Webinar or Talk
The Taliban Victory, Implications for Israel with Micky Aharonson
Watch on YouTube
Description
The Taliban takeover in Afghanistan encourages Islamists such as Hamas and Hezbollah while discouraging U.S. allies in the Persian Gulf. What does this surprise development mean for the Jewish state?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 6, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 uh hello and welcome to the middle east forum speaker webinar series and podcast i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mickey aronson a senior research fellow at the jerusalem institute for strategy and security and former senior director for foreign policy in israel's national security council join us to discuss the taliban victory implications for israel ms erinson will speak for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that i will turn the discussion over to mickey aronson thank you stacy thank you for inviting me uh i'm happy to be here although the topic of the discussion is not that it is what it is and we'll deal with it i would like to refer to the afghanian issue from an israeli perspective and also from a middle eastern perspective and i will deal with that in maybe three time frames uh past present and future
1:06 so past uh we have in general we have comparisons between uh kabul and saigon i would like to suggest that the kabul case is much worse because during the evacuation of saigon there was no social media so there was no um reporting in real time right now because there is the whole world is watching uh we saw the tragedy that happened yesterday we refer to it as tragedy but other terror organizations were inspired by the event today we can say uh many define the the american departure the procedure of the departure as a failure it's a repeating failure we see it also in the middle east we see it in syria in libya in iraq and so on there is a difference between theory and practice and i don't know how many events this uh these events would have to repeat till
2:08 we understand there's a pattern uh the failure actually is a question of if the expectations were as they were to change the dna of the country to change the afghanian set of values like happened in syria and like happened in iraq and elsewhere it could be defined as a failure you cannot change in 20 years people's dna this is a tribal theocratic society and it will not change over 20 years what could have been achieved and then it wouldn't have been considered a failure is to maintain a relatively uh western-like i'm saying relatively lifestyle for example well girls don't have to marry when they're eight and they can go to schools and study and this was reached with the presence of 2500 american soldiers as uh as were present in afghanistan recently
3:12 if this uh was the expectation this could have been considered a success but to change the the afghanian nation definitely turned into a failure now let's talk about the presence the immediate impact on israel we saw the the prime minister of israel was traveling to washington for a very high level meeting with president biden uh there are many expectations in israel from that meeting and it was cancelled it was postponed it is actually happening as we speak and we were reminded a lesson of modesty because we viewed here from israel from jerusalem we viewed this meeting as a a summit major world leaders and then this tragedy happened and and prime minister biden was told to wait which is also positive because the whole meeting could have been postponed to another another visit
4:17 we were reminded we are not the center of the universe and that the voters of president biden do not sit in tel aviv or in jerusalem they are in the united states and what interests them is not necessarily what interests us in israel um i have to say i don't know of any who are discussing the withdrawal from afghanistan i don't know of positive withdrawals i don't know photogenic withdrawals there are definitely no happy withdrawals so in that sense we could lower our expectations what does happen nowadays at present is a takeover of one of the most radical uh versions uh of of radical regimes it definitely currently encourages similar movements uh with a message that the us can be uh the us and the western general can be won over if you wait enough time if you use force you
5:21 can beat the mighty united states all it takes is patience and this is the message the terror organizations in the middle east and beyond are receiving now i completely understand that the us does not want to invest any more blood or treasure in wars abroad we can ask whether to the presence of 2 500 soldiers is a war but that's for the american administration to decide we saw it in during president obama's time during president trump's time and now president biden this is not israel's role to ask america to stay it is again the american administration's decision and we should not advise it on now a few a few words about the future the thinking that taliban in the future may change its practices is a victory of hope over reason the afghanian people know best the best
6:26 example is to see the people trying to escape as refugees to iran imagine viewing iran as the land of freedom this only stresses how bad the situation in afghanistan is and people on the ground know it there is a complete misunderstanding i think in the west and also within the american administration of the the radical islamic thinking a few days ago uh the spokesperson for the white house said before taliban took over the entire country almost the entire country said that taliban should consider which role it wants to hold in the international community and this is only a very good demonstration of the misunderstanding of the taliban's dna what role would the taliban wish to hold in the international community which discussions can they have with western uh with western states the european
7:30 union also called on the taliban to change its practices or the european union will enforce uh sanctions on the taliban i don't think the taliban expected to sign an economic attack with the eu for its drug deals or to discuss maybe cultural exchanges it is a different dna they will not change and again the hope that they will is absurd the countries that have leverages on them are iran are china or russia or pakistan does anybody expect these countries to to use any leverages in regard to human rights i think not iran we will have implications when it comes to various aspects when it comes to iran iran does not have any more a threat of a ground invasion from the east because the us is leaving the west is leaving the u.s prioritizes uh china and russia
8:32 for example but these countries just became much much more powerful because they are necessary uh if you want to stabilize the situation on the borders of afghanistan again because they are the ones that will deal openly and directly with taliban and therefore will have leverages over taliban russia for example is being very practical about it it is holding military drills with afghanistan's other tajikistan and with uzbekistan in order to prevent afghani afghani refugees leaving the country and military disorder iran will have to decide whether it wants to stop the flow of drugs coming from i want to discuss i have five more minutes very briefly two scenarios the positive scenario and the realistic the positive scenario is that states of
9:35 the middle east will unite in order to face a common threat of radicalism we will have the leaders of saudi arabia of egypt and since they are all afraid of the shia x's and the sunni muslim brotherhood they will find it very hard to resist pressures from iran and from turkey separately they can also act in cooperation with israel on matters of economy of defense of intelligence and unlike iran or turkey israel has no fantasies in the middle eastern arena if they act separately if their differences overcome the wish to cooperate there will be of course more chance for for radical islam to rise for israel american departure is of course problematic however israel never relied on the us to participate in the battlefield despite the fact that israel has
10:38 expectations for economic support for purchasing weapons and international backing from the united states there is no change in american commitment in that sense israel remains the most stable and close ally in the middle east for the united states the united states can rely on israel to preserve its and if the united states administration adopts a rational and practical thinking and not extreme progressive there could be positive cooperation there are shared values as opposed to transactional approach and these are crucial for facing the challenges ahead this was the positive scenario but we have the realistic scenario realistic scenarios that everybody will hedge their events as the russian ambassador that declared uh this maritime drill coming in the persian gulf in the participation of china russia and iran as he said he
11:41 stressed that iran is warming up towards its neighbors uh the saudis are having a direct dialogue with iran the emiratis send a representative to the crowning of also the emirati nsa just visited the visited it's considered to be better allies a bitter sorry bitter enemies uh qatar and turkey he paid a visit to them in one week everybody's hedging their what is the lesson to israel the lesson should be very similar to the lesson we learned from the year 2006 when hamas took over gaza in democratic elections we are often told by diplomats and by foreign security experts we should trust our security with palestinian security forces that received proper training from u.s experts we are told they will block islamic terror on a day of reckoning this is not to disregard the importance of moderate palestinian forces
12:45 support in the efforts of the idf to to combat radical islam every day but the demise of the 300 000 afghan security forces is a painful lesson for israel in this and we should remember that if ever a serious discussion of a settlement of the conflict between israel and the palestinian takes place u.s departure will not leave a world there are no vacuums in the real world russia and china and turkey and others will definitely come in both in afghanistan and elsewhere the implication for states behavior and state choices would be very clear it is very different if you have an american base on your land or you have a russian base on your land iran and turkey will have greater opportunity no doubt and therefore maybe uh may become more aggressive it seems that the rise of radical islam is almost inedible thank you and i would be very happy to
13:48 take questions i have to tell you in the background you can see a tv studio i'm speaking from a tv studio because i was accompanying the visit uh from here from jerusalem of prime minister bennett who is currently meeting with president biden so you see people walking around well thank you so much for for that expert analysis uh we have quite a few questions coming in from carrie hildebrand uh will the taliban be capable of forming a relatively stable government or do you see it fracturing into quarreling and far warring factions the honest answer is i don't know but judging from the past and judging from its behavior right now the taliban currently has a challenge of turning from a guerrilla terror organization into a state apparatus for that purpose it would need two things internal and some external international the tragic
14:54 event that happened yesterday the terror attack that uh daesh that isis claimed responsibility for was against taliban interests because taliban needs the u.s to leave quickly and quietly and this could trigger some american uh action against isis in the as we heard president biden say i believe what taliban would want is to uh afghanistan taliban as opposed to isis has no international inspirations it has inspirations when it comes aspirations when it comes to afghanistan so taliban would try to stabilize afghanistan quietly not to get into a fight with anybody right now it would even deal positively with iran despite the deep hatred and contempt between taliban the sunnis and and iran the shiites and they will have international cooperation from china
15:58 they will have international cooperations from russia and of course from pakistan and maybe with others from iran turkey uh we read that the taliban approached turkey uh to help them in operating the airport and i believe they will receive some cooperation from from external uh powers so i think they will try to stabilize the country i don't know if they managed understood thank you from morton maurer the progressive theory is that the reason there is not peace is that we haven't given given enough incentive to our enemies when will the idea that the sacrifice of israel be the final needed where else will israel turn for the lost american support i hope the american support is not lost and this is very important again we share values and uh we have a deep commitment in the us that is based on the understanding that israel is the single
17:00 the most the the stronger country that represents american interests in the middle east i believe this will not be lost again america expresses its commitment again and again i'm waiting to see the result of the meeting between president biden and prime minister bennett i think it was a very generous gesture from president biden to receive prime minister bennett during all this mayhem that is happening and all this uh chaotic departure from afghanistan and i believe that although the u.s suffers from middle eastern fatigue the middle east never lets you leave and if the middle east doesn't let you leave the us would need a reliable airline in the area and this would necessarily have to be israel thank you from love tristan is it possible for politicians to learn from history or do they always think they are too smart to fail
18:04 i am so fortunate to answer you that not as a politician well politicians have again the the victory of hope over reason or over history and they have also the limitations of the time they serve it's very hard to plan ten years in advance if you stay in office for three or four or five years or as we had in israel we had so many elections taking place almost every half a year i do hope they learn from history uh they will be very i hope disillusioned about taliban all these declarations for example we see about taliban changing suddenly what would i say liberal i wouldn't believe it till i see it i wouldn't like to be a woman in afghanistan right now i think it's a tragedy and again the people who know it best are those that are willing to jump on airplanes just to escape that country yes thank you uh from
19:13 sorry i can't pronounce that uh how does success of taliban embolden hamas and pla and impact on israel i think hamas was the first terror organization that congratulated uh taliban for its victory uh he was joined by a islamic jihad movement he was then joined by other radical movements in syria for example they are very much inspired um and again everybody sees what is happening and the mighty united states is leaving a country after 20 years in the hands of a radical movement uh with the potential of other even more radical movements like isis that have international aspirations and i think it's very negative and they are all these these uh terror organizations are celebrating and uh we will have to
20:16 be aware of it and prepare ourselves for that and i believe israel does thank you along those lines jay asks will terror bases form and launch attacks from afghanistan who will i'm sorry can you repeat please just a terror basis like will terrorist entrench in afghanistan and start launching attacks do you think well i was asked uh especially about al and i believe taliban will not clash with al-qaeda unless al qaeda does something like happened yesterday to attract american attention that would destabilize the country again taliban has an interest to stabilize afghanistan so it is able to rule it and and to turn from again from a guerrilla to a a state to be able to govern the state i'm sorry we have a bad connection here but i'll continue i'll continue to speak and unless taliban does something very radical that
21:20 that forces the united states to uh taliban will not clash at the moment with al-qaeda it will not clash with anybody it doesn't have to because it's interested in stabilization and quiet but we will see how al-qaeda behaves uh so the world leaders seem to be taking us sitting back and weight approach to how to deal with the taliban how do you think that they should well i can tell you how how i would like them to proactively react but that would be again the victory of hope over reason we see the countries in the region we see tajikistan uzbekistan and turkmenistan that border they understood a long time ago i think since even 2018 they have to deal with taliban because taliban is not going they understood that taliban is not
22:24 negotiating in good faith and the aspirations are to re-establish its rule over afghanistan they have been dealing with taliban and they will reach some sort of uh modus vivandi with it uh i believe other countries too uh will have to deal with taliban for example and this is i'm going to say something very unpopular but this is true uh america has to choose between two evils to choose the lesser evil it has to deal with taliban or it has to deal with isis and al-qaeda and if it deals with taliban it could at least try and i'm even afraid to say to cooperate maybe to against al-qaeda and against isis and we see that happening and if the united states wouldn't coordinate with taliban it wouldn't be able to have all the evacuation taking place because the taliban controls all the passages until the airport uh the us controls
23:29 only the airport so there would have to be some sort of i'm not saying cooperation but coordination and we have of course the economic issues i believe countries unofficially maybe would have to cooperate uh with with the with taliban i am sure that china and pakistan and russia and even iran would taliban afghanistan is a very promising land in turn in terms of natural and the temptation would be too big not to cooperate understood and you spoke of the rational and practical thinking by the us in the positive scenario what would this entail it would entail choosing the lesser evil it would entail understanding that the people that rely on u.s policy in syria for example are taliban alike if assad falls tomorrow
24:32 those who will take over will not be a liberal opposition they will be some sort of taliban i think the u.s has to draw some lessons from what happened in afghanistan and what happened in the past in other countries in the middle east to understand that this region will not turn into a liberal u.s or europe alike it will continue to stay a tribal society in an islamic society best case moderate islam worst case radical islam and in that sense the u.s would have to make some choices again these are very unpleasant choices but it is what it is in syria which is very close to israel and therefore um again i'm not from the united nations i am from israel i see what's happening on our borders and our choice today is between assad and we know what assad is we have no illusions but we know also who the opposition is and i'm not talking about the opposition that sits
25:34 in uh in the saloons in western capitals i'm talking about the position in idlib and the opposition that is supported by turkey again taliban alike and if i have to choose between them and assad the choice is very clear and i think the u.s would have to do the same and the u.s would have to choose between suffocating the assad regime and letting the iranians increase their their presence and influence or choosing tough choices from oh is israel likely to retaliate against any afghani taliban aggression uh the way it does against iran and lebanese hezbollah well we are very fortunate in this case because uh we are far away from and we have our hands full believe me we we have syria we have iran we have luckily i can say afghanistan is in the near future an immediate problem
26:40 of of others and not ours and i would like to stay out of this problem as much as we can of this arena so in our final few moments here is there any way to salvage this uh failed on the us's part well again as i said i don't think there are photogenic withdrawals uh i don't think they are happy withdrawals i believe that there's the support by the american people to leave afghanistan it's not something we in israel can comment about uh i hope as many people as possible would be saved i hope the negotiations uh will take place with people you would rather not negotiate with but again to save as many people as possible and to try and identify leverages maybe vis-a-vis different countries like russia to try and help those miserable people in afghanistan
27:45 thank you and before we go just i know this is an unpleasant subject you mentioned that right at the start but you know what would be the worst case scenario that we could see here worst case scenario for afghanistan is i think unbelievable that i say that is not talibani control works case scenario would be if it breaks into a country of warlords and we had it for some time in syria and if you get different warlords controlling different parts of kanista in afghanistan killing each other destabilizing the borders with central asian states and exporting refugees exporting terror and exporting this i'm afraid would be a far worse scenario than even than having radical government of taliban in afghanistan thank you so much for that and before we go uh could you just let us know where we could find some more of your work
28:48 yes uh thank you i'm a senior research fellow in the jerusalem institute for strategy and security jiss um also on twitter you're all welcome to follow and read and thank you very much for inviting me and let's now all join uh prime minister bennett in his uh visit with the with president biden yes thank you so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to speak with we really appreciate it thank you very and for our viewers thank you so much for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day