MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Israel's election is over, near-conclusive results are now in. Who is most likely to form the next government, the Bibi or the anti-Bibi faction?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 9, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 p.m eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question and now with no further ado i will turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening uh it's been quite a fascinating and interesting last 24 actually last 23 hours since the exit polls were first released those of you who have seen the results will know up until this point first of all we still don't have the final results we still have around 10 percent of the votes to tally and the reason for

1:03 is uh because we have what's caught in first of all when you vote here you put you get a series of little notes and you put whichever party that you want into an envelope and and then you put that into a box and that's your your voting uh basically um what happens is there's a number of votes from soldiers and diplomats people don't vote in their home address and they are tatted later because what happens is the electoral commission has to make sure that they only voted once because they could vote at their non-home address and in theory also then run home and vote there usually it's not that high a number and usually doesn't change the map significantly but obviously in the age of kovid lots more people are not voting in their traditional polling stations whether they be because they have covert itself or because they're in isolation or because they're in a hospital ward an old age home or whatever it is so the number's actually risen to about 10 percent whereas usually it's around a few percent

2:06 so they're going through each vote painstakingly uh ensuring that each person is only uh only voted in one place and we're expecting to find final results friday morning they want to get this done before the passover holiday which starts saturday night obviously sabbath is also a bit problematic so they want to get it done by friday but at the moment we have about 90 of the votes in and what we have is at the moment a sort of dead heat a situation where uh basically neither side not the pro netanyahu block including yamina who hasn't actually officially come out and said that they will support netanyahu but it's assumed that it's uh to include him in that block and the anti netanyahu blog at this point in time neither the netanyahu block with yamina uh is only making 59 and the alternate block uh is even less than that i think it's um i think it must be 56 something like that uh the wild card at this point is not even

3:10 yamina was supposed to be the king maker and still invariably may well be but at this point in time you mean it is not enough to give either side um the keys to the prime minister's office at the moment the real wild card is ram which is the islamic islamist run by matsuo abbas we've talked quite a lot about him he's the person that some would argue was turned quote unquote by prime minister netanyahu he broke off from the joint arab list to run independently and basically against a lot of people's expectations past the electoral and then some is actually up to five seats at the moment as we know four is the minimum and uh when the exit polls were released and for quite a few hours iran were considered very far from passing the electoral threshold in fact one of the pollsters said i do not believe there's any chance around passing the threshold but what now we understand is that in a lot of heartlands of ram

4:14 in the bedouin uh towns in the south uh the posters are not particularly strong so they did take them into account so now we see ram passing and passing extremely strongly ram is a real wild card because it has basically said that it will go with either side it's not in the pocket of either camp uh traditionally the arab parties have not gone with the right wing have not become part of any government has in the past supported the government from the during the rabin government starting 1992 uh so it is possible that that could happen that is something that manso abbas has talked about not being part of the government but supported from the outside which could lead in theory to a minority i personally see about three situations uh coming from this the first is that prime minister netanyahu with his natural allies will make 59 i think he'll be working extremely hard to try and get those extra two from some of the parties across the aisle

5:16 he doesn't want to rely on ram there's a lot of people within his block especially on the far right as we know the religious zionists uh did well and got in with about six potentially even seven seats um they will not sit well with ram even from the outside uh comfortably so i think uh netanyahu as we've seen many many times before will really do everything possible to try and bring some defectors across from the left or the center the most obvious is gideon sars party although gideon saw anser belkin another former liquid minister have said that they will not leave but i think the price will be high but as we've seen prime minister netanyahu will probably uh pay it uh another possibility is even benny gantz uh you know he said he won't but he said he wouldn't last time uh again there may be just other uh uh identified maybe yashatir to others again all he needs is two to get over to that magic number of another possibility is that we just

6:21 no one forms a government and we go to a fifth election as crazy as that sounds now that's not a solution for prime minister netanyahu even though he elongates his stay in power but as we remember uh going back into the current government or the previous coalition agreement uh netanyahu has to vacate according to that coalition agreement the prime minister's residence uh in about i think it's october or november now another series of elections with the coalition building with the time that that takes could potentially get something very very close to that point now would prime minister netanyahu want to risk that everyone would stall and stall and stall up into a point where benny gatz basically just takes the keys balfour the balfour residence which is the prime minister's residence um that's something which he wouldn't want to countenance but something that could be held over his head very prominently so it's something that netanyahu wouldn't want but it's certainly a possibility if no one comes sort of climbs down from their tree the third option which is being talked about

