Webinar or Talk
Erdoğan: Reckless or Savvy? with Soner Cagaptay
Watch on YouTube
Description
After a century as a mid-sized power, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan seeks to restore Turkey to something akin to the influence of its Ottoman past. But a rocky road finds Ankara with precious few friends among alienated NATO allies, angry Middle Eastern neighbors, and tensions with Russia and China. Has Erdoğan a chance to succeed or is he heading for a fall?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 6, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today where please have sonor chapai director of the Washington Institute for near Eastern policies Turkish research program join us to discuss air toan Reckless or Savvy Dr chapai will speak for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A Box locate at the bottom of your screen to type your question and now with that I'll will turn the discussion over to Dr thank you so much uh Stacy and uh uh good afternoon to everyone assuming many of you are joining from the East Coast or if you're from the West Coast or elsewhere a good time of the day to everyone uh I was asked today to discuss with you uh the political career of Turkish president erdogan I have written his political biography uh called the new Sultan uh I have recently finished a new book erdon called Sultan in Autumn and I think both of these books really tie nice to the theme of the today's conversation you know uh Turkish
1:04 president erdogan where is he heading where is Turkey heading for that I have prepared a presentation which I'm going to go through in a minute but I think it's really important to highlight that erdogan is one of the most consequential leaders of uh Turkish Politics on to our next slide please Spencer uh it's quite significant because uh often times Eran is compared uh to the founder of turkey here on the board you see uh two leaders on the left side is Mustafa Kamal atat tur who founded turkey in his own image as a secular Western European Republic in the 1920s following the collapse of the Ottoman Empire after which Ataturk liberated turkey now atat Turk's followers known as calist after his middle name Mustafa Kamal Ataturk that is uh believed that the political system Ataturk established secularist which became Democratic in 1950 and facing the west and part of NATO starting in 19 52 uh that this political system could not be torn down in a thousand years guess what erogan tore the system down uh I
2:10 would say or recalibrated many aspects of the system in under 10 years therefore I think he's a consequential leader so what I'll do is I'll explain to you how Eran re-calibrated or did away with much of cism because those steps in erdogan's decisions today to understand where erdogan is going I think we need to understand how erdogan came to power and Consolidated power in Turkey next slide please the first element of erdogan success was uh ver German word which means economic Miracle delivered phenomenal growth for about 10 years um uh from 2003 when he became prime minister just about until 2013 uh this was unprecedented in Turkish history incomes Rose living standards increased and turkey just became a more prosperous place on the left side there's a picture of isul skyline uh this is the downtown part of the city on the European side on the Forefront you see palaces from the ottoman times in the background the entire Skyline was built with record amounts of foreign
3:13 direct investment that came to Turkey during the first decade of erdogan R of course you see people from Istanbul called Istanbul L whining and dining on the right side so really a very optimistic period of growth and prosperity uh I've written a quartet on erdogan years and the first book in the quartet called rise of turkey is exactly on this era a facto I like most from this book is that when erdogan came to power infant mortality rate in Turkey was comparable to pre-war Syria that is pre-war Syria now that rate is comparable to that of spaines so basically the Turks used to live like syrians on average now they live like the Spanish on average that's why erdogan won over dozen Nationwide elections until recently that is until the economy went into recession so that's the bright side of the erdogan years delivering growth uh building a but even in that era erdogan was always worried about the military the secularist military that saw itself as the guardian of ataturk's legacy and that had in the past taken steps against uh his uh political islamist movement
4:17 known as welfare party from which erdogan became aul's mayor a position from which he went to become turkey's prime minister in 2013 and president in 2014 so er was never comfortable about the prospects of the military looming in the backgrounds and he wanted to act against it the military that is and guess who was his ally next slide please um of course at the time uh erdogan is a a strongly um you know a leader who feels that he's very much threatened so he makes alliances uh not a lecture goes by I would say uh when I'm talking about erdoan that someone in the audience gets up maybe also in this audience virtually and says well all about all is okay but what do you think think of this poor man Teta gulan who lives in Pennsylvania and who has been opposing Eran and I tell my audience there's only one part of that question that's factually true that gulen lives in Pennsylvania he's not a poor guy he runs a very powerful political religious movement not different than erdogan's and he also
