deal between Israel and Egypt. But the big the big threat then obviously was was Lebanon, terrorist groups in Lebanon and Syrian air defenses in Lebanon. The problem with air defenses is they move around. Some of them are mobile uh sand surface air missiles. So if you want to know where they are immediately, you can use drones. Another thing you can use obviously is piloted aircraft. If you anyone who knows about the Vietnam War has seen the movie Flight of the Intruder has seen a film in which, you know, American pilots were sent up using shrikes or missiles that were basically designed to home in on on radar or surface air missile uh facilities and destroy them. The problem with using piloted aircraft is that you have to go up against the very thing that you're trying to kill, which is a surface air missile. So that means that you're risking pilots and no and nobody wants to risk air force pilots. Most countries don't have a lot of air force pilots and most most countries the air force um jets are very expensive so you can't have them being shot down and in Israel's case what the big revolution was then in the in 88 882 and the 80s
8:18 was to use these cheap drones that were basically expendable to go up and figure out where all these deadly air defense sites were and then the Israeli air force could go in or and just evaporate and destroy all that stuff. So this was immediately seen by the US CIA and defense department as this is an amazing simple cheap technology. How can we learn from what the Israelis are doing? And within about 10 years um and actually it was it was an Israeli in in America who helped to develop the prototype of what became the Predator drone. And that became, if you all recall back in the 90s or early 2000s, the Predator drone was the kind of Sin Kuan of what we think of as a drone. One one example of them is in the in the uh what is that is the Smithsonian of the Air Space Museum. It's near um near Washington DC. You can see one of the originals that was built in the United States. It was used along with a few other types of drones in the 1990s.
9:17 There were drones that were used, not predators, but other types that were used even in the Gulf War. And if you read the accounts of it, they say that one one Iraqi uh unit even surrendered to an American drone, not knowing what it was. But basically what what's important to come away from that is that if you go in the 80s and the 90s, the United States and Israel were the big global superpowers in terms of drones. The Israel was building a lot of different types of drones. Some of them kind of similar to what you see in terms of the Predator. Some of them a little bit simpler. Some of them were specially designed like what's called the Harpy or Harrap, which are drones that were what we was now called the Literary Munition, which is a drone that's specially designed to seek out and hunt down uh radars and take out air defenses and things like that to basically suppress enemy air defenses. So, Israel was already evolving this idea of of drones.
10:11 Think about evolution like one of those um evolutionary trees where all the dinosaurs are are related to one simple dinosaur or whether it's dinosaurs or humans or whatever you'd like. So think of the drone like that that you have just a few types that were built back in the 70s and 80s and then you have this huge explosion of technology uh in the 90s and 2000s. So, Israel was building drones. Mo most of the global drone market in the '9s and early 2000s was basically Israeli drones. And that's because the United States building things like predators, the United States didn't want to sell that technology to anyone. The US wanted to use that technology for its own purposes in the global war on terror. And it's very interesting that the United States was arming the predator drones around the time of the hunt for bin Laden and was not able to use the uh the armed predators to go after bin Laden at that time, necessitating eventually a huge war. So you let's fast forward from there when you get to the US and Israel are pioneering and building all these drones and unsurprisingly during the
11:13 global war on terror some of these drones crashed and the Iranians got were able to get a hold of several several American drones and then tried to reverse engineer them. The Iranians are interesting because even back in the 80s Iran was building drones. They had probably seen pictures of what the Israelis were doing. And they had used drones in the front lines in the Iran Iraq war, but they had never gotten them to be very sophisticated. And when they copied American drones in the in the two or 2000s and the last decade, they copied things like the Predator, like the Sentinel, and other types of drones, but they were never able to to they were able to copy the structure, but they were never able to fill them with all the technology that you'd imagine, like satellite communications, like cameras, electroloptics, you know, missiles. they they didn't have all the technology that was there that was available to countries like the United States, like Israel, like US allies, like members of NATO, what have you. Um, so what the Iranians ended up doing, which I think is very interesting, is that they they realized, listen, we're not the United