7:24 but i think is a little bit of a long is that the anti-netanyahu camp and this would have to include uh ram the party we just talked about is that they don't necessarily have to make a coalition what they could do while there is a new knesset with all the new knesset members if they create a majority they can vote out uh the current knesset speaker which is yerev levine are very much confident of netanyahu and vote in one of their own we saw that attempted last time uh with the crazy scenes of julietoshen refusing to give up his post when he was speaker of the house even though the supreme court wrote that he had to that could play out again and then pick someone for the speaker of the knesset someone from the anti-netanyahu block perhaps someone from yeshetid or or one of the other parties now what that would do is give them a lot of power and a lot of control over the agenda of the knesset and then even vote in a majority of members to important connected committees like the

8:29 committee the arrangements committee is basically the knesset committee which the agenda in that sort of holdover period until the formal committees are then populated all the different kinesic members now that's vital because as i said if they took over those two then the anti-netanyahu block would control the and they could then possibly but again they would need every single member of so-called aunty netanyahu and ram to vote for a law which would prescribe uh someone who is you know in criminal proceedings under an indictment whatever the language would be from forming the government from uh becoming the next prime minister that would obviously uh have massive ramifications because it would ensure that prime minister netanyahu would not be able to form the next that is some way off that's being concocted by various figures uh uh avitor lieberman israel blatenu is that miro mikhaili of the labour party

9:32 said that she's very interested in also being part of that but that would again need you know all these sort of disparate parties uh to work together it would be much easier than for them to form a government because i think that would be not just unlikely almost impossible to have the jointlist israel baitino all sitting in the same government and with all these parties most of these parties apart from yeshua tid are in single digits so it'd be almost to even find some sort of coalition agreement let alone divvy up uh minister of positions so i think that that that you know to create a coalition out of these parties is impossible but there is this other not to necessarily form a government but to form a working relationship to take control of the agenda of the knesset in this sort of middle period and ensure that prime minister netanyahu can not form the next government i think those are the options on the table everything can change if a netanyahu gets 60 then what i just talked about in the

10:36 could not happen because the opposition block would not be able to get a at the moment he doesn't have it but not are there 10 percent of the votes still to be counted there's then the agreements the um between parties where they give the excess voting uh we talked about that a number of weeks ago where where two parties who have an agreement uh basically uh sign a vote sharing agreement and the party with a larger number of seats then gets over the over the number of seats that they have would then get from the uh party with the less amount of excess votes and potentially get another seat there's talk of for example sar and bennett who have that agreement and if it goes to tsar that's another seat for the anti-bb block but if it goes to bennett that could be number 60 perhaps even number 61 if they get another seat from the uh uh the the 10 percent that of the boats that are still

11:37 uh ready to be calculated so unfortunately we won't know any more today we won't know anymore tomorrow friday we'll know a little bit more but as i've said many times before governments are not formed on election night in israel there's no there's never a clear winner uh elections are won through coalition negotiations and what we've seen with netanyahu successfully over many many years is he may not win an outright not him certainly and not even sometimes his natural allies but what he does do is he does negotiate very well he that uh he can bring people across the we look at edward barack in the past tippi livni um benny gantz these are all people who said that they wouldn't sit amir paris who said they wouldn't sit with or certainly ran uh in opposition to him but then eventually came into his government so and and uh basically the bottom line is netanyahu needs very much uh to get to a 61. uh his political future

12:39 relies on it so i think that to my mind is the most likely uh scenario but it remains to be seen and with that i'm happy to answer any all right thank you so much the first first question we have in is uh what is rom's political position and how does rahm and the joint list parties differ well first of all ram in the last elections and ever since they increased the electoral thresholds i think it was in 2015 uh have run together because it was felt that each party on its own there used to be four parties or five parties each party on its own would not get over the electoral threshold so they ran together and they got anything nice double-digit numbers and the last election uh reached a high of 15 seats at the moment the joint list without ram are expected to get six seats which is a massive uh failure to a certain extent and they say that the

