MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

In this episode of Israel Insider, host Ashley Perry, advisor to the Middle East Forum Israel office, looks at where Israel stands one week after its election. The official results have been ratified and handed to President Herzog, but neither bloc is close to a majority: the opposition stands at 48 seats without the two Arab parties, and the current coalition at 53.

Perry explains what the swearing-in of the new Knesset means, including the opposition's plans to replace Speaker Amir Ohana and overturn laws from the judicial reform; President Herzog's consultations, where Ra'am recommended Gadi Eisenkot and United Torah Judaism declined to nominate anyone; and Eisenkot's options for a coalition: the Arab parties, the ultra-Orthodox, or a unity government with Netanyahu. He also discusses the investigations into alleged fraud in the Arab sector, the expectation of another round with Iran, and Israel's shock at President Trump's announcement, on the morning of the U.S. midterms, that military aid would end by the end of the year.

In the Q&A, he takes audience questions on whether the U.S. elections and Trump's comments will affect coalition talks, the oath Knesset members swear, Itamar Ben-Gvir and the defense ministry, Netanyahu's future if he fails to form a government, why Ra'am's support from outside the coalition may not work again, and whether the results will change Israel's alliances.

Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:20 One week on, still no clarity
3:37 The new Knesset and the speaker
6:33 Herzog's consultations
9:54 Eisenkot's options
16:01 The fraud investigations
18:00 Iran, Trump and U.S. aid
21:08 Audience questions
29:27 Closing

Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for new episodes and expert analysis every week.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 5, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 What they are shocked by is the fact that um on the morning of the midterms, President Trump no less came out and basically said we are ending military aid by the end of the year. That caught everybody in Israel um by surprise. Hello and good evening from Israel for another Israel Insider with me, Ashley Perry, advisor to the Middle East forum Israel office. Um I know Alex was here last week immediately after the election. Um it was a day after as we know there was uh quite a few surprises.

0:41 Uh surprise first number one was the Arab vote that uh increased substantially. Surprise number two was that the current government received more than the current opposition which wasn't true of pretty much most polls in the leadup. Um but we are now one week later and there's still really no clarity um as to what's going to come next. sort of a little bit jealous of the fact that the Americans had elections yesterday and you know immediately what's going to happen. Um which we'll talk about in in a little while. Uh but in Israel this could go on for weeks if not months without knowing is there going to be a coalition? Is there going to be a government? Who's going to be the next prime minister? Is there going to be a new prime minister or just uh the same prime minister um uh that we currently have? Well, today the official results were ratified uh and handed in a ceremony uh by the

1:44 head of the central elections committee, Justice Soulberg, uh to President Herzog uh officially uh giving the results. The opposition uh members of the committee agreed to endorse it. Uh interestingly we heard and and again we'll speak about it a little bit later the current coalition uh led by Prime Minister Netanyahu and his liquid party have um tried to contest the election results. They um they claimed that there were enough irregularities um that uh to delegitimize to say that the results should not stand. Um I'll talk about that in a little bit but interestingly enough they didn't vote against they just abstained. Either way, it's a pretty much foregone conclusion.

2:32 The results were handed in, so they are approved and they are official as uh we know them. What that meant is, and there's a number of things that that means. Uh one of them is that the process is President Herzog uh invited all the leaders of the party starting uh from the smallest to the biggest to basically consult with them in a normal uh uh after election uh process. It's pretty clear what the government will be. One side will have over 61 uh seats and so you know the consultations are more a formality than anything else in these elections. Obviously they're going to be a lot more complicated because neither block has uh a majority or even close to a majority. Um again I am leaving the Arab parties to the side for one moment because they are not really seen as part of either block for the moment. That could change. We'll have to wait and see. But when we're talking about blocks, we're usually talking about the opposition without the Arab

3:35 two Arab parties and the coalition. Um what also it means the official uh approval of the results of the election is that we will have a swearing in ceremony in the Knesset on Tuesday where all new I say new at least 80 of them are returning uh members of Knesset to the Knesset. I think there's around 40 new members of Knesset. Um but basically that mean the Knesset can work. The Knesset can even legislate. Uh we are in unprecedented uh territory and uncharted territory in many different ways. One of them is the fact that um there is major talk and probably will happen that there could be some legislation passed before we even know if there's going to be a government and who's running it. That's pretty unprecedented. Usually um while the Knesset members are sworn in um speaker may be elected or you know dislodged for someone else um and some

4:38 committees are starting to be populated that need to be uh moving as soon as possible. Um but on the whole it's sort of a wait and see until the government is formed. Um, according to uh lots of sources, including uh some uh of the members of the opposition themselves, they are actually intent on going beyond just replacing the speaker and actually trying to legislate or at least overturn some of the laws, especially on the judicial reform issue uh that were enacted during uh the last government.