5:19 helped erdogan consolidate power uh how did this work out let's move to our next slide and look at that um Gan helped erdogan build a court case called Eran uh the name is on the board on your screens uh alleging that there was a c plot against Eran uh this uh uh uh court case was used to lock down a quarter of active duty Generals in the Turkish military many of erdogan's opponents in Civil Society uh University presidents and journalists and journalist others came under attack so democracy in Turkey came under attack in this Century the first time not during the felu attempt of 2016 which I'm going to talk about but in the first decade of erdogan years when gulan helped erdogan create a Republic of Fear in which opposing erdogan through ideas was criminalized so Gan is I think completely complicit of undermining of democratic checks and balances this helps erdogan consolidate power let's move on to the next slide I'll look at that briefly of course um erdogan's inflection point in his career
6:23 I think when he's becoming a more autocratic leader is really around 2010 and 11 in 2010 he passed an amendment to the Constitution with significant support from Dulan owned media that allows him now to appoint a majority of judges to the high courts without a confirmation process eliminating judicial Independence and of course the next year the militaries top brass resigned in Mass recognizing that the indefinite U detentions of top brass generals had worked and the military was now telling erdogan and gulan you guys have won at that stage I think what happened was erdogan and and each wanted to run turkey by themselves what ensued was a ro power struggle that culminated in the 2016 K attempt in which GL Gan Allied officers played a key role so clearly we're kind of seeing a turkey that's M from optimism for about a decade of economic growth and prosperity and good International ties to a country that's now uh going to do things differently this want to next slide and look at how things change in foreign
7:26 policy taking stock with turkey's phenomenal economic growth growth a record in Turkish history uh the facto end of accession talks with the European Union I'm happy to deal with the EU uh part of this conversation in the Q&A um in other words the EU is not treating turkey's accession seriously this is allowing erdogan to turn away from the EU to the Middle East and of course taking stock with Arab uprisings erdogan started to launch foreign policy initiatives breaking with us and other NATO allies and EU countries when and if necessary uh this is around 20 11 2012 turkey getting involved in the uprisings in Egypt and other countries again happy to discuss these in the Q&A as well but I really want to bring it to Syria because that's where foreign policy challenges will mount for erdogan let's move on to the next slide please Syria is a big issue because from the very beginning erdogan involved turkey in the war there to house the Assad regime but with the rise of Isis the United States decided that the primary threat from Syria was not Assad was Isis and Washington Allied with a Kurdish group
8:30 called ypg people's protection forces which is an offshoot of another Kurdish group called Kurdistan Workers Party pkk in order to fight Isis the problem the pkk is a terror designated entity not just by us but uh but turkey and all NATO allies and on top of it of course it's offshoot uh is now a US Ally in which the US is made an alliance with an offsho of a terror group to fight another terror group turkey never accepted this policy turkey has always considered pkk to be an existential enemy and this is issue has now become a very serious uh you know I would say Discord uh cause cause for Discord in US Turkish ties but other issues will come in to complicate us Turkish relations in Syria next slide please one of these of course is the C intervention in Syria in 2015 Putin deployed troops to Syria now uh I mentioned that I have written a quartet on erdogan the foreign policy piece of this quartet known as erdogan's is the foreign policy piece it basically looks at Turkish Russian ties and other
9:34 topics and I had counted in my book uh that from the time they became neighbors until the collapse of the Russian Empire in 1917 the Ottomans and Russians fought 17 major Wars guess who started these wars overall uh the Russians guess who lost them overall the Turks so in Syria it looked like the 18th war was going to start and you did not need a crystal ball to figure out who would win very dangerous for turkey but then things changed let's move to the next slide uh the C attempt against erdogan that I mentioned earlier in which Glen Allied officers played a significant role uh the coup was thwarted thankfully because many of turkey citizens rejected the coup including those who opposed Eran and uh the attempt Was Defeated you see a picture of the Turkish Parliament bombed on the left by coup PLS by airplanes and you see civilians taking over tanks on the right the KU was very traumatic for erdan you know uh this was indeed an aerious plot and while many of turkey's Western allies at the time set