13:41 the uh percentage of voter turnout uh went down in general and especially in sector and even many in the arab sector may have voted for quote-unquote zionist parties mainstream parties and liquid may well have received one or two mandates from the arab sector which they uh sought during this campaign ram is an islamic party the other parties the the arab street is largely uh divided into three again this is a bit of an oversimplification but for the purposes of this there's the communist party there's the arab nationalist party and then there's the islamic uh party ram is the islamic party which is you know based obviously on religion holds very conservative views um one of the reasons for the falling out at least is because of other parties in the joint list support for lgbtq uh issues in the last knesset whereas hadash which is a communist party votes

14:44 the side of allowing greater rights for the gay community it is something with outside of the remit of ramen they will vote very much as ultra there will vote like the ultra conservative jewish parties very similarly and in fact they do coordinate on certain issues interestingly enough although they are an islamic party some refer to them as an islamist party uh they are not a politically extreme party they recognize uh israel or they're not let's just say you know as extreme as some like balad which is an arab nationalist party um but it was never thought up until a year ago that they could conceivably sit in an israeli government or support from the outside or hold a very good relationship especially not with it he could led to government these are impr unprecedented times uh rama playing their cards very close to

15:48 their chest or at least manso abbas the leader is the head of negotiation someone else in the party has said come out a little bit less cagey and said that they would prefer a left-wing government or a left-of-center or an anti-bibi block because that's more natural for them and because they wouldn't sit very with people like itamar being greer of the religious zionist party so there seems to be a little bit of a disagreement or maybe that's it's a planned strategy to show that they're not in either side and to see what monsoon bus says openly whoever gives them the best deal thank you and what influence did the amount of votes cast have on the coalition government in israel for instance does more seats allow for more opportunities to be appointed to uh the different i mean yes obviously the larger party you are the more seats you'll get in theory at least the more policies that you'll getting coalition agreements that doesn't always

16:51 happen uh we've seen many many times in the past the first party liquid makes an agreement with and it's relatively a traditional is with the united torah judaism the ashkenazi ultra-orthodox party which is at the moment six seats and or seven seats and traditionally smaller than the shasta party and some of the other parties but it's considered extremely important when the united tour jew doesn't go in shas will surely follow and then he shored up his most natural allies with the ultra orthodox community um those parties at least united judaism doesn't seek as many ministries but seeks a lot more let's say budgets uh and issues of importance other parties more interested in seats um but again we saw in the last knesset the labour party brought two seats to the uh government and receive two ministries which is obviously you know if you look at the wider uh implications of that you certainly don't have 61 ministers

17:53 uh so it doesn't always tally up it's it's it's down to what netanyahu's needs are what the demands of the party yamina which as i said could be the king maker possibly uh they can ask for the world and netanyahu will have to give it he's ruled out another rotation agreement another uh you know situation where he has to hand over the prime minister ship uh to someone else like he had in the last agreement um but if letting if if if um bennett is that 60 or that 61 he can ask for whatever he wants and as i said earlier probably netanyahu will give it to him because he's such an important part because all the other parties have pretty much said that they'll sit with netanyahu and they don't really have anywhere else to go uh naftali bennett in theory at least could sit in the ante uh bb block so it's all about uh leverage at this point understood and just for clarification uh for example could bennett ally with lee likun

18:55 coalition without having to always vote with netanyahu are the mks free to vote on issues as they see no i mean i i would say largely no like like in any government around the world there has to be a certain amount of coalition discipline you know it's you can't sign up to something and then basically voters you want the idea is then you are bound by an agreement uh to vote on certain issues and this usually in these coalition agreements it says on uh let's say on religious issues that uh we agree to vote on we agreed to abide by the status quo any uh laws that come up will have to be agreed by so-and-so or have to be done by this or that but on the whole there there should be coalition discipline because if there's not then there's no real reason for coalition because then everyone could just vote all over the place but usually uh the parties sit down and they work out points in the agenda and they ensure at least the coalition chairman is supposed ensure that nothing is put on the agenda which could cause any crises at least at

