MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Muslim-led Riots, France in Flames with Florence Bergeaud-Blackler

Watch Muslim-led Riots, France in Flames with Florence Bergeaud-Blackler on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

The streets of cities across France are currently aflame following the police shooting and killing of Nahel Merzouk, a 17-year-old Muslim with a long criminal history. Islamist groups have emerged to lead the insurrection; for example, they reportedly burned down the main library in Marseilles while chanting “Allahu Akbar.” How have Islamists exploited the violence? Where are the anti-Islamist Muslims? What are the long-term implications of this episode?

Florence Bergeaud-Blackler specializes in the study of Islamic norms in a secular context. She is the author of Le Frérisme et ses réseaux: L'Enquête (Brotherhoodism and its Networks: An Investigation) (Odile Jacob, 2023) which scholars received favorably but which prompted death threats from Islamists. She is a researcher at the Sociétés Religions Lucite Group at Paris Sciences et Lettres University. She holds a PhD from Bordeaux University and a habilitation to direct research from the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences in Paris.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 27, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:08 speaker webinar series and podcast I'm Stacey Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today very pleased to have Dr Florence bonjour blackler author and researcher specializing in the study of Islamic Norms in a secular context join us to discuss muslim-led riots France and Flames Dr Berger blackler will speak for 15 minutes then open up for questions for another 15 minutes should you wish to ask the question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Dr Florence bonjour um yes so I'm an anthropologist I'm my first encounter with Muslim Brotherhood was 30 years ago I was a student I Was preparing a master in anthropology University of Bordeaux and my specialty now is the study of the Islamic normativities in Europe I've spent many years to study the global Halal Market which is for me one of the

1:13 most powerful vehicle of the Islamic fundamentalist Norms in all sectors consumption culture economy so let me talk about the the situation in France at the moment and the riots so the the riots taking place in France at the moment have Echoes of the George Floyd case in the U.S um despite the appearance of the young man being killed in circumstances that the video shows to to be damning for the police officer uh the two cases uh those of uh George and the Nile have little in uh little in common if we accept the agonists of the colonial and work groups to denounce it as a political assassination by a police force that kills rationalized and underprivileged young people that's the story the policeman was jailed in the days that followed but the crowd is still

2:17 demanding Justice for the young men this Angel as the footballer kylian mbappe put it was driving without a license in a car that didn't belong to him and who in his frantic race endangered lives of several people before being stopped last fatally two groups immediately called for Revenge one forming the group known as Jean de barlier Joseph and another group a political party called La France and sumiz rebellious France at the left of the left wings uh noisy and influential in the your in the this party did not attempt to calm down the riots even though it's called exceptionally high in the suburbs at the last elections the intersection of these two groups is

3:21 formed by another the Muslims and amongst them the Muslims um the the islamists and in particular within the islamis the Muslim Brotherhood want to turn the future of the Muslim Nation the ummah into a cultural economic and political force for the brothers the riots are both an advantage and a disadvantage an advantage because riots are the proof of the failure of assimilation of Muslims into the secure of France a disadvantage because they want these young Muslims to form an Elites rather than to be Pro proprietary nice so what do the Brotherhood want for young European uh French Muslims to find out we can for example read the document called strategy for Islamic action outside the Islamic world that

4:26 was inspired by the Muslim Brotherhood and in particular the French branch and published in 2000 in Qatar this document signed from izesco which is the Islamic equivalent of UNESCO lists the measures to be taken to manage young Muslims in the non-muslim world their children and their grandchildren the all is to make them to I quote respect Allah's Commandments and prohibitions to Adorn themselves with Islamic ethics and to reject secular values that would make them unhappy and undisciplined for the Muslim Brotherhood because they are Muslims they will be impossible anyway to assimilate in France so only Islam can provide these young Muslims with an education that is I quote again generous and tolerant based on The Good the right equity and duty to act within the framework of the