12:15 States, we're not Boeing, we're not Lockheed Martin, we can't build what they can build, but we can build lots of these simple machines, and what we can do is kind of create an instant air force. Because it's important to remember the Iranians don't have a real air force. Iran is a is a very dangerous country, but most of its planes are actually planes that are uh hangovers from the Sha Air Force in the 70s. We're talking about aircraft like the F4 that have now been flying for 50 years. So Iran built an instant air force. They built a lot of drones and then they got their precision and targeting down and they they packed them full of munitions and they began to use them in the last few years to attack oil facilities in Saudi Arabia to attack ships in the Gulf of Oman. And it's obvious that they've gotten those drones to be a lot better than something that's simple like a German V1 or something in the Second World War because they've been able to target ships that are on the move, which means you need some sort of real-time intelligence. It's not just a matter of uh just giving the drone a pre-programmed destination. And when Russia decided to invade Ukraine,
13:19 apparently because Russia wanted to wage war on the cheap, Russia was able to acquire a whole bunch of Iranian Shahed style of drone. And Iran in the past had not built huge quantities of drones. It doesn't have a manufacturing capacity exactly at the United States. Although once again what's interesting is that the manufacturing capacity it does have for drones. Some of the factories are actually old factories from the Sha era that were actually built by American technicians. But be that as it may, the Russian decision to acquire Iranian drones I think has probably put their program on steroids and probably means that Iran is going to get a lot more technology transfers or some sort of other uh payment in kind from Russia.
14:01 Well, that where that should lead us, I think, in terms of as I wrap up the this 15minute discussion is to is what's happening today, which is that Iran's drone program is very dangerous. It's it's threatened and Americans, it's killed Americans uh in attacks or maybe it's not killed them, but it's it's been involved in a lot of attacks in Iraq and Syria. Um it's been involved in attacks on Israel again and again. Iranian drones have been flown from Syria, from Iraq, from Iran, against Israel. It's now been used against ships uh off of the coast of um UAE and and Yemen. Usually Iran targets ships they think are actually commercial ships that are somehow owned by Israelis. Although in this case when it comes to international shipping, usually ships are owned by one one company and then there's another company involved. Very complicated. But they're point is very dangerous. And Israel has pioneered the kind of air defense systems that can stop the drones. And obviously he was heard a lot of calls I think from Ukraine you know that Israel could try to supply them that kind of stuff like like Iron Dome is very good against drones. Um it's obviously a short range defense system.
15:04 Israel's building lasers now. Laser you can lose lasers to shoot them down. You can actually shoot down drones with with air missiles. You can scramble F-16s. Most drones don't fly very fast. So you can you can there's a lot of ways to kill kill these things. But the the next I think the next generation of what we're going to see in terms of drones and technology is not not just what the Iranians are doing with these kamicazi drones um or even things like the predators and stuff like that. What you're going to see is a lot more drones used built and used in the west that are drones using what's called you know artificial intelligence and all of this kind of deep learning. What that means is the individual soldier can go into battle with a backpack like special forces hike into hiking, you know, 20 kilometers in, take out a drone from their backpack and a canister, push a button, the drone shoots up in the air and it deploys and the the soldier can sit there with a with a little gadget like this and he can he or she can point and click and they can see where their enemies are. The drone will also h have a munition on it so that if the soldier
16:07 wants they and they see a target opportunity like a terrorist or what have you or an enemy squad, they can slam into that squad and kill those people or they can bring the drone back, put on a new battery and they can send in send in people to to neutralize the target. You'll even have drones that nowadays like robotic dogs and things that can go into houses and scan the house and identify weapon systems. And because it has artificial intelligence, it has deep learning. So the more that it sees of a type of enemy, it learns how that enemy behaves or what to look for the next time. And you that means of course that you have a lot of this kind of big tech, big data like uh drone swarms and things like that. I mean, for people that are a bit scared about a future that looks a bit more like um you know, Terminator 2 or Robocop, I think it's uh it's actually not far off. And I think that's what we're we're seeing and we're seeing a lot of it. And in the Middle East is a big um I don't want to see yeah say testing ground test bed for a lot of this technology because for instance Israeli companies have sent unmanned surface vessels basically
17:09 drones to the Gulf to participate in US uh naval initiatives navy initiatives that because the US Navy wants to use unmanned systems at sea because you want to patrol the Persian Gulf and the Gulf of Oman. Do you want to patrol it with three destroyers and aircraft carrier or do you want to use 500 little unmanned surface vessels? Well, if you're if you were a Navy captain, I think it's probably easier to deploy a bunch of naval unmanned surface vessels and you don't have to have uh any interactions with the Iranians in which they you might have people get captured or something weird like that. So, that being said, I'll wrap up and then you all can ask questions or whatever you'd like. We can take this however you'd like. I didn't mention China. I only had 15 minutes. China's obviously a big drone power today and we could talk about that as well if you like.
