Webinar or Talk
"Jamaat-e-Islami: A Threat at Home and Abroad?" with Sam Westrop and Cliff Smith | Ep. #09
Watch on YouTube
Description
Sam Westrop and Cliff Smith talk about the global influence of South Asia’s most prominent Islamist movement and its connections to terrorism here in the United States.
Filmed on April 15, 2020.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 13, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 Right. Hello. It's one o'clock. Um, hello and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series. I'm Stacy McKenna and I will be moderating this discussion today. We are pleased to have Cliff Smith, director of the Washington Project and Sam Westrop, director of Islamist Watch, join us to discuss Jamaat Islami, a threat to Americans. Mr. Smith and Mr. Westerrop will speak for roughly 5 to 10 minutes, then open it up for questions. Should you wish to ask a question, please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen. We will do our best to get to all questions, but we have many participants on this webinar. So, I apologize in advance if we do not get to yours today.
0:36 And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr. Cliff Smith and Mr. Sam Wester. Hello. Um in previous webinars and in fact in articles and reports that Islamist watch has published over the last few years we have tried to make one thing very clear and that is that Islam and Islamism in the west is not a single homogeneous block. It is very diverse with many competing components which sometimes spend more times fighting each other than than the outside world. uh and within the world of of nonviolent or or lawful Islamism, groups active in the west that are advancing their ideology through generally lawful means there is that same diversity that is that there is that same array of of differing views and ideas. Now, one of the problems with counterlism analysis in in not just this country but around the western world has been an obsession with a group called the Muslim Brotherhood. And the Muslim Brotherhood exists and is dangerous. Um, but because of that obsession, other
1:41 groups have flourished uh under the lack of spotlight. And no group has flourished quite so well and so successfully as Jamati Islam um a South Asian Islamist organization uh founded in the 1940s and very active here in the US. There are, as I mentioned, many different groups to focus and worry about, but Jamaat is perhaps one of the most egregious, one of the most dangerous because it mixes terror elements with a powerful ability to affect change here in the west using western politics, western courts, western media. Uh, it is a multifaceted organization uh that has proven itself able to advance its sinister ideology, advance its iniquitous ideas uh in many different fields. Uh and until about a few year or two ago, very few in America had heard of the group uh very few were concentrating on its effects and the damage it uh is able to cause. Uh Cliff I think will explain a little bit more about it its history. Cliff, hello everyone. Uh yeah, Sam, thanks for
2:50 that introduction. Um Jamaati Swami was founded in British India. So that's India while it was still under British rule before it was partitioned into Pakistan before Bangladesh existed and it was founded by a man named Abdullah al- Madudi. Um Madudi was very similar in many ways to the ideologues um the radical ideologues of the Middle East such as Hassan Albana and the Muslim Brotherhood. But in many ways he was actually more innovative and more effective than they were particularly in his time. um he admittedly by his own in his own words believed Islam was a non-conventional religion and instead was a quote unquote revolutionary ideology that called for an international revolutionary party. So which he then went about establishing that being Jamaati Islami. Um he had many starts and stops. He had he had a lot of hiccups and a lot of um but a lot of success too including not only in British India at the time which was not too long after he founded it partitioned
3:52 into India and Pakistan but um also across the world really. Um, famously he corresponded quite a bit with Sed Kotub. Saied Kotub as anybody that follows um, modern events for the past 20 years knows was one of the chief theologians responsible for inspiring Osama bin Laden. But um, while Sed Kotub has gotten so much of the um, publicity and the fame, the truth of the matter is Madudi was probably more influential on Kotib than Kotib was on um, on him. So when we talk about the success of Abdul Almadudi um you have to realize just how um universal his writings and thoughts and organizational structures were on radical Islam. It wasn't just in South Asia. Anyhow he was not um he didn't have a particularly strong opinion on the petition of India as he viewed basically you know the entire system is corrupt. But once Pakistan and India separated, he became a very very big
4:55 oning to control Pakistan and make it into a Islamist government which he had worked from the very beginning to do. um all and then of course as he gained influence in Pakistan that became very influ very a big deal a uh seismic impact on how they [clears throat] handled their politics including to the creation of Bangladesh which is a very big event in Jamaati Islam's history can talk a little bit more about that so 1971 Bangladeshies were fighting for their independence from Pakistan and the Pakistani military in an effort to suppress the the academics the intellectuals the students, the protesters turned to Jamaati Islami to help them uh and help them violently.