5:32 Sharia which is based on two principles ordering the good and prohibiting the end of quotation only Islamic education conceive and develop educational visions and methods capable of sparing children from the problems characteristic of life in Western environment and freeing them from the cultural split from which they suffer and of course these young Muslims must therefore be protected against cultural Invasion and alienation and to be granted the cultural security and Immunity necessary for the development of the Muslim these proposals of the Muslim Brotherhood are inadmissible in the front in France in a country that is very attached to National Education and for most French people

6:39 um secularism is a means of preserving National unity and avoiding religious wars it is preferable to keep righteous practice in private Sphere for oneself even if religious expression outside the home is not forbidden you can practice you can show your belonging your religious uh uh belonging to in the street there is no problem but uh state representatives must not display religious symbols but citizens may do so as long as they do not jeopardize public security France don't want community-based displays just as races are not political for most of the French race is a biological and not a political fact there has in France never been any racial segregation regime and racism has

7:43 always been criminalized the Muslim Brotherhood proposed to use international law diversity with reference for example to the United Nation to convince westerners not to seek to assimilate young Muslims and the subversion is here claiming the right to not apply the common right in the name of the common right today Muslim Brotherhood openly asked the French state to be untrusted for the re-education of young Muslim for example a preacher in north of France has published just yesterday a video saying these young people talking about the riots these young people could have gone through a mosque we could have done some educational work we can be media clothes we are factors of preventing violence and last isn't it in society's interest to promote this

8:47 cultural and religious associations to help young people to have principles and yeah this allows me to go back to my book that explains the history of the development of Brotherhood in Europe so this is a book I just published in in which I develop uh their ideology in Europe their strategy uh and its Doctrine was Satya if if I can summarize I describe brotherism as a system of action it's a transnational movement that wants to conquer the world and therefore non-muslim countries by first making it Sharia compatible its strategy of implantation and extension is different from that of islamist groups in the Muslim countries

9:50 because it is primarily based on culture and on economy in a globalized world dominated by the ideologies of free trade and inclusiveness the doctrine of this movement is the wasatya Islam of the middle way which was uh terrorized and modernized by Yusuf alakardawi the share was inspired by the founder of Muslim Brotherhood Asana and also by the Hindu Pakistani Abu Allah the brothers as I conceive it and I Define it in my book uh is not a theology or neither a legal school it is what I call the system of action that sets out to steer the various theological and legal components of Sunny Islam from a middle position to fulfill the ultimate Prophecy of the establishment of the caliphate on Earth

10:54 brotherism uses the skills and specificities of each of the schools of the movement Jihadi Sufi liberal to redirect and to guide them towards the objective by infiltrating the environments public institutions by sectors education university health Justice police but also private Enterprise in order to influence them and to modify their DNA to make them Sharia compatible it works very methodically by plans considering itself and acting mostly within the framework of democratic laws in our modern societies Brotherhood as a preference for the influence through the culture and the economic because the political way is not accessible for now the anti-racist and the anti-radicalization networks of ngos in

11:59 Europe are widely infiltrated by the Brotherhood who seek and this latest Generations who seek to impose the idea of a mistreatment of Muslims in Europe and therefore we want to promote special rights for them positive discrimination they Define for example anti-muslim hate as a hate which seeks to dehumanized Muslims of course this has never been proven any demonstration of it that the Western European democracy seek to dehumanize Muslims but what they do not want uh what the the European Union don't want is to uh to have a Islamic fundamentalism that the Brotherhood convey uh I will finish that to to like place to the to the questions um what is the strange in Europe is that uh the EU uh in particular continue to propagate the studies of islamophobia