17:58 Absolutely. Thank you so much. Uh so on that note, can you actually discuss China a little bit? The the US China race for the drone drone intelligence? Yeah, 100%. So, you know, China's China's interesting because as you can imagine, China is a huge emerging economy. It's it's a rival for global hedgemony with the United States and the West. And if we look at, you know, drones I think are very symbolic as as the drones came into existence with the rise of the US and countries like Israel. When the when the go when the cold war ended, the drones suddenly became the thing that the US was using to fight the global war on terror because the Soviet the defeat of a a state like the Soviet Union was replaced by all this global chaos. And China has jumped into that vacuum of global chaos and it has of course decided to do what China does with everything else. It has built built a huge number of drones using massive manufacturing capacity but a little bit you know but unlike it's not like Iran it has really good technology but again when you compare the Chinese China builds knockoffs a lot
19:00 of them are knockoffs a bit they look like predator drones and things. They'll build something looks a lot like an American drone but it doesn't fly quite as far. It's not as quite as endurable. It can't survive all weather conditions. Its missiles aren't as good. It's like every single thing is there. It's just not quite there. But as you all we all know with China, you know, just like with the Navy, they don't care if they say, "Okay, well, we'll build we'll build a thousand of them." I mean, China knows how the American military thinks. Procurement systems in America think, "Well, we'll buy 50." The Chinese say, "Okay, we'll just build thousands. We don't care. So, so what? It's not quite as good. It's expendable. We'll build more." And I think China has flooded the the world's drone market. First of all, the commercial market, all almost all of its Chinese, but the military market for a while in the Middle East because US partners and allies, and I don't mean Israel here. I mean the Gulf States and things. No one would sell them drones because the Americans were saying, "Well, we don't want armed drones.
19:56 You're going to use drones to kill, you know, human rights. We're not sure." Well, the Chinese said, "Okay, that's fine. We don't care about human rights. You can have as many drones as you want. Just give us money." So all these countries in the Middle East did acquire Iran Chinese drones. But again, I think the record has shown actually the Chinese drones are not quite as good as ever as China wants to claim they are. And China's not the only country jumping into that. Turkey as well is building drones. And I think again with Turkey is another example where the hype doesn't make the reality. Turkey built what's called a Bayar drone. It's a it's a simple cheaper vers smaller version of a Predator Reaper. It has missiles. they exported them to Ukraine. But if you Google around, I' I'd be interested to find or I'd be interested to challenge anyone to find any reports that show that they're that Ukrainians are really still using them. That may be because the Turks are not sending the missiles.
20:44 But again, there you have a system that works, but it's again, it's not really quite as good as what the West is building. And so again with China, we're going to see a big problem with China in terms of if there's a conflict in the Pacific, China will try to use drones and hypersonic missiles to overwhelm using mass uh the US user or friendly navies over there and that will be their tactic and I think that will be of course a day that nobody wants to see but I think that day could come Thanks so much. Sorry my mouse is acting up. Uh Ariel Grumbberg asks, "In 5 years, will battles be fought by a technical specialist or soldiers?" And Jay Lewis follows up. At some point, will piloted aircraft become obsolete?