5:11 So, we'll have to see what that looks like. Obviously to pass anything you will need um at least some of the Arab votes because as I said the opposition without the Arab uh parties are at 48. The current coalition is at 53. So they need at least uh what is it six uh votes in favor of laws in favor of a speaker of Knesset uh to uh to overcome uh the objections of the current coalition. You do not need a supermajority. You just need an a or an absolute majority. You don't need 61 uh votes for this. You just need um more votes in the other side. Um so we'll have to see exactly what happens. There are threats from the coalition that if if the opposition current opposition does get in and starts changing the Knesset speaker away from Amana names have been touted like Y laid OD for who's um from Yeshua Betenu party or

6:18 um Gadi Eisenot himself which will be quite interesting because again usually the the leader of the largest party doesn't become the speaker of the Knesset but they're looking for someone that they can all trust and is palatable to the Arab parties. What also now as a result of today's uh consultations with the president, as I said, the first parties started to meet with the president and beyond just asking who they would like to see have first chance at forming a coalition. He's also trying to ask more questions, you know, who would you sit with, who do you rule out, what are the issues of importance to you, etc., etc. But and and and the only surprises so far which are significant um are that Ram has uh designated uh Gaddy Eisenhot. It's not the biggest surprise but they could have abstained and that would have given uh the two if the two Arab parties would have abstained that would have pretty much given Netanyahu the first shot. Uh but the fact that Ram uh did actually asked

7:24 for Eisenot that now gives if every if every all the other members of the block are true to their word which I'm sure they will be um that now is almost certainly going to give Gaddy Eisenkot the first chance of trying to form a coalition. But even more so today, which is a major shock, is that the United Torah Judaism, the Ashkanazi Karedi party, I think six seats or seven seats, they actually have um decided not to nominate either side um in the leadup to that decision. Netanyo and his adviserss were furiously trying to get in touch with anyone they could in the party, close to the party, some of their rabbis who are the spiritual advisers of the party in a desperate attempt to get them to um to nominate Netanyahu. But the fact that they are not going to nominate Netanyao is a major blow because what they've decided is that after they saw that Ram will decide to have decided to give their support to Gaddy Eisenot,

8:30 it's a foregone conclusion. So they don't want to come against Eisenot and rule out the possibility of them joining an Eisenot le uh coalition which is very interesting and it speaks to perhaps one at least one of the options that Eisenot has in the there's 28 days and he can ask for an extension of another 14 which they always do. So basically it's 42 days uh from when the designation is officially handed to Eisenhot in in another ceremony with President Herzog probably will happen usually will happen you know pretty quickly after the consultations but today we heard President Herzog say this is a unique period and I will not just be asking the delegations that are coming but I may invite other people from within the different parties for different views to confirm some of the views that I'm hearing. ing to consult to ask them difficult questions. So again, it's very interesting. The president usually it's a formality. His

9:34 position is rather usually symbolic at this point. But now all eyes are on President Herzel because he's going to um as he says in in in his own words do everything possible to avoid uh another round of elections which is still very much uh one of the options at this point. So what are the options if Daddy Eisenancot gets the mandate? Well, there's pretty much three options for him to approach. The first two um let's say is to bring in either the Arabs or the ultra orthodox. Bringing in the Arabs uh is going to be very problematic. Um, you know, it it's not because they're Arabs. It's because a lot of uh the members of the uh the Arab parties have taken extremely problematic views. Not one of them, to the best of my knowledge, has actually come out and condemned Hamas and called it a terrorist organization. Some even called it a charitable organization. I've fallen very short in condemning October