10:37 on their hands kind of trying to see how things would unfold Putin made a really smart for Russia and a strategic decision globally he reached out to erdogan and the first phone call that came to erdogan from a major leader was not from President Obama at the time it was uh not from NATO Secretary General it was from Russia's leader imagine the leader of turkey's historic Nemesis is reaching out to erdogan to say how is everything can I help you therefore it's not surprising that erdogan's first visit after the coupe was not to Brussels for a NATO sub Summit of support it was not to Washington but it was to Moscow next slide to actually Russia next slide please this is to St Petersburg uh very significant right not Russia's uh contemporary Capital but it's imperial capital uh the significance of this I think by Vladimir Putin is to telling to tell erdogan look my predecessor Katherine the Great who built this Palace constantinos Palace in St Petersburg where we're meeting is also
11:40 the Russian Zar or Zarina who started the tradition of bullying you Turks I Putin the great can end this let's have a deal this was a handshake I think Putin reached out there one uh offering him soft power sharing deals in Syria and Libya but also becoming his protector and of course um Putin's platitudes don't come for free uh the biggest issue in US Turkish ties now from the US perspective is Turkey's purchase of russian-made S400 missile defense system for which turkey has been sanctioned on the hill if you ask me you said son when did Putin first angle this offer to sell erdogan this missile defense system I would say at this meeting at the constantinos palace where Putin decides he tells erdogan he's going to support erdogan uh he's going to back but of course that means now erdogan has to purchase this defense missile defense system which is a permanent Fisher so Putin is a very smart almost like a 3D chess player right he peels turkey away from the US he creates a Fisher point in
12:42 the relationship and he also wins erdogan's heart but doesn't mean of course Russia and Turkey are allies the two countries have many differences about which I'll talk in a little bit let's move on to the next slide because I do want to wrap up um of course Putin and turkey and Russia are now in tenous power sharing deals in Syria in Libya in South Caucasus these are tenuous because they're not firm you know there's always conflict uh the two sides do engage in military escalation occasionally so all of these are exposure points for turkey because if uh turkey doesn't go along with Russia's game in one of these theaters let's say Syria Putin can easily undermine turkey in another theater in Libya and erdogan thrives on his Global strongman image domestically so a Russian escalation would of course hurt erdogan's image tremendously at home and he has many other challenges at home uh let's move on to the next slide and review these before I finish Russia is one of them this is ironic because I explained to you how strongly bonded erdogan and Putin have become since 2016
13:45 but it doesn't mean turkey and Russia are allies they have many differences eastmed Cyprus Crimea anation of crimeia Black Sea issues Ukraine on all of these tury and Russia opposing sides and even where they are on the same side they have many differences such as in Syria and Libya refugees is another big challenge for erdogan uh Turkey already hosts 4 million refugees it's the largest Refugee hosting nation in the world turkey's population is 84 million people so that means refugees constitute 5% of turkey's population this is quite significant it would cool enough the United States getting 18 million refugees in about a decade uh turkey should be commanded for extending a really warm welcome to these refugees with little international support of course for about a 10 years uh period but that welcome is now wearing thin because the economy in Turkey is in bad shape the economy went into recession in 2018 it's the the first time under erdogan after a break uh record-breaking 15-year period it's that is the main reason why erdogan lost or his
14:48 candidates lost elections for Mar elections for isul anara other big cities the economy has exited recession but it's only showing signs of slow growth and erdogan's Bas is simply imploding opinion polls are showing his party at around 30 35% even with allies he's not able to get to 50% that's required for him to win the next elections in 2023 right now what ERD wants to do is to deliver strong strong growth for which he has to maintain good ties with the United States and European Union but he also has to balance other actors let's move on to the next slide I kind of want to give you a sense of erdogan's world so he needs to get along with West that is with Europe and the United States and NATO because not withstanding erdogan's efforts to recast turkey's identity uh politically uh and erase the walls between religion and government Turkey's economy is completely integrated to that of Europe uh because of Customs Union in place between turkey and the European Union since 1995 and as a resourceful country