21:31 I think we'll see a lot more we where drone, you know, drone operators are are trained operators and they're not pilots. In the United States, you know, it's like everything else. when they were building drones, there was a big debate about whether the Air Force or the or the or the Army would use them and whether the CIA would operate or them or the Air Force. And of course, the Air Force was saying, "No, no, we should have pilots flying them." And it's like, "Well, yeah, that's nice, but someone who worked to become an F-16 pilot. They really want to fly drones at Creech Air Force Base in a in a room like this." Um, so I think that actually today most countries have transitioned to train obviously drone operators, which which is totally different than being an actual piloted aircraft. And I think obviously when we talk about, you know, battlefields of the future, like we're even seeing here with Israel in in Gaza and places like that where a lot of drones are being used. I mean, yeah, I just think you'll see a lot more of those specialtists. But it's just like everything else in in I guess in the way that that wars are fought. When you have a new technology, when you have a when you have a tank, you suddenly need to have tankists. When you have um new types of submarines, so you're going to
22:34 have a bunch of engineers on nuclear submarines. And you say, "Well, an engineer is not a traditional soldier. You know, he or she's not running around with an M16." Okay, but that's how wars are fought nowadays. You don't need, you know, these aren't we don't fight wars now with millions of people. It's not the US Civil War World War I. Even in Ukraine, fine. Okay, it's a conventional war. But in the end of the day, what's maybe going to decide that war is the technology being sent to Ukraine, not the people in the field. Um, will manned aircraft be absolutely no. I don't think they will because I think that I don't think there's any evidence that drones can do what an F-35 can do yet. So, a lot the drones are always are a usually able to fill a niche. Like there are drones that do surveillance. There are drones that are kamicazi drones. There isn't a drone that does what an F-15 does. I mean, we're just not there yet.
23:24 So, could we get there? Yes. But a military would have to decide that let's build this thing and have it be well I think the the next the next step is what's called optionally manned build a these new bombers I think the US is building that are these kind of flying wings the stealth bombers they they say they could be optionally manned which is a good which is basically it's like you know you can have an aircraft like an SR71 that could have been optionally manned if if they'd had the technology there's no reason to have people in SR71s so I think Yeah, a lot of stuff can be optionally manned, but you know, for very sophisticated aircraft like F-35s, what's called fifth or sixth generation aircraft, I think the idea of having a human in there is important.
24:07 And OB and so I think that and you know, look, air forces are are import are prestigious um goldplated parts of the military. You think that the militaries military people don't like to just give up their jobs, right? I mean, so even if you don't need the people, they still want to have people in there. Thanks so much. Alexis Giller asks, "How successful has Ukraine been in combating Russian missiles and drones? Chances that Israel might yet provide the Iron I think that Ukraine has been very successful even without Iron Dome. Um, it's it's it's apparently shooting down, you know, 60 to 80 90% of what's being thrown over at it. So, you know, again, you don't want any of this stuff to get through. Even Iron Dome, I think it's, you know, it's approaching like 98% success rates or whatever. But, but, you know, one missile falling on a civilian or a hospital is not acceptable. So, we want 100%. This just isn't the type of wars that people fought, you know, back in the day when everyone thought like,
25:08 well, it's okay, whole cities are are destroyed. It's okay. That's fine. We'll all be we'll all survive. So, Ukraine is being is successful, but it's suffering grievously. Most of the UK most of the suffering in Ukraine is not because of Russian drones. Russian drones are just, you know, just a few here and there. The big suffering is other things like the fact they have a front line and lots of people dying and and Russian artillery destroying cities and things. So I think that uh I don't think Israel will supply weapons to uh Ukraine. I think that the Netanyahu government is even is probably less inclined than the last government.