19:58 the beginning of a government but uh these days uh we don't have uh too much of that and there's crises after the first day uh but in theory uh a government should vote together on the majority of issues there are certain issues which sometimes you're you're allowed in a free vote perhaps on lgbtq issues in the past uh amir ohana for example is an openly minister in the liquid government he's been allowed to vote against the coalition let's say on those issues that's something which the prime minister or the coalition chairman allowed him to do and there are other issues like that usually they're not considered the most pressing issues like for example on religion and state which is extremely important to the ultra-orthodox parties it would be seen as strange for members of uh the government to vote what they may do sometimes if they feel that it's against their conscience is excuse themselves but that can come uh with penalties uh certainly you know from the coalition whip

21:00 again this is not necessarily unique to interested thank you um so with voter turnout being fairly low this time around has there been any serious movement in israel for advocating term limits for prime ministers or considering electoral well first of all it wasn't low it was just lower um it was a few percent lower not too significant but the second part of your question my personal view is it's absolute necessity because we're moving towards if we're not already there in political paralysis um we look at the blocks we look at the last few elections and and just we could just go on and on and on uh there's a lack of governability uh in the system and that needs to be changed uh gideon sales party ticker had a shot which in the end really uh really didn't do as well as was expected very much has that on their platform they want term limits some other parties have also talked about that yeshua obtained of being one of them uh government reform electoral reform is the third rail

22:04 in israeli politics is the thing which is most needed but the thing least likely to be talked about or acted on quite simply because there are too many parties invested in the current system if you uh reform the system raise the threshold had constituency based elections there are too many parties which are now in power or part of the decision-making process which would then lose that power so they're not going to vote away that prime minister netanyahu did bring it up i believe after the 2015 elections he did bring it up made a whole speech for about an hour about the need electoral form and then never mention it again my assumption is uh more than an um that basically he got told by some of his natural allies the smaller parties it's not going to work for us so drop it so it's a really problematic issue in israeli politics but one desperately needs it to my mind at least so how likely is it that the knesset might raise the threshold again uh very unlikely if anything it may

23:08 because as we saw there were a lot of parties scrambling on the day of the elections to pass the threshold in the end all those that were threatening you know were sort of on the did pass but uh it's it's possible but i don't think there's a great move for it it's essentially not to move it any great amounts up or um it's possible um but at the moment i don't think that's necessarily on the agenda but remains to be seen and at what point does a coalition government become unnecessary a coalition become unnecessary we have to have a coalition government because we that that's the system that we have no party receive 61 on their own so you always have to have at least a number of parties you know we go back to the days where there was only three or four parties in the government but that's usually when one party reached you know numbers in the 40s so then they only needed two or three

24:09 other parties to reach that magic number of 61 but invariably a little bit more uh we haven't had that for a long while you know they could are supposed to have done very well in the last few elections by reaching the 30s but they've always needed multiple parties uh that's part of the problem um but at the end of the day in the current system there is no alternative uh to to rule one has to have a majority they can asset and that's 61. so unless a government will have 61 it simply cannot walk because it can't pass any laws thank you for clarifying that uh is the new hope part of the 59 netanyahu block are they considered opposition currently at the moment they're considered opposition gideon was very staunch after the results came in that he will not be joining a liquid led government but or at least netanyahu led government but uh as i said before we've heard these things and there are a lot of people around the knesset which don't necessarily believe that he'll hold out especially if he's offered a lot but that remains to be seen and even if

25:11 gideon saw himself will not join maybe others in his list thank you and what individuals in the parties uh might be tempted to move over to le coudie as i said um once he has uh bennett and by the way bennett has not said that necessarily join uh many um assume that he will because he wouldn't want to be seen as responsible for not uh forming a right-wing religious government because that's where his base um but even if you go at the moment according to the numbers that leaves you 59 so he needs at least two more as i said get on sar's party is the most likely because almost everybody who's joining the is a formerly kudnik um you have someone like um us handle who's not formerly a a liquidnick but he sat very comfortably or not amazingly comfortably but uh he was in the last government uh

