Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
Can the “Change government” sufficiently withstand both external pressures and internal divisions actually to be sworn in?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 6, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forum's webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today very pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacy and good evening from israel um well this is possibly probably the last uh israel insider webinar before we have a potentially fully functioning government for the first time in uh two years plus uh at four o'clock on sunday if there are no last-minute surprises there will be a new government sworn in um there's still a little bit to go and the pressure's still on
1:03 uh the the sort of calendar uh of events let's say uh that's supposed to take place over the next few is as follows by friday um all of the coalition agreements with the various parties have to be handed into the knesset speaker's office that means um the the agreements that yeshua did as ruling party or the largest party the party which uh currently has the mandate from the president to form a government uh has been signing agreements with or is finalizing agreements with all the major parties uh the media's got wind apparently of some of the uh some of the clauses and uh we can talk about that a little bit but basically they have to be handed in officially uh they're not closed yet there are still some outstanding disagreements they have to be handed in by friday uh on sunday morning there will be a on a new speaker of the canister that's very important yuri levine is going to be replaced by uh the coalition's choice which is mickey levy of yashatid then mickey levy will
2:07 take up his position as speaker of the house and he will then preside over what is certainly going to be a very um how do we say a challenging few hours there's going to a tremendous amount of hostility from the opposition uh pretty much the government as it stands the only the only uh party that's going to stay on from the current government is blue and white like liquid and the ultra orthodox parties and the religious science parties are going to the opposition and uh first of all we'll have we'll hear from naftali bennett as the incoming prime minister he'll present the government he'll present who's going to be minister of what he'll present uh the outlines or the guidelines of uh this uh coalition and uh he'll speak for certain amounts of time then the prime minister as the leader of the largest party prime minister netanyahu at least for the next few days
3:08 will then uh be able to respond and sure to be vociferous to say the least and then every uh leader of every party will have the ability to speak if the 24 hours 48 hours is anything to go by the attacks are going to continue to be nasty in the last few days naftali bennett has been called a suicide bomber by a member of liquid my golan she compared naftali bennett and gideon tsar to suicide bombers um uh the ultra orthodox parties uh called naftali bennett worse than reform and in their mind that's one of the worst curses you can call he's not religious he should take his kippah off um duty am salim of the liquid party also said i was new enough tony bennett's not religious and now it's proven they've come up with all sorts of conspiracies we've heard for the probably the first time uh from prime minister netanyahu and other members of this party this concept of the deep i know in the us there's a lot of talk about the deep state well
4:11 that language is certainly come across and it started to be used by netanyahu and some of his partners the judiciary the media is against them they're trying to get them out et cetera et cetera and today there was a knesset meeting to try and arrange what's going to happen on sunday and the language that used was has been called outrageous uh incitement etc etc um there's still i i wouldn't say much of an opportunity most commentators say there's a very small likelihood that the won't be sworn in don't forget as we've spoken about it's the governments of 61 so even if there's one defector it could prove problematic or even one decides to it could still pass if there's a majority but it would need every single uh the the final let's say up until this outstanding uh member of yamina who is still back and forth about what he was going to do near finally uh in the last couple of days
5:15 said that he will vote in favor of the government uh it is likely he'll be given a ministry they say ministry of settlement affairs um so according to uh sources in uh yamina all of their six mks don't forget they originally had seven but uh one of them decided he would not vote for the government he'll vote against the government so they're down to six but all six will vote for the government unless there is a major surprise the last sort of problematic person in the coalition who seems to be making a bit of noise as if elkin suddenly he's bringing up some demands now more than likely and this is what i'm hearing it's just a matter of trying to get in some last minute changes something more favorable to him and his position um but he seems to be the one that uh the eyes are now they could pass i believe it was uh today earlier today in their central committee the ability of prime minister netanyahu to hold three spaces open in the next