15:51 Turkey needs to have good ties with the United States so that Global Investors will feel comfortable to put their money into turkey erdogan has to get along also with Russia he wants to avoid trade and tourism sanctions that could Target turkey's economic recovery remember he needs really strong growth to win the next elections strong meaning nearing double digits he wants to get along with China because he wants to break ground with some Mega construction projects including Canal Istanbul uh it will be a Waterway running parallel to the bosor funding War which uh will probably come from China and now of course he's trying to make up with Arab majority States and Israel with which turkey's tide had collapsed during the uh Arab uprisings so he has a tall order to accomplish but erdogan is also quite an astute politician I would not uh rule out the possibility of erdogan managing all these relationships at the same time ultimately whether or not he wins the next elections in Turkey depends on economic growth erdogan is a bright side which we have discussed quite phenomenal
16:55 growth that he has delivered he also has a dark side he is an naous populist leader he demonizes brutalizes and cracks down on demographics unlikely to vote for him so he has a very robust and strong opposition constituted by groups demonized and brutalized by him they want to vote him out opposition does not have a unified leader yet but numerically right now opposition parties seem to be in the lead uh elections are in 2023 there's a chance they could be early but all of that we can discuss in the Q&A with that I want to wrap up and move on to the next slide and then turn to you Stacy for any questions or comments all right thank you so much we have quite a few questions coming in um multiple ones regarding NATO uh Mark Hagar asked why have NATO countries allowed turkey to remain a member of NATO oh uh good question well NATO is not a club of democracies it's not the European Union you know Greece and Portugal became NATO members when there
17:57 were dictatorships uh must saying turkey is a dictatorship uh it has three elections and erdogan could be voted out erdogan is an autocrat but I think that NATO leaders never look at the country's Democratic records when they decide if they're going to keep a country NATO and you know what um turkey out of also there's no mechanism to kick a country out of NATO uh it wasn't constituted like that and even if there was a mechanism even if it made you feel good what would you get out of it turkey would become closer to Russia uh and would become a more of a spoiler I think that the for this Administration and previous ones The Benchmark has always been and I support that is to keep turkey NATO while erdogan is on the scene because obviously turkey's neighborhood it uh borders Iran Iraq Syria Russia across the Black Sea and formerly ISL territories means that whatever US policies are regarding those four states and one entity Iran Iraq Syria Russia and Isis they're easier with turkey on board much less cumbersome much less
19:00 costly so I think there's great benefit to the United States of having turkey inside NATO and I'm a big proponent of uh you know keeping that relationship as the Bedrock of us Turkish ties going forward wonderful thank you Lawrence JY ask uh this may be counterfactual but had the EU agreed to turkey's entry might eran's story have turned out differently uh great question you know I I gave you guys inflection points I said look one flection point is erdogan takes over courts I think that's dangerous for any leader however good their intentions are if he eliminate checks and balances you know ultimately power I think goes into people's heads and they stop paying less and less attention to uh Democratic traditions and Norms that has been the case in turkey with erdogan but I believe you accession is an external inflection point Sorry in the sense that erdogan um was given a Au path in 2005 when turkey started accession talks that did not really seem to be fair you know
20:03 it had loopholes it had specific turkey uh uh uh you know spe turkey specific criteria which made it look like turkey's accession would never come forward I'll give you an example turkey and started start Croatia started accession talks at the same time in 20 205 2005 Croatia very deservedly joined the European Union in 2013 great country I've been there speak their language turkey's accession is nowhere near that of Catia um t uh you know I was doing this lecture uh a few weeks ago uh for for a group of students uh someone asked me the same question and I told them that there's about 200,000 pages of EU legislation that turkey and the European Union have to negotiate and Implement before turkey can join the union and they said how much of it as turkey finished with the European Union and I said only one and a half pages so even if you want accession to move forward it does not look realistic EU has not given turkey the the fair treatment from the very beginning European leaders said
