Webinar or Talk
Western Islamists Turn Right with Sam Westrop and Benjamin Baird
Watch on YouTube
Description
As a growing number of figures on the Right, from mainstream GOP officials to internet "influencers" such as Andrew Tate, align with Islamist activists, American Muslims display unhappiness with their self-appointed leaders' embrace of progressive politics. Why is this re-alignment of Islamists with the Right happening? What does this shift mean for the future of Islam in the West?
Sam Westrop, director of MEF’s Islamist Watch project, and Benjamin Baird, head of its Islamism in Politics project, will discuss the changing politics and evolving dangers of American Islamism.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 30, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 hello and welcome to the Middle East forums regular webinar series my name is Sam westrop I direct the Middle East forums islamist watch Project and I'm joined today by Benjamin Baird my colleague and director of the islamism in politics project our subject today is Western islamism turns to the right and this follows an essay we recently published at our Outlet uh focus on Western islamism examining some very interesting curious ideological shifts within American Islam indeed within Western Islam and so Ben and I are gonna summarize some of our discussions and some of our findings in these writings and and answer questions from you now if you do have questions which we'll try and get to at the end please do enter them in the in the Q a box at the bottom of your screen on on zoom and we'll we'll try to get to them but um let me start off by by before I turn to Ben um let me start off by just introducing this subject very very briefly I think a lot of you will have heard of the
1:04 concept of the red green Alliance as that's popular known this idea that there has been a long-standing productive relationship between islamists in the west and the left um and to a large extent this is this is arguably true um certainly groups aligned with networks such as the Muslim Brotherhood groups whose names you might have heard of groups like the council and American Islamic relations or the Muslim American society and so on they have indeed worked with with with leftist activists and causes for for many years and that brought them a certain amount of legitimacy and access to political power meanwhile the left could claim a minority under their belt with which to uh bolster their own arguments and and so on but this wasn't always the case and especially before the 9 11 attacks there was a very concerted effort by the Republicans to work with Muslim vote voters to work with Muslim demographics to reach out and encourage Muslim
2:08 support and indeed in the run-up to the 2000 election George Bush relied heavily on the Muslim vote and down in Florida he relied particularly on a man called Sami al-arian very prominent islamist activist and Ariane and his wife went around Florida went from mosque to mosque preaching the virtues of the Republican party and encouraging Florida Muslims to vote for Bush vote for the Republicans as you know Bush won the Florida election by just a few hundred votes and arguably the presidential election by just uh a few hundred votes it seems highly possible and Sami Aryan has claimed this that he won this islamist activist won the presidency for George Bush now take that with a pinch of salt if if if you want but just a few years later Samuel Aryan after the 2000 election Sammy alariam was arrested convicted on terror finance charges imprisoned and ultimately deported he's now based in Turkey from where he continues to run radical activism that affects U.S politics so before 9 11 a very strong involvement a
3:12 very strong collaboration with the Republican Party 9 11 happens and uh as especially around 2003 as the Bush Administration is is pondering military action in Iraq the left is starting to uh strike an anti-war tone starting to push especially in Europe starting to push uh uh uh an agenda that islamists especially but also Muslims and those of Middle Eastern descent uh could yeah of course they could be attracted to cause the left recruited them to so islamists were were roped in to anti-war support um and the left encouraged this and in 2003 you might remember enormous protests just on the eve of the Iraq War and no enormous protests organized by both islamists and the left in close in close collaboration all across European cities with hundreds of thousands marching around the world um and you saw not just placards reading no to war in Iraq but also placards
4:15 reading free Palestine and freak hashmir um this was the beginning of a very productive relationship for the left and the SMS now fast forward to today 20 years later and things it seems are beginning to change uh there have been some extremely interesting developments uh in recent years I think the first sign of this was was possibly following the the Syrian Civil War where you started to see not just far left activists go to Damascus on planes paid for by the Assad regime to meet with Iranian islamists and their assaddest proxies but these far leftists found themselves sharing planes sharing transport and accommodation with European far-right activists as well and for the first time at least for the first sort of noticeable time in a while um there was suddenly two ostensibly opposite ends of the political Spectrum uh who would spend their most of their days attacking each other suddenly finding themselves in somewhat agreement