10:37 7th massacre. um you know uh it's played very either non-zionist or even anti-ionist positions etc etc. So it's it's it's problematic um for quote unquote Zionist parties um to partner with the Arabs. Yay Golan as it seems is the only one of that block who is openly welcoming and calling for uh an alliance with uh the Arab parties and certainly if the Arab parties join with the current block they would have uh enough well over 61 I can't remember the exact numbers probably 66 something like that so a very comfortable majority but it's I would say it's it's pretty unlikely um first of all because we've heard at least ADM and Napali Bennett two significant players in the block say that they will not sit uh in a coalition with the Arabs or even um allow uh the ABS to Arab parties to support them from the outside. The other option at this point is the ultra orthodox which are

11:41 certainly in play. um together I think that would give them 61 which is again a razor thin uh majority but that would also mean that at least one of the players uh in the um in the so-called change uh you know uh block uh the the current opposition would have to break its promise and Victor Leman Nafali Bennett uh at least again said that they will not sit uh with the ultra Orthodox though we haven't heard as much vehements against sitting with the ultraorththodox as we had with the parties which is interesting because the parties of the the change block very much the the issue apart from replacing the tiny which appeared to unite them in the campaign was u on the ultraorththodox enlistment issue uh and involvement and participation uh in in in the army and uh the workforce etc etc. The other option which will not be

12:47 looked at certainly first is a unity government with Netanyao. Um at the moment that probably won't be debated until they look into whether the one of the other two options is available possible and only then they will maybe turn to Netanyao. Netanya will have very little interest um to negotiate that because he knows that if they turn to him that means they don't have any other options and he can just wait it out [clears throat] then he will take um the uh designated person to form a government because if if the first person can't do it after 42 days uh another member of Knesset could be any member of Kesset but it would be usually the second uh the person who receives the second most designations then has 28 days to form a uh a coalition and if they're unable to do so then we go immediately to an election. So there will be very little interest in Netanyao giving Eisenot uh the power when he

13:51 knows he can then switch it up days later. So Eisenot is in a bit of a problem. It'll be interested to see if there's any uh any any sort of developments there. I would be very surprised if he's able to form uh a 61 uh government in these 42 days. One never knows, but I just don't see where it will come from because all of these options are very problematic. Um and what we've got to understand even when there seems to be some movement like there is at the moment towards the ultraorththodox, a lot of what's going on is about leverage and framing.

14:29 [clears throat] What do I mean by that? First of all, leverage. You know, the ultraorththodox parties could sit. They've sat in leftwing governments. They sat in centrist governments. They've sat in right-wing governments. It doesn't really bother them so much. So, they have leverage that they can sit with either side. They are certainly more comfortable in a right-wing religious block certainly the current coalition but they are very angry with Netanyao that he was not able to um legislate [clears throat] a law which they found satisfactory uh to ensure that the majority of the ultraorththodox community uh did not serve uh in the army. So they basically say whoever gives us a better deal we'll sit with them. Now, Eisenhot could give them a very good deal, but Lieberman and Bennett will be far more problematic to persuade, but again, it could be that they just decided that okay, they have to pull back on one promise um to basically fulfill the main promise, which is to replace this government. Um but again the ultraorththodox might just be playing uh Gaddy Eisenot and behind the scenes trying to strike a higher

15:34 price from Netanyo. The other issue which we'll see a lot of is framing is no one will want to be seen as the person who prevented a government and led us to another round of elections which to my mind is still a very strong likelihood um very possible likelihood. So no one will want to be seen as that person. So a lot of what we'll be hearing in the days and weeks ahead will be to do with leverage uh and framing. Uh another point is the legitimacy of the elections. Um there has there are ongoing investigations um into some of the votes in the Arab sector. Uh some of the Arab parties have been accused uh even foreign funding either from the Palestinian Authority, from PATA, from other sources. We don't really know what's going on. What we do know is there is some sort of The uh Shinbet um the domestic intelligence uh agency in Israel is basically investigating how wide the uh the corruption, the