6:17 uh electoral uh list uh which was originally put there to sort of say to natalie bennett or if any of you come across or even one of their members we will then put you in a reserve spot in that it could list uh in the next elections and they decided to go through that anyway just in case so that in their using their language there are any last-minute defectors but it does seem like there's very little chance even liquid are talking that way um it could also be uh you know they're using the language using the language that this is a done deal and this is a government which uh will not fall so quickly um there was an interesting meeting today between the leaders of the ultra orthodox parties and the ultra-orthodox media and they asked for complete blackout of any uh person in this coalition they said you should not interview this is what the politicians told the media you shouldn't interview anyone especially not from yemen especially not naftali bennett or any of them um basically you know saying that
7:21 you should fall in line you know with the ultra orthodox leader uh political leadership uh so that was certainly a little bit problematic um and again using some very problematic language against some of the religious members of yumina so it's it's and another interesting element of that is they demanded of the journalists to stop saying this government won't last very long they said they can't rally their people their base if they believe that this government is going to be short-lived so it's very i believe not just in the ultra-orthodox media but any of the media affiliated any of the current government future opposition to give the impression that this will be short-lived uh because then it's much harder to rally there will be large large gatherings and rallies over the weekend outside the homes of any of the amina or new hope uh members of knesset they believe could still be swayed even though it doesn't seem likely um there has been
8:22 as as i said earlier quite a lot of incitement they've shown on the media and around what's up groups some messages to some yamina mks you know calling for their death calling for their children's to suffer you know there was death notices put out with near orbach's name as if he'd already been killed there's been all sorts of threats um terrible terrible threats uh to the point where i believe all but one yamina mk now has full-time uh naftali bennett has got unprecedented security for um for a prime minister in waiting uh a few new hope um members of knesset also receiving um security so so it's very tense my personal belief is that once the government is sworn in um i think that tempest will lower a little bit i think once it's you know a lot of people take a bit of a deep breath and realize okay
9:24 now we have to take a step backwards and we you know that the government will have to try and find a way to work together the opposition will try and find a way uh legally constitutionally politically to try and you know bash them as much as they can there's a lot of talk about how long this government will last um there are some optimistic people i i spoke to in yeshuate who believe that once they pass the budget because the budget is the first minefield and if you don't pass a budget within six months then the government automatically falls but uh a lot of the details on on future budgets already been uh worked out i'll talk a little bit about some of the issues that are going to be tackled by this first of all on religious state because that's a major first of all it should be understood that when you have a government with right-wing left-wing and arab party there's not gonna be too much movement on issues where they uh there's a there are diverse opinions and usually left and right are are
10:28 navigated according to your belief on the palestinian issue on security issues those issues probably won't be developed uh too much at this point because there's no way that enough tally bennett can agree with uh uh with horowitz of merits or even ram or labor so probably those issues can be put on the back burner they understand that there are diverging opinions so that probably will be put on the back burner but some of the issues that will be brought up again which can create some friction uh are religion and state there's talk about uh for the first time perhaps civil marriage there's talk about um re uh sort of and a couple of years ago there was this what was called the cocktail um decision where as anyone knows who goes to the western mall it's very much in the in the style of an orthodox syndicate with uh with the divide between men and women women are not allowed to read from the torah and all that sort
11:30 of thing so they created a separate uh place that was uh ironically that was when natalie bennett i believe was diaspora affairs minister um but that was never really instituted fully or that's one of the things that this government is going to do it's going to have public transport on the sabbath which is something that victor lieberman is very keen on it's going to allow municipal rabbis to do conversion marriage which at the moment is centralized in the rabbinate um which i think what else basically everyone every party as i said has an agreement with um with yeshetid but according to these guidelines the one uh agreement which actually stands sovereign to all other agreements is the one between yoshito and yamina whatever it says in there if there's any contradiction in the separate uh agreements that's the one that counts and naftali bennett certainly has a veto uh by both sides uh avobito uh yelpid and natalie bennett on on many of these issues economically
