Webinar or Talk
"Israel's Urban War in Gaza: A Technical Analysis" with John Spencer
Watch on YouTube
Description
John Spencer, a leading expert on urban warfare, has made four trips to observe the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza since Oct. 7, 2023, during which he has studied both its efficacy and its morality. Putting the IDF’s conduct in a larger perspective, he asks fundamental questions: How has it fared compared to other Western armies? What are the special circumstances in Gaza? From an ethical point of view, how does the IDF rank?
John Spencer has advised senior U.S. Army leaders, including four-star generals. A former infantry soldier and commander, Spencer served in the US Army for 25 years, during which he undertook two combat deployments to Iraq. He is the chair of Urban Warfare Studies at West Point. He has published three books, most recently, Understanding Urban Warfare, (Howgate Publishing, 2022), and many articles. Since October 7, he has written and spoken extensively on the ongoing Israel-Hamas war. He holds a BA from Arizona State University and an MA from Georgetown University.
You can follow John Spencer on X at @spencerguard.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:08 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums weekly podcast series my name is Anna Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion since October 7th of 2023 the Israeli Defense Forces have engaged in a targeted and meticulous military campaign against Hamas in the Gaza Strip a densely populated Urban battle ble field in which militants have embedded themselves deep within the civilian infrastructure across the Metropolis how is the Ida fared compared to other Western militaries what special circumstances make this war unique and from an ethical point of view how does the IDF rank joining us to discuss all of this is Mr John Spencer a leading expert on Urban Warfare who has made several trips to observe the IDF in action since October 7th Mr Spencer a former Infantry Soldier and Commander has served in the US Army for 25 years and he's currently the chair of urban Warfare studies at West Point he's published three books and countless articles and book chapters and
1:11 throughout his career he has advised senior US Army leaders including four star generals Mr Spencer will speak for 15 minutes followed by a 15minute Q&A session from the audience and with that I will turn the floor over to Mr John Spencer welcome John thank you thank you for having me so it's hard to go back in time but I think it's necessary to have a discussion on the war in Gaza Israel's war against Hamas and Gaza how are the framework you want to use which started on October 7th from a analytical perspective of the war on October 7th roughly 3,000 Hamas militants Palestinian Islamic Jihad terrorist and Gaz and civilians invaded Southern Israel and killed over 1,00 Israelis kidnapped 250 from multiple nationalities and then murdered raped burned killed
2:16 civilians lots of details on that day and the the scale of it the number of penetrations on Israel's border wall with Gaza but from an analytical perspective of the war it begun the war and on October 8th Israel declared war a war of self-defense against Hamas in Gaza Hamas being the political apparatus with a military Wing in a military of Gaza a self-governed area of terrain which really plays into effect of analysis of the war and what were the challenges the actions of the idea against Hamas in the war once Hamas in those who joined Hamas withdrew into Gaza with the 250 plus hostages it became one of the greatest military challenges of the modern era what where it's very hard if not inappropriate to compare it to anything else just on the
3:20 variables that I will discuss on the context of the war so in the war Israel's war against tamas with three stated goals return the illegally taken hostages destroy hamas's military capabilities remove Hamas as a goverment authority of Gaza and secure Israel's borders and prevent you know Hamas or any other group from Gaza from being able to do another attack against Israel and into Israel territory the the actual technical or I would say contextual information is very important to be able to do comparisons So within Gaza on the opening moments of October 7th there were also 4,000 rockets in the opening hours launched from Gaza towards Israeli civilian sites all of them being um inaccurate as in not able to actually determine where they're going but there were thousands of more Rockets so you had Rockets emanating out of enemy territory at this point you had the 250 plus
4:25 hostages Gaza is a very dense piece of terrain 200 is 25 miles long 5 to seven miles wide with 24 cities 10 cities of over 100,000 Gaza City over 600,000 highly dense portions of Gaza highly dense populated areas but from a military context and why it's really hard to compare in in the history of urban Warfare is that Hamas the governing authority of Gaza since 2005 also spent over a billion dollars just in their tunnel complex range of over 350 mil some some estimates are higher of military only purposed tunnels underneath the urban areas of Gaza ranging from just underneath buildings to over 200 feet underground it was not just that investment but every aspect of the environment of Gaza was prepared by Hamas for war for over 20 years basically since They seized power in 20
