MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

In this episode of Israel Insider, host Ashley Perry, advisor to the Middle East Forum Israel office, walks through the coalition negotiations of the bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot, now around 10 days in with little official progress, and the four main tracks it is exploring: a coalition with the Arab parties, a coalition with the two Haredi parties, a unity government with Likud, and an emergency minority government supported from outside the coalition.

Perry explains why Avigdor Lieberman, for years one of the biggest opponents of the ultra-Orthodox parties, is now leading talks with United Torah Judaism; what Naftali Bennett's two-and-a-half-hour meeting in Prime Minister Netanyahu's Knesset office means for unity talks; and how the replacement of Speaker Amir Ohana with Matan Kahana could let the opposition swear in a new government within 24 hours. He also discusses Netanyahu's argument that an imminent need to strike Iran calls for unity, the opposition's doubts about that, and why the final decision on a strike rests with President Trump.

In the Q&A, he takes audience questions on the place of Arab citizens and Arab parties in Israel's democracy, how Israel's intelligence chiefs and the IDF assess the Iranian threat, what a caretaker government can and cannot do, and whether the opposition bloc is as divided as it looks.

Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:33 Day 10 of coalition talks
1:25 Option one: the Arab parties
2:12 Option two: the Haredi parties
6:31 Option three: unity with Likud
9:17 Option four: a minority government
13:15 The push to strike Iran
20:55 Audience questions
28:16 Closing

Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for new episodes and expert analysis every week.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 19, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 As much as Netanyao would like a strike uh on Iran, it's clear that the one uh who will make the decision is Donald Trump. And Donald Trump certainly is um raising the threat level. [music] and good evening from Israel uh for another edition of Israel Insider with me Ashley Perry, advisor to the Middle East forum Israel office. Obviously, there's really only one place to start here in Israel, and that's in the ongoing coalition negotiations where I think day 10 or day 11 there hasn't been too much official progress um on any particular track, but all options are still being explored by the Eisenot le block. And I'll explain um what the options are and really who in the block is leading it because it does

1:03 seem like there's a fullcourt press uh by various uh leaders or parties in the so-called change and reform block the Eisenot le block. Um but there's obstacles to all of them of course and so I'll go through them of four main ones um uh and and and go through them one by one. Um I would say probably the least likely is a coalition with the Arab parties. Um this is certainly mathematically doable and actually would probably be the most stable government in terms of numbers. Um this particular track is touted to a certain extent led by Democrat leader Yolan.

1:47 Um it's unlikely because pretty much everyone else in the block uh will say no to it. Lieberman has uh said he will not sit with the Arab parties in the government. Um Bennett I I'm pretty sure has also made those comments. Eisenot will not do it. Uh so really it's his own really trying to put that option on the table. The second option is a coalition with the two Kedi parties. This is very surprisingly if you'd have suggested this two weeks ago being led by Avdor Leeman of the Israel party what is described sometimes as the arch secularist party and certainly a Victoria Leeman over the last what is it probably almost decade has been uh probably the biggest opponent of the ultraorththodox parties in terms of enlistment in terms of budget in terms of pretty much everything and he ran a campaign on 100% to soldiers, 0% to those who do not serve. So, it was a

2:52 very explicitly anti- ultra orthodox or at least uh ultraorththodox parties and their policies um uh campaign and now he is pretty much leading uh the negotiations to possibly create a coalition with the so-called change and reform uh opposition and the two kari parties. What's interesting here is that he had Leeman had a long-standing relationship with Ariad. They were extremely close friends for many decades. They fell out um a number of years ago and Leeman wouldn't join the government on the enlistment issue. Um so one would have thought that would probably be the best way in. Uh and usually the Shas party historically is not as right-wing especially Ariad himself. He sat in leftwing governments uh and usually they are more amanable.

