Webinar or Talk
David Betz: Four ways Britain's conflict could end
Watch on YouTube
Description
How could it end? Prof. David Betz of King's College London sets out four possible outcomes for Britain, and says the most likely is a long period of balkanization. From The MEF Podcast.
Watch the full episode, "Islamism in the U.K.: A Looming Civil War? with David Betz," hosted by Lauri Regan: https://youtu.be/YGIlbvHsnYY
David Betz is Professor of War in the Modern World at King's College London.
Views expressed are the guest's own.
Middle East Forum: https://www.meforum.org
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 18, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 The most likely though is the fourth. The fourth is a long period of Sam also has asked what sort of system might ultimately follow such violence and breakdown. Someone also asked whether the woke left and the non- assimilated immigrants remain on the same side throughout this process for lack of a better word. Let me take the last half of that question first. I think that there's an obvious looming breakup of the woke left and the Muslim largely it's the Muslim population. I think that's that's almost inevitable. I don't see how that alliance holds together. And one can also already see how that is fracturing.
0:37 And you know, I think the best example of this for people who are interested in understanding that dynamic might be to look at the fate of the UK Green Party which started out as an environmentalist movement and essentially has transformed itself into a Gaza party and I don't exaggerate. So that's so I think that is going there is going to be a breakup on that front. What will the post conflict settlement look like? I mean, that's extremely difficult to predict. There's a long way to go before we get to a settlement and many things could happen and academics make bad predictions all the time. I freely acknowledge. But I think logically speaking, I see sort of three possible or three quite plausible outcomes in not quite equally plausible.
1:20 The one outcome is essentially what JD Vance outlined when he said what was it a year ago or maybe even longer that the UK may be the first Islamist country with with a nuclear weapon. I think he was trying to throw a hand grenade rhetorically, but his reasoning was not completely exotic and essentially what he was painting was a picture of the trajectory of the country in which the demographic projections hold true or accelerate and that that's very plausible if you just look at the current trajectory and then you think about things like chain migration.
1:54 Anyway, it's not completely implausible. I think it's not the most likely occurrence. However, another possibility though is but the elites win out, right? But basically, but they but I think that form of winning out essentially means the termination of democracy as we know it. We'll have something possibly performative or maybe they won't bother with that. But you can see the emerging signs of that in the increasing kind of algorithmization of security of domestic security particularly the policing of speech the which is very acute here in the UK as I think everybody now understands. And so the result there is something like, you know, maybe a version of 1984 but less gray perhaps with, you know, some combination.
2:38 Anyway, a kind of reassertion of an authoritarian pattern on some line in which we basically give up on this democracy thing and possibly give up on a lot of security as well, though maybe they would be able to deliver on that, but it wouldn't be with much liberty left over. The third possibility is that basically the native mass successfully punishes its own elite enough that it is scared and compelled into governing again as a national elite and you have essentially again for the second time in 100 years in Europe mass movement of population. There is a fourth possibility and I I actually think that the third is the most likely or more likely than the previous two. The most likely though is the fourth. The fourth is a long period of bulcanization. I think rather than me describe, I encourage people to pick up a relatively famous book by an American author, Jack Wulmarmac, kind of random acts of senseless violence, which is a a novel written in the early 1990s. It's presented about the United States, set
3:42 in the future, actually roughly about this time in the future. And it's written from the perspective of a 12-year-old Jewish girl, actually, it turns out, living in New York with her family in the United in a future version of the United States in which presidents are assassinated a couple of times a year. Policing is effectively collapsed. You're in a state of more or less chaotic application of martial law in which intertribal violence is endemic and so people attempt to self-secure through various measures including home hardening local defense measures and while at the same time trying desperately to maintain a degree of normal civil economic life and economic functioning. Suffice [clears throat] to say it is a very unpleasant book to read. It was popular and relatively popular in the 1990s, but I think bears rereading today because it feels, I think, to be an image of what is the most likely to me interim solution.