5:31 7 but before then as well even during um Israel's occupation of Gaza Hamas was building tunnels and preparing from a military analysis that's something very unique and really hard to compare in history is when the enemy is in the Urban Terrain and has prepared it for defense matter of fact most of the urban Battles of History are where the defender has had little amount of time and the more more amount of time that they've had to prepare the defense the greater the battle the more protracted the more destructive it is and many of the big biggest battles of urban Warfare history like Stalingrad or orona or others were essentially meeting engagements where two militaries met in the Urban Terrain unique to let's say where somebody might say the 21st century which is really trying to dramatize the history of War even in the past 20 years some of the biggest battles were because
6:34 of that nature of the defender having time to prepare the biggest battle for the US military in the entire Iraq war was the Second Battle of fuia over this small city of 300,000 but where the enemy was given about 6 months to prepare for the battle that would ensue the biggest battle since World War II before the invasion of the Ukraine war was the Battle of mou which was a 9month battle to take back the city from Isis of 3 to 5,000 Isis Fighters and the reason it was the biggest battle since World War II with over 100,000 security Force Iraqi Security Forces used to take the city back is because Isis had two years and prepared it for defense so when you extrapolate that out to the conditions of the cities of Gaza especially those bigger ones like Gaza City you have 20 years of preparation where you have every step you take there's a tunnel underneath you every house essentially
7:37 has been militarized or most houses where they have cachets or House born IEDs or sniper positions the amount of preparation can't be discounted when trying to compare this to other situations also the enemy's context really matters so not just what Hamas did on October 7th but how does it fight how does it prepare for defending Urban Terrain and fighting the IDF and what strategies does it use hamas's strategy was is not to fight the IDF but to cause what is historical in Israel's Wars for the International Community to Halt Israel before achieving a victory even after the horrific crimes of October 7th so Hamas historically even has been use example that I teach in classes of using a human shield strategy where it violates the laws of war and uses protected populations like civilians and
8:39 protected sites hospitals schools mosque un buildings and uses them for military purposes trying to use the protections afforded to those buildings or populations so that the attacker cannot attack them and must use other methods and complicates the operations it's a violation of War but it's called human shield strategy where you're putting something in front of you so the enemy can't attack you Hamas did that and prepared every basically every hospital every school and every and used it for military purposes in some way but Hamas also uses a human sacrifice strategy unlike again comparing this to even 20th century or World War II World War I where Hamas both States and acts that it needs its civilians to die will put its civilians In Harm's Way will not allow civilians into protective tunnels that they use that's human sacrifice strategy into where Hamas leaders will say I need
9:42 the death of the my population which is a very unique aspect to get to the conduct of so that's all the variables on from day one from October 7th Rockets coming in and if anybody's ever been to Israel and Gaza their proximity Rockets coming into Israel hostages every second counting the preparation of the environment from the enemy the enemy strategy it's political strategy which is to use international pressure to force Israel to stop before achieving its goals to to create these ideals this is also a war being fought unlike other Wars of the past in the global eye of algorithm driven social media which really changes things even if I take you battles of modern history if you're talking the 2017 Battle of moari 2016 Battle of mul 200 you raqqa Aleppo the battles of fuia ramadi others where you have media coverage but this is the
10:48 first war of this scale and intensity where you have cell phone driven social media driven algorithm driven condemnation or footage and then all different experts which really gets to you know all war is a contest of will so when this war started it was you know hamas's will to believe that it could achieve its goal of conducting the October 7th attack and maintaining power and surviving as a political and military organization of the war the contest of Wills Is fought both locally of course between Israel and Hamas and Israel's population in a Democratic Society against Hamas and its population of being basically governed ruthlessly but the influence through social media of the population of the world where we've seen to include people that we would consider experts try to convince people on top of the social
