Webinar or Talk
Iran and Hostage Diplomacy with Nizar Zakka
Watch on YouTube
Description
Taking hostages has been a mainstay of the Iranian regime’s foreign policy since the U.S. embassy seizure in 1979, enabling it to extract concessions from the West (recall the $6 billion just paid for five hostages). What benefits has hostage taking brought Tehran? What harm has it done the West? What can the outside world do to end this practice?
Nizar Hakka, a Lebanese national with U.S. permanent-resident status, attended a conference on entrepreneurship in 2015 in Tehran – at the invitation of the Iranian Government. Kidnapped by the IRGC on his way to the airport, he spent almost four years in captivity. Upon his release, he established Hostage Aid Worldwide, a U.S. non-profit organization that assists “hostage victims and their families by providing insights on their cases, coordination with governments & UN bodies” and develops “a strategy to disrupt the hostage business model.” He holds a B.S. and M.S. from the University of Texas.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 26, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:06 hello and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased that F Nazar zaka founder of Hostage a worldwide after having survived his own kidnapping by the irgc join us to discuss Iran and hostage diplomacy Mr zaka will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Nazar zaka hello thank you for having me so uh first if we go back the hostage taking with in Iran has been an industry it's a business model that have been since 1979 since the start of the re of the Islamic revolution they have they start with with hostage taking and they have benefited and that's has continued and developed the practice has developed as we move on so they they had two
1:10 objective out of this hostage taking objective one was to to make sure to to get concessions from the west and the second thing was to limit the openness of the Iranian Society to the West as well so by so start with 1979 kidnapping all the way through using the proxy for kidnapping and as as we move on they start all the way till most recently the $1.7 billion swap in 2016 and until recently the $6 billion doll swap in 2023 all these all these cases shows how the Iranian regime has been has played with the West because the same happened with with in Belgium uh with release assadi Assad assadi recently a terrorist who wanted to make to blow um
2:15 the convention center in Paris um for the Irani opposition so having said all this we see today that they have two objective objective one is to uh to to get concessions objective two is to get openness in Iran in in over the years you will see that the Iranian regime has developed this practice it started with the student in 1979 then it moved to using the proxies likeah in Lebanon and taking the West the Western hostages and then all the way till today it developed into four into different stages uh the today hostage Tak is the is Step One is identifying a profile of a person then taking him hostage then step two will be to uh to arrest him and to to to do U to take him hostage and to make a a sham trial then we do we go to phase three
3:20 which is promoting the hostage in order to make sure they can get and they use they use the marketing a different ways sometimes they promote sometimes they don't but they they Market the product in order to get the highest price out of it and step four and the phase four is this SW so we will see how Iran and each phase of these phases has its own people even though behind the scene are the same uh players who are the same the same team who's playing everybody but different faces you will see during the Sham trial you will have some judge like judge salawati during the negotiation we used to have zar to negotiate so it's a different different game and they play with each country separately they play with with France with they do not negotiate with everybody together so we will see this practice ongoing and the West not fighting it properly except using this the same method of sanctions about and and some other diplomatic
4:23 approach and and this so this is from one part but the part that is more interesting the part that is about openness because Iran believe that the Islamic revolution the most danger you can get to the Islamic revolution is if you get it through uh uh openness and that's why they try to use hostage taking by preventing um companies foreigners to go to Iran to do business to interact with the society and and this is the area that is the most interesting so if I go to my case I was I was I was like I was the chairman of the public policy of the world ICT organization and as well I was at the same time I was a vice chairman of the of the world technology organization so I I had a big gole I was speaking all around the world about technology about internet freedom and and I was invited multiple time by the
5:27 Iranian ICT organization or by the by the Iranian government to speak in Iran about the role of Technology about about how the private sector of Iran can improve it was really good it was 2015 it was during the jcpoa in July to be signed it was the whole world was focusing on Iran everything looks Prosperity looks everywhere Young Young Generation Highly Educated they all eager to to to to to interact with the world so it was everything was perfect but this is something that the irgc as the Revolutionary go of Iran wasn't on their mind they didn't want this openness to happen so in September of 2015 I was invited to speak in uh in Iran on wom empowerment and to address workshops for the Iranian technology private sector during this trip it was very successful and on my way back it was four days trip I was an official