12:36 there's going to be quite a lot of uh reforms i think to eliminate the finance minister has pledged not to raise taxes um he's pledged uh it came out tonight that up until now there's uh there's a a system during coronavirus where you would get paid without work as i'm sure they had in many other countries around the world and there's a big debate exactly when that should finish because the economy is pretty much starting to get back on its feet but there's a lot of people are still taking advantage of that especially uh amongst younger whereas a lot of uh jobs are just not being filled they're restaurants that can't open because they can't fill their so um he's already evitable has already been in to meet the staff in the finance and a decision that has apparently been made that anyone under 45 will only have another three weeks of paid vacation and then it's back to work um so there's a lot a lot of uh new decisions we've made as i said on
13:39 some of the weightier diplomatic and security issues those will probably take uh take a back seat there are still other issues that need to be worked out mikhaili who's going from the labour party is going to be transportation ministers apparently angling for control over transportation judea and samaria something that uh is supposed to be the within the scope of the defense uh ministry and certainly something that you mean a right-wing party and you hope uh would not like to see they wouldn't like to see a left-wing uh transportation minister uh getting involved with these issues because obviously they have less sympathy to it so they have to still work out some of the wording there um but it seems like uh we have a coalition on the way and it really is just a matter of crossing the t's and dotting the eyes at this point and on friday these coalition agreements will be handed into the knesset i'm sure the liquid will put out as many negative messages as possible over anything that they can get their hands on
14:42 but they only have 48 hours because on it's it's the decision time if the change government can bring every single member 61 votes then we will have a new government and we will for the first time in 12 years have a new prime minister as i said the likelihood of that happening i think at this point is 95 one never knows and as i've repeatedly said over uh many months if not uh longer you never bet against baby but if this moment in time it doesn't seem like he had to there's too many cards left and with that i'm happy to open it up any questions all right thank you so much so the first question we have in is from kenneth brahmowitz do you think the supreme court might not allow this new government coalition to form as it violates the basic laws by allowing an arab party to that the national anthem and does not accept an undivided jerusalem um well basically that's all worked out whether they can run
15:45 all parties have to sign on to a basic declaration that they accept that israel the nature of israel is a jewish and democratic state and there are certain arab parties who in the past have held their nose and signed on in fact there's probably quite a lot of language in there that even the ultra orthodox parties will have a problem with but if they've been allowed to run then at this point there's no there's no problem with them that usually is worked out before the and there have been some individuals who have not been able to run because they did not meet the criteria in fact i believe the only ones that have ever not been able to wonders on the jewish on the far right jewish side um but those are details which i i don't believe that there's anyone who's even called this into question on that particular point of view um it would be you know because a lot has come out over the last few days um about about liquids negotiations with ron so
16:46 it's everything basically the bottom line is everything that ron will get from bennett according to all sources uh netanyahu offered them far more and if the religious zionist party had uh to allow netanyahu to use ram as a as a party to support the government the outside that's that's the government that we would now be uh witnessing so i think that's uh probably too late and i haven't heard uh that the supreme court is taking up this thank you from reuben hawk assuming the change government is sworn in on sunday what would be the considerations for enacting a law preventing an individual who is under criminal indictment from or serving as prime minister um or that that particular law almost certainly will not be uh put up yamino have said that they're not looking to pass any laws to buy any particular individual uh from for office what is probably going to be enacted at some point is a law that a prime minister can only serve two
17:48 terms or eight years whichever is longer uh to ensure that there isn't this uh sort of seemingly everlasting situation we have the same prime uh for for more than that amount of time uh that would be relatively unprecedented in parliamentary uh but that's probably the most that we'll see on that issue i don't see it there are many parties in that coalition who would want to pass exactly that law but i think yamino will veto that they don't want to be seen uh they've talked a lot about it so one never knows but they don't want to be seen as passing any laws which are specific to any one person especially in the tenure understood thank you we have a few different phrasing of this question but what do you think the new government will change do you think the new government will change things in religion and if so which ones in religion of state yes that area we will see quite a there's this thing in israel called the status quo and religion states which the idea