11:51 media driven algorithm footage photos reports studies that Israel was from day one conducting some type of illegal operation and this is where we into basically the metrics so the conditions that Israel had the capabilities that Israel had to enter Gaza to retrieve its hostages to remove hamas's military capabilities vast military capabilities Hamas on October 6th was a political organization with a military of roughly 30 if not up to 50,000 militants spread across the Gaza Strip in 24 organized battalions with Brigade leaders Battalion company with uh 20,000 rocket supplies each Battalion owning defensive terrain a vast capability the actual condemnation though when Israel had to enter that
12:53 terrain like historical examples which would be a very destructive War based on just the nature of the complexity of dense Urban Warfare when the defender can't be convinced to surrender or flee or other examples we've seen in this war people try to use the numbers to justify their opinions about the war and what's called condemnation so the law of war and I saw it from day one on analyzing this war and I have now been to Gaza with observing the IDF operations across the spectrum of their operations from interviewing the Prime Minister the chief of the IDF all Brigade commanders Battalion commanders IDF soldiers in the field assessing their performance their capabilities their actions in the war no matter what I tell people on that it absolutely is a moral ethical disciplined Force achieving unique
13:59 things in the most complex Urban scenario that any military has faced in modern history if not history given of course Wars are fought under the context of the times in which they are fought that is also the laws of war the geopolitical aspects all of those elements a challenge nobody to face and achieving incredible means in in their pursuit of just execution of the war everybody agrees they had a just reason to defend themselves well most do but we've become in this world where we we believe that the numbers justify without an access to information and this is where the law of War especially things proportionality require any military to assess the military Advantage the concrete military advantage of their operations against the potential collateral damage and then take all reasonable and feasible measures to
15:02 limit that damage that's called precaution since in this war we've seen everybody who who has an opinion who really hasn't done research try to use numbers to say I don't care what the laws says I don't care what the IDF have done this number means that they're intentionally causing civilian harm and can intentionally destroying civilian infrastructure when that's not true and that's not the way the law War works this is where I've been I've said statements like Israel has done more and implemented more measures to prevent civilian harms than any military in the history of urban Warfare which is very controversial but factual because of the fact of when Israel entered Gaza what are the known ways to limit civilian harms both on strike policies evacuating cities limiting the use of force handing out your Ms to communicate with the civilians all of these measures that maybe we'll talk about in
16:04 questions this effects-based condemnation or trying to convince the world what the laws of war say how they're different in different contexts of Rules of Engagement has been really problematic in providing technical analysis of Israel's performance in Gaza all right well thank you for your insights John uh on that note regarding the uh effects-based condemnation here one question that is often brought up as you mention typically by adversaries of Israel is a question of Civilian to combatant ratios in these operations now you have served in combat tours in Iraq how does the conduct and the CIVC ratio of the idfs operation vary from those of American operations in say Iraq or Afghanistan so it's I play these numbers or I don't play the numbers I I provide the numbers from a case study perspective so yes I can give you case studies of uh us-backed operations and the operations of missou where again the
17:07 problem is in the numbers and this measure of what is your civilian to combatant ratio isn't how the laws of war or even analysis of individual military operations is done but it became something that the media and Advocates used to try to portray some type of legality intention actions that the number was higher and no it wasn't one the numbers are not true especially from day one the world started taking the numbers provided by the designated terrorist organization by 20 different countries Hamas the Gaza Health Ministry started putting out numbers of this is our estimate of civilians and they do not distinguish between civilians and combatants or non-combatants and combatants and most people need a class on what is a non-combatant in war that is somebody who is a protected person who is not partaking in the hostilities in any way and then what is the combatant is
18:11 definitely a member of hamas's military Wing whether no matter what they're doing but also anybody who's partaking in the hostilities yes in certain parts of the war if you compare to any like scenario although I just went through a very long detail there is no like scenario Israel's Civ ion to combatant ratio is still historically low given any comparable context whether it's high-intensity operations in the battle mul fuia rqa Aleppo moari Manila all of these but it's really essential that people understand that this these are just forms of lies damn lies and statistics these are people taking a number without context and saying look this proves this proves it look how how many combatants has the Gaza Health Ministry ever declared were killed zero how many it took Israel about six months to come up with a number and that is very hard to do I can tell you as an urban Warfare researcher there's never