6:30 guest of Iran on my way back to the airport they stopped me a car blindfold me took me hostage for four years so the objective was of Iran at that time was to stop any openness before before September 2015 every single company in the US around the world would love to to talk to Iran to go to Iran to open new large 80 million 80 million market so it's very very very important so everybody will give you any CEO in in in the US will give you the five minutes to speak about Iran everyone so I went I was I was cooperating also with Microsoft Cisco Intel all these big companies so Iran took me hostage while I was there it was a very clear message before ratifying the agreement between the the p5+1 and and and Iran it was what supposed to be in in January 2016 so they took me before making sure that
7:36 even if they will sign and ratify this agreement no no openness will happen to to between Iran and the west and this is they were successful they took me and four months later it was uh in in mid January 2016 the agreement was signed ratified by by the UN and and a swap of 1.7 billion happened between hostages and Iran all this happened but no company came back because they made it very clear by taking me representing the ICT sector the technology sector that we are not open for any business and they have been very successful in this so This Is How They see things we see we see we see two different way we have a two different approach and I believe the West hasn't been very smart in the approach first we never took into consideration that we look at at time in a different way than the Iranian look at it the the Iran look at time in a different perception completely so time
8:40 is not like so important and they have they take they play a game of time and they try to negotiate each one separately each country separately so I don't see a possibility this I I see that this price of swap or whatever is going to grow and keep on growing unless the whole world will unify or will have a a global declaration about hostage taking fighting hostage taking and this has to become in a way by bringing the multi-stakeholders all together in order to fight to to stand together against any hostage taking you know all all everything has been tested directly with with Iran each each country uh each country tested this with Iran but they never tested it together so irgc is playing so irgc is playing Iran uh perfectly sogc is trying to one day isgc playing the West perfectly one day they
9:44 take the French one take their Swiss every time they have a country that they take their hostages and they release and and the French or this country think that they have a very very skilled negotiation in fact the irgc is the one who is giving this credit to this country or to this country to release their hostage the only way we can do that is by having a multi-stakeholder where we bring all all parts of the society to to empower the government to stand because Government after a few months they are under a lot of pressure to release their hostages so what we need we need to bring all countries together with with a Buy in from the stakeholders within each country like bringing Civil Society former hostages subject matter expert private sector and government all together in order to to empower the government in order to to be firm and to co cooperate with other country in order to take stand against hust sharing otherwise this will keep on growing and growing because they
10:47 are they they have been so powerful with this and they are and they are developing new skills in it every time they have new techniques new new strategy and and while we don't see it every single kidnapping has something behind it has a very very clear message being sent to certain people who even if the countries does do not declare it every single kidnapping is related or they want to release their their terrorist or they have different objective to show to show their power because some of the kidnapping and the swap gives that gives them power within Iran to this region showing them that we are we we are we are powerful look how the West give in to our demands and this is this is how if we want to stop it we have no other choice and to have and to fight and to fight openness we need to keep on promoting in every single possible way internet freedom in Iran
11:50 getting access to the youth because the youth really need the support and with this openness we will achieve what we couldn't what what usually is achieved by War but this is will be much this soft war will be much more productive for Iran in my opinion I hope I answered I I talked enough thank you very much so the first question is from Andrew rosemarine a British lawyer who helped many Iranian dissidents uh asking from the UN in New York uh the Iranian government holds Us prones prones in contempt and keeps British spies far away are the British government's weak excuses for not Banning the Iranian revolutionary guard guard likely to be a result of Iran buying influence in the British government and its friends well it has always been it has always been first the question about spies I I don't believe anything within all this hostage taking of Iran is
12:52 related to spies but I believe that that the UK unless the UK will start cooperating with other countries in order to to to to clear to to free their their their hostages they have been able to to get anushi out and to get nazanin out recently and this was very this was very successful Swap and we look forward uh but you have to have a system that will immediately is triggered once hostage is taken otherwise we cannot we need to have a global system the Canadian has started they are they have a declaration that have 71 count sign signatory to it but it doesn't it it doesn't have a straightforward approach everybody it's it's like you can come in you can join you can uh leave whatever you whenever you want so it's not very powerful in my opinion it has to have more more commitment from the