18:50 is that things uh don't move one way or another but that's absurd anyone who's seen the situation since the 80s with the advent of shas and and their growing power there is no census quote it keeps on moving further and further towards the uh population uh but any time anyone wants to move it back a little bit even to the pre-80s situation uh we hear these shouts of status quo status quo so it's it's an absurd statement that there is anything that looks like status quo in um but it certainly is a large majority who would like to shake things up in that particular respect we've heard a lot in in recent weeks about that they're going to follow the line of that sahara organization so organization is a is an orthodox organization some may call it a liberal orthodox organization what it wants to do is take away uh the monopoly from the chief rabbinate or the rabbinate on issues like conversion like marriage and divorce
19:52 and on casualty on kosher at the moment unless you have a certificate from the rabbin hood your restaurant will not be cannot even use the word kosher that's how absurd the situation is so zohar has started giving certificates but they can't use the word kosher so they've come up with all these clever ways around it so it's a relatively absurd situation uh so there is an idea to liberalize this to take away the monopoly of the uh of the official revenant and also try and replace some of these national state institutions with religious zionists what some would call in the west modern rabbis and leaders are taken away from the ultra-orthodox uh parties and political control so i think uh we'll see quite a lot there there is talk about things like uh allowing though there was a law passed uh over the last year i come in exactly when it was called the mini markets law which basically didn't allow many markets to open
20:54 on the sabbath that's something which uh is talked about uh to be repealed uh there is talk uh something that avitor lehman would like to see and quite a few other parties is public transports on the sabbath because uh you know there's no rule against breaking the sabbath in israel but if you don't have public transport all you're doing is punishing people without i'm achieving the weaker elements of society um so that's something that uh we also might see if it changed but again we'll have to see don't forget yamina still does think of itself as a religious party um so it will toe the line to a certain extent there's that's certainly going to be a you know a point of attention and we'll certainly see the ultra orthodox parties are certainly worried about this undoubtedly they're extremely extremely worried about losing their monopoly and also maybe the stipends to their yeshiva students another thing that avigdor lieberman and yale appeared and others are very strong on is ensuring that every school israel which receives some sort of
21:58 government stipends has to teach basic secular subjects like english like maths at this point in time that is not the case but that's something that uh coalition agreements at least the latest version that we've seen uh are going to address so um these are some of the things which are at least in the draft uh coalition negotiations we've seen thank you and along those lines uh michael kerbel asks will the new government require the hurriedi to serve in the idf or some type of national so another thing that's come up and don't forget this was the thing that really started this whole cycle if we remember back after the first elections the reason we didn't have a government it was because there was no compromise uh on this law that was written uh by the defense ministry officials when evita lima's defense minister which was a really low level uh integration for the ultra orthodox into the army and it was something the
23:01 ultra orthodox would not move on habitat even considered himself at that point compromising or and that was remember if we remember that was the the point for him that was the red line and he didn't enter that government and then we went for another election and another election and ironically now we're back to that point and it seems like uh that is going to be a law um it's not an overly burdensome law as i said it's a very low level of integration the number there's a series of numbers which escalate each year but again we're talking about relatively low numbers that the ultra orthodox almost already meets so it's more of a principle for the ultra orthodox then suddenly every ultra-orthodox student is going to be pulled off into the army that's not going to happen that's not on the table but the principle that there will be numbers that have to be met every year according to this law that that's something which uh seems like it will be