25:40 And look, Israel has a lot of Israel needs the technology in Israel. There aren't exactly there aren't farms out there with iron domes just floating around. You there aren't there aren't extra Iron Domes. So if in so far as Iron Dome could go to Ukraine, who makes Iron Dome? The America also makes it. Rathon makes Iron Dome. So Rathon could build it and send something like it. And and by the way, there's other systems out there like Iron Dome. And Iron Dome is not is not the magic wand against drones. Iron Dome works very well in Israel because Israel is a small country. But it's a short-range air defense system. I don't think a huge battlefield like um Ukraine. Maybe Iron Dome is not the best solution. Although you could use it to defend cities like Kiev. Again, there's other stuff out there that's similar to it that that can work. Patriot Systems, by the way, Patriots can shoot down drones. Patriot Systems is kind of like Iron Dome. It's a bit of a waste of money because you're shooting down a simple drone with an expensive missile. That's why Israel is building lasers because lasers are the ne are the idea as well. Why do I have to waste missiles on this? But again, it
26:44 looks like the West will send patriots to Ukraine. So, I think the whole question of Israel sending stuff may be moot. Although, if you know, there are air defense systems Israel makes um that that obviously could could be potentially used if everyone agreed on Thank you so much for that. Uh, Marqu Feller asks, "Is it likely Iran has armed Hamas or sorry, Hezbollah with its drones, and how effective are Israel's defenses against swarms of drones?" Jeffrey Chef then follows up. What is the appropriate defense against swarms of small drones?
27:18 So, Iran has obviously supplied Hezbollah drones and Hezbollah, you know, has been acquiring them for many years. Hezbollah has flown them into Israeli airspace. has used them to target or uh attempt to target the gas platforms off the coast of Israel. Hezbollah is estimated to have thousands of drones, although you know most of them could be quadcopters. These are not necessarily all game changers. Um you know these Hezbollah drones can be detected. They can be shot down that they're not it's not I don't think it's a huge threat. Although I think that because the Hezbollah missile threat and precision guided munition threat is probably a big worst problem. But that you know there is of course a question at some point if there's a conflict you know does Hezbollah have something up its sleeve using like you know 40 or 50 drones to target some sort of sensitive infrastructure and try to overwhelm Iron Dome. Let's remember that Hamas did that. They tried to overwhelm Iron Dome in May 2021. They fired like a hundred or 140 rocket salvos and they didn't succeed. They came close. But so are we seeing evidence of Hamas getting drones
28:21 from and you and doing the sending up 50 of them? No, we're not. We're seeing one, two, three. So it's just not there yet. I think that Israel has a you know, Israel is probably the most heavily dispended defended airspace in the entire world. The just the the pure amount of firepower Israel has is just ridiculous in terms of confronting all the stuff that's being thrown at it. And of course, the enemy is throwing a lot. So, Israel is always have to keep up. And and Israel is always making Iron Dome better, faster, you know, integrating systems and doing all sorts of things to make these things, we don't even know some of some of it because obviously it's under military censorship. But the degree to which Israel is always trying to push the envelope to keep up with all the threats. And I think Israel is there because Israel's Israel's view is there can't none of these systems can get through. You can't have one drone fly into Bengarin airport. um you can't have one of them land at a airfield, right?
29:17 Because one is too many. So if your if your goal in life is zero, zero car accidents, well, you have to work really hard to make cars really safe. So if your goal is zero penetration [clears throat] of Israel's airspace in terms of drones and missiles, you have to work really hard. And I think Israel works really hard. And I think that you know Israel's enemies like Iran sending drones to the Houthies in um you know in Yemen the Houthies have drones that can threaten Israel now. So the whole theory of Iran is just to give Israel lots of front lines everywhere and make it harder for Israel to deal with this like 360 and that's the that's that's an Thank you so much. And if you wouldn't mind taking just a few more moments.