5:40 Jamati Islami was part of of many different killing squads which went around the country murdering uh in huge number, thousands, tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands uh Bangladeshi women, men, children. Um some of the leaders of these killing squads were pretty prominent Jamati Islami students. after the war ended and the new found Bangladesh was established. Um these Jamaati Islami leaders fled um many some many fled to Pakistan some fled to the west um and when they fled to the west they did not give up their Islamism they did not give up their ideology uh they set up new branches. So in the United Kingdom, a man called Cho Muadin who was part of the Alba killing squad uh um he set up a group called Muslim A today one of the largest Islamic charities uh still today tied closely to Jumati Islami. He set up a number of community groups too. And here in the US uh Ashraf Zan Khan uh another albada killing squad leader uh became closely involved in the Islamic
6:45 circle of North America. the most important representation of Jumati Islami in America and identified by some as one of the key branches of Jamaati Islami in the world today. Uh now Jamaat in America especially Jamati Islami Pakistan and Jamaat Islami India uh uh branches are yes best represented most keenly represented through IKna the Islamic circle of North America and IKna is a hub for all sorts of dramatic activities. It's not just one group. For a start, it has local chapters all across the country. But it also runs several charities. It has IKNA relief, its domestic aid charity. It has helping hand for relief and development. It's international, it's foreign aid, it's humanitarian aid charity. It has young Muslims, a youth group uh that indoctrinates young Muslims through study circles and various religious activities. It has uh gain peace and why Islam groups that aim to proitize uh uh bring more people into not into the Islamic fold but into the Islamist fold into the jamaati Islami fold. Um INA is an all-encompassing organization that
7:48 seeks to provide social and religious services across the US to as many different Muslim communities and non-Muslims as well. And as part of that um they receive government funds. The INCA relief has received $10 million from the federal government between 2016 and 2018 and and note those dates. That's under a Trump administration. Um uh helping hand for relief and development has been praised on various government websites. Um uh and you know across the country officials will find themselves praised by local counselors uh by local politicians. The city of New York gave IKNA a grant to host religious services which you would have thought would be a challenge to separation of church and state uh several years ago.
8:34 So there's the IKNA has intertwined itself with local politics um with international aid programs with domestic aid programs. As I say this is a a powerful a powerful force. Now, as part of its work within the Muslim community, it runs one of the largest conferences that the Muslim community has each year. Uh, and does that in collaboration with a group called the Muslim American Society, which is more traditionally linked to the Muslim Brotherhood. Uh, it runs these conferences at which tens of thousands attend. Very prominent politicians speak. I believe Bernie Sanders was slated to speak at uh uh uh one such conference. Um, although that ended up not going ahead. um the uh power they have to uh uh organize themselves the face of American Muslims is huge and politicians recognize that as such and attend their conferences. Um but it's not just about uh the the the radicalizing America's Muslim community.
9:27 They're also funding uh Jamaati Islami efforts abroad. So as I mentioned helping hand for relief and development is IKNA's overseas arm and the money it raises is spent enormous amount of it a large proportion of it is spent in Pakistan and a couple of years ago we caught helping hand for relief and development working with two front organizations for Lashkarat Taiba the Pakistani terrorist organization responsible for the 2008 Mumbai attacks. We caught them working together. They ran a conference together in a in a Pakistani city. This was an open collaboration. is a shameless collaboration and we suspect it's just the tip of the iceberg and certainly we can see that helping hand partners closely with very key Jamati Islami proxies across Pakistan including groups tied to terror like the al-qidmat foundation the charitable arm of Jamati Islami which openly funds mass which openly is tied to his bulajin the paramilitary wing of jamati Islami so the American jamati Islami movement while it's tied very carefully
10:30 into lawful activities here in the US. It's also still funding unlawful violent activities overseas. And and just two examples I'll very quickly mention. I'm speaking to you today from Boston uh and about uh 20 miles from me is a group called the Islamic Center of New England. Very prominent mosque and for many years helping hand for relief and development has run events there. Uh NA has run events there. It is a an important mosque for Jamaata activities in New England. The Imam in the 2000s was a man called uh Hafi Muhammad Massud and he it turned out is the brother of Hafi Muhammad Sah the leader of Lashkar Taiba. And when this was pointed out in the 2000s, Muhammad Masoud says, "Oh yes, he is my brother, but I share nothing in common with him. I have no no links to his his terrorism. I I I repudiate I reject his ideology and every everyone believed him. The media believed him. Local politicians believed him. Then in around 2008 he was deported. Turned out he lied on his visa application. He was deported back to
11:33 Pakistan. What did he do the day he got back? He became the official spokesperson for Lashkarata. Um, so I think this sums up this this this this the problem of of Jamaat able to transform itself in the west on the one hand being this supposedly lawful uh generous organization and on the other hand being indelibly tied to terror and extremism. Um that's not the only example of domestic uh Jamat terror links though uh in Connecticut something very interesting happened last year. Uh yeah. Um just last year, a man named Fared Khan, who seemed to be just a simple mechanic working in Connecticut was um arrested and then later convicted of lying to the FBI as part of a counterterrorism investigation um from a counterterrorism task force um effort.