13:05 um which is the main um instrument for the propagation of uh brotherism um despite of lack of evidence of its existence what I mean by islamophobia here is the structural or state islamophobia not uh I don't mean racist which is a which exists and not just for all right wonderful thank you so much uh so the first question is from JL asking these riots seem to shatter the myth of a Muslim population that can be integrated into European cultures uh it also has a parallel with the rides that took place in Israel in the mixed cities last year uh is the so-called moderate Islam a myth or is this still possible to achieve well I wouldn't say that it's uh it's a myth because I knew it I mean I've been working on this topic for 30 years and I remember 30 years ago I I've seen uh an Islam which was not fundamentalist it was possible to not

14:07 wear the hijab to not be uh attached to any halal food it was possible to uh to to be a Muslim uh as as as a self-islam as as a self-definition um it was possible even to say that I'm not a Muslim anymore and this uh this is not possible anymore if you say that you are not Muslim anymore then you will have trouble so it's preferable preferable to to to hide it for example um the other indication of the the the influence of muslin Brotherhood on young Muslims is um it can be uh given by by numbers for example we know that Muslim Brotherhood exerts a great deal of influence over mosque they were the first to address young Muslims in French uh with someone like Tariq hamador with a speech of

15:11 Pride women and men hesitating to where the veil uh which had almost disappeared before uh incitating to it Halal which was completely new to live in the Halal way of life it's it's a completely new formula and today uh we know that 65 of the French young Muslims things Sharia is more important than the civil law which is uh which is a considerable um in France so we have 10 million uh Muslim over 68 millions of French um 10 Millions is the highest um number it's between 8 and 10 with great variations according to the national territory um the pleasure over the the teachers at school to reintroduce the veil uh which is forbidden at school since 2004 is

16:18 um teachers are being prevented from giving certain lessons that are not compatible with the Sharia law uh almost 60 percent of Southern Secondary School teachers censor themselves don't say uh some courses or avoid some topics um which is a huge number um the Ramadan also fasting is increasingly followed by very young uh we have seen recently games of prayers uh in the school uh by seven years old children very very very young yeah and and this is in rupture with the population in France for example there is a recent poll that shows that 77 percent of French people are in favor of banning a female football players um hijab which is which which is the very

17:23 contrasting with the the trends of Muslims at the moment thank you uh David estoven asks how is it that North African Jews do so well in France but not North African Muslims or how is it that Hindus from India do so well in the UK but not Pakistani Muslims well Jews in France are are in France for many many centuries um while Muslims are arrived numerous uh during this so it's completely different and well to say that they do well they do do Jewish do like other French and of course because they are more recent uh in the territory Muslims are still amongst uh the the less uh Rich population but this uh this is changing we have now middle class Muslim middle

18:27 class who do very well yes I think uh he was asking is is there some sort of a simulation that is not happening or or is is this uh our Muslims assimilating to the French society nationalism yes Muslims are stimulating quite well um you can see them in political parties uh you can see them in all the the sectors of uh of the Enterprise or or public institutions they are amongst French that there is no the idea of uh islamophobia has been constructed uh since I would say the the the median the social medias uh in Middle 2000s we start to hear about islamophobia before that we knew that there was there

19:31 was racism there was racism and especially during the 70s because there was tension between Algeria and France for historical reasons but uh this was that there was reasons for that and that that was not uh um constructed reasons like uh religious perfect thank you so much I appreciate you uh clarifying that uh Andrea spindelis none of the western or a few of the western governments have banned uh the Muslim Brotherhood and Associated groups and mosque but Muslim countries have done so should France Canada U.S Australia ban the Muslim Brotherhood and vet immigrants well I don't know if it's because it's extremely difficult to uh to identify the Brotherhood as the Muslim Brotherhood that the contrary it's difficult but they also have infused in society uh what I call the

20:37 brotherism which is not uh the the the Brotherhood itself which is more uh its ideology and this ideology completely infused uh the the Islamic field uh in France today so even if we uh forbid the the Muslim Brotherhood as a as a group as a it may not be a very efficient and especially they are acting within the law so we will have to to fight an ideology which is extremely difficult we have freedom of expression how can we do exactly uh so Hugh kitson asks I I have seen reports from the recent rioting including attacks against Jewish properties is this true you have to understand that this riot is the fact of individuals there is no um at the initiating this right uh you