19:14 been a war or battle because there's a big difference where anybody could tell you daily down to the single digit how many civilians or combatants were dying that is so ridiculous that somebody believe that Hamas the Gaza Health Minister could tell you every day and the way and not ask the question well how did they develop that number is it from bodies coming into hospitals that started that way is it self-reported missing Personnel is it this is it the numbers have been very analyzed but I don't like because it isn't the it falls into that effects based condemnation yes if we took the numbers and compared it to any like scenario it is historically low but I don't want people especially in the future of War saying look I know you had the right to defend yourself but what's your civilian to combatant ratio in this scenario that's not the way the law the law of War works or war in general right thank you now uh of course
20:17 the media likes to uh run with these inflated numbers provided by the uh Gaza Ministry of Health or Hamas really but uh can you explain why International organizations like the UN the ICC or the icj who should be tasked with enforcing International humanitarian law why is it that they are so reluctant to uh point out hamas's lack of distinction between uniformed soldiers combatants non-combatants their embedding of civilians with or excuse me combatants within civilian infrastructures uh why why are they So Silent on that it's a really great question and I've asked this multiple times just as a an objective and despite what people think and I'm not Jewish I'm not Israeli I'm a war researcher as an injective observer but also watching Wars beyond the Israel Gaza or Israel Hamas War watching the Ukraine war watching other Wars throughout history watching these politicized organizations decide
21:20 on which side they're going to advocate for you're right the United Nations a whole host of United Nations Affiliated organizations do not condemn in at all not even from barely from October 7th but especially in the execution of the war hamas's use of human shield strategy weaponization of all the hospitals schools M their own population what they do to their own population I can't tell you why I can I can point to many of the reasons um from a really there are some good intentioned human rights activists who have now Authority and positions of some credibility you have an anti-israel cohort within that you have an anti-western cohort within that you have an anti-war cohort but this especially within the United Nations which is a political organization by its very nature and its history of thoughts opinions statements votes towards Israel
22:24 is very problematic but within the objective context of Hamas to say things only on one side it needs to be called out I can't answer why like when you say hospitals are off limits which is not a true statement in in war and I've been vocal on that absolutely hospitals their staff the wounded everybody protected population but for the enemy or anybody to use it for military purposes is the violation the violation is not moving forward and removing military personnel and military equipment and all this from protected sites but all these organizations not one call for Hamas to surrender to unilaterally unconditionally give up the hostages stop violating the law of war in the way it's executing its side of the war I can't answer why but I can definitely say it is 100% a valid question all right thank you now uh now on that note uh everyone seems as you point out to
23:28 use uh casualty figures and uh you know proportionality measures to determine who's in the right and who's in the wrong but uh how different would this war look if Israel didn't have the defensive capabilities that it has like the Iron Dome or David sling Etc yeah that's also very important question I thought you were GNA ask me how different would this look had it happened with a different Nation like the United States um with different capabilities uh you're right the defensive capabilities of Israel especially for the anti-rocket you know Iron Dome David sling other aspects uh when you see that Hamas launched you know 13 to plus thousand Rockets had Israel not had those defensive capabilities in this war tens of thousands of Israelis but this also gets into what I call Rocket diplomacy that that negates the violation it's the same thing when the Islamic regime of Iran launched historic level of ballistic and cruise missiles
24:31 against Israel to then say well Israel is so strong and has invested so heavily in its defensive capabilities it didn't harm anybody no no this intention and action can't count for only one side intention and action absolutely all of those rockets that Hamas and others Palestinian Islamic Jihad and others which many of those Landing inside of Gaza killing gazan and adding to the ratios those Rockets are not discriminate they do not know where their exact target they're going every one of those 13,000 plus Rockets are a violation of the law of War but you're right if Israel hadn't invested billions of dollars in its defense those Rockets would have killed thousands and thousands tens of thousands if you know the proximity of the ground that we're talking about even from to Tel Aviv to Jerusalem from Tel it would have caused tens of thousands of deaths for sure thank you now uh now of course you