12:23 this um he had a brother that court documents indicate was a Lashkar Taba supporter um and over $200,000 went through his bank account and one of the things he was conf um he the things he was um convicted of lying about was that he claimed he only sent clothes to his brother in Pakistan. Um all indications were he really was part of a moneyaundering operation. Um he also was a chief INA HHRD fundraiser in the area. In fact, he was spoken to by um FBI agents when he um was busy raising funds for Islamic Circle of North America. Um so this is just another example. Again, we don't know how far that goes. We only know what's been put out publicly by the Justice Department, what's in court documents. Um but this is just another example of their ideological extremism at minimum um having a lot of terrorist connections if not uh you know overtly being involved in these kinds of things.
13:19 Um the medley storm has been working for some time to bring attention to this issue with a fair amount of success. Um last year um Congressman Jim Banks introduced HRES 160 which calls out Jamaati Islam's actions across the board in India and Bangladesh and Pakistan um and also their fundraising arms and their links to terrorism in the US. Um, Congressman Banks and a number of others, including Congressman Flechman, Congressman Weber, a few others, sent a letter to um the counterterrorism coordinator, Nathan Sales, um, bringing attention to some of these um, actions by various IKNA officials and um, that appear to be terror links calling for a a more thorough investigation. This got a lot of coverage in the Indian media. U got several wire stories written by a US um Indian correspondent that really brought a lot of attention to this issue. Um that led to something very interesting. We learned not long after that a umbrella group called Interaction
14:23 which has roughly 200 um charities underneath it. It's an umbrella organization, many of which are totally innocuous, but they have a sub umbrella of five charities which are very closely linked to terrorism. In some countries, some of these members of the sub umbrella called the Together Project are designated as terror financers. The explicit goal of the of the the other project is to basically deflect um any accusations of terror finance to deflect any ties to terrorism to basically normalize these groups as much as possible. We discovered not only were the was this interactions together project meeting with congressman discouraging any kind of investigation but had even hired Perkins Kuey, the large international law firm responsible for the famous steel dossier on President Trump to essentially try to discredit some of these very public and very easy public open source um um facts that we had uncovered um and to try to basically obuscate and deflect
15:25 attention. Um, so that shows how deep their influence goes. Sam, I wish we had more time to explain the full extent of Jamaat activities here in the US. I certainly recommend you read the many articles we've published on the subject at mforum.org. Um, but I just want to end with this. Uh, Jamaat is a dangerous force. It has flown under the radar for decades. Um, across the US, it is radicalizing the next generation of Muslim kids. Uh, we need your help to oppose it. So write to your congressman uh tell them that the federal government cannot be funding one arm of the IKNA network while the other arm of the IKNA network openly partners with designated terrorist organizations in South Asia. So write to your representatives, see if IKNA and other Jamaat groups are active in your town, in your city, speak to local journalists. Uh work to halt, to diminish, to challenge the influence of Jamati Islami. Um, you just have to look to Europe to see what happens when you don't stop that radicalization in time.
16:28 Uh, if we don't further kids running off the joint terrorist groups, more terror finance, uh, a more extreme Muslim community and fewer chances for moderate Muslims to gain back control from the grip of Islamists. Thank you. All right. Thank you both so much for that. uh with Chimat expanding in South Asia steadily for more than a decade, what can the United States do to counter that expansion and is Chumat Islami already having cells within the United Well, I think as the the discussion about shows yes, Jumati has cells all over the United States states. I mentioned it. There are others. The the Muslim Umar of North America for example is the best representation of Jamaati Islami's Bangladeshi's uh branch. As it comes to the United States, look, India has already designated or banned Jamaat Islami from operating in some parts of of the country. Uh other countries including Bangladesh have have spoken out about the dangers. The United States
17:31 should be taking on board what these two South Asian countries are saying. they should be making sure that any US charity that works with a designated terrorist organization is investigated and that so far doesn't seem to be happening. Uh Cliff, yeah, and that's really the thing. I mean, this is not secret. This is very open. Um [clears throat] Islamic Circle of North America and um MUNA, all these other groups, HHRD, they don't really hide their um Jamaati affiliation. I mean, any kind of separation. I mean, I'm not saying there's one guy in Pakistan controlling them, but they clearly share ideology.