16:38 fraud uh goes. Um, according to the head of the central elections committee, he's called for the investigation, but he said he hasn't seen any evidence that it is uh considerable and enough to change uh the results. That's certainly not the position of liquid and its allies. They say it is considerable and the attorney general who is you know the the the the seen as the to a certain extent the leader of the opposition to the nikud has basically asked for evidence from the shimet um before she gives the okay to investigate to interrogate to question um members of Knesset and even their allies there seems to be a big you know question mark. What exactly is going on? The attorney general said that she hasn't received any evidence to be able to uh allow such investigations and she's been asking for the evidence. Uh the the head of the Shimbet as we know who's recently appointed by Netanyahu on

17:42 the one hand said the results were absolutely fine and then the next day he said actually there was widespread corruption and then goes back again. There seems to be a bit of a zigzag there depending on which side you are. uh really uh leads to where you're sitting on this uh issue is issue. Um all of these considerations could change obviously with what is still very much expected in Israel, some sort of um another round with Iran. Uh as we know the US is moving many of its um military assets back to the region. Um many Israelis feel it's just a matter of uh when not if and obviously that could change calculations that could lead uh to a national unity government people could make the argument you know what we are in the middle of war and we have to do what's necessary finally uh in Israel certainly in Jerusalem I don't want to talk too much about the US midterms because I'm not an expert on American politics but certainly um Israel's been shocked um by some of the events of the

18:46 US midterms, not necessarily in who got elected and who didn't because um you know they they they've seen this before with Mandani with with Ilan Omar and some of the others. So a few more you know is is not unexpected but what they are shocked by is the fact that um on the morning of the midterms President Trump no less came out and basically said we are ending military aid by the end of the year and that's something agreed to with Prime Minister Netanyo that caught everybody in Israel um by surprise. The finance ministry said that they didn't know anything about this.

19:20 Certainly the IDF didn't know anything about this. It is supposed to be phased out in the next two years, but if those amounts are not given, that's going to be a major shortfall in Israel's uh defense budget. Um but more than that, it's very symbolic that a very pro-Israel president feels the need on the morning of elections um to talk about ending Israel military aid um demonstrating that they believe that Israel uh the aid to Israel um is a problem for him. Um and then we heard even more from Vice President JD Vance when he gave four reasons for um the failure of the Republicans in the midterms. And the last one is the US relationship with Israel. So it's certainly shaken things up here uh at this and not necessarily the results. Uh the results are not as bad as people like to imagine. And also the fact that the Democrats uh got such uh a majority means that they are not going to be held

20:24 ransom by a few individuals um extreme individuals uh in in the Senate or certainly uh in Congress um in the House. Um, so the results are not terrible. That is for every anti-Israel headline uh grabber result that we've heard we've seen, there are many other pro-Israel or at least, you know, sort of more quiet on Israel, but quietly supportive of Israel who who who did either return or get in. So, Israel is not overly worried about the results, but certainly the tone and the fact that the Republican party leadership, the administration feels a need to distance itself uh from Israel at this point, that's certainly of great concern. And with that, I'm going to go to questions.

21:12 Um Eric Sulkov uh asked, "Do you think the US elections and Trump's comments about NDA will affect the formation of the new Israeli government?" Well, the first person to actually react on that was Gaddy Eisenot and basically laid the blame for Netanyahu uh saying that this was a failure of diplomacy. It's another failure of the government. Interestingly, Vdor Leeman, another uh leader of a party in the opposition block, uh went further and said, well, this is the quidd proquo for President Trump's um support, very viciferous support uh of NetA um before the elections. Um, it probably won't affect uh the negotiations very much. We'll have to see if President Trump inserts himself into the coalition negotiations.

22:00 There are some suggestions he might he might try and push together some sort of unity government, but again, that's speculation. Uh, at this point, um, Larry Greenos, what oath do MKs have to swear? Um, I think it's a pretty standard. I mean, I've seen it many times. Um I you'll have to Google that. I don't think it's anything out the ordinary. Um Barbie Rambo asked today headline read, "Will Eisen cop be chosen at Bing V's expense? Did Liquid promise the US that Beng wouldn't become Minister of I mean if Netanyahu's block would have received 61 that would have been uh the government that would have been an easy to formulate government. It would have been basically a continuation and that would have meant uh Beng would have continued. There's certainly no love loss between Netino and Beng also understands Ben how he looks to the

23:04 outside world. I don't think there was any promise given because I think if Natino would have needed Beng he would be uh in uh the government and he would have been able to uh demand min defense. Obviously that would have been Natino's nightmare. He wouldn't have wanted to do that but again coalition negotiations about leverage. He's appointed many ministers of defense that he didn't necessarily want. Um and certainly Beng would be less controllable than many of the others.

23:38 Um, Hari Isma asks, "What will be the fate and the political future of Netanyahu if he fails to form a government?" First of all, he might not even get the chance. Again, [clears throat] he may well get the chance. Um, but if we go to uh a second round, he would be confident of actually expanding his support. And I'll explain why. First of all, the apparatus that the opposition used uh bringing in 70 80 90,000 Israelis from abroad really they were motivated after years of demonstrations dissatisfaction October 7th if all they could get after all the end of it is 48 the like and and and Netino got 53 the likelihood is uh that the uh trend would only be uh towards Netino NetO probably or Netino's block would improve on the current uh election and I my assessment would be that the the opposition block would actually probably lose a couple of

24:42 mandates. So Netino, it wouldn't be the worst thing in the world for him to get uh another election and I'm sure he would uh you know be the leader of the liquor party in theory according to the liquid constitution they have to hold another election for party chairman before each election but as we saw last time if no one stands against Netino there's pretty much uh no election. So, I think he would uh lead the liquid into the next elections and probably uh do a little bit better. Would he be able to get from 53 to 61?

25:18 Unlikely, but you never know. If there's not as many Arabs who come out and vote as they did in an unprecedented number. Um then that could change the numbers because obviously if you know it's all about how many uh people come out to vote. This was a record number of people came out to vote and that means each seat was worth more. If less people come uh out then each seat is worth less. So you need uh less uh votes to get more seats. Uh I hope I've explained that well. But basically the bottom line is I think Neta will be fairly confident about the repeat elections.

26:06 Eric Savvas since Abbas, you're talking about Mans Abbas leader Ram used his delegates uh to one Israeli government in the past even though he wasn't part of the government. Why wouldn't that model work again? Potentially that could work again. But the problem is uh he would need more than just the I think it's six seats of Ram cuz six seats of Ram let's say even seven would still be well short of uh a majority would or of a of a workable coalition. So he would so Eisenh would actually need uh both parties uh to support him or he just simply wouldn't have uh that majority necessary for a stable government. Um so it's not the same situation as it was in 2021 or was it 2022 with the Benet Lid government where the Ram party supported the government from the outside. It's part of the coalition but not part of the government. Um that model can't work because it simply doesn't have uh the um Georges Pelios asked, "Do you believe

27:13 that the results of the elections in Israel have any effect on current alliances?" Um it's a good question. I think uh geopolitically, no. What I think many may not understand around the world is the differences between Netanyahu and perhaps Gaddy Eisenot on geopolitical issues on defense issues are very minimal. Um there's certainly a great chasm between them in whom uh how they believe that the government should be run but how they feel about um uh you know Hamasbah Iran is is not as great as perhaps others would believe around the world and certainly the alliances um that they have whether it's in the eastern Mediterranean whether it's in Asia uh Europe obviously uh the US etc.

28:09 I think that uh Gaddy Eisen would probably get a uh more of an ear internationally especially in the west because he's not Netanyahu and Netanyo has uh whether rightly or wrongly uh not the greatest reputation and also let's not forget there is a warrant for his arrest with the ICC and again we can debate the merits of that but the fact is it's there and and some countries have said that Netanyao would be arrested if he was in our territory. So Gaddy Eisenot certainly would be a reset for the international community. He would be something different for the international community who have pretty much apart from one year only know Netanyahu for the last what is it 18 years. Um so I think there'd be a general reset to a certain extent not as much as people might think um but certainly there would be a breathing uh space for Gaddyot that Netanyahu would not get if he continued to be uh prime minister. But as far as uh geopolitics, um its uh uh defensive posture, its

29:13 posture towards Hamas uh uh Iran and many of its opponents and enemies in the region of Balon, I don't think much of that would change even with an Eisenkot uh le uh government. And with that, I'd like to thank you for your questions and thank you uh for your participation. Um, have a good evening from Israel, good day wherever you are and look forward to seeing you next week. [music]