21:05 that even if Turkey fulfilled all their criteria for accession uh this was still an open-ended process and because the EU gave erdogana a way out I think it allowed erdogan to Pivot turkey away the European Union more easily now had the EU given turkey a clear accession uh P you know with an end date or ex or entry date to the European Union it would have been more difficult I think for erdogan to Pivot away from the European Union accession process so I would say yes it takes it to tango perhaps erdogan dro the bll in EU accession as well but I think in this regard the blame also goes to the two largest countries in the EU France and Germany that treated turkey's accession differently uh than other countries and still do it to the state and what what erdogan has done instead is he has uh responded to this transactional way the European leaders approach turkey by trans nationalizing Turkish U ties so right now it's fair to say that there are Turkish U talks are de facto dead they're not going anywhere but the EU relies on Turkey to prevent
22:09 Refugee flows and illegal Migra M migratory flows and as a result of that I think for a very long time turkey has more leverage over the EU than the EU has over turkey understood thank you uh hooki Walker asks what considerations governed eran's reaction to to the Arab Spring in Syria uh great question so the Arab uprisings really started as you know in Tunisia in the beginning ER was not too crazy to jump on board he hesitated a little bit and he actually worked with the United States in Egypt when the mubaric government there fell uh but erdogan's policies changed when AR Rising arrived at turkey's doorstep in Syria uh erdogan believed at the time with his uh foreign minister turned prime minister Ahmed dutu the architect of turkey's Arab uprisings policy that by intervening on behalf of the rebels and supporting them politically and then militarily turkey could shape the
23:12 outcome of events in Syria now turkey has a very powerful military very strong institutions this was not unreachable the goal of shaping the outcome of the events in Syria but not without securing Firm support of the United States I think that's why and his foreign minister turn prime minister dutu failed they failed to read that for President Obama there was no way he was going to get the US involved in a war in a Muslim majority country having come to power on a platform of ending Wars in Muslim majority countries or not getting into new Wars it was Unthinkable that Obama would agree to support turkey militarily in Syria and I think because erdogan misread us intentions he uh he thought the US would follow from behind mind if Turkey went in forcefully supporting the rebels that never happened that left turkey ultimately alone against its historic Nemesis Russia and its competitor in the region Iran turkey's competitor that is and that's why at uh it almost looked
24:16 for a while in 2015 that turkey was going to lose the war in Syria because Russian deployment changed the balance of power Russia gave Assad quite a superior Air Force that Assad used to decimate the rebels uh that triggered the refugee crisis of 2015 by the way Russian deployment uh uh things looked really bad foran but uh the postol uh felu Outreach by Putin to erdogan changed U the calculus in Syria meaning Putin basically told erdogan you don't have to worry about me uh just don't fight Assad go fight to ypg so clearly the seran war shows how you have multi-layers of foreign policy moves right uh first erdogan thinks the US is going to support turkey uh then the US of course does not support turkey turkey is left alone it looks like it's going to be overwhelmed by Russia uh but then the C attempt happens and turkey and Russia patch up their differences at least in Syria and that gives a kind of a sustainable if that is the word balance of power in Syria sustainable only in quotes because it's a horrific
25:20 humanitarian crisis what is happened in Syria of course thank you and you brought up Iran there Andrew Rose Marine asks uh if Israel bombs Iranian nuclear facilities how would I uh erdogan react uh publicly I think turkey would react to this and say this is unacceptable but uh turkey and Iran are not uh um you know in love with each other they're historic Rivals I described earlier the Turkish Russian relationship I said that the two countries are each other's Nemesis not withstanding the current War ties between erdogan and Putin that have any differences now Turkish Iranian relations are different Iran is not a nemesis for turkey I would say turkey and are more like competitors you know they're both former Imperial Powers both hegemonic both want to influence outcome of events in the region but they're also competitors who will not fight uh the Turkish Iranian border I'm a map nurse I would love to share this detail with you guys it's the oldest permanent Border in