18:04 They have links openly. They talk about them on their website. This is not some kind of, you know, conspiracy theory. This is, you can go look on their website and see what they say about themselves. They're not hidden about what they think and who they admire. Um, this is clearly what is going on. The more interesting question is, you know, why do people um not recognize them for what they are and for the danger they are? And that I think is in large part because as Sam mentioned, you know, we've had this obsession with the Muslim Brotherhood, which the Muslim Brotherhood are not good guys. And that's not beyond that's beyond dispute.
18:37 But there's been this monomomaniacal focus on them as the you purveyor of all radical ideologies related to Islam and it's just not true. If anything, I would say that Jamaati Islami's franchise groups, its friends in the US have been more influential, have gotten more funds, have gotten more respectability, and have been more involved in shaping policy than Muslim Brotherhood linked groups have been, and certainly of forming the minds of certain radical Thank you. What can be done to drive a wedge into the red and green alliance to pull away the leftist allying with Islamism in the United States and That's a very interesting question. Yes, the questioner is right. For decades uh by the Red Green Alliance, what he means is the the link between Islamists and members of of the far left and even the the the moderate left uh in America. Um it is very puzzling indeed that there are some on the left in this country who would work with Islamists who openly
19:40 advocate for the killing of homosexuals for the imposition of barbaric theocratic laws that would that would wipe out the smallest vestage of liberalism uh if it were ever in power. It is mad that this alliance exists. It but it does exist. It always has. Um it's not just with Sunni Islamism as well. just look to see uh the Iranian links with far-left groups. Uh you know the point is that they may not agree with the others ideology but they see utility in working together. Uh I think this can be stopped by appealing to the center left. There are sensible people out there who you know have certain political views economically, socially but they do not identify with the dogmas of the far left. And I believe and I've experienced that they are horrified when they find out that some of their partners they regarded as as good faith minority partners are actually people who are advocating the most fascistic of ideas, the most intolerant and violent of ideas. It comes down to a question of education. So explain the dangers of Islam. Explain what Islamists believe.
20:43 Show them what Islamist clerics are saying and what Islamist charities are doing. Uh facts are our friends here. uh we need to we need to educate the left just as much as we need to educate the right. I would also add that I think that the left is um obsessed with the idea of the oppressed and the oppressor and the Islamists are often very good at painting themselves as oppressed when you actually see a lot of what Jamaati Islami groups have done do is show that you know the South Asian Muslims are oppressed in different ways that's what they claim all the time and to the point you but in in truth um in most places in the world the Islamists are the oppressor and to the degree they are being oppressed it is often because they are trying to commit acts of terrorism create theocracies things like that. So to the degree you can show look no they are not the oppressed they are the oppressor they are posing as the oppressed in order to be able to oppress more that is something I think that over time if that takes um that um hold in
21:48 the ideas of the left that will be a valuable contribution to breaking up this alliance. Thank you. Um, so which one would you say is more dangerous to the west in America? Jamaat al-Islami or the Muslim I would suggest Jamaatsi Islami. And I say if you'd asked me that question 20 years ago, I would have said the Muslim Brotherhood most likely. The point about the Muslim Brotherhood, this is a slightly different topic, but the Muslim Brotherhood today very briefly does not exist in the form it once did uh 20 years ago. There is it is there's no evidence that organizations founded by the Muslim Brotherhood in America, groups like the Council on American Islamic Relations, the Muslim American Society, there's no evidence they're still taking directions from some sort of centralized Muslim Brotherhood hierarchy in Egypt or Qatar or Turkey or wherever. The Muslim Brotherhood is split and dissipate uh dissipated. It is no longer a cohesive force. Jamaat very much is. It's an organized force. the different branches leaz with each other
22:51 very closely. There's a clearer ideological uh uh agenda. There's a clearer organizational structure. Um Jamaat is dangerous because it's organized. The Muslim Brotherhood remains dangerous because its ideology is so pervasive. But it doesn't have the power to organize mass change uh in the way that Jamaat potentially does if it continues to exert an ever greater influence over American Muslims. Thank you. So, we have time for well, we don't have any time, but we have two more questions that I'd like uh ask. Uh, how are Islamist war criminals accepted into the UK and US? And why do you think the governments were blind to these I would say that I think that especially when um Bangladesh was partitioned um I mean there was a lot of confusion about the in the west or what happened, who was responsible, what was going on. It was it was uh something the west had not focused on. it was something we were not you know deeply knowledgeable about. Um and I think that also the v various problems in Bangladeshi government the