25:34 are not a Hamas Commander or Hamas official but uh on the other side of that question it seems like these tactics that Hamas uses of employing human Shields and human sacrifices seem to be largely defensive now what would the case what would the conflict look like if instead of these sort of ragtag uh rockets and missiles and some of these low LEL missiles from Iran they had the same or similar capabilities as a modern military great question also would look greatly different um all Warfare is asymmetric so there's no world where two peer enemies fight each other you know in the open field using their their match strengths like all Warfare is asymmetric and why we've seen an increase in urban Warfare around the globe is because of weaker forces believing and knowing they can get an advantage to pull an advanced military into Urban Terrain so and the goals matter right so Israel has fought
26:39 many wars against Hamas and Gaza but the the goals of the wars like stopping the Rockets is being the goal reducing hamas's rocket capabilities has been the goals but in a war where the goal is to remove the enemy military's capabilities you have you can't do that strictly through bombing you have to enter the enemy's territory and take those capabilities away in the dense Urban environment we call it the great equalizer for a reason there are nuances there is that it will negate even the most powerful military of the world's capabilities and if you prepared it for 20 years it will definitely challenge the military no matter their capability and in war sometimes it isn't about killing the other again war is a contest of will matter of fact sunzo said you know the greatest form of war is to win without fighting and this contest of Wheels within International politicians everything Hamas built this environment not to win but to delay so that the
27:42 international condemnation as we saw will build so greatly that it will constrain Israel it will stop Israel or anybody else there was a different way for Israel to do this operation 100% And historically I would have said in order to do this and not just John Spencer but generals like General Mark Milly who was the US joint chief of staff for two presidents said that absolutely the us would have done this differently we would have used more combat power to try to end it quicker because that's what you want to do fighting protracted Block byblock House by house Wars like we've seen is highly destructive and leads to what we've seen the questioning of the goals the questioning of the ability to achieve the goals and now the criticism of the military like you could have done it a different way absolutely you could have done it with more Force to make the enemy in this case Hamas believe that you don't have a chance of winning and
28:43 unfortunately within the political context of this war many nations have sent Hamas messages and the United Nations just hold out you can win and we will stop Israel all right thank you uh I think we have time for maybe one more here now um typically we are used to seeing Hamas Fighters equipped with kalashnikovs and AKs more recently we're seeing footage and images emerging of militants using American M16s and m4s do you know where they're sourcing these weapons from no I've seen that and actually when I observed the equipment that dead Hamas and others left in Israel during the October 7th attack it ranged from Russian North Korean Iran Ian so the global arms sales and where the US weapons are given or like in Afghanistan left um that isn't indicative to me of something different than absolutely um we should be questioning how Hamas built this vast
29:48 arsenal of rockets Munitions you name it and how it got those in in the so-called blockade that Israel and evidently Egypt has been imposing on Gaza but that that specific about us weapons um is not surprising on the global smuggling of of weapons and and where they come from all right well thank you very much we have uh unfortunately reached the end of our podcast for the week I want to thank you again John for taking the time to join us on such a interesting topic thanks for having me of course now for our viewers and listeners is there somewhere that you could direct them if they'd like to follow more of your work sure I mean all most of my work uh I just released a really important podcast on my Urban Warfare project podcast that they can get anywhere they find their podcast about this topic of legitimacy laws of war Rules of Engagement that's a really great source and then uh John Spencer online.com is where I hang most of my Publications that I I produce all right very good now for those of you
30:52 watching in the future on YouTube I will be sure to link those in the video description below uh if you don't already please be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel and you can also follow the Middle East Forum podcast on Spotify Amazon Apple music and uh most platforms where you follow podcasts as always we thank you again for taking the time to join us and for your participation I hope you all have a wonderful day and a safe and joyous weekend thanks