26:23 the Middle East it was drawn in 1639 uh excluding minor land swaps the border has not changed which makes it the third oldest Border in the world after the Spanish French and Spanish Portuguese borders why have turkey and Iran not fought major Wars or why have hasn't their border changed since the 17th century because the two countries decided in early 17th century that they had ended up in a premodern version of what is called mad mutually assured destruction that is if they fought they would not only destroy the other side but they to themselves would be destroyed in the process so I would say turkey has therefore avoided conflict with Iran Iran has avoided conflict with turkey but it doesn't mean that if Iran's military capabilities are undermined turkey will shed tears over this uh turkey will oppose it condemn it uh but probably not be very unhappy about it overall uh should Iran become a weaker actor in Middle East politics in the long term understood uh Janet Potter asks what caused the 2018 recession in turkey and how can that be turned around
27:28 uh good question 2018 recession was basically driven by uh number of things economic mismanagement uh um uh and also the end of uh investment coming to Turkey the first 10 years of erdogan rule this phenomenal growth was mainly underwritten by quite uh record amounts of foreign direct investment that came to Turkey that money dried off with unfortunate Terror attacks by ISIS and pkk on turkey and at this moment economic model switch from uh actual uh FDI to hot money coming into Istanbul's stock market that also dried up around 2018 with increased in stability and economic mismanagement and resulted in a 2018 crisis erdogan's current hopes are to take turkey out of economic crisis by jump starting the economy through Mega projects uh Canal Istanbul the waterway that would run parallel to the Bosphorus is one of these projects it will be the largest construction project in the history of modern turkey and of course
28:31 very few countries can fund such a a a gigantic uh undertaking China is one of them and that's actually one of the reasons I think why erdogan wants to get along with China together with everybody else thank you for that uh one question how popular is Aran is there any strong political opposition to him coming up in the 2023 elections absolutely and I do we have time for more or I think one minute so I'm just going to use my time well to answer this is the final question so erdogan's popularity is at an all-time low uh you know he reached almost 50% at the height of his popularity uh now opinion polls show his party together with his allies hovering at 40 45% so that means in a two-way race opposition could win uh it all depends on the effectiveness of the opposition to remain as a United block uh then they can vote erdoan out and so far the opposition is also missing a Le unifying leader there are number of leaders that uh you can uh you can look up mayors of big cities uh uh Turkish nationalist e party leader actionaire
29:35 her faction is rising in opinion polls so he has quite a few Challengers I am I'm a big uh fan of uh you know following turkey I've studied this country for about 20 years I'm always fascinated by it I think that if countries could be vegetables turkey would be the analytical onion if never has a core you know you think you got to the core and you understand turkey and something appears there and basically says wait a minute there's more to this country that you think there is so I would say uh never rule out a democratic future for turkey or the prospects of a democratic comeback given that turkey has had free and fair elections since 1950 longer than has at Spain it has a very strong Democratic opposition civil society and Democratic resilience I think that's erdogan's biggest challenge more than the foreign policy challenges um if the lesson of Iraq and Afghanistan to us is that it takes very long time and a lot of money to build a democracy the lesson of turkey under erdogan is the opposite it also takes a really long time to kill a democracy so I have a lot of Hope in the uh in in a future
30:38 Democratic turkey and I think we're seeing some of these Dynamics already in place thank you and before we go can you just remind our viewers where we can find some more of your work absolutely uh you can find my work uh at the website of the Washington Institute for near policy at that's Washington institute.org and you can also look up my new book Salton Autumn I hope Spencer was able to type that into the chat box so you guys can download and that is available also on my website at chop d.com that' be my last name c a g p ASM Peter tsmom ay.com I hope to see everyone again soon and stay in touch you can also look me up on Twitter and Linkedin wonderful thank you so much we've come to the close for our webinar I thank you again Dr chopai for speaking with us today thanks for hosting me uh Stacy and thanks everyone for coming it was a great conversation of course for our viewers and listeners please be on the lookout for our weekly webinars offering email coming out over the weekend thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day