13:55 countries on that note what kind of commitments do you are you talking about with that it's a we had we had recently we worked on a case for uh for Irish for f an Irish citizen who was taken hostage in Iran and and in couple of weeks the Irish government wanted to open an embassy in in Iran and we just started a campaign say hey we don't want anything from you but don't don't open an embassy so because otherwise you're telling the Iranian government if you want to ask countries to open embassies just take the citizen hous doesn't make any sense so so we tried this and the Irish the Irish government start toing taking a very strong and firm stand so what we believe we believe if if it's not only Ireland will take it if it's a mult if if it's many countries together working and the society coming connecting with the Iranian civil society and building connection and trying to make it so
14:58 clear clear how much damage is happening to the Iranian Civil Society to the private sector to the people because of this hostage taking then the pressure will be coming to Iran internally as much as it be coming out from outside world and really and of course sanctioning sanctioning quickly and to to all the players into the four phases of Hostage taking if we can sanction individual people and in fact if you know the person who who took uh it's a vice president who took this this in 1979 the US Embassy hostage she was the spokesperson of the students at that time she her her daughter is is Liv in the US and she's studying in the US it doesn't make sense it need to have they need to suffer out of it they need to feel that when doing something like that is going to hunt them for the rest of their life cannot they cannot do that and get and get over so we don't understand why governments are not acting all together in order to to to
16:02 stop this business model thank you uh don Sable asks or States I'm surprised that the US government uh did not years ago make it illegal to travel to Iran uh do you have any thoughts as to why this has not been done well I want I want to be clear about that uh I I believe the US government or the UK or any government to tell people not or or especially dual Nationals who have family in Iran not to travel to Iran it's an easy it's an easy thing you're making the Dual National pay the price for the lack of actions by our government okay so the US government is not taking actions saying hey you take you you just don't travel over there and then that's it it's sold so who's paying the price it's the poor uh people who has his father dying he's going to the funeral you know he really need he never he he never felt they give him the regime give you some confidence what we say sometime give you enough rope to hang yourself so so that's what
17:05 they do so I I believe I believe no I don't believe this is this is a solution the solution is to have a firm action not to take you cannot tell somebody not to travel to Iran and that's it that's the easy way no no dual Nation no they are citizen like they have rights and they should travel see their parents and see their loved one H and if you don't want us to travel go to war declare declare Iran as an enemy country and declare war to Iran and other country do the same but don't don't tell us oh no but we go we negotiate with them we do everything but at the same time don't travel so the Iranian people will be paying the price and I don't believe fair absolutely and can you expand upon how that also uh goes against this openness that you're you're talking about it U keeping yeah exactly exactly and then stopping the Iranian by going it's Iranian is the most like the Iranian living abroad is is the fresh air coming to the people of Iran they feel that they are connected that
18:07 people from outside what they feel about them okay we disconnect them and then we we we leave them we leave the Iranian population Hostage to the irgc who is controlling everybody at least let them let the for let Iranian living abroad go to Iran try to connect with the Iranian and and make sure that the Iranian regime if they will do anything would you would be paying heavily for thank you Murad Karas based on what you said the West needs a comprehensively unified needs to be comprehensively unified so that it can stand up firmly against the Iranian regime nonetheless you are not suggesting that they should not negotiate at all unless the West remains indifferent to the fate of the hostages something no civil civilized government can do what uh what are what are you suggesting will actually work I am not saying not to negotiate you have to negotiate you have six you know I I we are as an organization we represent former hostages we are me we are found
19:11 like founded by former hostages all the way from 1979 till today from all around the world from anyway so what we saying we're saying we give the benefit of the doubt to government for six months you know we stay quiet we say he's NE they negotiating after six months you people people families have to talk have to raise the issues they have to make a problem but having said that nobody is saying that government should not negotiate we're not saying that but punishment has to be unified punishment hit like going against one against all but and and then I do not recommend that to have West only it has to be a global a global convention a global agreement because if you say the West only then it will look West against whoever it's it's not the West against the it's everyone it's the case for everyone and this is why we should like like when we came because my background is internet freedom and what we did when we wanted to promote internet freedom and when we want to promote internet governance and
20:15 to make sure internet governance is not controlled by government we try to bring everybody together because this is something that involves every single person in the world so so even the government will be pressured to open the internet for because because we can we cannot allow a government to to control to to damage a society by limiting their access to information limitting and this is what the Iranian regime is doing they started by doing something called internet Halal they want to do an internet for Iran and now they want to disconnect people and now we are trying to help Iran by telling them okay Irani you cannot go to Iran no we have to we have to we have to discuss this we have to negotiate but we have to punish the punishment has to be unified globally thank you uh Eric zelov ask what do you know about Bob levenson why was he or his body not released by Iran in the recent us deal well well well this is a case that is on the heart of every single person