23:54 Bangladeshi government has problems of its own has led to this in the case of Bangladesh we don't actually recognize you know their war crimes tribunals like so in other words if Bangladesh convicts someone of a war crime the US doesn't automatically accept that as being true it basically has to go through its own processes um I think it is important that the government does go through its own processes and um you know investigates these guys and comes to what I believe was in most cases um the right conclusion by the Bangladeshi government for example. Um and there's indications that that's happening. Um there's even stories recently about um the US um various law enforcement intelligence agencies um asking for information on um Bangladeshies. There's even a story about that what two days ago of someone that was convicted of war crimes. But that's something that should go keep going on. But it's very sad that they have lasted for this long here um and that we haven't gotten a handle on it again. And I think it partially goes to um radical Islamist in particular Jamaat franchise groups that are trying to whitewash these individuals and
24:56 protect them. I think that's a big part of it too. Thank you. So last question. As American citizens and I guess around the world, we have quite a few viewers elsewhere. Uh what can we do to pressure our governments or media to do to more openly expose the connections between Islamic charities and terror activities without coming across as Islamophobic? I think one of the and a website where we can buy one of the huge problems we have um when it comes to Islamist charities in the west is the lack of information about how they operate in areas of the world where terrorism exerts an influence. Uh so for example uh in the Gaza Strip um many western charities fund local partners have local charities they work with. They're not required to publish lists of those local partners. So it's difficult to see if they're working with front groups for terrorism. The same is true in Kashmir. Uh the same is true in Yemen and across the Middle East and other parts of of South Asia particularly. Um legislation improved
26:00 legislation can help with this this this question. Forcing charities to open their books uh uh especially if they receive government funds so that the public can hold them accountable and find out who they're working with. Uh I think that would be particularly important and that's something that that the Middle East forum is looking into uh at the moment. Uh information clarity that's that's what's key. Persuade your government to stop funding any group that has ever worked with a proxy organization for a terrorist group unless there's evidence it was an absolute accident and it has since reformed. There are too many Islamist charities in the west who have funded terror in the past and simply uh gotten away with it uh either because there isn't the willingness to prosecute or because perhaps they were working with this group before it was designated but now it is designated. There needs to be much better government uh uh scrutiny of these charities and their activities and you can encourage that and the media can encourage that. So don't just speak to your legislators, speak to journalists.
27:02 present them with the evidence that we collect and that you can collect and let's hold government accountable to make sure that we're not subsidizing Islam's terror in the name of humanitarian aid. Let me add to that just a little bit. Um it it is clear to me although you can never know their inside of their thinking um that the amount of exposure that um Jamaati Islami and their franchise groups in the west have gotten in the past year or so due to some of our research and the research of some of our friends um has really rattled them because they've never gotten this kind of coverage before. In addition to um the research we've done, for example, I mentioned um that when um Congressman Banks wrote that letter um there were several wire stories written um that got puffed up across the world um that really brought this issue to light just in the past few weeks. Um um RT Singh a reporter has reported a number of things about what these are groups up to in the US. Um and it's we've gotten some US coverage of it too. Obviously the South
28:03 Asian community has a particular interest in this. And so my point is they've never gotten scrutiny like they have gotten in the past couple of years. And journalists paying attention to these kinds of things really makes a big difference over time because it influences governments um a lot when you get a lot of coverage of these kinds of All right. Thank you both so much for taking the time out of your day to speak with us. Uh we have come to the close of our webinar. Thank you again for joining us today. Uh there will be a short survey to fill out at the end to better help us serve you going forward. Also, if you're looking for more information, please visit our website Uh we will have Robert Spencer join us this Friday at 1 p.m. Eastern to speak on is Islam globally waxing or waning.
28:50 Thank you again for joining us and I hope you have a great day.