24:03 certainly happening in the next thank you from eric selkov how do you think the new government will engage biden it's a good question as i said those kind of issues the issues of the palestinians and peace is going to be very tricky if it comes up because as as we know we have on one side uh gideon-san naftali who are against the two-state solution we have a victory and you're certainly uh not necessarily against it in principle but certainly skeptical uh gans and lapid in the middle and then you have uh the labor party marist on the left and wrong so how you can try and navigate that issue with all these disparate views is going to be very very difficult but it depends how much room uh the biden administration give them it could be an opportunity for the biden to try and push them into it don't forget they they're familiar with all these figures any gans
25:05 defence minister he was in the u.s this week to meet with his contemporary and mostly talk about the iran deal and security issues but still these are not new faces necessary for the american administration or many of the people in relatively new america administration um but as far as moving ahead on the palestinian issue there's been a big about what will be included in that coalition agreement because again you have to find language which will suit everybody and that's going to be very difficult it'll be very interesting to see what in the end comes out on friday in this coalition agreements on that um but i think the relationship will be will be good i think uh there's certainly a lot of mistrust between many officials in the administration which are leftovers from the obama administration which certainly did not have a good relationship with the netanyah administration so i think there'll be a certain amount of uh you know a new page uh being drawn between the two sides um and if the bible administration still has this sort of hands-off
26:08 uh approach to the palestinian uh peace talks then i don't think there'll be too many problems between them obviously everyone maybe except for the far left rahm i don't know iran's position on this are pretty much in line with netanyahu and the iran agreements the jcpoa at least the vast majority so on that issue israel's stance will will certainly not change visibly the mighty administration thank you for that uh from jack mckay if netanyahu is legally exonerated how will that change the political dynamic well legally exonerated that probably be seen one way or another for a number of years this court case is going to go on for years each case has hundreds of witnesses both sides have to go through the witnesses i think we're still on the first witness weeks later of the first case and they're still hunters to go so this is going to go on for years and then we could have appeals by either side so that's not going to happen for a while that's certainly not relevant for this
27:10 particular period of time i'm interested in from eric belkov uh what will happen to netanyahu after the new government takes over that's that's a good question my feeling is from what i'm hearing he will stay on uh he won't resign he'll become officially leader of the opposition and my particular feeling is he'll become a very bullish opposition really taking any opportunities to try and snipe at the i think he'll feel that there's an opportunity within the year to try and bring it down or maybe it will just self-destruct one never knows as i said there are some optimists in this government who believe that it could last for over two years especially once they get the budget out of the way my particular feeling is i wouldn't if i had money i wouldn't bet on it lasting more than a year but one never knows um and netanyahu can then present himself as an alternative when we next go to the polls it could be
28:12 that there is some movement within the liquid we see tonight or tomorrow night nearby cut is having a mega event thousands of people spending a lot of money bringing in some top israeli entertainers apparently feeding i guess very very nicely it's a show of force nearby cut is seen as the most likely um contender to netanyahu he said at this point in pretty much every uh they could uh you know big week has said that uh they're not looking to replace him at this point but certainly there's there's a lot of grievances within the liquid there's especially much the uh the more popular elements uh they're not happy about the fact that they're sitting in the opposition they feel that if netanyahu himself would have stood aside rather than offering everybody else and every other party after bennett to be first in rotation uh they felt that maybe he should have given that rotation someone else and then he could and then they wouldn't be sitting in the opposition there would have been no other excuse for get on naftali bennett to go with the change uh so there's no love lost there and and
29:15 they are looking for opportunities uh julie edelstein has been rumored to also be one uh who may challenge netanyahu i feel that netanyahu will probably try and show this up sooner rather than later while he's still relatively popular because the longer he sits the opposition probably the the weaker he'll look um so there is some talk that he won't need he doesn't need officially to face any leadership race until i believe 2025. uh i'm not 100 sure exactly how that works out but netanyahu is a strategist he knows how to stay ahead of his competitors so don't write him off yet and i have said to a few people this week i would not bet against seeing benjamin netanyahu back in the prime minister's residence at some point in the future well on that note i guess we'll be asking people to tune in next week to see what happens uh we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this
30:18 and thank you all for joining us and have a great day