26:13 unto netanyahu there's no love lost to any of these people but if they're offered enough maybe they'll go uh yes roberta no i don't see you know they've been offered many many times and so far they no one has broken off um the labour party i don't see uh it's not amir perez it's mayor of michaeli and i don't think that anyone from her block will join merits certainly will not even be invited the joint list will not be invited um blue and white benny gantz's party it's a possibility as we've seen he's promised before not to see what netanyahu ended up doing it perhaps there's other people lower down on this list who may because bloom might probably will not be as successful sitting in the opposition uh for a few years so perhaps uh people lower down on the list we'll see an and then there's yeshutid which is the largest party uh yeshetid is probably not the first place he's going to look but i'm sure that netanyahu being the strategist that he is will he have even

27:17 identified people on that list who he thinks maybe he can turn thank you has there been a single decisive issue for israeli voters during this election aside from for against netanyahu not really that's the bottom line this has been very much uh you know that the elections of brand uh if you look across the um really the whole campaign um and the election results no party i would say no single party has managed to build anything beyond its there's been no party which has really gone beyond what is relative i wouldn't say expected because the labour party in blue and white did better than was expected or at least the polls were indicating but again they they just sort of rebuilt their base there's no game-changing party which really did very well in keeping its base and expanding largely i would say because there was no compelling message there was no single identifiable compelling message to drive uh from other walks of life from other

28:23 uh to vote for a party outside of their and i think because of that we're again in this sort of political paralysis um and i think that's a problem and i think as long as there isn't someone who comes in with that strong and compelling narrative that's really able to move populations towards them we're going to be stuck in this situation uh unfortunately it was mostly about iu4 or against netanyahu there were some other issues on the periphery yeshua betena tried to make about the ultra-orthodox the ultra orthodox tried to make it about yeshua peter and they played off against each other a little bit at the end of the day um the strategists you saw the posters or anyone who saw the posters and i know what sort of messaging was very much uh brand politics personality politics with very very few issues involved thank you and our last question of the day has the kova pandemic hurt netanyahu or any of his competitors well the interesting thing is the

29:26 narrative is that the um the vaccine program which has been very successful and continues to be uh is a large reason why netanyahu got the number he did but if you look at the polling all throughout the campaign and even a little bit before uh because now we've become a nation which likes to poll every two days regardless of elections netanyahu was always polling between 32 and 28 and in the end he's getting 30 or 31 and that's regardless of the success or before the vaccine program so i wouldn't say that that really contributed it's clear as i said going back to my point i made before that netanyahu has a solid base of 30 a little bit more a little bit less voters will vote for him regardless of the situation economic social health whatever and if you look around the other parties i would say that again most of them pretty much went back to their base i would say the two parties with who really didn't uh find a base are

30:29 probably the two parties which certainly struggled the most uh from a early high and that's yamina and uh and uh both of those parties at one point were polling in the 20s and in the end got relatively low digits party which considered an alternative at one point to netanyahu is now poland is now expected to get six perhaps it will get seven but still massive uh come down uh yamina uh again was polling at one point in the 20s and was considered an alternate uh alternative to uh prime minister netanyahu in the end is going to get perhaps it will squeeze an eight but even that is still because quite simply they didn't really have a base uh or they didn't know it were a base uh they tried their their two right-wing parties filled with right-wing uh members of knesset or potential members of knesset who tried to reach out to the center and center left and at the end of the day when it really mattered a lot of these people just went home to the left and the left of centre parties that's why

31:32 you saw merits pass the threshold easily labor do well blue and white uh and yesterday pretty much did as it's been polling throughout the election so we didn't see great movements uh we didn't see you know uh numbers uh you know there were some surprises but again no party which managed to break beyond his base and i think uh that's really to me uh the message of these elections that we need someone with a very strong new and compelling voice who's going to be able to reach out beyond the base and really change the dynamics and change the numbers because without that we're going to continue on this tie or you know this political paralysis so so that's hoping that voice comes at some point soon well let's hope so and i'm sure he'll have more for us next week as far as this goes uh so we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with steve emerson discussing does the third

32:33 lebanon-israel war lie ahead thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a great day