5:17 about uh supporting Assad and supporting the series now this was a minority view very few in mainstream left and right of course supported the islamists that backed the Assad regime but it was a sign of something and over the next few years you started to see an increasing number of far-right activists now to find that however you want but far right activists supporting islamist causes in France you had an increasing support for the Iranian regime you even had islamists supporting the far-right party uh National rally here previously known as the national front uh run by Marine Le Pen uh you saw this in Germany in uh Poland in in Hungary uh the rhetoric coming out of some of the the radical right parties that started referring to Islam as a bull walk against the onslaught of leftism and progressivism and so on now these are extreme examples these are these are known as far-right groups but then this phenomenon of what is popularly referred to as the
6:18 alt-right uh also started to make some some interesting remarks and interesting allies figures such as Jordan Peterson very prominent uh voice on the right uh started speaking with taking part in debates with very prominent islamists such as the British radical preacher Mohammed hijab he and Peterson have a dialogue they do webinars together hijab is a an awful man someone who incites violence against Hindus who who spouts the most extraordinary violent anti-Semitism who was encouraged and cited violence against Jews and Hindus in in the United Kingdom but Jordan Peterson and a couple of others from that scene were working with him folks who spouted anti-vaccine conspiracies um were suddenly found uh triumphing the the or or or or lionizing people like Imran Khan that opposed islamist leader of Pakistan so all across the so-called alt-right new rhetoric was emerging that seemed not just uh a sudden fondness for for Muslim allies but an Embrace of
7:21 islamist Partners as well and this was a radical development a very extraordinary change just a few weeks ago a very prominent uh uh I think the best way to describe them is a social media influencer uh which is a a popular non-job of our of our time a chap called Andrew Tate is wisely known uh uh influencer for one of a better word uh who'd been the subject of great media coverage in the past because of his very well reported comments about women and they're placed in the kitchen and these sort of traditional misogynist ideas that both the left and even elements of the right really attacked him for Andrew Tate has millions of followers online the whole generation of young would be misogynist as Andrew Tate would would call them Andrew take converted to Islam suddenly after just a few weeks of wooing from islamist forces he converted to Islam and he did so following uh uh some rhetoric he expressed claiming that he respected the violence uh that that islamism had brought to defending Islam
8:27 from attack and from critique and from mockery he respected that he thought it was admirable something to emulate he thought the weak West the weak weak Christians weak uh the weak mainstream in the west would never defend themselves against such an onslaught of progressivism and and weakness only Islam could offer the strength to push back against the threats posed by aggressivism as he sees it now all these examples I've given these are Fringe figures these are Fringe figures who do not represent mainstream parties this is not the Republican Party in the US this is not the conservative part in Canada or the UK these are these are figures however we are starting to see some changes in the mainstream as well um we're seeing some interesting rhetoric and partners and choices made by the GOP in the US and I'd like to turn now to Ben who has looked at this subject and just written a couple of pieces on this subject and really Ben I think I'd just like to start with the question what is the GOP doing has there been a shift and what examples can you give us give us of this shift
9:31 sure um thank you Sam first of all for establishing that uh historical precedent there uh giving us some context for this story um there certainly has been what I think is a political reshuffling uh going on at the moment involving not just Muslims and the conservative right but also islamists uh which have as we've discussed at islamists watched many tend to represent the uh uh tend to claim to represent uh Muslim Americans they are the most politically active they have the political infrastructure in place so they claim to speak on behalf of Muslim Americans uh this new partnership I think has manifested itself most clearly in two locations over the past few months first in Minnesota uh a state which we know has a very large Somali American population uh we've seen a great deal of coordination between the state GOP and Somali Muslims uh this included a large
10:35 religious gathering called super Eid in July uh the GOP actually established a Somali Republican Outreach Center in South Minneapolis in August where Somali Muslims could come and pick up political paraphernalia supporting Republican candidates and then in September there was a Somali Republican dinner which was attended by uh the top Republican candidates for Statewide office and many um Somali Muslims including um a guy I'm going to talk about in a moment who is in a well-known islamist um but first I think it's important to note that Muslim Outreach is important for Republicans uh Republicans um share Many religious and social values I think with Muslims they both want a strong economy minimal government involvement in their lives religious freedom they want to to raise children who are safe and morally upright but
11:40 where Republicans Heir I think is in the same place that Democrats make mistakes when it comes to working with Muslim Americans they fail to properly vet their partners and they end up working with islamists and when doing that they end up legitimizing them as the spokespersons of Muslim Americans um certainly this was the case in Minnesota where the state's gop's number one liaison uh was a man by the name of Imam Tawakal Ishmael um Imam Ishmael despite being the number one liaison to the Muslim American Community for Republicans uh doesn't seem to speak a lick of English um if you follow his sermons they are all in Somali language he does tend to write very infrequently in English but they are always closely curated messages that he repeats many times um so he he's been in America for many years and this is um you know kind of points to the problem with assimilation among many Somali Muslim communities uh
12:44 but one of the big problems with Imam uh Ishmael is that he was a graduate of the Islamic University of Minnesota which the investigative project on terrorism has done great reporting on this University they refer to it as a hotbed of extremism instructors there of cursed Jews they've praised Hamas they've made excuses for um and there's is some evidence that Ishmael believes in some of these things uh on his Facebook he shared a sermon accusing Israeli Jews of massacring Palestinians for instance but really the high point of the GOP Outreach effort with somalis in Minnesota occurred at superheed this was a mass prayer 40 to 50 000 somalies attended I was marking edallada which is the end of Ramadan but it was also heavily attended by islamists who actually appeared in photos with some GOP candidates very embarrassing photos for instance Republican gubernatorial candidate Scott Jensen appeared next to
13:50 um really a very nasty islamist his name is Walid almanisi he's actually a chancellor of the Islamic University of Minnesota that we mentioned uh he's a salafish jurist he is cursed Jews publicly made many anti-semitic comments and he's instructed Muslims living in the west to not obey man-made laws there were many other GOP candidates um at Super Eid there there was the Secretary of State candidate candidates for attorney general and state auditor and it wasn't just extremist prayer leaders that were at Super read in fact the event was sponsored by two uh very well-known islamist Charities that we've covered quite a bit at islamist watch one of those being Islamic relief USA which in the waning days of the Trump the Trump Administration stopped supporting them it's cut ties with them the other one being helping hand for Relief and development another islamist charity uh that has actually appeared at
14:55 conferences with terrorist groups in South Asia including a group lashkari taiba which is which was was responsible for the Mumbai attacks um so moving on um there was also something that happened in Dearborn Michigan and this was more reactive while uh what happened in Minnesota seemed to be a very highly coordinated with the GOP in Dearborn we saw uh Republicans react to events on the ground there um this this was born out of local opposition to sexually explicit school books uh pro-gay school books that were available in local libraries um there ended up being quite a bit of demonstration many Muslim uh Americans attending uh the deer Dearborn Dearborn School Board uh to protest these books Dearborn is a Muslim majority city um hundreds packed into these school board meetings but there was also an underlying islamist agenda there
15:58 um you know there were Republicans at these events as well uh conservative non-muslims who attended but many of the Muslim Americans uh attended these events at the behest or encouragement of local islamist leaders including uh Hassan kazwini who is in charge of his Shia mosque in nearby uh Dearborn Heights and uh dawood Walid who works for care the Council of Islamic American um he's been known to support black nationalism and violent uh criminals um but I think it's important to note that these protests um like some protests we see from the far right um you know they weren't your regular um these were angry protests uh there were anti-gay chants that were heard um islamist leaders sought to provide religious justification to the crowds to not just oppose the sexually explicit school books but oppose gays and lesbians in general uh the crowd booed
17:02 and heckled left-leaning figures at the school at the school board meetings who called for Unity between gays and um but throughout all this despite the involvement of islamists a number of very prominent state-level political candidates as in Minnesota uh showed up here to support um to take advantage of the political unrest the opposition um this included Matthew deperno he is an attorney general um Christina Carano I'm sorry attorney general candidate Christina Karama who candidate for Secretary of State depano actually told the media I think you're seeing a shift in the Republican party in regards to the conservative Muslim demonstrations that were so in both cases in both Minnesota uh and in Michigan we saw the coming together of Muslims and conservatives based on shared values in Minnesota somalis were upset um with ilhan Omar's Ultra Progressive agenda uh back in in June I believe it
18:05 was elohan Omar was actually booed off the stage of a local Somali concert um they spent 10 10 minutes doing her in fact uh and then when she ran in the primary election she was expected to win big but she um it was a very close election in fact um and she ran against the centuries and I think what you're seeing there is that Muslim Americans are upset with uh her stances on transgenders or anti-police views and I think this upsets many conservatives mollies and Michigan we saw a single controversy uh related to the same gay rights sexually explicit school books but it was enough to draw together two very different groups that have actually worked in opposition with one another in the past um so I think these uh Outreach efforts are perhaps the beginning of a nationwide Trend uh we're going to see more Republican and islamists uh coordination in the future we're going
19:06 to see them come closer together but I think sadly we will see Republicans make the same mistakes that Democrats have been making for the last two decades and that Republicans really have already made uh during the early Bush years yeah I would agree I certainly agree of that that the last conclusion that thank you for that one very important now I think point to make is well what are the islamists saying about this we're talking about the right here and their approach what are the what are the islamists uh uh uh uh doing and one thing that the Middle East Forum has been studying over the last few years has been the changing politics within Western islamism um uh especially over that the question of Islam islamism and Islam's relationship with the left and so there's a growing Force within within Western Islam uh especially from hard lines salafi backgrounds who look at groups like care look at groups like Islamic Society North America and say
20:08 you've been working with gay rights groups with feminist groups with organizations that go against some pretty fundamental ideas that we radicals promote especially when it comes to gay rights especially when it comes to questions of abortion and and and these these topics and as a result a new generation of clerics and followers have have risen and one person we've mentioned before in our webinars and we interviewed uh in fact as part of a webinar not so long ago is Daniel hakakachi a very prominent online creature who has hundreds of thousands of followers mostly Western Muslims who follow his every word attacking not the Middle East Forum not not Ben or me not uh uh uh various Jews or right-wing folks no he spends his time attacking care attacking illanum our attacking Rashid and to life he attacks them as people who are betrayed and diluted Islam and this approach is winning him Florida and support from from around the Muslim World especially from from radicals
21:11 um we are seeing a growing direct of the left by islamist now some of those rejecting the left are saying well what about the right and don't get me wrong because some are saying that's true politics completely stay out of it uh we will promote our own radicalism without the Democratic process without working with any fellow traveler uh non-muslim but others are saying what about the right and so we are starting to see as they notice the GOP reaching out to them as they see European conservatives reaching out to them they are starting to reach out to the conservatives and we're seeing this uh time and time again but then that leads me uh to ask the question in fact one of our uh the uh the questions in the Q a was uh uh is the willingness of conservative Republicans to affiliate with islamists a consequence of exhaustion prompting people to embrace a why can't everyone get a long narrative or is it a consequence of political ambition and I think that's a good question and Ben I'd like to ask your thoughts on on this um let's take the Trump Administration
22:13 hardly known ideologically as a friend of radical Islam I think we all remember his speeches as a candidate in 2016 where he says we have a problem with radical Islam I'm going to declare a Muslim ban or quite call it that but I'm going to do all these things to stop radical Islam in its tracks and then as the Middle East Forum documented that wasn't quite the case uh you know the Trump Administration moved millions of dollars into the pockets of islamist groups here in the United States four times as much as the Obama Administration did and again something we've spoken about before but what it explains this then was the Trump Administration just just did it just not care about who is it funding did it just was it was it uninterest or was it genuine ideological shift in other words when things like that happen when Dearborn happens when superine happens are they aware of the extremism they're overlooking or do they simply uh not know and fail to look into it in other words is it complicity or is it uninterest that governs Republican Behavior
23:19 um I think what we're seeing is mostly ignorance with the issues um part of that driven by uh political ambition you know maybe they don't want to know uh who some of these people they are that they're getting in bed with um but I think uh you know in Minnesota it was it was different than what you saw in Michigan in Michigan it was a very last minute effort um I don't think you would have seen Matthew deperno uh and others converge on Dearborn unless they saw an opportunity to sort of I think what some have said is own the lives they're getting involved with the islamists because they want to smear progressives um you know and point out some of the radicalism of progressive policies um but when you are allying uh with extremists to do that it's very I think counterproductive for I think that's about right I would make
24:23 one one caveat point to that well I agree that for the most part this is uninterest and and ignorance as you say as you put it on behalf of the right there is a trend in the more extreme sections of absolute awareness of what they're doing and this does not yet reflect to the mainstream circles as he pointed out but on the extreme and we saw this recently with uh an interview we wrote about six months ago between Daniel hakakachi the islamist preacher I mentioned and someone called Mark Collett a very prominent British Neo-Nazi and by Neo-Nazi I mean Source took a tattoo the whole the whole nine they agreed on everything they didn't realize they were going to agree on everything when they started talking but in a course of a two-hour debate they suddenly realized that they had a shared Mutual hatred of Jews of secularism of of liberalism and it ended with an extraordinary admission by Mark Collett this year Nazi he said that yes he'd accept an Islamic State in Europe he'd be okay with the Islamic States in Europe his only caveat being that it must be white it must be a
25:25 white Islamic State now practically one can't quite see that working out for Europe but that's a fascinating concession nonetheless ride that this Neo-Nazi this active neo-naz is this leader of of a genuinely far-right cause can regard Islam as an asset something to help him impose his designs rather than something to to stop for his designs from materializing in in the first place um so there is there is that that question of what the far right we're doing until what extent the far right and the other extremes will that influence seep into the mainstream into the into the regular uh conservative right can I can I add something on that um I think it's important when looking at the future of um GOP islamist Alliance that it's it's vulnerable unlike the progressive islamist Alliance um the conservative islamist pact is vulnerable to the next terrorist attack on U.S soil uh or the next uh U.S foreign policy action in the Middle East so in the former case you have
26:29 conservatives who would become unwilling to work with islamists and perhaps Muslims in general were there another large-scale terrorist attack on U.S oil and in the latter case uh you have the potential for military action in the Middle East North Africa targeting a Muslim majority country which would make it politically unfeasible for islamists to continue working with the right I um so I think that is what sort of sets the conservative islamist Alliance apart from progressives um is that it is vulnerable to those sort of activities yeah I thought it's an extremely deceptive point I mean absolutely absolutely now we're near the end of our time I want to just take a couple of questions which I'm going to roll together from the Q a section uh both from Anonymous attendees so um uh one asks um was it the Strategic oh sorry one is is not from an anonymous attendee the uh Dennis carp asks uh can write uh uh the you know extremists on the right and
27:30 extremists on the left be opposed simultaneously by coordinated current campaigns especially Jewish organizations uh and then another question that says what are the Strategic implications of all this for folks intent on rolling back islamist encroachment in the U.S in other words what choices do counter islamists have to make in the light of this information and this this this discussion so I suppose putting these two questions together Ben what can we do about this do we carry on doing what we've done with the left do we do we need to adapt and change our approaches how do we stop islamists from Gaining allies on all sides of the political spectrum and becoming even more dangerous than they were before um I think regardless of where you stand politically if you're a conservative you should oppose conservative islamist Alliance alliances um if you are a Democrat you should oppose those same alliances uh from your own political party um and I think that's important we um you know
28:34 for the benefit of small term strategic alliances that make the other side look um we should not encourage these relationships at all I should say with the right um it does present sort of an um progressives tend to be very opposed to hearing about how the partners Partnerships there forming uh are extremists it often elicits um accusations of islamophobia or anti-muslim bias from the left um the right tends to have more of an open ear when it comes to this um so she we should never um miss an opportunity to inform lawmakers about the mistakes they're making when it when it comes to working with islamists Ben thank you very much um that's all we have time for this is a part of a regular webinar
29:39 Series so if you would like to see more webinars in the Middle East Forum please do sign up at me forum.org if you'd like to read more about the subject Ben and I were discussing today as I mentioned there is an essay we have published at our media Outlet focus on Western islamism you can read it by going to uh the domain name islamism.news and you'll find the essay there it's titled the conservative islamist Alliance uh thank you very much and I hope you all have a very pleasant weekend bye