3:48 Interestingly here is actually Leman seems to be dealing with Yakov Asher who is the relatively new leader of the United Judaism, the Ashkanazi party made up of the um so-called kidic faction and the Lithuanian or non-hasidic faction. Um there was all sorts of uh sort of exercises here. Leeman and uh went across to uh Yakov Basher's office ostensibly to get coffee. Um but obviously things are moving in in that direction. Um there are a lot of obstacles here. First of all, even if you get United Torah Judaism on board and that's a very big if, will Shas join? Um I did say shas are more meaningable and sh certainly have um sat on you know more left-wing governments but Arya is a very close ally to uh prime minister Netanyao and has said I will not join government not led by Netanyao. [snorts] However, it is

4:52 thought that if United Torah Judaism decide to join and their spiritual leader Rav Lando basically says this is the government the Harim the ultraorththodox have to join it'll be very hard for Shas to say no Shas um [clears throat] uh usually in in when when their spiritual leader Ravi Yostf was alive uh it was a different ball game. Today Ravlando is seen as the head of the Karedi world and it's hard for even Chas to go against his wishes probably if they did it would be partly not wanted to go against his wishes and partly having that cover to enter uh the government. There's obviously very big obstacles on what will happen to the enlistment law uh or non-inlistment law depending how you look at it. Um but interestingly enough, Avidor Leeman was named as chairman of the very important and influential defense and foreign affairs committee and he said that the focus uh is going to be on trying to uh

5:57 sort out some sort of enlistment law and he even said that the three changes the three stages it has to go through has to go through the IDF. First the IDF has to agree to it and it has to meet their demands. Second is the legal system and third he specifically name checked Rav London. In other words, it also has to go through him. Um it's a big about face. Um but certainly there is disqu amongst other members of the um the the coalition perhaps Bennett Yolan against that particular move. The third one is unity with Liquid. Um and that's something which has been touted from the beginning. Um it's not a major track. Uh but today it got a major boost with Naftali Bennett, leader of uh the um Yahad party with um with Yeshid's um Yid. He was seen going into Prime Minister Netanyahu's Knessa office and

7:01 certainly didn't try to hide it. did in front of all the cameras, although it's very hard to sort of get away from the news cameras cuz they are uh planted outside Prime Minister Netanyahu's office. Um, and he was in there for 2 and a half hours. And what's interesting about that is it's clear that there was a lot to talk about. Uh, ostensively, officially, it was a military briefing. And at one point um Netanyahu's military secretary was brought in and certainly that was discussed but clearly there was also uh discussions political discussions and there was um uh discussions about uh whether there could be some sort of unity government. Uh Netanyao has certainly been beating that drum. Uh since Eisenhawk received the mandate from President Herzog to try and form a coalition. Netanyahu has basically been saying there's only one thing to do. You can't rely on terrorist supporters, can't rely on this, you can't rely on that. The only way forward is unity. Obviously, the way he sees it is uh unity would have uh be led by Netanyahu or at least in a rotation

8:07 agreement. Netanyahu would want to go first primarily uh because he can't serve in any other ministerial position. he doesn't want to leave the prime minister uh position but also he wants to take advantage of the last two years of the Trump uh presidency. Um this obviously has major obstacles. First of all, Avidor Leeman and Yolan both said that they will not serve um in such a government although the numbers you know that with Eisenot and Bennett they wouldn't necessarily need Leman and Golan. Um but also there would be that problem who would go first. Uh Nettingo apparently according to some sources has even relented and says I don't demand first rotation.

8:56 Perhaps it could be a broken up into a year two years Netanyahu and then a final year for Eisenot. Eisenot on his behalf came out and said I do not believe in rotation even if I'm going to go first. But clearly the lines are being uh drawn at this point. But again as I said there are limitations to that. The fourth option at the moment is swearing as an emergency government a minority government. It would not have the 61 uh members of a coalition, but it would be supported on the outside by either Ram, which is the more moderate Arab party, which sat in a coalition before with pretty much all of these uh leaders of the change block, or perhaps even United Judaism, where they wouldn't have to commit fully to be in the government, but they could support it from the outside for some concessions, but clearly not all of the concessions, and that would be enough to just get them over uh the line as far as a majority, especially if the other Arab party abstained and then then pretty

10:00 much they could swear in a minority government. And um that is hinted at pretty regularly by uh official statements from the uh the the the change of reform block, the opposition block of GI Eisenh. Um the way the statement was put out today after the meeting with Bennett uh all the uh the five leaders uh met and then they put out a statement that you know they need an emergency government and that basically means something close to this uh minority government. Um this week one of the most important perhaps steps towards that and and a lot more was the replacement of the previous speaker Amir Khan of the Lur party with Matan Kahana of excuse [clears throat] me Gad Gaddy Eisenkot's party. Uh this was obviously very controversial especially for supporters of the current government because it relied on support of the two Arab parties and thus had a clear majority. I think 66 out of the 67

11:06 possible members of outside of uh Netanyahu's block. It's not completely unprecedented, but it's certainly rare that a speaker would be uh sworn in um a new speaker before government uh would be sworn in. Um but we live in very strange and unprecedented times. Um what this and it would be pretty hard to now get the speaker out unless we went for another round of elections, which is obviously a fifth option I didn't talk about, but it's always there in the background. But uh as well as the importance of being able to control the Knesset, the pace of legislation, the agenda, the scheduling etc etc. Perhaps one of the most important parts of uh the fact that they now control the speaker's office is if they wanted to swear in this uh minority government, they could actually hold uh uh a vote on it within 24 hours. What usually happens when a uh the person who's been given

12:10 the mandate to try and form a coalition at some point if they can form a government they basically inform the president I have it it's literally said I have it in my hands which means I have the formation of a government then that person is given up to 7 days to finalize coalition negotiations to sign the agreements to um put those into the Knesset for perusal and then finally a vote on it that process could be hurried up within 24 hours um with the uh assistance of the speaker. In other words, if um what what's today? Wednesday. Perhaps even tomorrow within 24 hours if they decided to do it, uh the speaker could hold a vote within 24 hours for an emergency government even though it would not be uh perhaps the permanent government coalition negotiations perhaps would even continue. But uh there will be a new prime minister, a new government and new ministers within 24 hours. And that is a significant thing to hold over Netanyao um and

13:13 perhaps could happen. And the reason that could happen is in a part of the um the statement that came out today from the change block after they met after the Bennett Netany 2 and a half hours meeting was that um basically the next few days are going to be crucial in terms of security etc. Netanyao is trying to convince uh Bennett and through Bennett um his partners in the change block that a there is a an imminent need to attack Iran uh for imminent security needs. Um something uh similar was uh explained to Eisen Court when he got a security briefing. I think it was around 10 days ago or a week ago.

14:00 Um [clears throat] and so there is there is a feeling amongst the the the change block that clearly that there you know Iran is trying to uh you know uh uh restart their nuclear uh program to increase their missile supply etc etc and even target uh you know important sites and and certainly things are going on in the region but they don't think uh it's it should be imminent. They think you know these things don't don't change within a matter of days. Netanyahu is trying to make the point that it does.

14:36 Um and the question is who you believe. If you if you stand with Netanyahu then you believe that you know there needs to be unity now because we need to deal with Iran. If you are on the other side of the fence, you think that maybe it's a political ploy just to try and force uh unity through and make sure that this uh that there's no coalition uh uh until these matters are are are sorted out. Um so there's a lot going on. Um there clearly uh is uh something going on. The demon mayor, for example, came out and said um quite astonishingly today in a radio interview, he he was told that something was going to happen this Friday night. Um I don't know where he got that from, but he is uh a prominent member. Uh he's very close to the the current government and the liquid party.

15:30 Um other things going on, the commander of Sententcom uh was in Israel for meetings with the chief of staff and interestingly also the Mossad head Roman Goffman. Usually meetings uh don't include um the Mossad head. They usually involve um you know the IDF chief of staff, director of planning, the IDF, people like that. But clearly um there's something going on because also the Mossad leader just came back from the US where he met with the senior members of the Trump administration according to reports was trying to convince them there is a need for a strike uh immediately and apparently even traveled down to Miami to meet with Steve Whit also um to uh deliver uh that message.

16:15 Um the question is what will happen and clearly as much as Netanyao would like a strike uh on Iran perhaps because of security reasons perhaps because of political reasons perhaps because of a mixture of the two. It's clear that the one uh who will make the decision is Donald Trump and Donald Trump certainly is um raising the threat level. He's brought a third aircraft carrier to the region. So obviously, you know, he's trying to build up as much force as possible if he decides uh to strike [clears throat] and we heard today um from uh a head of US intelligence that there is a threat to uh Americans in the region and even at home. There were reports, I believe, on CNN that there was a there are attempts by Iran to perhaps even um bring a dirty bomb into DC somehow to try and um uh attack senior administration level uh leaders.

17:21 Interestingly, I think there's at least four or five senior members of the Trump administration who have been moved to military bases. Now, is that because there's a credible threat? Well, that's been um or or an imminent threat uh that's been denied, but it's clear that there is at least some uh level of threat there. So, um certainly the rhetoric is um is increasing. There is also the feeling that as a result of the midtone elections and the drubbing that the Republican party received uh Iran is now um taking a harder line negotiations believing that it now has the upper hand and Trump is a weaker perhaps even lame duck president uh than he was before the um the midterm. So things are clearly heating up. Is there an imminent uh military strike in the offing? Only the the days and weeks ahead uh will tell us exactly uh what's going on, but here

18:24 it's clear that Netanyao would like uh something to happen soon. It's clear that members of the change block would like to hold off as much as possible to try and at least get uh a coalition together, whatever that may be. Um because these decisions should not be in the hands, this is the way they would certainly phrase it, of a caretaker government, which is what the net government is at this point. Um and they may even take matters um on themselves and basically decide to as I said go full um speed ahead to some sort of minority uh emergency government. We are seeing various other attempts in the Knesset uh to uh on on half of the the change and reform opposition to repeal some of the um judicial and communications reform that the previous government did and the other side is trying to embarrass uh the opposition by trying to pass laws that they know uh

19:28 they would not be able to vote against. So uh there really is a lot going on. Um, usually as things go, we won't know uh anything until we know anything. In other words, everyone's playing their cards very close to their chess. I would argue that anyone who says that they know for sure what's going to happen doesn't know. Um, and because I don't think even the players themselves know uh where things are going. There is no great progress on any of these tracks. um especially with the Arab parties and with the uh ultra orthodox and with the uh unity government but we'll have to say we'll have to see could be days it could be weeks um uh but Eisenhot has at least 30 days left and then uh Netanyahu would probably have 28 days after that perhaps and this is something that's been talked about there could even be a third uh um uh uh person approached to try and form a government and there are whispers that

20:31 that could be a Vdor Liman that's what he's playing for to try and get the couad involved on his side to try and get members of the opposition on his side and even some breakaway elements within liquid that's what some of the whispers are um it's a long shot and it's certainly a long way off um but certainly that is what some people are describing and we'll have to see in the days and weeks ahead what exactly is going to happen with that I will go to your questions. [clears throat] Um, Barack Camar's also for Arabs will definitely be kept out of office. What is the point to let them in the elections in the first place? Does this trend make Israel more Jewish, more democratic or makes Israel kind of quasi party state? Well, first of all, every Israeli citizen has the right to vote and every Israeli citizen has a right to form a party and they've been Arab party since the beginning of the state. Let's not forget that they have and always have had members of the parliament. What we're talking about now is trying to form a government. These are two very different things. So is Arab Israelis

21:34 have significant representation. 19 seats and that certainly did not happen under any apartite state or any um you know sort of ethno state which is also some accusations against Israel because clearly Arab our vote is in fact the only Arabs um in the region that have a full open and democratic process is in Israel. So it's the furthest uh thing from what you claim. Um, but certainly there are concerns, not because they're necessarily Arabs, because there are some Jews on uh on on both of those lists and there are Arabs in uh some of the other parties that are uh being talked to in the government, etc. Uh so it's not about being an Arab or being a Jew. It's about whether they feel that uh Arab leaders uh who basically will not call Hamas a terrorist organization will not recognize the legitimacy of Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people. Um whether they are uh potential allies of a government. We've seen Ram,

22:39 the Islamist party actually being part of a coalition before uh for the current one. So Arabs have been in government. They have held uh minister ministry positions and they have been uh in the coalition. Um and as I said they're even in discussions uh at this point in time. Some agree uh some don't. That's a democracy. Well Alan Lan Lansber brings up an interesting issue with regards to Iran rather than believing PM Netanyao or not. Aren't there intelligence and IDF sources that are regarded as honest assessors of the risk uh by the party heads including Netanyahu and G Bennett and Neiman? Well, the intelligence as I said Mossad head Roman Gooffman who was appointed by Natao um does want to push for a strike does believe that there's an imminent need for a strike. Um the IDF according to all sources, Zamir is in favor of a strike. Whether he

23:43 believes it needs to be done right now, the next couple of days is certainly uh open to debate. Um, obviously he hasn't really gone on record uh about this, but um there's there's pretty much resounding and wallto-wall support that Iran should not be able to continue its return to nuclear uh capabilities. It should not be allowed to resume its ballistic missile program. uh whether that is imminent today, this week, this month, um there are differences of opinion, but all are united in the fact that Iran still has to be uh faced uh Um Devi Eden asked, "What does caretaker government mean in terms of power activities?" It's a good question and there's no specific uh rules to this. um they're not allowed to make major decision, but they certainly could make the argument that going to war is, especially if there's an imminent need,

24:47 is something that a caretaker government can do. Can Netanyahu launch an attack tomorrow? Certainly. He is the prime minister still until there is a new government and he could initiate a strike on Iran. um what that would mean. I doubt that members of the opposition would uh openly criticize when we're in the middle of a a war. Um so that could be a part of what Netanyahu is hoping for. Again, if you're a critic of Netanyao, you could say that's what he's hoping for. Uh make it also more amunable for unity talks. Um because obviously you know when when you're at war, when you're in open military uh conflict, there is that uh need for unity. There is that rallying round the flag. And um again, that is an argument the uh supporters of the opposition would say um is why Netanyahu wants uh the war the war uh immediately. Um but we'll have to wait and see. As I said,

25:50 there seems to be um a lot of uh difference of opinion. The opposition block are not convinced there's an imminent need um for such a conflict to take place uh at this moment. And they do have days, they do have even a few weeks to try and get this coalition negotiations finished to get the government sworn in um to replace the prime minister. that is what they consider the most important thing at the moment according to their statements at least and the question I I would leave um before we finish is and and this is certainly one that's open to debate are is the cor is the current opposition under Eisen is it united is it working on the strategy where each leader is looking at different coalition options perhaps to give it more leverage because obviously the more options you have the lower the price uh will be. Are they coordinated? Some would argue that Bennett met with Netao without notifying um Eisenot. I think that would be a hard

26:57 case to make. Bennett walked into Netanyao's office in in full glare of the cameras. There's no way Eisenot could have missed it and it was certainly a statement. So, I doubt he did it without the knowledge of the other members of the block. Are they trying to look disunited again? Is that part of the game plan to try and put out different messages that this one is leading this, this one is against this? So again, trying to lower the price of those who would like to join a potential coalition. These are all questions I would say that there's probably a lot more uh cooperation and coordination than some are giving them credit for.

27:34 They seem to be well coordinated. They're meeting regularly. They are given different jobs. they are given different people and different [clears throat] options to look out to to to test the water. Um but I think there's a lot more uh cooperation coordination than meets the eye. uh how far that will go and whether there are competing interests at the end of there. Of course there are. Uh but how much so we'll we'll find out. If they go straight for this emergency government, minority government, then obviously it will be extremely well uh coordinated because you couldn't do something like this without it and exactly who will support them from the outside, who will abstain will be extremely crucial uh to understand who wants to be in the government and who doesn't. And with that, I'd like to thank you very much for your questions and for your presence. And I look forward to seeing you next week.