21:42 have groups who have tried to instrumentalize these riots but neither Muslims or nor the France are are behind this uh they try to capture and to orientate the the movements with the with the faith I mean this at the moment the the riot is decreasing and nobody can control it uh it just it's decreasing because the police have showed their their muscles thank you Leslie Shaw asks what can we do to stop the advance of the Muslim Brotherhood in Europe I think first of all we need to identify it we need to uh to understand how it works what what you want to do when I talk about Sharia compatibility for example to understand how they proceed they have what I call a vision an identity and a plan VIP

22:47 we need to understand how they think uh how they act what what where they want to go where they want us to go and if we are clever enough uh if we are passions because they are we will understand how we can behave to avoid uh the the way they want us to go um this season this cannot be this is why I wrote my book to to to to to make uh the the public understand how it works and and what they can do as individual to avoid a society which will be shya compatible and then Islamic because that's their points they want to they want to destroy the most democracy which they started to do by uh acting against the freedom of expression it's it's very serious I I

23:51 explained that 60 of the teachers censor themselves so it's it's very serious but that is not just teachers they are also just ordinary citizens or of the cultural movements or there are things that we cannot say anymore so uh so and they want to feel crazy and we have a democracy and they are not so I did this book I wrote this book very detailed uh that showed the story of how it happens uh how it uh proceeds to uh to um to re-equip uh people and make the more strong uh to uh to defend uh it will not be a war uh it will be um uh intelligence War um not uh not fighting with guns but fighting with our mind or or our

24:56 absolutely uh Taffy goldas uh will there this result in more influence of Marilyn Penn an anti-immigration and can that possibly succeed or is it too late um it is sure that this uh riots will help the the movement uh the the right very wide right right-wing party to to but um I'm not sure that National of Marine Le Pen uh will be able to uh tackle this problem um I think all parties much must uh work together just one party will never be able to to stop that so we need to to de-politicize the problem uh in terms of uh party political party we need to work all together against theocracy as absolutely and uh it's with the secular

26:02 secularism in France being held so dear uh is there any chance of the islamist joining the government and and trying to enact any any Sharia law into the but they are they are trying they are up to now they don't succeed to change the law but they try for example uh they try to remove the law against hijab in the school uh they try hard and they try for example uh to pass a law to allow the hijab in the sports uh they failed but they will try again again because they they have a long time they have a long perspective they will not stop to try until we said no we don't want that and we know what you want us to do and we don't want it if until we are not firm they will carry on Steve says it's still is it too late for

27:06 France and how can the US learn before it's too late for here well I I don't think it's too late it's never too late anyway uh but um we have a warning and um the these riots are not just social economic problems there are also uh cultural and religious problems we still don't really want to do to see it as it uh as a religious problem and it's a Pity so it really depends on on our faculty of saying identifying the problems uh if we and I think things are changing in a positive way people understand what is uh that Islam is not islamism um that we can have an Islam but we don't want islamist and so we just need to see the difference and people are learning with what happened in in media with social media

28:11 um and uh they don't accept to be treated as a extreme right or fascist or Nazi they don't accept it anymore they can stand and say well no we don't want this but doesn't mean we are fascistic streaming so and so on so the mentality are changing and I think it's the only thank you so much so it's a wonderful way to wrap it up uh mgbodish as will your book be available or is your book available in English well not yet because I'm still looking for a publisher uh uh it's it's selling very well in France I must say as as surprising because usually social science books are not very well sold but this one has found is public and I hope you will find a English public English speaker public absolutely we hope that uh that comes

29:13 out soon in English and for any French it is available now I think I saw it on Amazon there all right well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar uh thank you again Dr uh Berger for joining us today thank you of course for our viewers please join us Wednesday at 3 pm Eastern for an update with Alex selski this week thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day