21:20 and Bob lenson was we don't till today there is no proof DNA proof of his death there is an General understanding because with Bob levenson the issue is that was never admit Iran never admitted to have have him so still it's a vague we know that he's in Iran we know where he was taken from Kish Island we know all the deta but still there is no acknowledgement of his taking and that's why the Iranian regime is saying that we don't know and and I we believe that if they wanted to yeah so that's why and and the US government declared him dead few years ago with the family approval and we are still looking to have a DNA sample that in order to prove this thank you uh so you did mention the four stages of the hostage uh situation the identifying the profile arrest and
22:24 uh creating a sham crime uh does this go against the the promoting the hostage then uh so they go no no because because first they want to it's not they they profile they they profile this is what they do they profile somebody they take him hostage then do a sham but then they want to sell it they want to do this work that's why they start promoting them and sometimes they do not promote they do not promote because they believe uh giving ambiguity uh if someone is very important they would let it like keep like they did with youan European the EU employee the Swedish EU EU employee he hasn't been announced hasn't been promoted but definitely it's a big deal to have a a a un offical EU official being taken hostage in IR thank you um so don zable follows up to his earlier question uh but Iran
23:31 receives money after they take Iranian Americans as hostages question mark uh so I'm not I guess just a how how do we stop them getting getting the money uh this business practice this business model yeah it is it's we're not as long as we're doing it this way we will not be able to stop them because they are increasing the amount every time it's increased and now and now they me tell you in the US like the US Administration will tell you it's not it's not it's Iran money that was swapped to to that was given to them indirectly they cannot spend it except on on the humanitarian this is all like the administration knows that better than we do first convince Iran that they did not get six billion for this first don't convince we are okay we We believe We Believe admin but convince the Iranian people and Iran that they didn't get $6 billion in
24:34 return for the hostages they did is and we cannot convince them otherwise the second when you give them for humanitarian okay I okay so they will buy for six billion in in humanitarian according to many Iranians that I talked to the 6 billion even if we buy humanitarian we can sell the humanitarian for 5 billion and get 5 billion in cash to give it to so this is all you can dump the product elsewhere send it to Third Country and get the cash and give it toah or give it to any country any any proxy and this is what's going on and this is not giving Iran six billion this is I don't we we don't buy it and this is why it's gonna keep on going and the money you know if anybody else tomorrow maybe this guy who is negotiating this time for the six billion next time we have somebody else who will be negotiating for convince him that he can take less than 1.2 billion per person otherwise he PR that like the one before him he he's
25:38 he's smarter he's better he should be like he should he should get more money anyway absolutely thank you so can you tell us a little bit more about what you do with the hostage Aid with hostage Aid we doing currently we have a we we have a data we try to collect data from 197 8 all the way till today about cases of hostages we have been we using Ai and in order to to to get and we have been reviewing over millions of record of cases we have evaluated like unique case of poage taking around 7 to 8,000 cases and around the world and but it's not only it's all around the world and for all countries and these cases are we we're developing a pattern and now if you go to our we have app you can go over there and you can check uh you can do check age gender reason whatever anything and then we also created another thing we created risk predictor and this one if you're going anywhere in
26:43 the world it would be interesting if you go you enter the data you have and it will give you a signal of how high are are you at risk of going to this country because of the different factors based on historic data till today and and and it will it will give you like red blue green whatever colors like present so it's an interesting this what we do as well as we try we try to advocate for hostages we we we do we we do campaign to make sure that they're not forgotten we connect with the families to make sure that the families because the family is the first the family is you know you know something the first six months the family doesn't know anything and they lost they don't know and they are they are in the hand of governments who all what they want governments it's everywhere in the world is the same stay quiet they don't want anybody to bother Mage as stay quiet we are working on it in fact what the person who's talking to the family in fact he has a check box he said okay I talked to the family now they quiet for two months we required so this is doesn't work this way we need to
27:46 have accountability more accountability to make sure hostages are returned home as as quickly as possible absolutely thank you and for our viewers can you please tell us that website it's hostage a.org all the app is hostage Aid on on on Android or wonderful thank you so much uh for joining us we've come to the close of our webinar thank you again Mr zaka for joining us thank you have a good day you too for our viewers please be on the lookout for our weekly webinar offerings email coming out over the weekend thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful