Webinar or Talk
The Dangerous Game the U.K. Is Playing with Israel with Jake Wallis Simons
Watch on YouTube
Description
In this episode of the Middle East Forum Podcast, host Lauri Regan speaks with Jake Wallis Simons, Telegraph columnist and former editor of the Jewish Chronicle, about the dangerous game the U.K. is playing with Israel. Wallis Simons traces how relations have deteriorated since Labour came to power in 2024, from Keir Starmer's recognition of a Palestinian state while Israeli hostages were still held in Gaza to the sanctions that Andy Burnham's government and Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband imposed on Israel during the Holborn and St. Pancras by-election.
He explains what Britain stands to lose: trade worth several billion pounds, medicines made by the Israeli company Teva, Israeli defense technology, and intelligence sharing that, he says, helped foil a bombing plot against RAF Fairford. He also describes a Foreign Office culture that he says runs on virtue signaling and contrasts the government's treatment of Israel with its approach to Iran.
Regan and Wallis Simons also discuss whether Labour's hostility to Israel is ideological or electoral, why he considers talk of civil war in Britain an exaggeration, the fragmentation of the British right, and the argument of his book Never Again? How the West Betrayed the Jews and Itself.
Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:20 Welcome and introduction
1:32 Relations since Labour took power
2:23 The Greens and the Gaza Independents
3:47 Recognizing a Palestinian state
5:59 Andy Burnham and the Holborn by-election
7:07 Sanctions on Israel
8:43 Israel's response
9:40 What Britain stands to lose
10:33 Intelligence sharing and the RAF Fairford plot
12:04 The two-state solution
13:31 A foreign policy of virtue signaling
15:02 Are the sanctions just for show?
18:47 Courting Iran
19:49 Is Labour's hostility ideological?
23:20 Is Britain headed for civil war?
27:48 Can the right win power?
31:02 Never Again? The West and the Jews
33:49 The Manchester Arena bombing
35:13 Three tribes of radicals
38:12 Closing
Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for new episodes and expert analysis every week.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 17, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 And the irony of it is that meanwhile we're facing terror threats from Iran on our own shores. The whole thing is an utter catastrophe. Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast. We're living through historic and dangerous times and I want to thank you all for being engaged and for your continued support of MEF's critically important work. This afternoon, I'm very pleased to be joined by Jake Wallace Simons, a columnist, broadcaster, and foreign correspondent who writes for the Telegraph and the Jewish Chronicle, which he edited from 2021 to 2025. He also co-hosts the Brink podcast with Andrew Fox. As a reporter, Jay covered the Islamic State attacks across Europe and stories from Zimbabwe to Venezuela. And he previously worked at the Sunday Telegraph and as associate global editor at the Daily Mail. He is the author of the 1920 I'm sorry, the 2023 Israelophobia and the 2025 book Never Again: How the
1:04 West Betrayed the Jews and Itself, as well as four novels. Jake is joining us this afternoon to discuss the dangerous game the UK is playing with Israel, which on the heels of our viral podcast last month with Professor David Betts on Islamism in the UK is sure to be an important and insightful conversation as well as very timely given the relatively recent deterioration in relations between the UK and Israel. Welcome Jake and thank you so much for joining us this afternoon. I hand the floor over to Hello. Well, thank you for having me and uh what a grim topic the uh relationship former relationship perhaps between uh Britain and Israel. I mean this has really deteriorated sharply since Labour came to power in 2024. I think that's a useful starting point because although uh Sika Star's party as it was then won a landslide um 2/3 of the vote or something like that um uh it was only based on a third of the electorate sorry 2/3s of the seats and a third of the
2:06 electorate something like that. It was a very uh broad and shallow landslide, very fragile majority, a loveless landslide it was called at the time. Uh and largely it was because people were sick of the Tories, but that's another story. But the moment that throws a light on Britain's relationship with Israel during that election campaign was the challenge that the Labour Party faced from um the Rising Green Party and what has since been called the Gaza Independent. So these were Muslim um prospective MPs campaigning solely on anti-semitism on on Gaza uh and threatening Labor in some of their seats in the Midlands in the north because they perceived Labor to be too soft on Israel. Um and the Gaza independents were successful in I think was about five seats. And uh the Green Party again surging in the polls, a completely anti-semitic party that
3:08 recently confirmed at their conference the policy that Zionism is racism. So Labour faces this uh challenge from the left, from the Greens, from the Gaza independents, and that challenge challenge isn't going away. And the only thing that these people seem to care about is quote unquote Palestine. So that's the domestic picture. Now K when Kharma was was was leader of Labor and of course prime minister um his relationship with Israel was up and down. Started out being relatively supportive compared to what we have now but quite quickly went downhill. uh there was the nadier of that relationship when he joined with Emanuel Macron and some other European countries to unilaterally recognize a state of uh about a year or two ago. And that came when the Israeli hostages were still in the tunnels. They didn't have the dignity or decency to demand that they were released before they offered
4:12 that recognition. It came with a string of um requirements is too strong. It was there was a wish list. So they said to the Palestinians, please hold elections. Please get the anti-semitism out of your textbooks. Please stop paying money to uh to terrorists uh incentive money to to terrorists. Um but we'll give you the recognition anyway. And lo and behold, the elections that were promised by the Palestinians have been cancelled. Um, there's still anti-semitism throughout their textbooks. One of which I happen to have in my in my desk drawer. Genuine Palestinian textbook with genuine glorification of of terrorism inside it.
4:53 There you are. There's a picture of a terrorist on page whatever it is uh 9 or 10. Um, uh, and and still pay for slay is is continuing and so forth. So, the um have uh, as we say in Britain taken the piss out of out of the British government by taking the recognition. Thanks very much. And why the hell should they make any changes cuz they've got what they wanted to begin with. Now that was a a Nadia in my mind. It was it was characterized by the unholy spectacle of Hamas offering their official congratulations to Sakir Stalmma and his government when he recognized the Palestinian state.
5:36 About a week later was Yam Kapour when the synagogue in Manchester was attacked by a man who was named jihad literally. and Hamas uh were presumably celebrating that Hamas style attack while Akista affected to offer his condolences while receiving congratulations from Hamas almost contemporaneously. So that was a a low point. We thought that that was the low point but it turns out that Britain could go lower still. because Andy Bernham took over from um Saki Starmer who was a disastrous figure for Labour as it turned out totally um lacking in in charisma, lacking in vision and lacking in any kind of political good sense. Um so he was uh he was replaced by Andy Bernham. Now Kristama then resigned from his seat in parliament Hoben and Sankress triggering what we call a bi-election. So a competition for to win his seat. Now Hoben and St. Pancress is a London seat.
6:41 It's an urban London seat. It's quite a typical urban London seat or urban uh seat across Britain in that it is very progressive with a big Muslim vote uh and and a big left-wing uh ground swell of support. So, Labour was going to be fighting off the Greens um in that seat and was determined to win because they didn't want to encourage any further momentum leftwards. And this was the moment that Andy Burnham and Ed Miband, his new uh foreign secretary, he's only been foreign secretary for 2 months and yet he's been wreaking untold havoc in those in those eight weeks. Um this is when the the moment they chose to impose sanctions upon Israel or sensibly because of the West Bank uh settler violence. Um now that was a weird moment because it was there was electioneering on both sides in a in a way it was a response to Basal Smotrich uh in Israel pushing ahead with settling uh with with building on E1. But Smatri himself was
7:45 doing it in in during an election campaign to try to um shore up his own base, his own farright base. So the more of a row with the international community, the happier he became. Meanwhile, in Britain falling straight into that dynamic, the the more the Israelis are upset, the better for Labour campaigning in Hobon and Sankras to demonstrate their anti-Israel credentials to the anti-semitic left to try to attract their vote. And lo and behold, Labour did hold. in fact that seat in Hoben and St. Pancress. Um but those you know those sanctions against Israel were really deplorable. I mean they followed a pattern that uh has been in evidence ever since in fact Sikama's time of continually condemning Israel and very rarely if at all remembering to condemn Hamas or Iran or or any of the other jihadi forces threatening the existence of Israel and indeed ourselves elsewhere in the West. Um and it's just got worse since. So those sanctions were met with uh quite an aggressive Israeli
8:49 response banning the British contingent from Kiryatgat from the uh the command hub that oversees the development and security of Gaza, the international hub there. Uh so we no longer have any influence in that arena. Uh and originally the plan was to close the UK consulate in East Jerusalem. after some negotiation that became downgraded to a mission rather than a consulate. Uh a good number of diplomats were expelled. So it was pretty humiliating for Britain but the final blushes was spared by Israel agreeing to keep it open sort of um just in a diminished way. Ironically that consulate was playing a big role in coordinating aid to Gaza. So again Britain has um gone against its own ostensible uh foreign policy agenda in that arena as well.
9:40 Um and of course Britain has really harmed itself in taking these actions against Israel. Uh it's harmed itself economically. We have you know several billion pounds of of trade which works in our favor with with Israel. So that is hanging in the balance. One in six one in seven medications that are prescribed in Britain are produced by Teor an Israeli pharmaceutical company. uh many thousands of jobs are uh exist in Britain working for Israeli companies and so on and so forth. Israel Israel of course is a tech leader. Um and our defense relies to some extent on Israeli technology. There's a an anti-missile system called the Trophy which is going to be installed in our new tanks which was produced in Israel. Bits of our war plananes are produced in Israel. Um and of course our intelligence sharing is vital. I mean intelligence sharing I think they share with us rather more than we share with them. Let's put it that way. You know, in fact, a British security official once recently actually described uh the Israeli secret uh sort of spy services, Mossad and and the
10:42 Shabbach um as being not about national security, but about national survival, which tends to focus the mind rather, and their prowess is reflected in that. You know, we had um an attempted bombing plot on RAF Fairford, an RAF base, Royal Air Force base here in Britain that was conducted, it seems, by the Iranians, and that was foiled by a Mossad tip off just days before the sanctions were imposed by Britain on Israel. So, if Israel were to withdraw that intelligence uh help, uh our national security would be put at risk. That right now hangs in the balance. It's a lever that Israel could pull. There's no indication that it has pulled it yet, but certainly there's been some talk about it considering doing so. So, our national security has been damaged. Our economy has been damaged by this as well. Uh, in fact, just a few days ago, 13 US states, which between them have doubled the GDP of Britain uh sent a letter uh threatening Britain with with um economic warfare if these sanctions against Israel persist. that's harmed us
11:46 economically, harmed our national security, has reduced our influence in Gaza, both in terms of providing aid v via our consulate in East Jerusalem and being involved in Kerak Gat in the international effort to administer Gaza and determine its future. Um, and it has also diminished our influence in terms of any kind of drive towards a two-state solution. Now, my view is that the two states two two-state solution is dead, probably permanently, not necessarily, who knows the future, but right now in the medium-term dead. Uh and yet the two-state solution is a matter of faith. So quite a zealous faith for Ed Milliband, Andy Burnham and the British establishment. Um but they have now lost any kind of sway or influence in Jerusalem when it comes to nudging the two-state solution forwards. So it's gone against their foreign policy agendas of aid and care for the Palestinians and advancing the two-state solution. So there really isn't any kind of upside to Britain internationally um or in terms of our own interests at home uh by the damage that we've done to our
12:50 relationship with Israel. only benefit that it has offered is uh that lay managed to shore up its left wing flank and hob and sankas the bi-election there was really the litmus test of that and also allows Britain to parade its virtue on the world stage whether it's with Macron or Mertz or in the European Union or whatever with or with Mark Carney or any of the other as I call in my my book centrist fundamentalists it can pile around with those and display its virtue and that's a kind of feelood factor that money can't buy. So, this really seems to be the driving force of of of Britain's foreign policy towards Israel, but also, I should add, um its foreign policy in general. You know, you mentioned um the podcast The Brink that I present with the former parachute regiment officer, Andrew Fox, who I believe has been on this podcast before.
13:39 We recently interviewed a uh a former diplomat by the name of Air Ketcha, former foreign office diplomat who was based in Israel who was head of Palestinian affairs at that uh that embassy in in Tel Aviv. And he told us that it's not just Israel. Britain's foreign policy on the whole runs on the basis of virtue signaling. PE diplomats in the foreign office are promoted largely on the basis of whether they have uh engaged in DEI initiatives. So if you set up a, you know, a coffee group for black women or for gay people or whatever it is, then you stand a further chance of advancement than your colleagues, regardless of your ability in the actual job. Uh we spend our time trying to do things like stopping African states from imposing the death penalty on their citizens, which frankly has nothing to do with us. It's all based on trying this sort of postc colonial kind of um uh patronizing attempts to lecture the world from our position of moral uh superiority while at the same time totally neglecting our own national interests whether economical security or otherwise um I in
14:43 the process. So the whole thing is an utter catastrophe and Israel is um is a very sharp example of the way in which Britain has betrayed itself uh in betraying Israel. Thank you so much for that uh really in-depth and informative uh analysis of where things are right now. Jake, um I have a number of follow-up questions, although you you covered a lot of what I wanted you to touch on, so I thank you for that. Um you wrote an article in September just after Miban's announcement of sanctions on Israel and the very next day they were then labeled by British diplomats as being largely symbolic. Um and in your article you wrote, I'm going to quote you that tells you everything you need to know about this government. Contradictory messages to different people on the same day.
15:27 This isn't about running the country responsibly in the national interest. It is about managing optics, appeasing its own bench uh backbenchers and wavering progressive voters on the one hand and managing the demands of reality on the other. And then you added, according to a Labour MP who wrote to the Telegraph anonymously, these measures were intended to reassure muppet backbenchers who were freaked out by email campaigns from Gaza activists and the Greens threatening to steal their seats. So, you've talked about what has motivated the election, [clears throat] excuse me, but can you just elaborate on what you think will actually um be the reality with these sanctions? Will they actually be implemented? I know that there's a a period of time before the legislation is complete. And then also, you know, just the the the double speak reminds me a lot of Yaser Arafat and Makmoud Abbas, you know, telling the West one thing while they were speaking in English and then turning around to the Palestinian community and and saying something completely different in Arabic. Uh, is that what's happening in the UK?
16:28 Well, sort of. I think that Britain basically is trying to um have its cake and eat it. It it doesn't want to I mean, our economy is is [clears throat] bad. I mean, you know, there was a headline just this morning saying that we've had uh far greater than expected growth um economic growth as a result of an AI investment boom. [clears throat] And that magnificent figure was 0 0.7% growth whereas Israel is talking about growth of 5 to 6%. So our economy is is is doing badly. Our national security is bad. Our our defense investment is a joke. Our armed forces are in a steep um you know we are not in a good in a good way. So the last thing that the government needs to do or the last thing it wants is to harm its relationships overseas to the extent that it will be felt here in Britain. And yet it has this overriding desire to signal its virtue for the sake of its backbenches, muppet backbenches as that Labor MP so memorably put it, for the sake of the
17:32 Gaza independence, for the sake of the Muslim vote. I mean, that's the name of the campaigning group, the Muslim vote that thrust the Gaza independence to power into and into parliament. Um, so it's got those pressures and it just has a preoccupation with itself with its own self-image, with this sort of narcissistic self-fulfillment of, you know, self- fashioning. Um, and so I think it's trying to manage those two things, manage the demands of reality and manage the demands of politicking and its own self-expression. And all of this is totally alien to how a proper responsible government should be behaving. It should be conducting pursuing policies in our national interest that makes Britain uh richer, more prosperous, more secure and happier. It should be negotiating or engaging with the outside world on the basis of carrots and sticks, on the basis of pulling levers that it's that it's got to our own advantage and to the advantage of our allies. making allies with like-minded nations that are going to contribute towards our well-being and security and seeing uh those who oppose our way of life and who wish to kill us
18:35 as enemies. Whereas Britain currently has that totally the wrong way round while sanctioning Israel um and damaging our relationship with Israel even though it benefits us economically and in terms of national security. We're sucking up to Iran. You know the foreign minister Ed Miban famously shook the hand of the Iranian foreign minister um Arachi at the United Nations which created some constonnation amongst right-minded people in Britain and as we speak today the news has broken that Britain waved through the appointment of Iran uh at the United Nations to a body overseeing things like women's rights and counterterror whereas other nations including Australia stood against that appointment and so we have it utterly the wrong way around. And the irony of it is that meanwhile we're facing terror threats from Iran on our own shores. Um there are many many that have been foiled over the past year, scores over the past few years. Kidnap attempts, assassination attempts, bombing plots, and all the rest of it. And yet we still appease them and treat them with much
19:38 more warmth than we treat Israel, our ally, who's actually preventing us from suffering those the effects of those terrorist attacks. So the whole thing, I mean, Topppsy Turby doesn't even doesn't even really cover it. So, you know, I former Israeli ambassador to the UK, Mark Reg, observed that the UK Israel relations have never been as bad as they are now. And I'm just wondering, is the Labor Party, you know, the party that was home to anti-semite Jeremy Corbin until last year? Is it so entrenched with with Islamist ideology and Jew haters that as long as it remains in power, things will continue to deteriorate? And um you know I I I note that while Miban's rhetoric may not sound as extreme as Corbin's, he certainly has a similar warp sense of morality implementing policies that would make Corbin very happy. Um so are these true ideological convictions I I mean the you you brought up the green threat and and the whole seat, but but Labour won that seat and the rhetoric hasn't changed. So, I'm just wondering how deep this this conviction goes or whether it it really is just motivated
20:40 by um by electoral uh panic and and uh you know, focused on the six to 6.5% of the population that's that's Muslim in the UK. Yeah. I mean, I I think that it is an entrenched culture in the Labor Party of hostility to Israel. Uh and there's obviously a range within that. I mean right now I think we are seeing Labour taking positions that Jeremy Corbyn would have embraced had he become prime minister um god forbid back in 2019 when he was beaten by Boris Johnson. Um and Jeremy Corbyn in turn has moved further to the left. So he is demanding uh arms embargos and and all manner of investigations and so forth from Britain. Um of course although we we we do sell some arms to Israel, we buy a whole lot more. So actually the net result is that we b we're a purchaser of Israeli arms rather than a contributor but that doesn't seem to make really any difference um to these people. Uh but yes you're you're right. I mean Hobenas
21:43 was one but we didn't see a change in policy. Were Gaddy Eisenot to take over from Netanyahu in the coming weeks I don't think we would see a significant change in policy from Downing Street um or from the foreign office. Um this is on the left since October the 7th in particular um hostility to Israel has become the norm. Uh it's just a question of degree. The baseline is of hostility. Uh but then it spans all the way to basically jihadism when you get to the further reaches of the of the Gaza movement whether they're Muslim or or pro progressive radicals. I mean, at the Labor Party conference a few weeks ago in Ed Miban's keynote speech, he mentioned Israel, Gaza, Palestine, I think it was 18 times in the speech. Um, and he mentioned Sudan on one occasion and the interesting thing was that when he mentioned Sudan, the phrase was the
22:46 world's worst humanitarian crisis in Sudan. Now, it rather begged the question, if that's the world's worst humanitarian crisis, why was it only mentioned once when Israel, Palestine, and Gaza were mentioned 18 times? So, this is the world that these people occupy. It's not sensible. It's not logical. It's not rational. It's not proportionate, and it isn't really motivated by any concern for alleviating suffering overseas. Um, it's motivated by two things. overall ideology and appeasing the far-left.
23:20 It's it sounds Labor is very similar to the Democrat party here or vice versa. The Democrat party here is very similar to what's happening with with Labor. Um and uh you know I'm wondering, as I mentioned in my introduction, we had um David Betts on about a month ago talking about possible civil war in the UK and it turned out that was just prior to the streets of of France blowing up. And then of course we've seen protests that that are ongoing in in France and across other countries in Europe, Belgium, Italy for instance. What do you see happening in the UK and and in in the context of responding to this question, I'm curious to know what the views of the general population of the UK is and whether they support Miliban's comments and policies that are coming out of the Burnham government. um and whether there's a chance that a conservative or reform government could be elected uh you know in a as a backlash to this or or you know the civil war concept where is the population of the UK okay lots of lots of questions rolled
24:22 into that one um um so civil war I mean Britain is it's strange we're much less violent than the French you know they they take to the streets at the drop of a hat and set fire to things and and get tear gas and have running battles with the cops. And we're seeing that of course stretching all across Europe now. Um we don't you don't see that as much in Britain. We're far more moderate uh far more respectful respectful far less revolutionary in our in our national sentiment. Um and yet of course we've been affected by mass immigration um to a similar in a similar way as the continent has although of course they've had it worse because there isn't a channel in between their country and the Middle East or Africa. Um so you know our Muslim population is smaller proportionately than that of France.
25:09 France is about 10% I think. Here it's about 6 or 7%. Um it's a bit smaller. Uh we suffer the same kind of progressive incursion. In fact even more I think. I think the angophone countries taking our lead from you guys in America um suffer from the progressive ideology creep through the institutions worse than franophile countries or countries that speak other languages. Um so there's that but I think that it really depends on where you go. I mean if you go to um you know areas of London, Stratford, Tower Hamlets, if you go up to B areas of Birmingham where the um Israeli fans for Makabi Tel Aviv were recently banned from a game on behalf of Muslim anger if you go up to to Yorkshire leads other places you will feel at times like you are in downtown Karach you know you won't see very many white faces you won't see any British people you will just see foreigners um some of whom may have British passports, but that's about the only thing that's British about them. Um many
26:12 of whom live on benefits, many of whom don't speak English, um you will see those whole communities, often dirty, um culturally alien to the to the majority. So you will see that. But if you come out a little bit into other areas, more affluent areas of the cities, into the suburbs, certainly into the countryside where I live, um you will progressively feel like you're going back in time to how Britain used to be, if you like. I mean, where I live, um you know, I went to the um we had on on Sunday Remembrance Sunday with our two-minut silence for the for the dead of both world wars. Um I went to a service in the local uh abbey afterwards attended the senate half. [snorts] It was packed. Um very few uh immigrants.
27:02 There was a sense of cultural coher coherence and cohesion uh respect for our history uh and for our fallen and a sense of cultural memory there. So I think to generalize about Britain I think is difficult and to say that this will become a civil war I think is quite absurd. I I I don't think we are looking at any I mean our cops don't even carry guns. I mean how are we going to have a civil war? You know this is not this is not we're not generally a violent country uh to each other. Um so that's not to say that we don't sometimes have violence. We've had you know in 2012 I think it was we had riots similar to those in France. Uh we've had unrest here and there before. We're not immune to violence, don't get me wrong, but I I think that civil war is is a is an exaggeration. So there's so so that's that. Um but remind me of the other elements of your of your question. Oh, I just was trying to get a sense of the UK of the of the British population and um and their views on what's happening and whether there would be a backlash, whether whether there's a backlash against Labor eventually and whether a conservative or reformed government could be elected that would reverse uh
28:06 much of what's been emanating out of the Burnham government. Um and Stormer before that, as you pointed out, with the recognition of a Palestinian state, which seems a bit uh insane to me. Yeah, certainly. [clears throat] Yeah, I mean I think I mean that the hope obviously is that uh this government will be sent packing and replaced by a right-wing government. That's the hope. Uh right now it's far from certain that that will happen because of um political fracturing. You know, Britain has for many generations been really a twoparty system, a little bit like you have there in America, uh, with Labor and the Conservatives being the two main parties. You've had the Liberal Democrats, which are like a third party on the side, but they've never really been in much hope of winning an election. They did a had a coalition in 2010, but that's quite was quite unusual. Basically, it's been alternating between the Tories and Labor. Uh whereas now uh we're finding that for the first time that political stability is beginning to fragment.
29:10 You've got um on the left the challenge from the Greens. Um you've got the Gaza independents, as I've said, who are going to almost certainly um have a better showing in the next election. You've got the Liberal Democrats, of course. Um and then on the right, even more significantly, you've got this the rise of reform, Reform UK, the Reform Party. uh and that has basically hived off the right-wing rump from the Tory party and given it its own identity um out of anger for the way in which the Tories slid into liberalism um over the past 14 years. You know, Kami Baden made a very good point in her um in a man a sort of um statement of ideals or principles that she produced during the Tory conference uh recently which was that um Labor fails when they adhere to their principles whereas we fail when we depart from ours. Something to that effect and the Tories certainly departed from theirs with mass immigration and all the woke stuff that was all under a Tory government over the last 14 years.
30:12 And so that's what fueled the rise of reform and that resentment, that hatred really from reform for the Tories, saying, "Look, you're supposed to be right-wing, you're supposed to be conservative, and you've actually been progressive, [snorts] you've ruined our country. Um, we hate you and we're going to now fight the fight." Um so with with those two parties dividing the right and a further even further right party called the restore party with Rert Low who Elon Musk and Donald Trump are quite partial to you've got a fragmented right and so you may have a situation where the majority of the country votes for parties of the right and yet parties of the left get in because the right vote right vote is is is spread over various parties and that's a real danger and we're far enough out now from the next election to not have any clarity about which way it's going to fall.
31:02 Okay. Thank you for that, Jake. Um, so I want to end by sort of expanding the conversation um to the West more generally and I I'm going to ask you about your book and you I I mentioned it in my intro. It's called Never Again: How the West Betrayed the Jews and itself, but there's a question mark after never again. And we haven't really focused on anti-semitism as much as anti-Israel animist from the government, but there is anti-semitism that's very pervasive across the West, not just in in Britain. Um, so I'd like to end uh by asking you if you can share what you see playing out across the West more broadly, because to me it's frightening frighteningly similar to Germany's circa the 1930s. I mean there were brown shirts on campuses and boycotts of Jewish businesses and um the the boycotts now are emanating from the UK government. So um do you do you think that there's a will in Western governments and um to to prevent a repeat of history?
32:06 It's a good question. Um I mean one of the reasons why I started with the idea [snorts] of never again with a question mark is that the uh state of affairs that we see today um with progressive dominance with uh with kind of thought policing um and with open b or you know poorest borders with with you know cultural uh degeneration lack of coherence and all those things um complacency, luxury, narcissism. I mean all those things are downstream from an original attempt to stop the second world war from occurring again. The idea right, you know, after the Second World War, certainly after the Cold War, was that um if you want to prevent totalitarianism of the 17 20th century from arising again, you got to stop the seeds of fascism. And the seeds of fascism lie in um pride for our history and patriotism, in respect for the flag,
33:08 in respect for our borders, uh in the idea of of an outroup and an ingroup. you know, foreign people being outside, therefore uh shouldn't be cared for as much as as the inroup as people who live here, citizens. Um, and so [clears throat] it was those ideas that developed into this kind of culture of nicely call nic uh sort of vacated the the the space where our patriotism and self-respect used to be. um you know nism I mean it was is sort of enforced by the elites um sometimes with very serious consequences. I mean I in my book I talk about how the Manchester Arena bombing of 2017 which I I happened to be there actually strangely enough I was just down the road covering a different story and um heard the bomb or heard the bomb reported didn't hear it go off but I was close enough to dash down there and was there in the aftermath and stayed there for some time reporting on it. Um there was uh in the inquest they uh
34:13 interviewed a young security guard called Kyle Lawler who was on duty at the Manchester Arena and saw the bomber Salman Abdi uh walking into the arena struggling under the weight of a heavy rucks sack and looking suspicious and he said that he didn't stop him because he thought to himself that his own suspicion was an example of his own um inherent Islamophobia and so therefore he was being a bigot and stopping this suspicion took man with a heavy backpack would have been an example of bigotry and islamophobia. And so we've been taught to suspect ourselves, to suspect our own instincts, to tamp down our own common sense, whether it's our own pride or respect for our history or ourselves or our own sense that someone is dodgy just and and be able to say it. Um and so I think that that sort of cowardice and appeasement and um sort of flaccid flaccidity and and kind of um complacency has led to a great many things. And in my book I I talk about how that space that it left was seized
35:19 upon by the new radicalism by these three tribes of radicals progressive radicals um Islamist radicals and the ethnationalist not traditionally a big problem in Britain but recently a little bit more so much more of a problem for you guys. Um and so I think that and that radicalism has really gripped um a lot of our public debate a lot of our institutions certainly the progressive radicals and their ismist colleagues. Um, and I think that we're seeing across the West the rise of this kind of anti-establishment radicalism. Um, whether it's progressive or isamist or or or ethnationalist.
35:56 Um, all of which share a disdain for the old guard, a disdain for the old nicism, a disdain for what I call the centrist fundamentalists who tried to persuade us all that isophobia was a thing and that any kind of instinct um of suspicion towards Muslim was should be taboo and so on and so forth. And this anti-agement further is really unhinged because it's flowing through channels that are not um well established that are not responsible that are not stable but are reactionary. You see that whether with with Trump or and his allies in Marine Le Pen in France or Alice Videl the leader of alternative for Deutsland in Germany or even reform here in Britain or restore these populist aggressive reactionary parties or you see it in the the progressive um maniacs whether it's Jeremy Corbyn whether it's any of the other progressives that you see across the West and so I think that really the condition of the West now is that we're in the grip of these different types of radicalism all competing with each other to gain the leaves of power and the old
36:59 guard has lost its confidence, has lost its sense of self and has lost the ability to return and and restore any kind of order. There are very few people that you see who have that kind of common sense politics. Uh not with the nicism and not with the radicalism, but actually just with sensible politics. You see very few of those today. And I think that meanwhile there's a sense of a silent majority. Now whether it's still a majority or not, I don't know, but certainly a silent sizable silent constituency in Britain and across the West who just want things to be sensible um but remain silent. So whether we're going to see those silent people finding their voice, whether the midterms will be a tipping point for something more sensible or it will just veer towards the other end of the radical spectrum, that's all the biggest question of our times. But certainly my argument is that we have to get back to remembering how we used to be to reinstate what Edund Burke called the the the pact between the dead, the living, and the yet to be
38:01 born. That sense of cultural coherence to return our our values to ourselves and to remember what what a sane society will look like before it's too late. Thank you so much, Jake. I'd love to continue the conversation, but we've run out of time and I appreciate you you joining us this afternoon. It was really uh compelling, important, and I urge all of our audience members to follow your work. You're you post on X and you've got the Brink podcast and uh you you publish articles in both the Spectator and Jewish Current. So, please to the audience follow Jake's important work and again, thank you so much for joining us. I wish you a wonderful afternoon.
38:38 Thank you. You too. [music]