29:59 David Fine asks, "What can we learn from the recent conflict between Armenia and Azarbaijan in terms of the effectiveness of drones on the battlefield?" I know we had you on for an entire webinar on this. So, uh, if you could just sum that up now, that conflict is very interesting and important. It's one of those things where you say, well, it's a case study. Like, if you were studying conflicts that were important to understand in the Second World War, you might study the use of air power um in the the Spanish Civil War or something. So you know the Spanish civil war is actually such a huge game changer but just because you started to see certain types of things that were later used. So what we saw in the battle between Azarbaian and Armenia is that Azarbaian is a country that has money and it has support uh from Turkey and from Israel in the west some countries in the west perhaps but Azarbaijan was not able to acquire lots of war planes for its air force tries to be a friend of the west but it doesn't want to go shopping in places like Russia or China. So that being said, what what Azar Bjan realized was, wait, we don't have to train F-16 pilots. We can't get F-16s anyway, but we're not going to do that. We're just
31:01 going to buy a bunch of drones. And what they did very successfully, and I think it's very fascinating, is they did acquire a lot of drones from Turkey. And it's public, it's public information. They acquired them from Israel. Israeli companies do business there. Israel and Azarban are strategic partners. And Armenia, by the way, at the same time when there was an arms race there, Armenia was just totally asleep at the wheel. Armenia was using old Soviet systems. Russia, they were totally reliant, dependent on Russia. They didn't upgrade their air defenses. And um they went into war with a a 1980s or 90s style Soviet army, which by the way was fine for Armenia in the 90s. They did very good against that. But um you know, Azarbaian used drones to just pick apart and totally destroy this lumbering slow Armenian army that couldn't defend itself and and dealt them a very bad dealt them a blow. I think it was very depressing and sad for what the Armenians have faced. I think that it does show if you want to take a lesson away. Look, if especially for smaller countries, why why would you waste money on waiting and waiting and begging to
32:03 get one F-16 when you can just buy drones? I mean, you don't need F-16s. I mean big countries need them but it it would by the way it would have behooved if unfortunately I think if Ukraine had acquired a lot more drones before the war and better air defenses they would have been in a better position. Drones don't win wars but drones can do what for what for Azarbaian's type of war which is to decimate an enemy's ground forces and allow you to move forward a bit. By the way if the Armenians had chosen just to keep fighting forever like the Ukrainians have done that war would still be going on. It's just the Ukrainians or Romanians were not able to do or willing to do I guess what what Ukraine has done. So that's another part of the story there which is Azarbaian won but Azarbaian was never going to go all the way to Arav Yeravan with drones.
32:49 It wanted to accomplish very limited goals and it accomplished them. So it's a it's certainly a lesson but it doesn't tell us anything really about what big wars look like because we're seeing in Ukraine that the drones are not winning. What's the lesson of Ukraine? The Russian [clears throat] drones are not winning. And look, eventually Ukraine will get the right technology, including lots of drones, and maybe Ukraine will begin to win. And that when you knit all those systems together with artificial intelligence and all this like new battlefield technology, then the drones help you win. But they're they are not at the point yet of being what the tank was for the Germans in 1940.
33:26 Great way to sum it all up. All right. Well, thank you so much. We've come to the close of our webinar. Before we go, can you tell our viewers where we can find some more of your work? Sure. You can find uh Drone Wars, the book about the drone stuff on Amazon or any uh Barnes & Noble, any place. Obviously, you can find my other book after ISIS, which was about the war on ISIS, which about my own experiences also at those places. And you can read at the Drew Zone Post, my my daily I write, I don't know, three or four articles a day. You can read what I write at Defense News. I cover defense technology. And every once in a while I write for the hill or I or I I'm on Twitter. You can follow me on Twitter.
34:04 You can follow my Facebook if you like, I guess. All right. Well, thank you so much, Dr. Franceman. We really appreciate you joining us today. Thank you. Of course, for our viewers, please join us Wednesday at 3 p.m. Eastern for Israel Insider with Ashley Perry. Thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day.